Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutA Guide for the Redevelopment & Revitalization of the Waterfront-1989II III II 1 1 11 1 11 1 1 11 11 1@I Mull 11111 II 1191 I I II I 1 11 II1 1111111111111111 11141.P1 *IIIII■1!■1 Jill 11 III 111 1 IMPRIIN luulll IoolpiRippm"" ". ,,, III1plilli 11 Ii� ll III IIIMI � I.I . � Ilp 1 nIll IlII h Pill V IIIIdI,11 !11YII I I 11llrI IIIli III, II I IIICI IIII rh IIII I 11 III"II 1 hit I IIIIII I I Ill I II I1111 ' IIII1 I I I ill,, ' 111 Ill I Ill +I , I uII a1� I 1 41 II1 I 1 I I I I 11 I1 rI 111 'I iI 1 II I I I I I M I I 1I 1 I I �III Iqll I�IIaI IA7I 1 � , IllI 1I1I 1II,�"� i R11AII1I II1IIII 1 II1III1IIIIIIII11I IIII IIIIIIII II I IIIII II II I IIIIII � I � II1 AIIII1'11 I1III 'IF I I I II I I IIII II IIII IIII ill, I I I I I III I'll I III I I 1 I ' I I I1 l10 I 1, I0I 11 11, I I I ' I I 1 I. I �' � I I I I III I ' I I I I I I' r � I I I I I I • I u I I I I I' I 1 I 11 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I 1 f I I I I I 1 R I 1 I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 7 ■ 1 I I 11< �1 I �D z I � I 1 � I I I� I I I � I i I I I I I ° A I 1 ( I I ' A I I I I t I I I I I I I 1 4 I I I I i 1 1 I I I I 1 1 I I � I 1 1 I I ' I I 1 I I I I I I I ,I 1 I � 1 I II I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I� �I 1 11 I 1 I I I I I I I I , I 1 1 I I I I I II 1 I 1 I I I I I I I I I I 1 I 1 I 1 ' , I I I I I I i I I I " RICHARD NEIWLON & ASSOCIATES ARCHITECTS 3704 MACOMB STREET NIW} 1211 QUEEN ELIZABETH STREET 202-966-1111 9 19 - 473 - 3 2 8 2 Of II WAS H I N G,T 0 NDo'Co, MANTEO, NORTH CAR,OLINA I I I I I I I I I TCA RICHARD NEWLON 3104 MACOMB STREET N.W. 202-966-1111 WASHINGTON, D.C. & ASSOCIATES, ARCHITECTS tli UII[[X FIItAB fiX SIYFFI 919-113-3181 MANTEO, NORTH CAROLINA I '01 W-/mmmmgapg mo-.000polm RICHARD NEWLON 3704 MACOMB STREET N.W. 202-966-1111 WASHINGTON, D.C. i & ASSOCIATES, ARCHITECTS 111 OUF[M FIIlIB[IX SLAFFi 91 B-I11 -3113 MANTEO, NORTH CAROLINA 1. 1 J��� 1993 1994 1996 1997 1998 1999 000 PROPERTY OF DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT PLEASE DO NOT REMOVE A GUIDE FOR THE REDEVELOPMENT AND REVITALIZATION OF THE WATERFRONT COLUMBIA, NORTH CAROLINA COASTAL 2NST=AT2VE C0MM2TTEE COLUMBIA/TYRRELL COUNTRY Mr. Walter Spencer Mr. Charles Ogletree P. 0. Box 593 P. 0. Box 510 Columbia, NC 27925 Columbia, NC 27925 Mayor George Owens Chm. P. 0. Box 174 Columbia, NC 27925 Mr. Gordon Deaver, ✓ CA #I Route 2, Box 94 Columbia, NC 27925 Mr. Al Hollis Route 2 Columbia, NC 27925 Mr. Larry E. Jones, Jr. P. 0. Box 360 Columbia, NC 27925 Ms. Virginia Haire East Carolina Bank P. 0. Box 337 Columbia, NC 27925 Ms. Gail Bunch P. 0. Box 56 Columbia, NC 27925 Ms. Peggy Sawyer Route 2, Box 277A Columbia, NC 27925 Mr. J. D. Brickhouse, Finance Officer Tyrrell County Columiba, NC 27925 Mr. Walter Oakes Seaboard Fed'1. Saving Bank Mr. Carlisle Harrell, Manager P. 0. Box 630 Town of Columbia Columbia, NC 27925 Columbia, NC 27925 Mr. Franklin Furlough Route 1, Box 48 Columbia, NC 27925 Mr. Willie Hunter P. O. Box 3 Columbia, NC 27925 Mr. Cadwell Bowser P. O. Box 295 Columbia, NC 27925 Ms. Linda Cecil, Secretary 506 Main Street Columbia, NC 27925 Rural Villages... "strip and desolve our pretensions and cultural accretions ....... offer to become a part of all who tend and love them. One returns to the roots of something beyond one's personal descent." -John Fowles -1- QUALITY OF THE FUTURE "A NEW LIFE FOR COLUMBIA...TOURISM" establishes a goal for revitalization of the Town of Columbia. It is a theme that is compatible with the life-styles of Tyrrell County residents. The theme is honest, emphasizing the ideals of the residents of Tyrrell County for their county seat. The following plans attempt to establish the quality of the development, and provide criteria by which various specific proposals can be designed, evaluated for appropriateness, funded and built. -2- COMPATIBILITY WITH PRESENT LIFE STYLES The challenge is to revitalize and develop the waterfront in such a way that it appeals to both townspeople and visitors. The Town should be able to share its past and present; it should not become something it is not, just to attract tourists. The character should be compatible with the life styles and aspirations of people living in Columbia now. The waterfront should be neither a period museum nor a carnival, but rather an alive town and a setting to present the continuous history and living culture of Tyrrell County. As an example, townspeople should be able to drive or walk downtown to the county offices, the post office, the waterfront, the hardware store, Popcorns, the pharmacy, and other facilities - - activities which are highly valued today. There should never be stores or restaurants that are so fancy or expensive that local people do not feel comfortable in them. The architecture should remain of human scale but eclectic, expressing the contradictory ideals and independent eccentricities of the Town. The waterfront should respect present lifestyles as it accommodates the future. The seafood business on Water Street should remain and be enhanced, not discarded to accommodate tourist expectations. The downtown should not be overrun with visitors. Buildings along Main Street, those parts of Columbia that are valuable and precious to townspeople, should be restored to their original fronts to enhance the rural eastern North Carolina "Village Experience". Tourist activities should be concentrated on the waterfront with ample parking away from the heart of downtown, the courthouse and the post office. But on the waterfront, tourist attractions should be dispersed and low key so local people can use the facilities without great difficulty, even in peak season. A goal to bring as many as 1000 tourists per day to Columbia when the waterfront is developed with a visitor center will cause inconvenience to locals. This should not seriously alter the lifestyles of the townspeople, but Columbia likely will want to perpetuate its small town intimacy by having an exclusively local annual celebration on the waterfront for residents of Tyrrell County in the off season. EVALUATING THE IMPACT OF TOURISM Once the waterfront is developed and Main Street revitalized, impact of increased tourism on local life styles should be measured yearly to determine its continued compatibility with local lifestyles and Columbia's rural village atmosphere. Each year que'stionaires should be sent to every household in Columbia to evaluate the positive and negative effects of tourism that year. The results should be monitored from year to year. A town meeting could be held to discuss the impacts and determine the plans for the following year. For example local citizens, after careful evaluation, might decide to delay the next phase of development or initiate parking by local permit only downtown. This would allow local citizens to maintain control, and consciously decide each year whether they wanted to proceed with their plans for the Town or modify them. Therefore, any plans for revitalization should be explicitly phased and developed to be evaluated yearly in terms of social impact, taxes, maintenance, jobs, and