Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLand Use Plan Update-1994how \► wro, V TOWN OF CALABASH 1994 LAND USE PLAN UPDATE • • • � • • •,,,ice • �- . Honorable George Anderson, Mayor Jon Sanborn, Mayor Pro-Tem Theodora Altreuter Raymond Card Keith Hardee Forrest King Robert L. Noe Edward F. Schaack _-zLal : • • Alfred E. Smith, Chairman Bruce Kibblehouse, Land Use Plan Liason Anthony Clemmons Terry Frink John Hannaway Phil Marlow Billie Mitchell Warren Pienack Douglas Simmons Mary Lou Taylor TOWN STAFF Janet Thomas, Town Clerk Margaret Partridge Mary Bruton John Fazekas Roger Bowman PLANNING CONSULTANT Margaret H. Hayes HAYES & ASSOCIATES 2222 Mimosa Place Wilmington, NC 28403 (910) 343-8801 FUNDING AGENCY The preparation of this land use planning document with associated maps was'financed in part through a grant provided by the North Carolina Coastal Management Program, through funds provided the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972, as amended, which is administered by the Office of Ocean and Coastal Resource Management, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. ' TOWN OF CALABASH. NC 1994 LAND USE PLAN UPDATE TABLE OF CONTENTS ' SECTION/DESCRIPTION PAGE(S) SECTION I: INTRODUCTION 1 SECTION II: PRESENT CONDITIONS 4 A. POPULATION 4 1. Year-round population 5 2. Seasonal Population 8 3. Population Summary 10 4. Social Characteristics and Composition 11 5. Population Projections 11 B. ECONOMY 12 C. EXISTING LAND USE 17 ' 1: Residential 17 2. Commercial 18 3. Governmental/Institutional 18 4. Recreational 18 5. Manufacturing/Industrial Use 18 6. Land Use Compatibility Problems 18 7. 8. Problems from Unplanned Development Areas Likely to Experience Changes in 19 19 Predominant Land Use D. CURRENT PLANS, POLICIES, AND REGULATIONS 19 1. Prior LAMA Land Use Plans 19 2. Transportation 19 ' 3. 4. Water Distribution Plan Waste Treatment Plans 20 20 5. Utilities Extension Policy 20 6. Recreation Policy 20 ' 7. Emergency Response Plan 20 8. Waterfront Access Plan 21 9. Calabash River Dredging Feasibiltiy Study 21 10. Local Regulations and Enforcement 21 ' a. LAMA Permits 21 b. Zoning Ordinance and Zoning Map 22 ' c. Subdivision Regulations d. Septic Tank Regulation 22 22 e. Building Code 23 f. Flood Damage Prevention Ordinance 23 ' 11. Federal and State Regulations 23 i SECTION III: LAND SUITABILITY 24 A. Areas of Environmental Concern 24 ' 1. Coastal Wetlands 24 2. Estuarine Waters 25 3. Estuarine Shorelines 25 4. Public Trust Areas 26 ' B. Flood Hazard Areas 27 C. Estuarine Erosion Areas 27 D. Man-made Hazards 27 ' E. Areas with Soil Limitations 28 F. Sources and Estimated Quality of Water Supply 28 1. Groundwater 28 2. Surface Water Quality 29 G. Closed Shellfishing Areas 29 H. Slopes in Excess of 12 Percent 29 ' I. Fragile Areas 29 1. Natural Resource Fragile Areas 29 2. Cultural Resource Fragile Areas 30 ' J. Areas with Resource Potential 31 1. Agricultural, Forest, and Mining Resources 31 2. Productive Water Bodies 31 3. Non -intensive Outdoor Recreation Lands 31 SECTION IV: CONSTRAINTS - CAPACITY OF COMMUNITY FACILITIES 33 A. Existing Water Service Areas 33 B. Sewer Service Area 34 C. Schools 35 D. Transportation 35 ' E. Solid Waste Collection 36 F. Police Protection 37 G. Fire Protection 37 ' H. Emergency Rescue and Safety 38 I. Recreational Services 38 J. Administrative Services 39 ' SECTION V• LAND USE POLICY STATEMENTS 40 A. Resource Protection 41 1. Areas of Environmental Concern 41 a. Estuarine System 42 (1) Coastal Wetlands 42 (2) Estuarine Waters 42 (3) Estuarine Shoreline 43 (4) Public Trust Areas 43 ' (5) Outstanding Resource Waters 44 b. Ocean Hazards Areas 44 ii 1 2. Other Natural Fragile Areas 44 a. Areas that Sustain Remnant Species 45 b. Prime Wildlife Habitats 45 c. Wooded Swamps and 404 Wetlands 46 d. Maritime Forests 46 e. Significant Archaeological and Historical Resources 46 f. Shellfishing Waters 46 3. Constraints to Development 47 4. Protection of Potable Water Supplies 47 5. Use of Package Treatment Plants 48 6. Stormwater Runoff 48 7. Marina, Bulkhead, and Floating Home 50 Development 8. Industrial Impacts on Fragile Areas 50 9. Development of Sound and Estuarine System 50 Islands 10. Rising Sea Level 51 B. Resource Production and Management 51 .1. Recreational and Fisheries Resources 51 2. The Impact of Residential and Commercial 52 Development on Natural Resources C. Economic and Community Development 52 1. Growth Management 53 2. Types of Development 54 3. Capacity of Existing Facilities and 56 Local Commitment to Providing Services 4. Desired Urban Growth Patterns 57 5. Redevelopment of Developed Areas 57 6. Commitment to State and Federal Programs 57 7. Assistance to Channel Maintenance and 58 Beach Renourishment Policies -8. Energy Facility Siting and Development 58 9. Tourism 58 10. Coastal and Estuarine Beach Access '58 and Parking D. Continuing Public Participation Policies 58 E. Storm Hazard Mitigation, Post -Disaster Recovery, and 60 Evacuation Policies 1. Mitigation 60 2. Evacuation 62 3. Post Disaster and Reconstruction Policies 62 SECTION VI• LAND CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM 65 A. Developed 66 B. Urban Transition 66 C. Conservation 67 I APPENDIX I• PUBLIC PARTICIPATION iii LIST OF TABLES AND MAPS TABLES PAGE Table 2.1: Town of Calabash Annexations, 1973-1994 4 Table 2.2: Year-round Population for the Town of Calabash 6 and Brunswick County, 1970-1990 Table 2.3: Town of Calabash Building Permits, 1982-1993 7 Table 2.4: Year-round Population Estimates for the Town of Calabash, March 1994 8 Table 2.5: Seasonal Residential Population Estimates for the Town of Calabash, 1994 9 Table 2.6: Monthly Golf Players at Championship Golf 10 Courses in Calabash, 1993 Table 2.7: Calabash Planning Area Population Summary, 1994 10 Table 2.8: Residential Population Estimates and Projections for the Town of Calabash Planning Area, 1994-2004 11A Table 2.9: Businesses in Calabash, August 1994 13 Table 2.10: Calabash Assessed Valuations, 1982-1993 16 Table 2.11: 1994 Residential Land Use by Type, March 1994 17 Table 3.1: Soil Characteristics for Calabash 28 A,B Table 4.1: School Membership and Design Capacity, 1994 35 Table 4.2: Average Daily Traffic Counts for Calabash, 36 1984-1993 Map 1: MAPS Location of the Town of Calabash PAGE 3 Map 2: Existing Land Use and Zoning Map, 1994 Attached Map 3: Flood Hazard Areas, 1994 Attached Map 4: Primary Nursery Areas, Spring 1994 32 Map 5: Land Classification Map Attached ' SECTION I: INTRODUCTION The North Carolina Coastal Area Management Act of 1974, better known as "CAMA", requires that the 20 counties located in the State's coastal region and their respective municipalities prepare Land Use Plans. These land use plans, although developed ' according to State -provided guidelines, allow local governments to establish and enforce policies to guide and manage growth and development of their communities. Local land use plans were developed initially in 1974-1976. The plans were to have a 10- year outlook in terms of projecting population, economic, land use, and community facility trends. However, because of the social, economic, and environmental dynamics of the coastal area, the State guidelines required that all plans be updated every five years. Such periodic updates permit local governments to reflect upon previously developed policies to see how they relate to newly emerging trends. Such is the case with the Town of Calabash. The Town of Calabash was first incorporated in 1973 and is located in southeastern Brunswick County as shown on Map 1. The initial LAMA Land Use Plan was adopted and certified in 1989. As indicated in the previous plan, population growth which requires ' an increasing utilization of land and resources, can lead to undesirable consequences if the land and community facilities are unregulated or improperly managed. Calabash, through the development and subsequent updating of its Land Use policy document and enforcement of existing local controls, is seeking to avoid the negative impacts of unmanaged growth. ' This planning document will closely adhere to the CAMA planning guidelines as contained in Subchapter 7B (as amended) of the State Administrative Codes. Four major components which are ' required to be in the Land Use Plan document are as follows: A. Data Collection and Analysis: This is an analysis of the existing patterns and trends within the Town's jurisdiction as far as population, the economy, land use, community facilities, environmental, and other resources. Section II of this report examines the present conditions of Calabash, Section III ' describes the environmental constraints, and Section IV examines the constraints of the community facilities in terms of projected growth. B. Existing Land Use Map: Map 2, which is attached in the back of this report, shows the existing land use of Calabash as of March 1994. C. Policy Discussion and Policy Statements: Based on a thorough analysis of existing conditions, trends, and ' developments, Section V states the policy of the Town on a number of important issues. 2 .D. Land Classification Map: Map 5 is the Land Classification Map and is attached to the back of this report. This map is intended to be a reflection of the Town's land use policies, based upon the projected density of development, for all the lands within its jurisdiction. The land classifications designated on Map 5 are for general reference only, and the final determination of a property's classification is determined by the written description found in the Plan. A number of data sources were utilized in the effort to analyze the population, housing, economic, environmental, and land use conditions in Calabash. Various state, county, and local agencies were contacted for both general and specific detailed information. Technical reports, the previous land use plan, the 1980 and 1990 Census, and other documents were reviewed as well. Extensive efforts were used to obtain citizen participation. In April 1994 a survey was mailed to 325 property owners and businesses in the Town and the extraterritorial jurisdiction (ETJ). This survey had an excellent response rate of 52 percent and the results are included in the Appendix. Issues were further identified during three well -attended public meetings conducted on March 9. May 16, and June 9 1994. The key planning issues identified by public input for the Town of Calabash are listed below: * Need for a public sewer system * Preserve and enhance small town character * Minimize tax rate increase * Commercial development * Annexation Other issues are also identified and addressed in other sections of this planning document. 1 1 1 1 K MAP 1: LOCATION OF THE TOWN OF CALABASH, NC w Ac J cksonvi ile WAR vk i ���aATe �Si 4 1 n SECTION II: PRESBNT CONDITIONS The beginning point of analysis for any Land Use Plan is an assessment of the population trends and patterns. For resort communities like Calabash subject to the seasonal fluctuations of tourists and golfers, this analysis can be rather complicated. However, many land use and growth management policies relate directly to the number of people using local land and facilities at any given moment. The following population analysis offers an overview of Calabash's annexations, a study of the year-round local and regional population, and an assessment of the seasonal visitor population. The Town of Calabash was chartered on May 9, 1973. The town limits were only slightly altered by 5 subsequent annexations. On August 31, 1989, the landmark merger with Carolina Shores quadrupled the geographic area of the Town by adding 877 acres and caused the town population to swell with the addition of 1,186 Carolina Shores residents. Only one satellite annexation of the Town ABC Store has occurred since the 1989 merger. Table 2.1 notes the annexations and merger. YEAR LOCATION 11/13/80 Dixon Property/Corner of Persimmon and Thomasboro 6/22/83 Block of Calabash East and Village Green Subdivision *2/27/84 Lots in Boundary Estate/Deli and Service Station *4/22/85 Victoria's Ragpatch 10/10/87 VFW and Lewellyn-Lewis, Calabash East ----------------------------------------------------------------- 8/31/89 Merger of Calabash and Carolina Shores *10/31/89 Lot in Boundary Estates. Town ABC Store ' * Satellite Annexation Source: Town of Calabash when incorporated in 1973, the Town of Calabash was initially 217 acres. Another 13 acres were added to the Town area with the 5 annexations between 1980 and 1987. The 1989 ' merger with Carolina Shores added 877 acres and the Town of Calabash is now 1,107 acres. At the time of the merger, the Town was divided into two districts: District One which comprises the 5 former Town and District Two which includes Carolina Shores and Carolina Shores Acreage Estates. The Town of Calabash established an extraterritorial jurisdiction (ETJ) on June 13, 1977. The initial ETJ boundaries were done by the Brunswick County Planning Department and consisted of an arc. The ETJ limits were redrawn on May 24, 1988 by using the proper guidelines and an agreement was established with the Town of Sunset Beach in the Bonaparte area where both town ETJ limits meet. The ETJ limits were extended again on to the maximum one -mile limit on August 28, 1990 based on the new town boundaries after the merger. Calabash, like other resort communities, experiences a fluctuation of population according to the season. Although the year-round population of the "original Calabash" has historically been very small, the real population impact upon Calabash is substantially higher. The Town's reputation as the "Seafood Capitol of the World" attracts thousands of visitors from both the Carolinas to its restaurants and shops. The popularity of Calabash's golf courses is steadily growing each year. This report estimates the 1994 year-round population of the Town and its ETJ as well as estimates the seasonal residential