income. Local people should not be expected to pay a major part of the expenses associated with the waterfront development. Only facilities with long term benefits for the people of Tyrrell County should be constructed. TYRRELL COUNTY'S PAST The history presented to tourists should be relaxed, fun and historically honest. The history should explain the Important events of the past, but should stress the dreams and struggles underlying each. A tourist should be told not only of the highest ideals but also of the commonplace dreams and occurrences. A BRIEF HISTORY OF TYRRELL COUNTY In 1663 Charles II granted Carolina to eight of his friends, the Lords Proprietors; Tyrrell County was part of this grant. In 1680, Captain Thomas Miller and Colonel Joshua Tarkington explored Scuppernong River and called the area Heart's Delight. Soon thereafter, small farms sprang up along the Scuppernong and at Kendrick's Creek near present Roper. Later a settlement with a log fort was established at Fort Landing on the Alligator River. The local Indian population, never large, dwindled rapidly, not from warfare with the whites, but from the white man's diseases. Early friendly relations between the races turned to mutual distrust. Finally the local Indians joined the Tuscaroras in an attempt to drive out the whites. In September, 1711, the Indians attacked whites throughout the region. The Scuppernong area was spared but a number of people along the Alligator River and on the Outer Banks were killed. The uprising was put down with help from South Carolina and the remaining Indian population either moved north to join the Iroquois or dwindled away. The Carolina colony grew and produced increasing revenue, so in 1728 the King asked the Lords proprietors to sell the region back to him. All of them agreed except Lord Granville, who retained the area containing the present Tyrrell County. The following year, 1729, the General Assembly met a Edenton and passed an act to appoint that part of Albemarle County lying on the south side of Albemarle Sound and Roanoke River as high as Rainbow Banks to be Tyrrell Precinct. It was named in honor of Sir John Tyrrell. The 100 mile long and 50 mile wide area included present Dare, Tyrrell, Washington and Martin Counties. Less than 50 years later, in 1774, the assembly created Martin County from the western portion of Tyrrell. By then opposition to British quit rents, taxes, and corrupt English officials was intense. At the Halifax Convention, where Carolina representatives voted for freedom, Tyrrell's Militia Leader Colonel Edward Buncombe was given command of the Fifth North Carolina Battalion. The battalion served under General George Washington and took part in several engagements. Buncombe was wounded and captured by the British and died of his wounds. With the gaining of independence, Carolina moved ahead. In 1793, the assembly chartered Elizabeth Town near Shallop's Landing on the east bank of the Scuppernong. The name of the town was changed to Columbia in 1810. -5- Large plantations were established by the Collins and Pettigrews of Lake Phelps. Slaves were used to dig canals to drain the land, provide for transportation, and to connect the lake with the Scuppernong River. Rice was the first major crop but it soon gave way to corn. During the prosperous years of the early 19th century Tyrrell farmers owned slaves but usually in small numbers except for the large plantations. At best, slavery was not a very economic institution but without mechanization, large scale farming required cheap labor. With the bombardment of Fort Sumter in 1861, North Carolina seceded from the union and joined the Confederate States of America. The motive was not to maintain slavery but to uphold the rights of the states. Tyrrell County suffered hard times during the later stages of the Civil War and Reconstruction. Local outlaws called Buffaloes were active and Union forces operated in the area. With Lee's surrender at Appomattox in April, 1865, the slaves were freed. Large plantations could not survive without slave labor, so they were broken up and sold. Former slaves became share -croppers and eventually land owners. Conditions stabilized in time and the county prospered again. In 1870 Tyrrell was divided for the third time and the area between Alligator River and Mann's Harbor became Dare County. With the new century, Tyrrell County built new roads and in 1908, the Norfolk and Southern Railway extended tracks to Columbia. The lumber industry reached considerable importance in the county during the early part of the 20th century. Several saw mills operated including the large Branning Lumber Company . After World War I, Tyrrell's agricultural boomed. The potato was the major cash crop but corn, soybeans, sweetpotatoes, and.peanuts were also important. Roads were improved so that the crops could be hauled to market. The truck supplanted the railroad which discontinued service to the county. During the 1950's when the regions to the west were becoming more accessible to the rest of the nation and Dare County to the east began to intensify its tourist industry, economic prosperity seemed to overlook Tyrrell County. Today, the County retains its agricultural economy in the heart of great undisturbed natural beauty. Adapted from an address by William R. West Im A BRIEF HISTORY OF THE TOWN OF COLUMBIA The Tyrrell region originally was settled by the Secotan Indians. Their two principal villages were located at what would later become the Town of Columbia and Grapevine Landing in Gum Neck. In 1788 the General Assembly of North Carolina passed a charter calling for the establishment of a town in Tyrrell County. This town was to be called Newport. But the town, the first chartered in Tyrrell County, never materialized. Some four years later in 1793, the General Assembly chartered another town to be called Elizabeth Town; it was to be located on the east bank of the Scuppernong River near the place then called Shallop's Landing. The plans for the town included a courthouse, jail, public green, taverns, and homes. The town was laid off in 1793 and it was made the county seat in 1799. The name was changed to Columbia in 1801 because of a growing confusion with another Elizabeth Town in North Carolina. The town's relaxed air was rudely disturbed in 1863 when Union troops, backed up by gunboats on the Scuppernong River sacked and burned the town. Recovery was slow; and at the beginning of the century, Columbia looked more like a hastily thrown -up frontier community than a century -old county seat. In the 1930's citizens got to work and tore down most of the old stop -gap building to make way for more permanent structures. In 1908 the Norfolk and Southern Railroad put a spur into Columbia which was terminated in 1948. In 1920 the Columbia Electric Light Company was formed and lasted until about 1929 when it was sold to the Virginia Electric and Power Company. During the same year a bridge was constructed across the Pint-O-Marsh linking the west bank of the Scuppernong to the town. In 1927 the local telephone company was established by one of the many Cahoons