population and discusses the impact of "day visitors" who come to Calabash to enjoy its restaurants, shops, and golf courses. The Town was incorporated in 1973 and made its first showing in the 1980 U.S. Census with a permanent population of 140 persons. In 1990, however, the U.S. Census showed a year-round population of 1,210 persons. This extraordinary growth is the result of the merger of the Town of Calabash with the community of Carolina Shores on August 31, 1989. Based on the 1994 land use survey and housing count, it is estimated that the 1994 year- round population within the town limits is 1,432 residents and 1,120 for the ETJ. The March 1994 estimated population for the entire Planning Area is 2,552. Table 2.2 details the 1990 US Census population characteristics for the Town and Brunswick County. BRUNSWICK COUNTY 1970 - 1990 ' PERCENT INCREASE PLACE 1970 1980 1990 1980-1990 ' Calabash -0- 140 1,210 764.2$ Brunswick County 24,223 35,777 50,985 42.5% Township Lockwood Folly 4,748 7,361 10,705 45.4% ' Northwest 3,356 4,657 7,454 60.1% Shallote 4,877 6,582 11,818 79.6%- Smithville 4,346 6,838 9,488 38.8%; ' Town Creek 5,215 8,357 9,260 10.8%; Waccamaw 1,681 1,982 2,260 14.0g ' Source: United States Census, 1970, 1980, and 1990. Town of Calabash LAMA Land Use Plan Update, 1989. The year-round population growth at Calabash is somewhat consistent with the strong overall growth trends in Brunswick County and the neighboring Myrtle Beach-Horry County, SC. Brunswick County grew by 47.7 percent between 1970 and 1980 and ' by 42.5 percent between 1980 and 1990. Over the twenty year period between 1970 and 1990, Brunswick County had a significant population growth of ill percent. As evident by the township ' data, most of Brunswick County's growth occurred in the beach areas and in the mainland adjacent to the Intracoastal Waterway. As a case in point, Calabash, Sunset Beach, and Ocean Isle are located in the Shallotte Township which experienced a 142 percent population increase between 1970 and 1990 and a 79.6 percent increase during the 19801s. Over one-third of Brunswick's County population increase during the 1980's occurred in Shallotte ' Township and the County projects that 56 percent of the 1990's growth will occur in Shallotte Township. ' Dramatic growth has also occurred in the Myrtle Beach-Horry County, SC area which Calabash borders. The population of Horry County, including Myrtle Beach, was 69,992 in 1970; 101,419 in 1980; and 144,053 in 1990. Thus the year-round population of the 1 Myrtle Beach area more than doubled between 1970 and 1990 according to the United States Census. k These growth trends were likewise evident in Calabash as revealed by the building permit data. Notice Table 2.3. Between 1982 and 1993, the Town of Calabash issued a total of 1,087 building permits for both the Town and its ETJ. These permits authorized the construction of an additional 1,172 dwelling units and 59 commercial buildings within the entire Calabash Planning Area. 'One should remember that the Town and ETJ boundaries changed during this time period so that a permit authorized in Carolina Shores prior to August 1989 was considered as an ETJ permit while a permit after August 1989 was included in the Town total. I 7 TABLE 2.3: TOWN OF CALABASH BUILDING PERMITS, 1982 - 1993 PLANNING AREA YEARS.F. M.F.* M.H. COM, S.F. M.F.* M.H. COM, TOTAL 1982 - - - - 6 - 1 4 11 1983 - - - - 66 1 [126] 13 6 86 1984 - - - - 94 - 15 7 116 1985 8 5 6 3 56 - 21 2 101 1986 4 - 2 - 43 - 33 - 82 1987 2 - 2 - 50 - 38 - 92 1988 1 - - 4 79 - 37 5 126 1989 28 - 4 4 6 1 [8] 28 19 90 1990 36 - - - 15 2[14] 37 3 93 1991 36 - 2 - 26 - 21 1 86 1992 38 - - 1 25 - 38 - 102 1993 34 - - - 31 - 37 - 102 TOTAL 187 5 16 12 497 4[148] 319 47 1,087 TOTAL 187 5 16 -- 497 148 319 -- 1,172 D.U. * Multi -family units includes single-family attached units in Carolina Shores Resort, Marsh Harbour, and Belle Croft. [ ] = Number of dwelling units (d.u.) permitted Source: Town of Calabash and 1989 CAMA Land Use Plan Table 2.4 shows the estimated 1994 year-round population for the Town, the ETJ, and the total Calabash Planning Area. For this report, a year-round resident is defined as a person who resides in Calabash at least 6 months a year•. The Town estimates were derived by assuming that growth since the 1990 United States Census was similar to the population and housing characteristics reflected by the Census. The 1990 United States Census reported that 76 percent of all housing units were occupied and that there E] were 2.0 persons per household. It was assumed that these occupancy figures reflected year-round versus seasonal housing usage. Of the total 146 dwelling units built in the Town of Calabash since 1990, it was assumed that 76 percent or 111 units were occupied by year-round residents. This number of 111 year- round units was multiplied by the occupancy ratio of 2.0 persons per household to calculate that an additional 222 year-round residents moved to Calabash since the 1990 United States Census. Consequently, it is estimated that the 1994 year-round population for the Town is 1,432 residents. The 1994 year-round population estimates for the ETJ were derived by the housing count obtained by the March 1994 Land Use Survey. There are no 1990 Unites States population statistics available for the ETJ; consequently, a slightly different methodology had to be developed. The Land Use survey revealed that there are 1,062 single-family housing units including mobile homes in the ETJ. There are an additional 58 multi -family/ townhouse units located in Marsh Harbour, Carolina Shores Resort, and Belle Croft for a total of 1,120 dwelling units in the ETJ. There appears to be a greater occurrence of seasonal housing in the ETJ than within the Town. Consequently, it was assumed that 50 percent, rather than 76 percent, of the ETJ households were used year-round. The same year-round average persons per household of 2.0 was used as for the Town; therefore, it was estimated that there are 1,120 year-round residents in the ETJ. NO. PERSONS YEAR-ROUND AREA NO UNITS PER UNIT POPULATION Town 716 2.0 1,432 ETJ 560 2.0 1,120 TOTAL 1,276 2.0 2,552 Source: Hayes & Associates The seasonal population in Calabash is composed of three groups: 1) out-of-town property owners who use their Calabash residences on the weekends and during the summer; 2) the overnight visitor population who rent condominiums or stay at the Calabash Motel; and 3) "day visitors" who are tourists and golfers who come to Calabash to enjoy its restaurants, shops, or to play a round of golf. Although it is difficult to differentiate between the property owners who reside in Calabash versus the short-term visitor, it is possible to estimate the peak seasonal population. In resort communities like Calabash, vacant housing during the off-season is typically second -property housing utilized by out- of-town owners as either vacation homes or investment rental properties. The 1990 United States Census showed that 24 percent of the Calabash housing was vacant during April 1990. These vacant housing units may be then be assumed to be seasonal ' housing, rather than year-round housing. Occupancy figures for the ETJ were not specified in the Census. However, there appears to be a greater proportion of seasonal housing in the ETJ; ' therefore, it was assumed that 50 percent of all housing in the ETJ was used on a seasonal basis. Table 2.5 details the seasonal housing and residential population. ' TABLE 2.5: SEASONAL RESIDENTIAL POPULATION ESTIMATES FOR THE TOWN OF CALABASH. 1994 NO. PERSONS SEASONAL ' AREA N0, OF UNITS PER UNIT POPULATION Dwelling units 222 2 444 Motel 9 2 18 (TOWN) (231) (462) ETJ 560 2 11120 TOTAL 791 ---- 1,582 Source: Hayes and Associates. The next consideration in the Town's population is the ' number of "day visitors" who come to Calabash to enjoy its restaurants, resort attractions, or to play a round of golf. The "tourist" population has a more short-term impact upon the Town's public facilities and services than the other components ' of the population. The most pronounced impact of this group is upon traffic and parking while the impact upon water and sewer service is noticed through restaurant, retail, and golf clubhouse ' usage. It is rather difficult to estimate the total number of tourist "day visitors" to this resort community. The Town is ' literally flooded each year with thousands of day visitors who may be spending vacations in neighboring beach communities from Myrtle Beach to Wilmington, but who make the pilgrimage to the ' small "Seafood Capitol of the World" to eat in one of the many restaurants and/or browse in the many shops. The 1993 average daily traffic count for NC 179 in the commercial district was 11,000 vehicles a day. This is the "average" year-round count and it is difficult to judge what the maximum traffic count during the peak summer season would be. Some business owners estimate that approximately 12,000 visitors a day come to Calabash during the peak summer season. Statistics from the three championship golf courses give an 1 indication about the number of "golfer day visitors." Table 2.6 1 10 Icites the number of golfers by month for 1993. As shown by the Table 2.6, 141,800 golfers played on the three courses during ' 1993 and the daily average number of "golfer day visitors" was 389 and the monthly average was 11,817. The peak golfing season is from March 15 thru May 15 and from September 15 thru November 15. Consequently, the peak golfing seasons occurs in the ' "tourist shoulder seasons" of the Spring and Fall which helps to extend business year-round. TABLE 2.6: MONTHLY GOLF PLAYERS AT CHAMPIONSHIP GOLF COURSES IN CALABASH. 1993 MONTH NUMBER OF GOLFERS JANUARY 11,900 FEBRUARY 14,550 MARCH 15,300 APRIL 14,800 ' MAY 11,750 JUNE 8,600 ' DULY AUGUST 10,000 9,500 SEPTEMBER 11,650 OCTOBER 13,500 NOVEMBER 11,050 DECEMBER 9,200 TOTAL 141,800 1 DAILY AVERAGE: 389 MONTHLY AVERAGE: 11,817 RANGE: LOW - JUNE 8,600 HIGH - MARCH 15,300 Sources: Marsh Harbour, Ocean Harbour, and Carolina Shores Golf Courses ' 3. Population Summary TABLE 2 7• CALABASH PLANNING AREA POPULATION SUMMARY 1994 EXTRA - POPULATION CORPORATE TERRITORIAL COMPONENT LIMITS JURISDICTION TOTAL Year-round residents 1,432 1,120 2,552 Seasonal 462 1,120 1,582 Subtotal Residential 4,134 1,894 2,240 ' Day Visitors 12,000 12,000 - Daily Golfer Average -- 389 ' TOTAL PEAK POPULATION 16.253 Source: Hayes & Associates. Based on housing count of 1994 Land Use Survey and estimates of day visitors. 11 I 4 Social Characteristics and Population Composition Social characteristics reported in the 1990 United States Census reveal that Calabash town residents generally are older, wealthier, and have recently moved to the area. The composition of the Calabash population in terms of age consists mostly of retirees which is significant in terms of planning purposes. The 1990 Census reported that 42 percent of the Town's population was 65 and over while only 5.6 percent was under 18. Not surprisingly, because of this age characteristic, 10.3 percent of Calabash residents over 16 reported a mobility or self -care limitation. The per capita income for Calabash residents was $16,040 in 1990 as compared to a per capita income of $11,688 for Brunswick County residents and $12,885 for North Carolina residents. The mean retirement income was $17,649. Only 6.0 percent of all persons were estimated to be below the poverty level in Calabash as compared to 15.4 percent for Brunswick County and 13.5 percent for North Carolina. Moreover, Calabash is a town of "newcomers." Only 46 percent of the Town's population had lived in the same residence as of 1985 and the remaining 54 percent were predominantly "newcomers" to the area. Of these, 42 percent had lived outside of North Carolina in 1985. The town residents are predominantly white. There are concentrations of minorities within the extraterritorial jurisdictions, especially in the Shingletree or "Goretown" area. An important aspect of the planning process is forecasting the future population of an area. Unfortunately, population forecasts are usually the least precise element of a land use plan since so many factors such as annexation, the economy, and new development plans directly impact demographic projections. This is especially true for a town like Calabash which has experienced a building boom as well as has expanded its original town limits by 410 percent through the merger and annexations since its original incorporation in 1973. The fluctuating nature of town and extraterritorial limits does not make a good point of reference for long term projections. What will be the Calabash's town limits in 1999 and 2004? A case in point is the population growth of Calabash which is estimated to have occurred from the time the United States Census was taken in April 1990 and the population estimates for March 1994. Based on the 1994 housing survey stated in Table 2.11, 'it is estimated that the March 1994 town year-round population is now 1,432, an increase of 222 persons over a four- year period. An examination of building development explains this growth. Since 1990, building permits have been issued for another 146 dwelling units or an average of 36.5 units per year Residential Population Estimates and Projections for Town of Calabash Planning Area,1994-2004 1994 1999 2004 Net Population Gain 1994-2004 Percent Change 1994-2004 Town Extra -Territorial Jurisdiction *Year Seasonal Total *Year Seasonal Total Round Round 1 A32 462 1,894 1,120 1,120 2,240 1,706 553 2,259 1 A25 1 A25 2,850 11980 644 2,624 1,730 1,730 3 A60 +548 +182 +730 +610 +610 +1220 +38.3% +39.4% +38.5% +54.5% +54.5% +54.5% *Resident who lives in Calabash area for at least 6 months or longer Source: Hayes & Associates Planning Area *Year Seasonal Total Round 2,552 1,582 4,134 3,131 1,978 5,109 3,710 2,374 6,084 +1,158 +792 +1950 +45.5% +50.1 % +47.2% Residential Population Estimates and Projections for Town of Calabash Planning Area, 1994-2004 0:1 K-i � 11 WI c 0 a 0.. 1111111111111KNO's] M M Al 1994 1999 2004 ■ year round ED seasonal ® total 1 12 11 which helps to explain the year-round population growth of 17.5 percent for the Town. In the ETJ an additional 244 dwelling units were built between 1990 and 1994. The ETJ averaged 61 dwelling units a year. For projection purposes, it was assumed that these building trends of an average of 36.5 new dwelling units in the Town and 61 new dwelling units in the ETJ would continue over the next five to ten years. It was also assumed that the household size and occupancy statistics exhibited in the 1990 US Census which were used to derive 1994 population estimates would continue as well. Table 2.8 and Diagram 2.1 shows the year-round and seasonal residential population projections for the Town, the ETJ, and the Planning Area for the years 1999 and 2004. Based on these assumptions, the Calabash Planning Area would have 3,710 year-round residents and 2,374 seasonal residents within ten years which is a net residential population increase of 47.2 percent. As Table 2.8 reveals, the residential population will continue to grow.steadily, contributing to the demand for land, utilities, and other public services. Moreover, these projections do not include the transient "day visitor" population, which would still be substantially higher than the residential population during the peak summer season. B. ECONOMY The resort characteristics of Calabash's I little since the 1989 Land Use Plan Update. dependent upon the restaurant district, real tourism, golfing, and travel. Calabash lies ' South Carolina boundary and the town's reput golfing attracts visitors from Myrtle Beach towns in Brunswick County. economy has changed The economy is still estate development, just across the ation for seafood and as well as beach Calabash's economic base consists mainly of services such as the restaurants, gift and speciality shops, a motel, and privately -owned recreational facilities which include the three championship golf courses, commercial and charter fishing, and marinas. Table 2.9 lists the 73 businesses within the town limits and the 53 businesses in the ETJ as of August 1994. Services are generally geared toward the traveling and vacationing public and, as such, the businesses are financially dependent upon the seasonal flow of visitors. The summer population influx also produces what is, by in large, a seasonal economy. However, more and more restaurants and businesses are staying open year-round because of the area's increasing number of permanent residents and the increasing popularity of tourism and golfing in the "shoulder" and winter seasons. In fact, 92 percent of Calabash's businesses are now open year-round as shown on Table 2.9. This is, indeed, a marked contrast to ten years ago when most businesses in Calabash were closed during the off- season. 13 TABLE 2 9 A• BUSINESSES IN CALABASH. AUGUST 1994 ' BUSINESSES IN THE INCORPORATED AREA *1. B & W Nursery and Landscaping *2. Bad Habit Deep Sea Fishing ' *3. Batchelor Sales *4. Beck's Seafood Restaurant *5. Bennett's Seafood Kitchen *6. Betty's Antiques & Collectible ' *7. Calabash A B C Board *8. Calabash Bakery and Deli *9. Calabash Deli ' *10. Calabash Florist *11. Calabash Golf Ball Outlet *12. Calabash Marina *13. Calabash Motel *14. Calabash Old World Coins *15. Calabash Photo Studio *16. Calabash Seafood House ' *17. Calabash Seafood Hut *18. Calabash Small Engine Repair *19. Calabash True Value Hardware *20. Callahan's Pro Shop *21. Callahan's of Calabash *22. Captain Jim's Marina- Fishing and Ocean Cruises >23. Captain John's Seafood House ' *24. Captain Nance Calabash Seafood +25. Captain Sam's Deep Sea Fishing and Ocean Cruises *26. *27. Carolina Golf Balls Carolina Blythe Utility- *28. Carolina Shores Golf Course *29. Cypress Dental.Lab *30. Cypress Jewelry - Repairs and Design ' *31. Don's Plumbing.and Water Service *32. Derbster's Restaurant & Tavern *33. Dockside Seafood House *34. Duncan & Associates Accountants *35. Eastside Calabash Restaurant *36. Ella's Restaurant ' *37. Gingerbread House Too!!! >38. Haley's Restaurant +39. Igloo *40. J & R Gifts & Crafts *41. J.M. Sports *42. Jimmy's Pantry ' *43. L & L Wings Larry's Calabash Seafood Restaurant >44. * = Open Year-round > = Open summer season, only weekends during shoulder season + = Only open summer season I Source: Town of Calabash 1 E 14 f! TABLE 2.9 continued: BUSINESSES IN CALABASH AUGUST 1994 *45. Lewellyn-Lewis Builders *46. Lewellyn Reality *47. Maxx Hair Gallery *48. Mole Hole, Inc. *49. Moore's Grocery *50. Murphy's Construction *51. Nations Realty *52. 19th Green Tavern and Grill >53. Ocean Atlantic,Inc. *54. One Hour Photo +55. Original Calabash Restaurant *56. Pawn and Antiques +57. Red Snapper. Charter Boat *58. RPI Computer Sales & Service *59. Santa's Attic +60. Scoby Do Ice Cream Shop *61. Seaside Animal Care, P A *62. Sheila's Country Kitchen *63. Simmons Beverage Mart & Grocery *64. Simply Shaker Manufacturing *65. The Carousel, Inc. *66. The Photo Shop *67. The Loft *68. Thomas Seafood Restaurant *69. Tony's Kwik Mart *70. Tony's Pizza *71. Trawlers Restaurant *72. United Carolina Bank *73. Victoria's Ragpatch *74. William Temple Allen, CPA, PA *75. Wings 1 _ ►I ► a 4:I: :4s44- : V :4 .1 Za 6 li• ' 1I1' • •� • s *76. Art Plus Gallery *77. Bagel Cafe *78. Calabash Barber Shop >79. Calabash Putt *80. Carbo's Club *81. Carolina Shores Resort *82. Carolina Travel Agency *83. Century 21 Real Estate * = Open Year-round > = Open summer season, only + = Only open summer season Source: Town of Calabash weekends during shoulder season 15 I TABLE 2.9 continued: BUSINESSES IN CALABASH, AUGUST 1994 *84. Citgo Service Station *85. Cutting Deck Hair *86. Dr. Charles F. Loomis- Chiropractic Clinic *87. Dr. Cheek and Dr. Deeb Family Dentistry *88. Dr. Chris Moshourres Optometrist *89. Dr. George L. Saunders, MD *90. Elizabeth Newman's Ladies Apparel Outlet *91. ERA Realty- Callahan, Teal, & Skelly Associates, Inc. *92. Everpure Water Treatment *93. Furniture Patch of Calabash >94. Granny's Ice Cream *95. Hearing Associates *96. Hinkle Brothers Factory Store *97. HJ's Marketing Company *98. Jeffcoat & Pike Attorneys *99. La Coquille Hair Design and Natural Nail *100. Lil Donut Factory *101. London Hair Company *102. Low County Jewelers of Calabash *103. Magnolia Lane Gallery *104. Mama Brava's Italian Pizza Cafe *105. Marsh Harbour Golf Links *106. Marsh Harbour Marina *107. Moonlight & Memories- CDs and Cassettes *108. Nations Bank *109. North Strand Medical Consultants *110. Oceanside Corporation *111. Pacific Beachwear *112._Pinehurst Builders and Realtors *113. Sandollar Reality *114. Seashore Pharmacy *115. Security Savings Bank *116. Simply Shaker Furniture *117. Tee Beaus Designer Western Wear *118. The Book Nook *119. The Calabash Gallery *120. United States Post Office *121. Waltons Accounting Service * = Open Year-round > = Open summer season and only weekends during shoulder season + = Open only during summer season Source: Town of Calabash 1 16 Not surprisingly, there are no agricultural, farming, or forestry uses within Calabash's town limits. Simply Shaker ' Manufacturing is a small furniture production use operating within the Town. There is one industrial site, Kool-A-Brew, and two farming operations in the extraterritorial jurisdiction. Restaurants, real estate development, and golfing are still the most significant factors in the resort community's economy. Moreover, the impact of the three championship golf courses is also significant as shown by the fact that 141,800 golfers used the three courses located within the Calabash Planning Area during 1993. These golfing statistics do not include the impact of the 9 additional golf courses located just 3 miles away from ' Calabash. Golfing is, indeed, a regional economic factor for the Myrtle Beach -Brunswick County area. The impact of golfing is growing even more significant as more and more golfers are taking advantage of special "winter packages" thus bringing more people to the area during the traditional off-season. The continuing real estate development and sales in the Town will most likely foster a continual growth in the number of permanent residents. As permanent residents increase, the demand for local services also increases. As local commercial services and activities increase, the Town may witness even more expansion of its economic base. Another indication of the significant and continuing growth trend of the Town's economy is the growth in property valuations in recent years. Notice Table 2.10: TABLE 2 10• CALABASH ASSESSED VALUATIONS 1982-1994 TAX ASSESSED PERCENT YEAR RATE VALUATIONS CHANGE 1982 $ 6,017,527 -- 1983 $ 6,290,020 4.53 1984 $ 7,055,239 12.20 1985 $ 7,832,589 11.02 1986* $ 16,293,350 108.02 1987** $ 16,236,584 -0.35 1988 .230 $ 16,329,864 .58 1989 .240 $ 16,531,471 1.24 1990 .150 $ 16,679,866 .90 Merger 1991 .105 $ 88,502,580 430.60 1992 .095 $ 91,241,893 3.10 1993 .095 $ 94,693,424 3.78 1994* .085 $ 114,770,606 21.20 Source: Town of Calabash * Years of Re -valuation ** Loss of personal property valuation and two businesses burned r 17 'C. EXISTING ' Although the town boundaries and land area have changed significantly since the 1989 Land Use Plan, the actual land use patterns in the Calabash area has basically stayed the same. The ' Town of Calabash quadrupled in size when it merged with Carolina Shores in August, 1989. The former mixed uses of the restaurant/downtown area are now combined with the 877 acre Carolina Shores golf course residential community. Notice Map 2, the 1994 Land Use Map, which shows the 1994 land use and zoning patterns and is attached in the back of this report. 1. Residential Land Uses Most of the residential land uses in Calabash consists of single-family homes including mobile homes. Table 2.11 shows the type of housing and vacant platted residential lots for the Town and ETJ. Eighty-nine percent of all dwelling units within the Calabash Planning Area are single-family homes. Many of the multi -family units are condominiums which are individually owned, but some of which are rented out on a short-term basis or are used as time share units. In this capacity, many of these condominiums actually function more like a motel in terms of housing use. There are still a substantial amount of vacant platted residential lots available in Calabash. Nearly 60 percent of all platted lots in the Town have been developed thus far while only 37.7 percent of the platted lots in the ETJ have been developed. ' Many of these vacant lots outside of the Carolina Blythe sewer service area have not been developed because the lot is deemed unsuitable to obtain a septic tank permit. Moreover, there are 1 still large tracts of land in the ETJ which have not yet been subdivided. Consequently, there is significant amount of vacant residential land left in the Calabash Planning Area which could ' be developed, especially if centralized sewer becomes available. TABLE 2.11: RESIDENTIAL LAND USE BY TYPE, MARCH 1994 ' TYPE TOWN ETJ PLANNING AREA DEVELOPED Single-family 749 1,062 1,811 Multi -family* 155 58 213 ' TOTAL DEVELOPED Motel 9 9 2,033 913 1,120 VACANT PLATTED LOTS 627 1,852 2,479 TOTAL RESIDENTIAL LOTS 1,540 2,972 4,512 ' PERCENT DEVELOPED 59.3% 37.7% 45.1% * Multi -family includes condominiums and town houses some of which are rented on a short-term basis or used as time-share ' units. Source: 1994 Land Use Survey 1 18 2. Commercial Land Uses ' Most of the businesses located within the Town limits are restaurants and retail shops. There is a strip commercial development along NC 179, which is the main thoroughfare running ' through Town. Most of the restaurants are located along Riverview Road and Oak Street which run south of NC 179 towards the Calabash River. ' 3. Government and Institutional Uses There are a total of 9 lots currently utilized for ' governmental and institutional purposes, including the Town Hall, the Calabash Volunteer Fire Department, the Calabash EMS Station, the United States Post Office, two fraternal lodges, two ' churches, and a utility substation. The Town of Calabash has purchased 10 acres located on Persimmon Road which is intended as the future site of a new Town Hall. ' 4. Recreational Uses There are no public recreational lands within Calabash's ' jurisdiction. Private recreation uses include the private pools, tennis courts, and other facilities located in many of Calabash's subdivisions; the three championship golf courses of Carolina ' Shores, Marsh Harbour, and Ocean Harbour; and the commercial "Wacky Golf" establishment located on NC 179 in the "downtown" area. There are also two private campgrounds and two marinas. ' 5 Manufacturing/ Industrial Use Two small manufacturing uses, Simply Shaker Manufacturing ' and Kool-A-Brew, are located within the Planning Area. 6. Land Compatibility Problems In the conventional land use planning concept, a land compatibility problem is generally identified as when two or more land uses are adjacent to each other and one use is somehow ' restricted from expansion because of the adverse conditions caused by the other use which discourages additional investment. This concept also extends to a mixture of uses such as ' residential, commercial, and industrial which are not usually not considered compatible with each other. Most of the development in the original Town of Calabash was built prior to the enactment of land use controls and there are numerous instances of a residence being located next to a restaurant or store. In many cases, this mixed use pattern was the result of a business owners wanting to live next to their restaurant or shop. Today this ' pattern continues and one can find private residences within the hustle and bustle of "Restaurant Row." This traditional mix of residential and commercial uses is now recognized as part of the 1 19 ' "character" of Calabash and permitted in the "Mixed District" zoning classification. t7 Problems from Unplanned Development Several problems have resulted from the fact that most of the Calabash area was developed without the benefit of subdivision and zoning regulations. Development was built with little regard to stormwater management and the increased ' pollutant loading from stormwater runoff impacts the quality of Calabash's waters. Many of the restaurants and retail establishments have inadequate and poorly planned parking facilities. Many subdivisions are a mixture of older mobile ' homes and conventional housing. Some streets do not meet any minimal standards. ' u Areas Likely to Experience Changes in Predominant Land Use Vacant land areas, especially several large tracts in the ' ETJ, are the areas most likely to experience land use changes over the next 5 to 10 years. Development will be more likely if centralized sewer is extended to these tracts. It is also likely that housing will be built along the Marsh Harbour and Ocean ' Harbour Golf Courses as originally planned. Provision of sewer to the downtown commercial area may result in some redevelopment. Many speculate that several hotels may be built in the downtown ' area. There is considerable amount of vacant land along US 17 which will probably be developed over the next 5 to 10 years. D. CURRENT PLANS POLICIES AND REGULATIONS ' 1. Prior CAMA Land Use Plans ' The Town of Calabash had its first CAMA Land Use Plan prepared in 1988. In both 1976 and 1981, the Town was included as part of the Brunswick County's Plans. The 1994 CAMA land Use ' Plan Update is the first plan to be completed after the merger of Calabash in 1989. 