which populated Tyrrell County. At its peak, the local company had 300 subscribers and a long distance line to Plymouth, North Carolina, 34 miles to the west. In 1953 Trailway Bus Company was established and in 1959 a new bridge spanning the Scuppernong River just south of the old bridge was built. Today, many of the substantial homes and commercial building of the 1930's still line Columbia's streets and undisturbed waterfront. Adapted from a report prepared by the Town of Columbia -7- TOURISTS Tourists should experience as much of the history as possible. Although the Visitor Center should be clearly visible as the starting point, providing clear and concise directions, history books, a walking tour booklet, and an orientation slide show that sets the tone for the experience, the story itself should be told and lived through the experience. The story should be told unobtrusively by local people doing what they do anyway: having coffee in local restaurants, running stores and the government, making crafts, and socializing. The tourists should feel both uplifted and welcome, their physical comfort should be provided for, and as a result they buy something while walking the waterfront and Main Street. A visitor should be welcome to stop and sit a while, view the activity and the water, eat, shop, learn and chat with other tourists or residents. Places should be provided for those activities: benches, chairs, and rocking chairs outside and more establishments like Popcorn's Restaurant, Pledger's Hardware, Ben Franklin, Tyrrell Hardware, and Country Things, where one gets the impression that the owners are equally concerned with your enjoyment as with the sales. There is a very different feeling in a town which embraces tourists and one which gazes suspiciously at newcomers. This feeling is very perceptible to visitors. In addition, there should be available public restrooms; a marina; shops and eateries of various price ranges; bicycle and boat rentals; an inn; and perhaps open air farmers market. All of these would serve both visitors and residents. Although there should be a separation between those activities that are more exclusively for townspeople like the post office and those for visitors, the visitor's experience for the most part should be integrated into the waterfront and Main Street. There should not be a separation of "them versus us", which often leads to buildings, facilities and activities being used by one group but not the other. experience on the waterfront can heighten one's sense of history. This can be accomplished by taking advantage of the extraordinary opportunity afforded by the Town's existing village scale, juxtaposed with the Scuppornong River and the downhome residential streets. By providing some visitor attractions on the waterfront and the beauty of the park across the river and by creating a pedestrian link between, a visitor will be constantly aware of the contrast between the un-developed shoreline and the new life for Columbia. This rare environmental opportunity should be maximized. The Town's existing character as a built up village center should be emphasized with carefully placed buildings. The unusual beauty of the river, the marshland, and the undeveloped shoreline should be preserved. The convenience and comfort of open spaces intermingled with the buildings should be enhanced to dramatize the contrast of built village, open space and natural environment. Various tourist facilities should be spread out to maximize this contrast, and to make the activities unrushed, yet each facility should lead to the next and never be more than 400 feet from another attraction (the acceptable walking distance between tourist attractions). N M - ,lam � Ir. ,N THE IMAGE COLUMBIA CO11VEYS The Town should appear to be what it is, a small rural eastern N.C. community that played a significant role in the history of Tyrrell County; a people proud of that history and eager to share it; a Town that is -the keeper of that history; a community whose waterfront needs repair and whose economy needs a boost. The Town need be nothing more, but its image must be clear for tourists and townspeople alike.. Visitors will leave Columbia with an impression that the Town is both relaxed and friendly, historic and commonplace, rural and natural. They should remember the waterfront. Visitors should feel involved. The image should be clear, reinforced and repeated throughout the community. A relaxed atmosphere should pervade; pretense, monumentality and suburban strip styles must be avoided. The facilities should be remarkable in that they are useful and consistent with Columbia's present character. The specific public facilities should include the following: 0 -10- PROPOSED PUBLIC FACILITIES � ..1.•r .i try- ��.t.. ' ::� ,.a iGi o•.. - ..,i:li �"'� 1. _ A) VISITOR CENTER The visitor center should display artifacts from the Estelle Randall. It should provide information about the history of Tyrrell County and the Albemarle area. It should include a welcome center, a small introductory exhibit and an introductory slide show. The visitor center must do the following: 1. It must be clearly visible to tourists from their cars. a. They should see it, drive past it, park immediately beyond it, and walk back to it. b. This sequence should be obvious, direct and without confusion. C. The Visitor Center should appear clearly as an information center and a "beginning point". 2. The Visitor Center should be located near the end of the extended Water Street the waterfront. 3. Its location must greet, welcome, and be comfortable for visitors. 4. It must be located with direct access to Highway 64 to minimize congestion downtown and negative impact on existing neighborhoods. The entrance should altogether avoid Broad Street used by townspeople for the post office. -11- 5. Parking should be provided for an appropriate number of cars within easy walking distance of the visitor center. a. The distance from parking to the Visitor Center should not be more than 400 feet. b. The walk should be direct, but enhanced by existing natural vegetation and river view. 6. The architecture of the Visitor Center needs to be in keeping with eastern North Carolina styles - - relaxed, comfortable and functional, "traditional rural North Carolina design". a. There should be a front porch with rocking chairs, and tables where people can be welcomed, relax, wait, meet others, or simply sit and watch the activity and surrounding environment.. b. Inside the building, a visitor should enter a reception space where a staff person is easily accessible to give direction and information. Information about Sommerset, Dare County attractions, other Albemarle area Counties, and accommodations should be immediately visible on one side of the room. On the other side, a small exhibit introducing the story of the Estelle Randall should double as a waiting space for the slide show. C. From the small exhibit space, a visitor may enter a room where a 15 minute slide show plays every half hour introducing the story of the history of Columbia and Tyrrell County. d. Restrooms should also be provided for use by visitors and staff. e. Upon leaving the slide show, a visitor should be clearly oriented, feel free to sit and linger on the porch or be directed to the next activity of his choosing. The major attraction will be the boardwalks and the historic residential walking tour, as well as the excursion boat, shops, restaurants, bike rentals and other private facilities throughout downtown Columbia. -12- B) "EXCURSION BOAT" The "excursion boat" will be docked on the Columbia waterfront. This will be the major attraction, and a primary setting for telling the Tyrrell County Story. Visitors the world around have intense interest in the antebellum south. According to Dorothy Redford, curator at "Somerset", Columbia played an important role in at least one phase of "Somerset's" history. 