2. Transportation ' The most significant feature of North Carolina's Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) pertaining to Calabash ' is the proposed widening of NC 179 to a three lane curb and gutter roadway from the South Carolina state line to Clariday Road (SR 1164) north of Calabash. The right-of-way and construction is scheduled to begin in 1995. The current widening ' of US 17 to a four -lane divided highway improves access to Calabash. There are no other major road improvements for Calabash included in the 1993-1999 TIP. The 1988 Brunswick ' County Thoroughfare Plan contained no road improvements for the immediate Calabash area, except for the widening of US 17 to a four -lane divided highway. ' 20 ' 3. Water Distribution Plan Most of Calabash outside of Carolina Shores is now a part of the Brunswick County Water System. Until June 1988, Calabash did not have centralized water within the Town limits. Throughout the previous years, businesses and residencies alike relied on ' private wells for water. However, in June 1988, the Town began purchasing water from the Brunswick County Water System as several other nearby communities such as Sunset Beach and Ocean ' Isle had been doing. However, there are still some private wells in use. ' The large Carolina Shores development and some other neighboring subdivisions have access to a centralized water and sewer system from Carolina Blythe, a private utility company which is based in Florence, South Carolina. ' 4. Waste Treatment Plans ' Calabash outside of the Carolina Blythe service area still relies on ground absorption systems for all sewage disposal as permitted by the Brunswick County Health Department. The Town of Calabash is investigating the need for a centralized sewer ' system. -In 1991, the Town commissioned the consulting firms of Powell Associates and Piedmont Olsen Hensley to perform a Comprehensive Wastewater Study of the town and surrounding area. ' As a result of the study, the Towns of Calabash and Sunset Beach formed the Southwest Brunswick Regional Water and Sewer Authority which is in the process of implementing sewer service to the ' region. The Calabash Board of Commissioners is also pursuing other means of providing centralized sewer services to the areas of Town not currently served by Carolina Blythe. ' 5. Utilities Extension Policy The Town's policy concerning extending waterlines to newly developed areas is for the developer to pay all costs of extension and installation. After construction, all the lines become the Town's property. ' 6. Recreation Policy Currently, the Town does not have a formal recreation policy and does not operate parks, public boat accesses, or similar public recreational facilities. Many of the subdivisions within Calabash offer pools, tennis courts, and playgrounds for private ' use by the neighborhood residents. The three championship golf courses within the Calabash Planning Area are open to the public. 21 7. Emergency Response Plan The Town of Calabash does not have a local emergency response plan and relies upon the Brunswick County Emergency Response Plan and Procedures. 8. Water Access Plan In 1992, a Waterfront Access Plan was prepared for the Town of Calabash. The plan was funded, in part, through a grant provided by the North Carolina Coastal Management Program. The Plan suggested ways that the Town of Calabash could improve public waterfront access for both residents and visitors. 9. Calabash River Dredging Feasibility Study ' In 1994 the Town of Calabash contracted with the Army Corps of Engineers to conduct a feasibility study concerning the proposed dredging of the Calabash River. 14, Local Regulations and Enforcement Provisions The Town of Calabash has recently codified its local ' ordinances in order to improve administration. The Town of Calabash employs a Code Enforcement/Fire Inspector and Building Inspector to administer the land use regulations. ' (a) LAMA Permits Because of Calabash's location and geographic features, only ' new development along the Calabash River and the Intracoastal Waterway is regulated by the CAMA permit process. The Areas of Environmental Concern described in the forthcoming section are ' areas which need protection. Enforcement of the CAMA permit process is a major means of that protection and is currently administered by the State CAMA officers in Wilmington. Eventually, the Town plans for the Building Inspector to become certified to issue the LAMA permits. 22 ' (b) Zoning Ordinance and Zoning Map Calabash adopted a Zoning Ordinance and Map in September, 1982. The original ordinance originally established six use districts (three for residential, one for commercial uses, a "conservation" district, and an agricultural district.) The ' current Zoning Ordinance now has the following 13 districts: (1) R15 - Residential District; ' (2) R8 - Residential District; (3) R6 - Residential District; (4) MFH - Manufactured Home District I; (5) MD - Mixed District; ' (6) CB - Central Business District; (7) HC - Highway Commercial District; (8) AD - Agricultural District; ' (9) ID - Industrial District, Light (10) MFH II - Manufactured Home District II; (11) MFH II P - Manufactured Home Parks; ' (12) CD - Conservation District; and, (13) PUD - Planned Unit Development. The Building Inspector likewise functions as the Zoning Officer. In conjunction with the Zoning Ordinance, the Town also has a Planning Board and a Board of Adjustment as well as employs a Code Enforcement/Fire Inspector. ' (c) Subdivision Regulations As of November 11, 1993, the Town of Calabash adopted subdivision regulations, which have been utilized to guide the general design of newly developing areas within the Town's jurisdiction. A subdivision is the division of any parcel or tract of land into two or more lots for the purpose of development. The purpose of this ordinance is to establish procedures and standards for the development and subdivision of ' land within the territorial jurisdiction of the Town of,Calabash. It is further designed to provide for the orderly growth and development of the Town and for the coordination of streets and highways within proposed subdivisions with the existing or ' planned streets and community facilities. The Calabash Planning Board reviews all subdivision plats and makes recommendations to the Board of Commissioners. ' i Septic Tank'Regulation Large areas within Calabash outside of Carolina Shores are served by ground absorption waste disposal systems that are permitted by the Brunswick County Health Department. Any system generating more than 3,000 gallons of waste per day is designed ' by engineers and submitted to the North Carolina Department of Human Resources for approval. Building permits are not issued until a septic tank permit or an approved site plan is presented. ' A final inspection is not given or a certificate of occupancy ' 23 ' completed until an inspection slip from the Health Department is in the Town file indicating that the waste disposal system was ' installed as permitted. (e) Building Code ' In 1982, the Town of Calabash adopted the N.C. State Building Code and revised the local building code on November 3, 1993. The Town Building Inspector issues building permits and ' inspects construction to ensure strict compliance with all code requirements. (f) Flood Damage Prevention Ordinance ' Calabash, unlike most other communities in Brunswick County, did not participate in the emergency phase of the Federal Flood Insurance Program in the 19701s. As of February 4, 1988, Calabash adopted a Flood Damage Prevention Ordinance and began participating in the Regular Phase of the Federal Flood Insurance ' Program. First floor building elevation requirements is 13 feet in the 11AE1' zone along the Calabash River. The Flood Ordinance is enforced as part of the Town's building permit program. The Town Building Inspector is also the enforcement officer. ' 11. Federal and State Regulations In addition to the local ordinances and county regulations listed and described above, there are also various state and federal regulations which could also affect land development in I Calabash. An important consideration is the consistency review required to be performed by federal and state authorities as mandated by the Federal Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972, the North Carolina Coastal Zone Management Act (CAMA), and the NC ' Executive Order 15 issued by Governor Hunt in 1977. Application for federal and state permits as well as acquisition, use, and disposition of lands in the coastal areas must be consistent with ' the North Carolina Coastal Management Plan, including the CAMA local land use plans such as this one for the Town of Calabash 24 SECTION III: LAND SUITABILITY Development in a community such as Calabash is often limited by constraints, factors which preclude or place restrictions on development. This section identifies possible features of the land or landscape which limit or could pose serious constraints to development such as Areas of Environmental Concern, flood hazard areas, estuarine erosion areas, man-made hazards, areas with soil limitations, sources of water supply, natural resource fragile areas, and areas with resource potential. One of the most significant aspects of the legislation which created CAMA was the designation of special "Areas of Environmental Concern" (AECS). These areas which are defined in the NC state statues require special protective consideration as far as land use planning is concerned. AECS are further designated under two major groupings, the Estuarine System and the Ocean Hazard AECS. Because of its interior mainland location, Calabash has only Estuarine System AECS which are described below. All development and development -related activity within Calabash's designated AECS is currently regulated by the Coastal Area Management Act permit process. The Estuarine System AECS include Coastal Wetlands, Estuarine Waters, Estuarine Shorelines, and Public Trust Areas. The recently created Outstanding Resource Waters designation does not pertain to Calabash. These areas and their general occurrence in Calabash are discussed as follows: These areas are defined as any salt marsh or other marsh subject to regular or occasional flooding by tides, including wind tides (whether or not the tide waters reach the marshland ' areas through natural or artificial water courses), but not including hurricane or tropical storm tides. Salt marsh or other marsh shall be those areas which grow some but not necessarily all of the following salt marsh and marsh species: Smooth or ' Salt Water Cordgrass; Black Needlerush; Glasswort; Slat -Meadow Grass; Sea Lavender; Bulrush; Saw Grass; and Salt Weed Grass. In Calabash, coastal wetlands generally occur in the marsh areas ' along both sides of the Calabash River and along the small section of the Intracoastal Waterway which is located in the Calabash ETJ. ' These wetlands along our coast serve as a critical part of the ecosystem. Estuarine dependent species like fish and shellfish make up over 90 percent of the total value of North ' Carolina's commercial catch. These coastal wetlands should be considered unsuitable for all development and for those land uses which alter their natural functions. Inappropriate land uses ' include, but are not limited to the following examples: 25 ' restaurants and businesses; residences; apartments, motels, hotels, and trailer parks; parking lots and offices; spoil and dump sites; wastewater lagoons; public and private roads and highways; and factories. Examples of acceptable land uses may include utility easements, fishing piers, docks, and certain agricultural uses, except when excavation or filling of navigable ' waters is involved. 