1. It should be a focal point of a visit to learn about Tyrrell County and visitors should be able to board and be taken on a cruise up river. 2. The boat should be prominently docked at the end of Main Street and visible for every person crossing the bridge. Information about the excursion should be available in the Columbia Visitor Center as well as in all other Vistor Centers in the Albermarle Region. 3. On an average summer day several hundred visitors may be expected to buy a ticket for the excursion. C) "THE WALKING TOUR" "The Walking Tour" should be one of the final products of an historic survey of the buildings in Columbia. Matching grant funds are available annually for historic building surveys. A local writer/historian could develop the walking tour and a a local organization print the guide booklet for sale to tourists as a fundraiser. -13- D) MARINA A marina primarily serving boats travelling the Intercoastal Waterway will be built. Some docks should be attached to the boardwalk on the Town side of the River and more marina facilities should be encouraged across the River on the old "Enterprise Property". A public/private arrangement for the construction and management of the docks, much like Manteo and Beaufort, proves to be the best possible economic solution to the problem of tremendous costs of building and managing marina facilities. It provides a much greater economic benefit to the community and without government expenditure. 1. The docks for the marina should be located on the main waterfront with separate facilities for townspeople and visitors. At least one free public pier with docking for several boats for locals visiting town by boat must be included in the overall marina plan. 2. The marina will be an attraction itself, providing activity that draws people from both the inland waterway and the county into the downtown. 3. Slips should be 15 feet wide for boats up to 35 feet in length. Larger boats can be accommodated at the end of each main dock. a. Catwalks should be 15 feet long, and should taper from three feet wide to one foot wide at the end. b. Water, electricity, cable T.V., toilet and shower facilities will be provided. No boat repair or maintenance service will be provided on the Town side. -14- • .... w E) BOARDWALK A boardwalk along the waterfront will extend from the Oil Company land south to the Visitor Center as well as across the bridge to Town Park connecting with the old bridge. F) PARKING Ample parking with specific plans for expansion over the years will become the single most important public facility that government must address. Too little parking will kill the Town and too much expanse of asphalt without trees and landscaping will destroy the rural small town atmosphere. Parking must be convenient, ample and interspersed throughout the Town. G) PUBLIC SWIMMING Swimming could be provided from the south end of the boardwalk. It should be defined by ropes for safety. The "Beach" needs to be accessible by foot or car. Parking for swimming efill be shared with parking for Visitor Center. H) BOAT RAMP The Boat Ramp might be desirable. It should have at least 30 feet of waterfront with access directly to the River and the free public dock. At the far south end there could be a ramp with access to deep water, space for launching (2000 sq. ft.) and additional parking for 12 to 15 cars with trailers. Other parking is nearby. I. The ramp should be a 6 to 15% slope. 2. Most cars with trailers must be able to enter and exit without backing. A large space (10,000 sq. ft.) should be provided for backing trailers into the water. 3. The facility could be adjacent to the Visitor Center but should not visually compete with that center, so a vegative screen should be planted between the two facilities. 4. Seating, out of the mainstream of activity, should be provided for boat parties and observers. f -16- LAND ACQUISITION Properties needed include: Site A, block 16 parcel 9 Site B, block 16 parcels 29-43 and block 15 parcels 1-13 and block 14 parcels 5-7 Site C, block 14, parcels 1 and 2 Site D, block 3, parcel 6 Site E, block 3, parcels 7 and 8 Site F, block 8, parcel 1 Site G, block 4, parcel 1 Site H, block 4, parcels 4-6 (See map of "Redevelopment Sites" for reference.) To accomplish the plans necessary for a successful redevelopment of the waterfront, various parcels of land are of critical importance. Some of the parcels need to be purchased for public use; some may be acquired by donation; some will require exchanges, easements, or leases; some will be developed privately. It is absolutely essential that a semi -autonomous Redvelopment Authority be appointed according to North Carolina General Statues. PRIVATE FACILITIES The Town should encourage the establishment of the following private facilities along Main Street and along the Boardwalk. 1. A variety store. 2. Local small scale industrial arts, especially those with historic value. 3. An inn -type hotel with about 16 to 24 rooms. 4. Rental office and storage for bicycles, paddles boats and canoes. 5. Several eating places including a cafe/grill, locally operated fast foods, and a waterfront/river view restaurant. 6. Local shops such as a craft shop, a vegetable market, a seafood market, a bakery and a souvenir shop. Approximately 20,000 square feet of new commercial facilities will be justified by the additional tourism. If this development is of high quality, it will become an attraction in itself. It will draw visitors into downtown. If this happens, the development will likely cause a "snowball effect" drawing even more development. This trend may be -17- desirable for Columbia, but Town leaders must be cautious that the downtown not be taken over by tourists. Locals daily routine must be respected by future development. The Town should cooperate with other towns and agencies on the Outer Banks to promote "A Day Trip to Columbia". Care must be taken to separate those facilities primarily for visitors, and those almost exclusively for residents, so residents may have easy automobile access to the latter. 