2. Estuarine Waters ' This AEC is defined as all the waters of the Atlantic Ocean and the bays, sounds, rivers, and tributaries thereto, seaward of the dividing line between coastal fishing waters and inland ' fishing waters. The North Carolina Marine Fisheries Commission classifies waterways as being either coastal, joint, or inland waters. Only coastal and joint waters are designated as estuarine waters. The Calabash River and the Intracoastal Waterway are designated as being Estuarine Waters AEC. The high productivity associated with the estuary results from its unique circulation patterns caused by tidal energy, fresh water flow, and shallow depth. The nutrient trapping mechanisms add protection to the many organisms. The circulation ' pattern of estuarine waters performs a number of important functions, including transporting nutrients, propelling the plankton, spreading seed stages of fish and shellfish, flushing ' wastes from animal and plant life, cleaning the system of pollutants, controlling salinity, shifting sediments, and mixing the water to create a multitude of habitats. ' Secondary benefits include commercial and sports fisheries, waterfowl hunting, processing operations, and tourist -related industries. In addition, there is considerable non -monetary value associated with aesthetics, recreation, and education. (15 7H .206) Appropriate uses in and around estuarine waters are those which preserve the estuarine waters so to safeguard and perpetuate their biological, economic and aesthetic values. Highest priority is to be allocated to the conservation of estuarine waters. Second priority may be given to water dependent uses such as navigable channels, piers and docks, and mooring pilings, provided that they do not directly or indirectly ' block or impair existing navigation channels, increase shoreline erosion, deposit patterns, violate water quality standards or cause degradation of shellfish waters. ' 3. Estuarine Shorelines Estuarine shorelines, although characterized as dry land, ' are considered a component of the estuarine system because of the close association with the adjacent estuarine waters. Estuarine shorelines are those non -ocean shorelines which are especially ' vulnerable to erosion, flooding, or other adverse effects of wind 26 ' and water and are intimately connected to the estuary. The extent of the estuarine shoreline area extend from the mean high water level or normal water level along the estuaries, sounds, bays, and brackish waters as adopted by the Wildlife Resources Commission of the NC Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources, for a distance of 75 feet landward. ' As previousily discussed, the Calabash River and Intracoastal Waterway are classified as Estuarine Waters AEC; ' therefore, the shorelines of these water systems and 75 feet landward are the estuarine shorelines in Calabash. Because development within the estuarine shoreline AEC can harm the marshland and estuarine waters, and because of the inherent ' dynamic and hazardous nature of coastal shorelines, specific standards have been adopted by the State for construction in these areas as outlined in NCAC T 1507H.029. A CAMA permit must also be obtained. By regulation all projects cannot weaken natural barriers to erosion, shall have limited impervious surfaces, and shall take measures to prevent pollution of the estuary by sedimentation and runoff. 4. Public Trust Areas ' These are described as (1) all the waters of the Atlantic Ocean and the lands thereunder from the mean high water mark to the seaward limit of state jurisdiction; (2) all natural ' bodies of water subject to measurable lunar tides and lands thereunder to the mean high water mark; (3) all navigable natural bodies of water and land thereunder to the mean high water level or mean water level as the case may be, except privately -owned lakes to which the public has no right of access; (4) all water in artificially created bodies of water containing significant public fishing resources or other public resources which are accessible to the public by navigation; and (5) all waters in artificially created bodies of water in which the public has acquired rights by prescription, custom, usage, dedication or any public means. Public trust areas in Calabash are the Calabash River and the Intracoastal Waterway. The significance of the public trust ' areas is that the public has rights to them, including navigation and recreation. In addition, these public trust areas support valuable commercial and sports fisheries, have aesthetic value, ., and are important resources for economic development. (15 7H .0207) ' The State allows appropriate private development within public trust areas, provided the development is not detrimental to the environment or to public access. Navigation channels, piers, marinas, and bulkheads to control erosion are examples of ' uses which may be found acceptable. 1 27 IB. FLOOD HAZARD AREAS There is potential for flooding along the lower elevation areas bordering the Calabash River and the Intracoastal Waterway. As of February 4, 1988 Calabash began participation in the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) flood insurance ' program. The Flood Ordinance is enforced as part of the Town's building permit program as administered by the Building Inspector. Map 3, which is attached, shows the general location ' of Calabash's flood hazard areas and there are three classifications which are pertinent: ' Zone VE: The VE zone corresponds to the 100-year coastal floodplains which have additional hazards associated with storm waves. Based on detailed hydraulic analysis, FEMA projects that floodwaters during a 100-year storm could reach depths of 16 feet ' (i.e. base flood elevations). The lowest elevation land bordering the Intracoastal Waterway in the Calabash ETJ is designated as being a VE zone. I 0 ZONE AE: These areas are within the 100-year floodplain and have a base flood elevation of 13 feet. Land bordering both sides of the Calabash River with elevations ranging up to 13 feet are designated by FEMA as being in the AE Zone as well as some land bordering the Intracoastal Waterway. Currently, some riverside restaurants, the marina and dry boat storage area, and some residences along Oak Street and River View Drive as well as some residences along River Drive are located in the AE Zone. The last time that major flood damage occurred was during Hurricane Hazel in 1954. ZONE X: These areas are designated as light gray on the FEMA flood insurance maps. These Zone X areas correspond to the 500-year floodplain or areas of the 100-year flooding where depths are less than one -foot [which would be areas of minimal flooding during a 100-year storm.]. Small pockets of Zone X border some parts of the AE Zone along the Calabash River. Calabash has extensive marshes bordering its estuarine shorelines which protects the shorelines from erosion. There are no known man-made hazards in Calabash prohibiting development. However, the maintenance of golf courses requires application -of pesticides, nematicides, herbicides, and other chemicals and the on -site storage of these chemicals could pose a threat if not handled properly or in the event of a fire or accidental spill. The three Calabash golf courses take proper safety precautions by maintaining the chemicals in storage sheds and by maintaining a minimum supply as needed. The Calabash Fire Department maintains an inventory of the chemicals stored at each 17 28 ' golf course and has plans on how to contain an accident or fire until additional assistance arrives. ' E. AREAS WITH SOIL LIMITATIONS A soil survey and maps for Brunswick County was completed in ' 1986 by the U.S. Department of Agriculture Soil Conservation Service. The report contains detailed descriptions and maps of the soil types and properties for Brunswick County with the ' discussions of the suitability for various uses such as dwellings without basements, septic tank absorption, sanitary landfills, and recreation. Soil maps for the Calabash Planning Area are shown on Sheet 14 and on insets on Sheets 13 and 17 of this soil ' survey report. Soils in Calabash are typical of those found in coastal ' floodplains, marshes, and uplands. Table 3.1 lists the general characteristics of the twenty-two soil types found in Calabash and discusses their suitability for dwellings without basements ' and septic tank absorption. This Table shows that the soils in Calabash are typical of the rest of Brunswick County. Most of these soils are poorly drained and subject to high water tables or frequent flooding. Eleven out of the 22 soils have severe ' structural foundation limitations for dwellings without basements. Nineteen out of the 22 soil types have severe limitations for septic tank absorption because of wetness, ' flooding, ponding, or poor filter characteristics. While these characteristics do not preclude development, these soil characteristics do suggest that a careful site investigation be ' conducted by competent, qualified persons before development begins or commitments are made. The lack of soils generally suitable for septic tank ' placement is a major concern for Calabash. Currently, approximately 45 percent of the Town, including the commercial\mixed uses of District I and most of Carolina Shores ' Acreage Estates, does not have a centralized sewer system. Many residential areas in the ETJ rely on septic tanks as well. However, the general declaration of limitations does not mean that sites within these soil types are absolutely unsuitable. Individual on -site investigations must be conducted to determine final suitability. The Brunswick County Health Department issues permits for septic tanks if all applicable county, state, and ' federal regulations are met. A final decision is based on soil testing and other site requirements as determined by local subdivision and zoning requirements. ' F. SOURCES AND ESTIMATED QUANTITY OF WATER SUPPLY 1. Groundwater ' Most Calabash residents and businesses purchase their water from either Carolina Blythe or the Brunswick County Water System. ' Few remaining households in Calabash now use private wells and ' 28 a ITABLE 3 1-A• SOIL CHARACTERISTICS FOR CALABASH ' SOIL TYPES GENERAL DWELLINGS CHARACTERISTICS WITHOUT BASEMENTS SEPTIC TANK ABSORPTION ' Baymeade Gently sloping soils on Slight Moderate lower coastal plains ' Blanton Moderately well drained Slight Moderate sandy soil of interstream ' areas Bohicket Poorly drained soils in Severe Severe coastal marshes ' Foreston Nearly level, well drained Slight Severe soils in interstream areas ' Goldsboro* Moderately well drained Moderate Severe soils on uplands ' Grifton++ Poorly drained soils Severe Severe on uplands Johns++ Poorly to moderately well Moderate Severe ' drained soils on stream terraces . ' Kureb Excessively drained soils Slight Severe on uplands Leon Nearly level, poorly drained Severe Severe ' soils in interstream areas Lumbee++ Poorly drained soils on Severe Severe ' stream terraces Lynchburg++ Poorly drained soils on Severe Severe ' uplands Mandarin Nearly level, poorly drained Moderate Severe ' soils on uplands ' * Prime Farmland Soil ++ Prime Drained Farmland Soil ' Source: U.S.D.A., Soil Survey of Brunswick County. NC November 1986. Brunswick County Soil and Water Conservation Service TABLE 3.1-B: SOIL CHARACTERISTICS FOR CALABASH SOIL TYPES GENERAL DWELLINGS SEPTIC CHARACTERISTICS WITHOUT BASEMENTS TANK ABSORPTION Muckalee Poorly drained soils on Severe Severe low flood plains Murville Poorly drained soils on Severe Severe upland depressions Norfolk* Well drained soils on Slight Moderate uplands Pactolus Nearly level and gently Moderate Severe sloping with moderate and poorly drained soils Pantego++ Poorly drained soils on Severe Severe uplands . Rains++ Poorly drained soils on Severe Severe uplands Tomahawk Poorly to moderately well Moderate Severe drained soils on uplands Torhunta++ Poorly drained soils on Severe Severe uplands and stream terraces Wando Excessively drained soils Slight Severe in interstream areas Woodington++ Poorly drained soils on Severe Severe uplands * Prime Farmland Soil ++ Prime Drained Farmland Soil Source: U.S.D.A., Soil Survey of Brunswick County NC November 1986. Brunswick County Soil and Water Conservation Service. ' 29 ' these remaining wells pose no physical limitations to development. All three golf courses utilize ponds to capture rainfall as their major source of water for their sprinkling systems. Two courses do utilize freshwater wells as a back-up supply to water their grounds. ' 2. Surface Water Ouality In November 1991, the North Carolina Department of ' Environment, Health, and Natural Resources issued a report for the waters of the Lumber River Basin which includes the classification of the Calabash River. The Calabash River along its entire length and the Intracoastal Waterway are classified as 11SA11 waters which indicates a tidal salt water system used for shellfishing, primary recreation, aquatic life propagation and survival, fishing, wildlife, and secondary recreation. The ' - relationship between land development, stormwater runoff, and surface water quality is a growing concern for the Division of Environmental Management (DEM) and the Town of Calabash. The ' increased pollutant loading from stormwater runoff may degrade water quality, adversely impact best usage, or otherwise violate water quality standards. G. CLOSED SHELLFISHING AREAS While the Calabash River is conducive for shellfish breeding ' as indicated by its SA classification, the Calabash River has been closed for shellfishing for many years. The quality of the Calabash River has deteriorated to the point that the North Carolina Division of Environmental Health, Shellfish Sanitation ' Branch has banned shellfish harvesting in the Calabash River. H. SLOPES IN EXCESS OF 12 PERCENT ' Calabash lies on a low -elevation coastal plain. Generally, there is no land within the Town which has slopes in excess of 12 ' percent which would pose a constraint for development. I. FRAGILE AREAS ' These are areas which could be easily damaged or destroyed by inappropriate or poorly planned development. Fragile areas include the CAMA defined coastal Areas of Environmental Concern ' (AECS) which were previously discussed. However, there are other potential fragile areas in Calabash which are not classified as Areas of Environmental Concern, but nevertheless, due to either natural or cultural significance, are environmentally sensitive. ' These areas -will be discussed below as either "Natural Resource Fragile Areas" or "Cultural Resource Fragile Areas". ' 1. Natural Resource Fragile Areas Natural resource fragile areas are generally recognized to ' be of educational, scientific, or cultural value because of the 30 ' natural features of the particular site. Features in these areas serve to distinguish them from the vast majority of the landscape. As described below, the Colkins Neck area is an area ' that sustain remnant species. However, there are no other significant natural areas such as complex natural areas, unique geological formations, or registered natural landmarks. ' According to a February 25, 1994 letter, the North Carolina Natural Heritage Program has specific records of several significant natural features within the current Calabash Planning Area. The most significant feature is a highly threatened example of the extremely rare Calcareous Coastal Fringe Forest natural community located in the Colkins Neck area along the ' South Carolina border. The Natural Heritage Program has named this site as the Colkins Neck Remnant and has given it a State Significance in its 1993 Natural Heritage Priority Areas List. ' This significant area is now being developed into the Ocean Harbour Golf Course and has already been severely impacted by development. ' Two other significant animal and plant species have been reported in the Calabash area. The Natural Heritage Program has reports that Bachman's sparrows (Aimophila aestivals) have been sighted in the Calabash area. This sparrow species is a C2 Federal Candidate and a State Special Concern species. Bachman's sparrows inhabit rather open strands of longleaf pine with a ' thick groundcover. Such habitats are rapidly disappearing in Brunswick County. The Natural Heritage Program also has records that coralbean (Erythrina herbace) has been sighted in the Calabash area. This significantly rare plant is limited to ' maritime forests, mainly in Brunswick County. It is likely to be found in the Colkins Neck area which is now being developed into the Ocean Harbour Golf Course. ' 2. Cultural Resource Fragile Areas Fragile coastal cultural resource areas are generally ' recognized to be of educational, scientific, aesthetic, or cultural value because of their special importance to our understanding of past human settlement. The 1988 Plan reported ' that there were 15 archaeological sites and one National Register of Historic Places located within the Calabash Planning Area. However, recent documentation from the Division of Archives and ' History reveals that only nine of these archaeological sites are located within the current Calabash Planning Area and that Hickory Hall Plantation is not listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Three of the archaeological sites are historic ' period cemeteries and six are prehistoric sites. Hickory Hall Plantation dates back to 1801 as stated by hand -forged numbers on the chimney and may be suitable for National Register listing. 1 1 31 ' J. AREAS WITH RESOURCE POTENTIAL (1) Agriculture. Forest. and Mining Resources ' Calabash has no major commercial agricultural, forest, or mining activities located within its planning area. There are ' pockets of prime and drained prime farmland soils located in Calabash. There are no peat or sand mining operations located in Calabash. ' (2) Productive W According to the North Carolina Marine Fisheries Division, the waters of the Calabash River east of the bridge on SR 1164/NC 179 are designated as a Primary Nursery Areas (PNA). Most of the PNA area lies within the Town of Sunset Beach Planning Area and ' only a small portion lies within Calabash's ETJ as shown on Map 4. The PNA areas have been designated by the State as being highly productive for juvenile habitat for marine species. ' Destruction of these beds, either physically by dredging or filling or by pollution, reduces their productivity which is the reason they were designated as PNA's. The Calabash River west of the SR 1164/NC 179 bridge is not designated as a Primary Nursery Area, but is still classified as SA waters as previousily mentioned. Numerous boaters come to visit and fish along the waterways of the Calabash River. There are no publicly owned forests, fish, or gamelands within Calabash. Moreover, there are no privately owned wildlife sanctuaries in Calabash. 33 iSECTION IV. CONSTRAINTS: CAPACITY OF COMMUNITY FACILITIES ' Of crucial importance to any community experiencing growth and the pressures for more growth is its capacity to accommodate that growth. In the case of a community, at the point which the population growth reaches the maximum service capacity of that ' community, it can be said to have reached its critical threshold, or its "carrying capacity." In a broad sense, carrying capacity is reached when any necessary parameter reaches its limit, t whether natural or man-made. However, the concept of "carrying capacity" will generally be applied to Calabash with emphasis on service provisions. The ability of the current and proposed water, sewer, education, transportation, solid waste, police, fire, rescue, recreation, and town administrative systems will be examined to determine whether each system has sufficient capacity to accommodate the projected 1999 Planning Area's 5,109 peak seasonal residents. A. EXISTING WATER SERVICE AREA ' Two water systems currently supply the Town of Calabash and its extraterritorial area. Carolina Shores, with the exception of most houses in Carolina Shores Acreage Estates, and several ' other subdivisions are served by Carolina Blythe, a private utility company which may be purchased by the Town of Calabash. The remainder of the Town and some of the ETJ is served by the ' Brunswick County Water System. All Carolina Shores with the exception of the Acreage Estates residents are required to be connected to the Carolina Blythe system; however, it is optional for town and ETJ residents who have access to the Brunswick ' County system to be connected. Most households utilize either the public or private water systems and there are only a few private wells functioning in.the Calabash area. Some ' subdivisions such as Shingletree Acres which are located on the west side of US 17 do not have any access to either water system at this time. ' Brunswick County acquires its raw water from the Lower Cape Fear Water and Sewer Authority. This authority obtains raw water from the Cape Fear River and the raw water is transported by 13 ' 1/2 miles of 48 inch lines to a 24 MGD (million gallons per day) surface treatment plant which has a 4 million gallon storage facility. The treatment plant is located in the Leland area. After treatment, the water is distributed throughout the county by a network of distribution lines ranging from 48 to 8 inches. The Brunswick County Water Service has a total treatment capacity ' of 30 million gallons per day. The water distribution system in District I is a network of town and county water lines. The Town of Calabash owns the water ' lines along River Road, Oak Street, River View Drive, and in the Village Green subdivision. The Brunswick County Water Service actually leases these water distribution lines from the Town of ' Calabash, maintains these lines, and bills its water customers ' 34 ' directly. The exact number of county water service customers who reside within the Calabash Town and ETJ boundaries is not known and can not be determined readily. Water lines along sections ' of Beach Road (NC 179), Persimmon Road, and Thomasboro Road are owned and maintained by the County Water Service. The Brunswick County Water Service recently completed a $8 million capital ' improvement project which increased the size of the distribution lines to the Calabash area. The Brunswick County Water Service has provided water to Carolina Blythe system when additional water was needed by the private system. ' The Brunswick County Water Service and the Town of Calabash water distribution system will have sufficient capacity to ' accommodate the projected 1999 peak seasonal residential planning area population of 5,109 residents. At an assumed consumption rate of 70 gallons per day for each resident, the highest peak day demand would be 357,630 gallons per day. The improved Brunswick County system has a capacity of 30 million gallons per day. The projected peak demand for Calabash is estimated to be ' only 1.2 percent of the County's total capacity. Sufficient water supplies will be available from the Brunswick County Water System to met the needs of its own customers as well as Carolina Blythe's customers if the need should arise. tB. SEWER SERVICE AREA ' As discussed previously, approximately 45 percent of the Town area, including the commercial/restaurant district and most of Carolina Shores Acreage Estates subdivision, does not now have a centralized sewer system. Septic systems as permitted by the Brunswick County Health Department serve these areas. Most of the ETJ utilizes septic tanks as well. A package treatment plant serves the Hidden Valley subdivision. Carolina Shores, with the exception of most of the Acreage Estates, and several other ETJ subdivisions are served by the Carolina Blythe which is currently a private utility company. The Towns of Sunset Beach and Calabash have formed the Southwest Brunswick Regional Water & Sewer Authority. The implementation of the proposed sewer system has been a major planning issue for the Town of Calabash. The issue has not been whether to develop a sewer system, but whether sewer service should be provided by the regional authority, by the Town purchasing Carolina Blythe, or perhaps even a combination of both a Town and regional system. Results of the April 1994 survey revealed that out of the 166 survey respondents who answered the specific question about the proposed sewer system 73 percent favored implementing such a system while only 9 percent did not. Another 18 percent had no opinion or were not sure at that time. Town residents favored purchasing Carolina Blythe by a 2 to 1 margin while more ETJ residents and business owners supported the regional authority. r 35 ' Meanwhile the South Brunswick Water and Sewer Authority is ' planning the sewer service for District I. Construction will - begin following the issuance of all required state and federal permits which is anticipated to occur during this Plan's 5 to 10 year planning period. C. SCHOOLS ' There are relatively few school -age children in Calabash. According to the 1990 U.S. Census, only 5.6 percent of the population in Calabash was under 18. By and large, Calabash residents consist of middle -age adults and retirees and this ' trend is likely to continue. Growth in Calabash should have little impact upon the Brunswick County School System. Table 4.1 shows the 1994 school membership and the design capacity for the ' schools that Calabash students attend. While growth in Calabash itself has probably had little direct impact upon the school system, the growth of Shallotte Township as a whole has had an impact on the schools. Union Primary School was over 150 percent capacity during the 1991-1992 school year. A new elementary school in Supply which opened in the Fall of 1992 somewhat alleviated this overcrowding. However, the Brunswick County ' School System is determining whether another elementary school may be needed to be built in the Calabash area within a few years in order to realign grades served by elementary schools (K-5), ' middle schools (6-8), and high schools (9-12) in accordance with State guidelines. TABLE 4.1: SCHOOL MEMBERSHIP AND DESIGN CAPACITY. 1994 ' 1994 DESIGN PERCENT SCHOOL MEMBERSHIP CAPACITY UTILIZATION ' Union Primary (K-4) 720 792 90.9% Shallotte Middle(5-8) 861 900 95.6%- ' W. Brunswick (9-12) 888 820 108.3% Source: Brunswick County Board of Education ' D. TRANSPORTATION US Highway 17 transverses the Calabash Planning Area and ' provides the major north/south traffic link to Calabash. This highway has been upgraded to a four -lane median facility which greatly enhances the accessibility of the Calabash area to the ' rest of the region.. The major traffic artery in Calabash is NC 179 which is the main commercial thoroughfare running through the Town and ' crossing the state line into South Carolina. The average daily traffic count for sections of NC 179 was 11,000 to 11,700 vehicles a day in 1993 and this road is heavily congested during the peak tourist season. NC 179 is scheduled to be widened into I M3= G a three -land road during 1995. The other major access routes in the Towns jurisdiction are S.R. 1167 (Persimmon Road); SR 1168 (Calabash Road); SR 1163 (Old Georgetown Road); and SR 1165 (Thomasboro Road). The other streets in the Town are neighborhood streets which are maintained by the Town. With the exception of the NC 179, the design capacity of these state roads is estimated to be sufficient to handle current traffic volumes. Table 4.2 shows the Average Daily Traffic (ADT) counts for the 6 locations in Calabash where traffic counts were consistently taken from 1984 to 1993. A B C D E F YEAR US17 NC179 NC179 SR1167 SR1165 SR1164 1984 4900 5000 3000 -- -- -- 1985 -- -- -- 500 1100 500 1986 4900 4500 7000 -- -- -- 1987 4900 4400 6200 400 1200 500 1988 5300 5100 7200 400 1200 600 1989 5300 -- -- 800 1200 600 1990 5300 10400 11400 -- -- -- 1991 7600 10400 11100 800 1200 550 1992 8200 8800 11000 -- -- -- 1993 9100 11000 11700 1100 1500 600 A = US 17 near Thomasboro Crossroads B = NC 179 (Old Georgetown Road) near Calabash EMS C = NC 179 (Beach Road) near River Road D = SR 1167 (Persimmon Road) E = SR 1165 (Thomasboro Road) F = SR 1164 (Clariday Road) Source: North Carolina Department of Transportation. The Town of Calabash leases a dump site at the Carolina Shores P.O.A. facility on Persimmon Road. All town residents use this site for depositing recycling materials and yard debris. Curbside collection varies in Calabash by district. Currently, the Town of Calabash contracts with a private contractor for residential garbage collection in District I. Residential collection occurs twice a week year-round. District II elected not to have curbside garbage pick-up and these residents take their refuse directly to the Town refuse station where it is collected by a private contractor and then transported to the Brunswick County landfill three times a week. Businesses and restaurants must arrange for their own solid waste collection. 