0 •, y a. M rr HISTORIC • • ; ` l . - /. �� '� � � . f,:�'�' s, VISITOR WATERF UT' b CENTER /�• I ~ ' •yrr 1 1 �I ' � 1 � li,. .r•;i; r 1 �� ENTRANCES Visitors may come to Columbia much like those who came by boat a hundred years ago except their trip should be clearly marked, with services available upon their arrival. Upon arrival, they may experience Columbia entirely on foot; indeed a tremendous asset for attracting inland waterway traffic. A) ENTRANCE TO COLUMBIA BY CAR 0 Most visitors will likely arrive by car from either direction along Highway 64. The approach from the Outer Banks is largely natural and undeveloped along the highway. Tyrrell County should work to preserve this increasingly uncommon circumstance that is very appealing to visitors. The open, rural appearance of Highway 64 is appropriate but commercial clusters inside the town limits district are important to tourists and .local residents alike. Those clusters should be encouraged to expand, yet stay concentrated in one spot to provide more one -stop shopping. The present character of Highway 64 near downtown is -19- distracting. It is cluttered with signs, offers no safe pedestrian access to stores, is out of human scale, and needs additional sidewalks and trees for microclimate control. These problems should be corrected if "A New Life for Columbia....Tourism" is going to succeed. A commission patterned after the Roanoke Voyages Corridor Commission should be considered as the mechanism to safegard the natural approach from the Outer Banks and to clean up the in -town segment of Highway 64. B) ENTRANCE TO DOWNTOWN BY CAR Entrances to the downtown district from Highway 64 should be as carefully planned with help from North Carolina Department of Transportation. Old neighborhoods between Highway 64 and the downtown commercial district presently define much of Columbia's relaxed, welcoming character and should continue to do so. There should be two major entrances for the visitor from Highway 64, a direct route to visitor center parking and a route through downtown to the waterfront. These both should be clearly marked, pleasant experiences. Disruption to existing neighborhoods should be minimized. IMPACT ON UTILITIES In addition to the public facilities already outlined, there will be an increased demand on public utilities. Water and sewer capacities need to be reviewed and addressed if necessary. Every effort should be made to have the utility lines in key locations placed underground whenever possible. IMPACT ON THE NATURAL ENVIRONMENT Most development will occur in areas already urbanized but the revitalization of the waterfront will necessarily impact areas of environmental concern. The impact of the new boardwalk and docks must be evaluated by various environmental regulatory agencies and adjustments made to the plan for least negative environmental impact. -20- ASSOCIATED COMMUNITY NEEDS A DIVERSE TAX BASE At the same time the Town prepares to expand its tourist tax base, efforts should be made to diversify the .economy. Small industries compatible with the waterfront development should be sought as well as spin-off art and specialized educational facilities. The Town will benefit in the long run from an economy not totally dependent upon either farming or tourism. This is especially true for low-income, poorly trained individuals who presently have only seasonal work out of County. NORTH EASTERN NORTH CAROLINA By increasing historically related tourism, Columbia will attract large numbers of people interested in North Carolina history. Display panels illustrating important sites throughout North Eastern North Carolina should form a permanent exhibit in the Visitor Center and subsequently increase tourism throughout this section of the State. Columbia should become a major attraction in the Historic Albemarle Region and much of the needed promotion could come from state agencies. PRODUCTIVE AND FULFILLING JOBS For those low-income, poorly trained people who work in seasonal service jobs out of county, the unemployment rate is more than a statistic. For them, it often means they do not -21- have a productive and fulfilling life, that their human potential is not being realized. For the most part, they will view the waterfront as a continuation of their neglect, which has been neither benign nor purposeful. One youth said "there ain't nothing in it (the waterfront development) for US. The rich farmers run this County and don't care about us." Indeed this very serious perception must be addressed and dealt with by local government. COLUMBIA MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION The Town could increase local tourist management capabilities and support by encouraging a merchants' association. The merchants' group could identify commercial needs and actively recruit private investment in Columbia. The group could also increase and improve the interdependence that will grow between business on Highway 64 and the downtown district. TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE A successful and beneficial revitalization will require an unusual number and variety of professional consultants to the Town. Many state agencies provide technical assistance for the asking. Each should be chosen for.his or her ability to work with other consultants in an interdisciplinary team, for their knowledge of their field as it relates to Columbia's conceptual grasp of the intent and tone of the waterfront development as defined in this report, for their ability to involve local citizens in his or her research, work and implementation, and for their commitment to local community development. The consultants should be flexible and able to apply professional expertise sensitively, appropriately and effectively to help Columbia residents solve their own problems. Only in this way will.a legacy result that produces facilities adaptable for local needs, and helps create a healthier community. WILDING STYLE: PF-57 R°OM5 [� EXu1 Pi IT SPACE. POIZCN ARC WAL EXN 1gir- LAYOUT, SECTION E LIV BVILOING SttLE'Ae&,dx& QPI. � LjA7.*at/, am/ ru'�ctuaul RETAIL � REFAI L p„zcN Tb eweownLK .TYPICAL FLOOR LAYOUT APT. A9r. [RETAIL RETAIL TYPICAL SECTION J,W wad PAIZ VJ NCB TYPICAL GU19TR,,QOM VLOOP� ,-I---- -_--- --- 7NCAL SECTION -25- FACILITIES, COST ESTIMATES, CONTACTS AND TIME SCHEDULES I. Facility: VISITOR CENTER Estimated Cost: $450,000.00 Notes: The Visitor Center should be funded by the General Assembly. The local delegation including Senator Marc Basnight, Representatives Vernon James and Pete Thompson should be notified as soon as possible of this request. It is imperative that Columbia and Tyrrell County have the support of the Department of Cultural Resources. Contacts for Assistance: Senator Marc Basnight Manteo, North Carolina 27954 473-3474 Larry Misenheimer, Asst. Director Division of Archives & History 109 East Jones Street Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 733-7305 Proposed Time Schedule: A presentation of the Master Plan should be made to Senator Basnight and Mr. Misenheimer not later than December 1, 1989. With their support, a request should be made to the General Assembly for a $25,000.00 planning grant in the 1990 Short Session. Funding for construction of the Visitor Center should follow in the 1991 Session with the Visitor Center scheduled to open to the public in the Spring of 1993. II. Facility: EXCURSION BOAT Estimated Cost: (Private