37 Calabash ETJ residents must arrange their own refuse collection and now must utilize the Brunswick County recycling station on NC 904. Solid waste is disposed of in the 55-acre Brunswick County Landfill after being dumped in a compaction unit at the Ocean Isle Beach Transfer Station. The Brunswick County Landfill is projected to last until 1998 at which time the County by State mandate must operate a lined landfill. The County is now exploring its options on how best to meet the 1998 State mandate. The capacity of the local solid waste management will be sufficient through 1999. Private contractors have the capacity to respond to increased local demand. However, Brunswick County must begin seeking options to accommodate future landfill needs of its growing population which will satisfy stricter state and federal guidelines. Calabash provides no local police services and depends upon the Brunswick County Sheriff Department for protection. A Community Neighborhood Watch is implemented in Carolina Shores and Calabash Acres. Brunswick County implemented a 911 system in June 1992. In the April 1994 survey, 35 percent thought that sheriff protection was adequate, 41 percent thought sheriff protection was inadequate, and 24 percent were not sure or had no opinion. The need for additional police protection may become more important as the population continues to grow. Most survey respondents favored having additional protection by establishing a Brunswick County sheriff sub -station rather than by forming a local police department. Calabash is the fifth largest Town in Brunswick County and most towns its size have their own police department. The Calabash Volunteer Fire Department is located at Persimmon Road and this department with 27 volunteers serves the Town, the extraterritorial area, and the outlying area within 5 miles of the fire station. The Town and County governments and local residents make annual financial contributions to the Volunteer Department. The fire station's equipment includes two 750 gpm pumper trucks, one 1,000 gpm pumper truck, and one 2,000 gallon fire tanker. The tallest fire ladder available is a 35 foot portable ladder with an estimated height access of 25 feet and it is estimated that the three-story buildings would need a 35 to 40 ladder truck. Consequently, the Calabash Volunteer Fire Department relies upon the aerial fire trucks located at either the Ocean Isle Fire Department or the Little River Fire Department in order to fight structural fires. The Fire Department does have back-up call agreements with the Sunset Beach, Ocean Isle, and Little River Volunteer Fire Departments. P 38 ' The fire insurance rating for Calabash is currently 7A for the planning area where fire hydrants are available and a 9A for ' the area not served by hydrants. Fire hydrants are located throughout most of the Calabash Planing Area served by either the Carolina Blythe or Brunswick County Water Service; however, fire hydrants are not located in the Shingletree Acres area and some ' other residential areas located across of US 17. Both water systems have sufficient capacity to supply water for fire- fighting purposes according to the Calabash Fire Marshall. ' However, the growth of the Calabash area is a major challenge for the Volunteer Fire Department according to the current Fire Chief. The Fire Chief contends that greater ' financial support from the Town of Calabash is needed for the Volunteer Fire Department to keep pace with growth as well as to have sufficient fire -fighting capacity. The Volunteer Fire Department needs to replace its outdated pumper trucks, to acquire either an aerial truck or a fire ladder truck in order to fight structural fires, and to update accessory equipment such as ' breathing apparatus. H. EMERGENCY RESCUE AND SAFETY ' The Calabash Emergency Medical System provides services to the Calabash, Sunset Beach, and Grissettown areas. This volunteer squad has 20 members on its roster and these volunteers have had EMT training. The squad has two ambulances which are equipped with standard basic life support systems and Advanced Life Support (ALS) systems. The Calabash Fire Department is receiving First Responder training in order to support the rescue ' squad. The Brunswick County EMS Service also provides back-up support. Most emergency patients are transported to the Brunswick Hospital which is approximately 20 miles from Calabash. This ' volunteer organization obtains financial support from Calabash, Sunset Beach, and Brunswick County governments as well as accepts donations from local residents. A Thrift Shop is also operated ' as a fund-raising project. I. RECREATIONAL SERVICES ' The Calabash River and the three championship golf courses provide the major recreational opportunities for residents and visitors at Calabash. Currently, the Town does not have a formal recreation policy or operates parks, public boat accesses, or similar public recreational facilities. Although 85 percent of the April 1994 survey respondents thought that recreational land use should be encouraged only 17 percent were willing to pay additional taxes for recreational facilities. Apparently, residents would prefer for recreational facilities to be provided by the private sector. 39 ' J. ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES ' The Town of Calabash employs a Town Clerk, two support office staff members, a Building Inspector, and a Code Enforcement/Fire Inspector. An addition to the Town Hall has been recently completed. A new town hall is anticipated to be ' built within 5 years. The Town of Calabash plans to hire a town administrator and additional support personnel. 1 40 ' SECTION V: LAND USE POLICY STATEMENTS The formulation of specific policies regarding growth, ' development, and management objectives is perhaps the most important part of any land use plan -- especially those prepared under North Carolina's Coastal Area Management Act. Because of regulatory requirements and local peculiarities, the policies, often attempt to strike a delicate balance between desires and objectives of local citizens, the local government, and the ' objectives of LAMA itself. Land development policies, which should be based on analyses of existing conditions (including consideration given to natural and man-made constraints) and projected trends, are to serve as general guides for future ' desired development. Under LAMA, the overriding issue is that.of growth management while protecting coastal resources. The special resources and constraints within Calabash were identified in the previous sections of this plan. The policy statements contained in this section will both address growth management and protection, and maintenance of these resources. The Coastal Resources Commission, recognizing the diversities which exist among the coastal communities, requires each locality to delineate specific development policies under ' five broad categories, each with its own subset of policy areas. The five required topics, addressed in order in this section, are: ' * Resource Protection * Resource Production and Management * Economic and Community Development ' * Continuing Public Participation * Storm Hazard Mitigation ' Although policies developed under these topics cover most of the local development issues, in some cases they do not. Calabash has the flexibility to address specific community issues ' within the scope of this plan and they have done this. It is important to understand the significance of local LAMA policy statements and how they interact with day-to-day ' activities of Calabash. Three areas are affected. First, the policy statements will regulate the issuance of LAMA minor and major permitting as required by N.C.G.S.-113A-118 prior to undertaking any development in any Area of Environmental Concern. A local government must adopt policies which are, at a minimum, equal to and consistent with the State's minimum use standards. The local government may, however, adopt minimum use standards ' which are stricter than the State's and the local government's stricter standards would become the determining factor whether a CAMA permit should be issued. ' The second area of application is that of establishing local policies and regulations which guide Calabash's growth and ' development. Under North Carolina legislation, land use plans 41 are not regulatory controls. Policy statements must be consistent with and implemented through local land use ordinances such as zoning or subdivision ordinances. The final area of application is that of "Consistency Review." Proposals and applications for state and federal assistance or requests for agency approval of projects are normally reviewed against a jurisdiction's land use plan to determine if the project is consistent with local policies. Inconsistencies of a federal or state project with local policies will serve as grounds for denial or revision of a project. The Town of Calabash employed several means of soliciting meaningful citizen participation in developing policies. Monthly meetings with Calabash Planning Board and planning consultant were held since February 1994 in order to prepare the Land Use Plan Update and these meetings were open to the public. Well - attended public meetings were held on March 9, May 16, and June 9, 1994. Citizens helped to identify planning issues as well as to suggest policy alternatives. A survey was mailed to 325 property owners and businesses in both the town and its extraterritorial area in April 1994. By the April 27 deadline, 169 out of the 325 questionnaires had been received for a total response rate of 52 percent. This is an excellent response rate since most mail surveys usually have a response rate between 30 to 35 percent. It should be noted that the survey elicited a voluntary response and therefore, it is not considered to be a scientific, random survey. However, the survey was a valuable form of input. A detailed summary of the public meetings and survey results are included in Appendix 1. The foregoing policies were developed to provide a general framework for guiding growth and development in Calabash over the next five years. A. RESOURCE PROTECTION ' i. Areas of Environmental Concern Calabash will support and enforce through its LAMA permitting capacity the State policies and permitted uses in the Areas of Environmental Concern (AECS). The State's policy statements for AECS offer protection for Calabash fragile areas through the CAMA permitting procedures. In accordance with those policies set forth in Subchapter 7H of the North Carolina Administrative Code, Calabash adopts the following policies ' concerning AECS within its jurisdiction. The Areas of Environmental Concern for Calabash were previously discussed in Section III, pages 24-26. 42 0 I 1 a. The Estuarine System ISSUE IDENTIFICATION: In recognition of the enormous economic, social and biological values the estuarine system has for North Carolina, Calabash will promote conservation and management of the Estuarine System as a whole which includes the individual subsystems of coastal wetlands, estuarine waters, public trust waters, and estuarine shorelines. The management objective for the system shall be to give highest priority to the protection and coordinated management of all the elements as an interrelated group of AECs in order to safeguard and perpetuate the above stated values, and to minimize the likelihood of significant loss of private property and public resources. Specific policies regarding acceptable and unacceptable uses within the individual AECS of the estuarine system are stated below. In essence, the permitted land uses in these areas shall be those which are water dependent. In all cases the particular location, use, and design characteristics shall be in accord with the general use standards for coastal wetlands, estuarine waters, and public trust areas as stated in 15A NCAC 7H. POLICY STATEMENTS: It shall be the policy of Calabash to restrict land uses in coastal wetlands to those that guarantee wetlands conservation and which do not affect their delicate balance. Calabash shall permit water dependent uses such as docks, boat ramps, piers, marinas, utility easements, and culverts, consistent with the definition and use standards of 15 NCAC 7H. Each proposed use will be evaluated for water dependency. Unacceptable land uses may include, but would not be limited to restaurants, businesses, residences, apartments, motels, hotels, floating structures other than boat docks, and parking lots. In some instances, it may be necessary and in the public interest for roads to transverse wetland areas. Where this is absolutely necessary, state and federal regulations may allow such with certain safeguards and/or mitigation measures. In recognition of the importance of estuarine waters for the fisheries and related industries as well as aesthetics and recreation, Calabash shall promote the conservation and quality 1 43 1 of this resource. Appropriate uses may include simple access channels, structures which prevent erosion, navigational channels, boat docks, piers, marinas, and mooring pilings which 1 are consistent with 15 NCAC 7H. The proposed centralized sewer system shall be encouraged as 1 a means to eliminate pollution from malfunctioning or inadequate septic systems and/ or package treatment plants. Boat launching, wet -slip marinas, and dry -storage boat 1 docking facilities shall be supported as a means of providing public water access provided that their development shall not adversely impact estuarine or public trust areas. Marinas and 1 dry -storage boat facilities should have pump -out stations. Floating structures other than boat docks shall be banned in 1 order to protect our estuarine and public trust areas. The Town will support those projects which will increase the productivity of the estuary such as oyster reseeding or dredging 1 projects which will increase the flushing actions of tidal movements. 