Vendor) Notes: Prior to solicitation of a vendor for the Excursion Boat, several things have to happen. D.O.T. has to remove a substantial portion of the old bridge, the boardwalk and marina facilities need to be in place. The consultants believe the economic viability of the Excursion Boat is predicated upon the opening up of the waterway from Columbia to Somerset Plantation. D.O.T. should be requested to study this possibility and estimate the cost of replacing existing bridges -26- with elevated short bridges across the canal. The Excursion Boat could be a barge -like boat requiring shallow draft and not more than 10 to 12 feet above the water; much like the renown barges that travel the canals in France and are extraordinarily popular with tourists. This request to D.O.T., like that for the Visitor Center, needs to be a joint request by Columbia and the Department of Cultural Resources. Contacts for Assistance: Ms. Lloyd Childers, Board Member Somerset Plantation North Carolina Dept. of Cultural.Resources Historic Preservation Branch 109 East Jones Street Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 733-4763 Secretary James E. Harrington State Department of Transportation 1 South Wilmington Street Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 733-2520 Mr. C.O. White Division of Highways Ahoskie, North Carolina 332-4021 Mr. Doug Bowers D.O.T. Waterways Wilmington, N.C. 763-5133 Proposed Time Schedule: After presentation of Master Plan to local legislative delegation not later than December 1, 1989, a joint request should go to D.O.T. in January 1990 with letters of support from Senator Basnight and Ms. Lloyd Childers. The Excursion Boat should be operating daily between the Columbia waterfront and Somerset Plantation in the Spring of 1993. III. Facility: HISTORIC SURVEY/WALKING TOUR Estimated Cost: $12,000.00 to $15,000.00 Notes: Matching funds are available by grant for the survey work through the N.C. Dept. of Cultural Resources, Historic Preservation Branch. Funding cycle is once yearly. -27- Contacts for Assistance: Ms. Lloyd Childers, Grants Administrator Raleigh, N.C. 733-4763 Ms. Drew York Eastern Office Greenville, N.C. 752-7778 Proposed Time Schedule: Columbia should apply for the grant immediately with survey to be accomplished in 1990-91. IV: Facility: MARINA Estimated Cost: (Private Vendor/20-year lease in exchange for construction) Notes: After completion of the boardwalk and after funding for the Visitor Center, a private vendor .should be sought for the construction of boat slips. The private vendor will determine the exact number and size of docks by market analysis and risk factor in consultation with The Redevelopment Authority. Contacts for Assistance: John Crew Coastal Area Management Box 1507 Washington, N.C. 27889 946-6481 Terry Moore Coastal Area Management 946-6481 Charles Hollis Corps of Engineers Wilmington, N.C. 251-4629 Proposed Time Schedule: Docks and marine facilities will necessarily have to be built after and only after many of the other facilities are funded and/or constructed. Costs of docks and their management have proven to be both expensive and time consuming for local governments. The consultants suggest that a vendor/lease arrangement patterned after Beaufort and Manteo be pursued by The Redevelopment Authority. -28- Perhaps a first phase of docks could be constructed over the next year, but The Authority's goal should be to have the marina facilities in place in the Spring of 1993 to coincide with the opening of the Visitor Center. V: Facility: BOARDWALK Estimated Cost: Phase I - (From Main Street south to the Visitor Center site) 920 feet of bulkhead $44,160.00 13,440 sq. feet of boardwalk 67,200.00 Total .............. $111,360.00 Phase II -(From Main Street north to the Gazebo) 750 feet of bulkhead $36,000.00 9,000 sq. feet of boardwalk 45,000.00 Gazebo 9,300.00 Total ............... $90,300.00 Notes: Phase I on the boardwalk should be pursued immediately. Grants are available from CAMA requiring but a 10% match if applied for through the Town of.Columbia. This would require Columbia to invest approximately $11,136.00 resulting in a $111,360.00 project. The $11,136.00 match could be a combination of cash and in -kind services. Proposed Time Schedule: NOW! (The Authority must acquire easements 30 feet in width across the waterfront of each parcel YESTERDAY) Contacts for Assistance: John Crew Coastal Area Management 946-6481 VI: Facility: REALIGNMENT AND EXTENSION OF WATER STREET PLANTING AREAS ALONG STREETS IN TOWN Estimated Cost: To be determined by D.O.T. Notes: After presentation to the local legislative delegation The Authority should ask Senator Basnight to request on their behalf that D.O.T. undertake a study and prepare cost estimates for this work. The Town of Columbia should request that D.O.T. accept Water, Main, Broad and Bridge Streets into their system and construct and pay for the improvements. -29- Contacts for Assistance: Senator Marc Basnight Manteo, N.C. 473-3474 Secretary James E. Harrington Raleigh, N.C. 733-2520 VII. Facility: PARKING Estimated Cost: $650.00 per space for asphalt on top of gravel base for off-street parking lots. VIII.Facility: BOAT RAMP Estimated Cost: $40,000.00 Notes: Perhaps the boat ramp could be included in funding for Phase II of the boardwalk through CAMA's water access money. Another possibility is the construction of a boat ramp with associated parking of the N.C. Wildlife Resource Commission. Contacts for Assistance: John Crew Coastal Area Management 946-6481 Richard B. Hamilton, Asst. Director N.C. Wildlife Commission Archdale Building 512 North Salisbury Street Raleigh, N.C. 27611 733-3391 Proposed Time Schedule: To be completed in the Spring of 1993. IX. Facility: LAND ACQUISITION Estimated Cost: Following is a list of Tyrrell County's assessed values of redevelopment sites A through H. Site A: Owned by the Town Columbia Site B: $45,300.00 Site C: $26,500.00 Site D: 5,300.00 Site E: Unavailable -30- Site F: 31,800.00 Site G: 8,000.00 Site H: 44,200.00 Notes: The above are taken from Tyrrell County tax values. Upon examination of recent sales, the consultants determined that in some cases fair market value is indeed as much as 2 1/2 times the assessed value. The Authority should negotiate individually with each redevelopment site owner for an option to purchase at fair market value for a period of 18 months. THE SOONER THESE OPTIONS ARE ACQUIRED BY THE AUTHORITY, THE LIKELIHOOD IS LESS THAT PRICES WILL BE INFLATED BY ADOPTION OF THE MASTER PLAN! X. Facility: ARTIFACTS FROM ESTELLE RANDALL Estimated Cost: $25,000.00 to $30,000.00 Notes: Underwater archaeology creates widespread public interest and significant media attention. Raising artifacts from the Estelle Randall for inclusion in the Visitor Center will focus much needed attention on Columbia. This component of the Master Plan needs to be pursued by The Authority with due diligence and enthusiasm. A member of The Authority should accept responsibility for insuring that the press is kept well informed and fed information so that Columbia may receive state wide attention. Contacts for Assistance: Funding for this project is more difficult than the other components. It is likely that it will have to come from the General Assembly. With the support of the Department of Cultural Resources, Columbia should request funding from the legislative delegation in the 1990 Short Session of the General Assembly. The contacts are: Renee Gledhill -Early Archives and History Raleigh, N.C. 733-4763 Mark Wild Ramsing Wilmington, N.C. 458-9042 -31- XI. Facility: PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT WATERFRONT INN, RESIDENTIAL/RETAIL,RESTAURANTS Estimated Costs: As preliminarily laid out in the Master Plan, private development costs would exceed $5,000,000.00. Notes: $5,000,000.00 increase in the tax base of Columbia will add a significant annual sum to the coffers of the town without increasing the tax rate to the local residents. While the public investment in public facilities is substantial, indeed it is a very small percentage of the overall costs associated with the Master Plan, the majority of which will come from private enterprise. Proposed Time Schedule: Upon completion of the Visitor Center and associated facilities in the Spring of 1993, a substantial portion of the private development should be completed. Attracting five million dollars of private investment to Columbia today would be impossible. But as soon as funding is secured for raising Estelle Randall, building the boardwalk and Visitor Center, The Redevelopment Authority should begin active solicitation of qualified developers. It would not be unrealistic to set Spring of 1991 as a goal for signing agreements with the developer. "Before I build a wall I'd ask to know What I was walling in or walling out, and to whom I was like to give offense..." Robert Frost, Mending Wall ��/ ""rpla a -32- THE PLANNING PROCESS FOR COLUMBIA In 1989, governing officials of Tyrrell County and the Town of Columbia have pivotal decisions to make. The town is beset with problems: one of the highest tax rates in the state, an eroded tax base, a useless downtown, haphazard strip development, racial inequities and economic disparities. Yet the town is a pleasant place to live; remote, naturally beautiful, a rural village with quiet neighborhoods accented by front porches where neighbors visit. In fact, its remoteness and small town rural character masks many of the problems. The quaint and charming downtown is punctuated with empty stores, inappropriately renovated storefronts, run down buildings and a neglected waterfront. Unemployment for lower income residents produces a sorrowful counterpoint to the faded memories of the early 1900's when Columbia was the thriving merchantile center of Tyrrell County. Today, with the help of the Governor's Coastal Initiative Program, the elected officials are embracing a tremendous challange to bring new life to Columbia and plan for it's future. THE SURVEY This report describes a single step in the process of developing a master plan for the redevelopment and revitalization of Columbia. To develop a plan for the future that would protect the most valued aspects of the town and address the most serious problems requires that those valued aspects and problems be clearly articulated not by just a few citizens but by a broad cross-section of the community. A survey was developed and mailed to a sample of people who represent the feelings of the entire town and county. The people were asked what things they like and what problems exist in their neighborhoods and in the town. The results obviously will be a most important factor in developing a master plan. The intent of this report is to summarize the surveys so elected officials may draw their own conclusions and participate in the design of Columbia's future. -33- RESPONSES On the following pages are the summaries of responses to the survey. In each case, the numbers have simply been totaled for each prescribed category, except where categories were derived on the basis of similar responses. As examples, in one question the answer could only be male or female; so the responses were added up. There were 72 males and 77 females. But in other questions the categories " natural environment", "people", and "lack of crime" were assigned by the planning team after looking at the responses. As an illustration, "loveable people" and "friendly" meant nearly the same things and could be classified under "people". In many cases the number of responses does not total 150, the number of respondents. In those cases there was no response written to a specific question on the survey. -34- USING SURVEY RESULTS TO DEVELOP A MASTER PLAN The integration of the results of the written survey representing the needs and desires of residents to produce a Master Plan involved direct and indirect strategies. For example, a result such as 76% of the respondants indicating that they wish to see Main Street redeveloped, clearly indicates an area upon which attention needs to be focused. Another response of 61% stating the closing of stores downtown as a serious or very serious problem reaffirms this. Furthermore, in addressing the redevelopment of Main Street we must be careful to remember the high number of responses (69%) which indicate that it is the hometown feeling, the village -like character or the good environment that they like best about Columbia and Tyrrell County. Clearly, Main Street is an important part of the physical and cultural environment for residents and they are concerned about losing it - either because of economic decline or intense tourism. For these concerns, the correlation between the needs and values of the people and the Master Plan is rather direct. On the other hand, when 69% of the respondants cite local taxes being too high as a serious or very serious problem, we must deal with the issue more indirectly. For example, one way to reduce the tax rate, or at least prevent its increase, is to increase the tax base. The public facilites proposed in this report and Master Plan would reduce the risk of private development and create an environment where there would be sound reasons for private development to begin to flow into the area. And, of course, such development would increase the tax base, indirectly satisfying the desires of residents with regard to the taxes they pay. It should be noted here that while the proposed Master Plan calls for public and private investment and development, the private development will initially be providing essentials for increased tourism; the majority of respondants want discount department stores. The resolution here must come as it does to any healthy town where a tourist economy is the initial major goal. With increased tourism, there will come a point at which enough tourists and townspeople combined in Columbia can support these kinds of stores which are not essential for tourism. Responses to the survey indicate that the three main categories of these stores are discount department store (63%), supermarket (32%) and fast food (20%). It will be important to weave these elements into the fabric of the town as set out in the Master Plan when private development reaches this point and not let them become superfluous -seeming, strip development. When available the stores should significantly reduce the number of people who go out of the county for most of their shopping (68% of respondants). -35- The majority of the respondants want boardwalks and boat docks. This focus where the town meets the water is in keeping with the historical integrity of Columbia and other coastal towns of North Carolina and is also the primary focus of the Master Plan. Of the 150 respondants, 114 (76%) indicated they wanted to see Main Street redeveloped; only 12 respondants (8%) were opposed to the redevelopment. Therefore, the Master Plan calls for the realignment of Water Street north of NC 64/264 and for the extension of Water Street south of NC 64/264. It also provides appropriate off-street parking, without which Main Street could never be redeveloped successfully. Small towns typically regard convenient downtown parking as very important; 37% of the Columbia respondants already cite it as a serious problem! A business located in Columbia that would create a significant number of jobs received a positive response from 85% of the respondants and the need for new industry and more job opportunities topped the "serious" or "very serious" problem list at 77%. A redeveloped Main Street, a marina and an excursion boat, together with a visitors center, will provide a significant number of both seasonal and year-round jobs. The majority of the serious problems tendered by the survey and interviews have been addressed and incorporated into the Master Plan with two notable exceptions, drug abuse and the lack of vocational training. Both of these concerns are beyond the scope of this project and while redeveloopment. may have benefits affecting these matters, each is a serious problem requiring the serious attention of government officials. -36- THE COASTAL INITIATIVE COMMITTEE OF THE TOWN OF COLUMBIA AND TYRRELL COUNTY RESULTS OF THE SURVEY [The number of responses to each question is shown of bold type.] The Coastal Initiative Committee of the Town of Columbia and Tyrrell County is committed to the development of a Master Plan for the redevelopment of the Columbia waterfront and the commercial revitalization of downtown. How do you feel about the need for such a plan?-87-(58%)agree,-15-(10%)neutral,-25-(17%)d1sagree. If such a plan is to be developed, it must be based on the needs and desires of the citizens of Tyrrell County. Please answer the following questions and share with us any other opinions you might have about the future of downtown Columbia and the waterfront. How long have you lived in Tyrrell County? [Responses were categorized either long or short term.] -128- (85%) long term (ten years or more) -22- (15%) short term (less than ten years) Do you live within the town limits of Columbia? -105- (70%) no -43- (29%) yes What things do you like best about Columbia and Tyrrell County? [The following responses were categorized to include similar responses.] -104- (69%) hometown, village -like character, good environment -72- (48%) nice, friendly people -9- (6%) lack of crime -4- (3%) freedom from governmental interference -2- (1%) good library -2- (1%) good climate What [The -56- -31- -31- -31- -16- -13- -7- -7- -6- -6- -4- -4- -4- -4- problems or needs do you consider to following responses were categorized (37%) unemployment and lack of jobs (23%) lack of facilities and guidance (21%) drugs (21%) lack of facilities (11%) high taxes (9%) inadequate law enforcement organization (5%) lack of medical facilities (5%) low salaries (4%) inadequate schools (4%) inadequate county leaders (3%) environmental problems (3%) crime (3%) inadequate roads and streets (3%) mosquitos be the most serious? to include similar responses.] for youth page 1 -37- Where do you do most of your shopping?. -102- (68%) out of Tyrell County -46- (31%) in town -33- (22%) in Tyrell County If most shopping is out of the county, where? -71- (47%) Edenton -40- (27%) Plymouth -30- (20%) Elizabeth City -10- (7%) Dare County -10- (7%) Norfolk and Virginia -6- (4%) Washington -3- (2%) Greenville -2- (1%) Chowan County -1- ( lAi ) Raleigh What kinds of new stores would you like to see in Columbia? [Responses of a specific chain store (e.g., K-Mart) were categorized.] -95- (63%) discount department store (K-Mart, Roses, Ames, etc.) -48- (32%) supermarket (Food Lion, etc.) -30- (20%) fast food (Hardee's, etc.) -6- (4%) good restaurant -6- (4%) specialty store (antiques, jewelry) -4- (3%) hardware -4- (3%) shopping mall -4- (3%) movie theater -3- (2%) bowling or skating -2- (1%) discount drug store (Revco, etc.) -1- (1%) bookstore If it were possible, would you like to see the Columbia waterfront developed with boardwalks and boat docks? -80- (53%) yes -39- (26%) no -23- (15%) not sure Columbia's old wooden bridge prevents boats, other than small craft, from being able to go upriver. In the past, the Department of Trans- portation has wanted to remove the bridge. If economic revitalization depends on its removal, would you support the elimination of the bridge? -63- (42%) yes -56- (37%) no -26- (17%) not sure Would you like to see Main Street redeveloped? -114- (76%) yes -12- (8%) no -18- (12%) not sure Would you like to see a business located in Columbia that would create a significant number of jobs? -128- (85%) yes -8- (5%) no -7- (5%) not sure page 2 The following may or may not be a problem in your community. You may consider some problems to be more serious than others. We would like to know your opinion about how serious you think these problems are in Columbia. [Responses marked "serious" or "very serious" on the survey list are tabulated below.] -116- (77%) Need for new industry and more job opportunities -116- (77%) Unemployment -113- (75%) Drug abuse -103- (69%) Local taxes too high -91- (61%) Stores closing in downtown -88- (59%) Need for downtown revitalization -79- (53%) Vocational training -78- (52%) Lack of tourist attractions in Columbia -77- (51%) The way the town looks -70- (47%) Need for town planning -70- (47%) Parks and recreation -62- (41%) Preservation of historic buildings and sites -60- (40%) Street paving and maintenance -56- (37%) Downtown parking -55- (37%) Playgrounds for children -50- (33%) Low-income housing availability -43- (29%) Need for picnic and sitting places -32- (21%) Zoning -22- (15%) Need for a boardwalk on the waterfront -15- (10%) Racial discrimination -10- (7%) Traffic congestion These last few questions are only for statistical purposes in order to insure that we have a cross-section of the population. Are you-72-(48%) male or-77-(51%) female? Are you-12-(S%) black,-134-(89%) white or-1-(l%) other? What is your occupation? [Responses were categorized to include similar occupations.] -45- (30%) retired -32- (21%) office worker/management -21- (14%) laborer -17- (11%) housewife/home maker -9- (6%) self-employed -8- (5%) farmer -4- (3%) professional -1- (1%) student Where do you work? -45- (30%) in Tyrrell County -29- (19%) in town -4- (3%) Edenton -4- (3%) Washington -3- (2%) Dare County -3- (2%) Plymouth -1- (1%) Elizabeth City -1- Norfolk page 3