1 (3) Estuarine Shorelines Suitable land uses within the estuarine shorelines are those 1 compatible with both the dynamic nature of estuarine shorelines and the value of the estuarine system. Calabash recognizes the close association between estuarine shorelines and the adjacent estuarine waters; the influence that shoreline development has on 1 the quality of estuarine life; and that the damaging processes of shorefront erosion and flooding to which the estuarine shoreline is subject. 1 Within the Estuarine Shoreline Area, the Town of Calabash believes that certain developed uses should only be allowed to 1 take place which are consistent with 15 NCAC 7H and as further defined by the Towns building and development ordinances, and which satisfy the following requirements: 1) natural barriers to erosion are not weakened or eliminated; 2) development does 1 not interfere with present public access or use of navigable waters or public trust areas; 3) the amount of runoff is unchanged; 4) no pollution is generated; 5) standards of the 1 North Carolina Sedimentation Pollution Act of 1973, amended 1990, are upheld; and 6) the construction of impervious surfaces and areas not allowing natural drainage is limited to that necessary for development. 1 (4) Public Trust Areas 1 The State of North Carolina and the Town of Calabash holds its waters in public trust and promotes public access to these areas. In the absence of overriding public benefit, any use 1 which significantly interferes with the public right of ' 44 ' navigation or other public trust rights which apply in the area shall not be allowed. Projects which would directly or ' indirectly block or impair navigational channels, increase shoreline erosion, deposit spoils below mean high tide, cause adverse water circulation patterns, violate water quality standards, or cause degradation of shellfish waters shall not be ' allowed. For the Town of Calabash, a navigational channel will be ' defined as any water channel which is passable by boats during high tide. Permanent obstruction of these navigational channels will not be allowed. Improvements such as bridges and docks must be built to allow boating access. Uses that may be allowed in public trust areas shall not be detrimental to the public trust rights and the biological and ' physical functions of the estuary. Examples.of such uses include the development of navigational channels or drainage ditches, the use of bulkheads to prevent erosion, and the building of piers or ' docks. Such uses shall generally be permitted as long as they conform to State development standards. ' (5) Outstanding Resource Waters There are no designated outstanding resource waters within ' the Calabash Planning Area. b. Ocean Hazard Areas ' Unlike many other tourist -oriented coastal communities, Calabash is not on the oceanfront and therefore, has no Ocean Hazard Areas of Environmental Concern. ' IMPLEMENTATION: ' Calabash believes that the existing development permit system enforced by CAMA, the U.S. Corps of Engineers, combined with the Town's Zoning Ordinance and Subdivision Regulations represent adequate measures to protect the discussed resources. ' Enforcement of these provisions will continue. 2. Other Natural Fragile Areas ' ISSUE IDENTIFICATION: ' Uncontrolled or incompatible development may result in the major or irreversible damage to fragile coastal resource areas which contain environmental, natural, historical or archaeological resources of more than local significance. In ' recognition of this, it is the policy of Calabash to encourage the protection of such natural or cultural resources. Development of such areas should not be permitted or if allowed, 45 7 IL to be developed in such a fashion as to preserve its natural significance. As discussed in Section III, pages 29-31 of this report, Calabash has the following types of natural and cultural resource areas within its jurisdiction: coastal areas that sustain remnant species, prime wildlife habitats, wooded swamps and 404 wetlands, maritime forests, and significant archaeological resources, and historic architectural resources. However, there are no coastal complex natural areas, unique geological formations, currently registered natural landmarks, scenic or prominent high points located within the Calabash Planning Area. POLICY IDENTIFICATION: Coastal areas that sustain remnant species are those areas that support native plants and animals which are threatened to be rare or endangered. According to the Natural Heritage Program, rare and endangered species are located in the Colkins Neck area now being developed as the Ocean Harbour Golf Links. The integrity of this natural area has been damaged by development and is no longer a pristine natural area. However, sporadic occurrences of endangered plant species may occur in the Colkins Neck area. POLICY STATEMENTS: All development plans for areas that are likely to contain remnant species will be carefully reviewed prior to the issuance of development permits in order to ascertain.whether there are any endangered species located within the project area. If endangered plant and animal habitats are discovered, the development must be,designed to protect the habitat from disturbance. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: The Town of Calabash will amend its development ordinances to require that development permits will not be issued for areas that may contain remnant species until the Natural Heritage Program has been contacted and it is ascertained whether the development will impact the habitat. The coastal marshes along the Calabash River serve as prime wildlife habitats. Development in these areas will be regulated by the CAMA major and minor permitting process and local development ordinances discussed previously. 1 46 ' c. Wooded Swamps and 404 Wetlands Calabash has some wooded swamps and wetlands located within ' its jurisdiction which should be regulated by the 404 wetlands regulations of the Corps of Engineers. The Town of Calabash supports the preservation of wetlands through the enforcement of ' 404 regulations. d. Maritime Forests ' According to the North Carolina Natural Heritage Program, most of the once extensive maritime forests in Calabash have been altered by golf course and residential development. e. Significant Archaeological and Historical Resources POLICY IDENTIFICATION: The mainland of Calabash was inhabited by Indians and 6 pre- recorded archaeological sites and 3 historic period cemeteries have been recorded. Most of these sites have already been disturbed by development. Moreover, Hickory Hall Plantation may be a significant historical structure. ' POLICY STATEMENT: ' There may be some undisturbed archaeological resources within Calabash's Planning Area. The Town believes that all development plans in such identified areas should be carefully reviewed prior to approval and that the NC Division of Archives ' and History should be contacted. Moreover, the State Division of Archives and History will be contacted if any additional archaeological sites previously not recorded are discovered. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: ' The Town of Calabash will maintain information concerning the location of archaeological sites within its Planning Area. If a development permit request is submitted for an area that contains a prerecorded site, the applicant will be informed and ' the State Division of Archives and History will be contacted prior to the approval of the requested permit. ' f. Shellfishing Waters All of the waters of the Calabash River are now closed for shellfishing. The Town of Calabash hopes to reverse the negative ' impact of water pollution by supporting more effective local and regional stormwater management and by providing a centralized sewer System. 47 3. Constraints to Development POLICY IDENTIFICATION: ' Calabash has two major physical constraints for development: the general lack of soils suitable for septic tank use and the ' amount of land included in the 100-year floodplain as discussed in Section III of this report on pages 27-29. The lack of soils generally suitable for septic tank use is a major concern for the ' Town and ETJ area not currently served by a centralized sewer system. The South Brunswick Water and Sewer Authority is pursuing developing a sewer system to serve those areas currently not served. There are no man-made hazards such as heavy ' industries or airports located within the Town which would limit development. ' POLICY STATEMENTS: (1) Until such time as a central sewage collection and ' disposal system is developed, growth and development will not be permitted in areas where septic tanks will not function. All septic tanks must be in compliance with State Health Regulations through administration by the Brunswick County Health Department. ' (2) Development may be constructed in areas with limitations for building foundations only if corrective measures for ' stabilizing foundations are incorporated into the building design. (3) All new construction and substantial improvements in the 100-year flood zones must comply strictly to the Town's Flood Damage Prevention Ordinance which has been adopted in conjunction with Calabash's participation in the National Flood Insurance ' Program. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: ' The Town of Calabash will continue to enforce its Flood Damage Prevention Ordinance and Building Code as well as support the enforcement of the septic tank regulations by the Brunswick ' County Health Department. 4. Protection of Potable Water Supplies POLICY IDENTIFICATION: Carolina Blythe utilizes wells to supply water to its ' customers in the Calabash area. Only a few private wells, mostly in the ETJ area, are utilized in Calabash. Development near the public or private wells does not pose any hazards. 48 CIS POLICY STATEMENT: Sources of potable surface and groundwater for the Town of Calabash shall be protected to the maximum extent possible. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: The Town of Calabash will regulate land uses near wells through its zoning ordinance and will enforce site requirements that private wells be located suitable distances from septic tank systems. POLICY IDENTIFICATION: ' Ground absorption systems are the main means of sewerage disposal for the Town and ETJ area not served by Carolina Blythe. There is one package treatment plant now in Calabash which serves ' the Hidden Valley subdivision. If the centralized sewer system is not developed, one can anticipate that additional package treatment plants may be built to serve larger residential development. This is especially true since much of the remaining ' undeveloped soils are "hard -pan" soils which are not suitable for septic tanks. L C (1) It shall be the policy of Calabash to allow package treatment plants where they are deemed necessary and if they can be constructed with the overall intent of this plan and meet all federal and state environmental regulations. If and when centralized sewer facilities are made available to areas served by package plants, hookup to the sewer facilities will be required, and the package plant(s) eliminated. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: The Town of Calabash will support enforcement of package treatment plant regulations by the Brunswick County Health Department. The Town of Calabash subdivision ordinance will be amended in order to require that the developer of a package treatment plant must submit a maintenance plan to ensure proper servicing of the plant, that the package treatment plant is sited to provide minimal negative impact on the environment and proposed development, and that the package plant will be eliminated upon the availability of centralized sewer service. POLICY IDENTIFICATION: The Town of Calabash shares the concern of the State Division of Environmental Management (DEM) that stormwater runoff 49 E P 0 n 0 from urbanized areas is contributing to declining surface water quality. According to the DEM, the increase in stormwater runoff associated with land development can substantially increase inputs of waste constituents present in stormwater. The increased pollutant loading from stormwater runoff may degrade ambient water quality, adversely impact best usage, or otherwise violate water quality standards. Maintenance of water quality is a concern to Calabash. The Town recognizes the value of water quality maintenance both in terms of protecting commercial and recreational fishing resources and providing clean water for other recreational purposes. The Town is also very much concerned about the potential adverse effect on water -quality from large open -area recreational development. Improving stormwater management in order to protect the coastal waters was a major concern expressed in the April 1994 survey. POLICY STATEMENTS: (1) Stormwater runoff from new development will be reduced by enacting improved stormwater control regulations. (2) The Town of Calabash encourages the use of "innovative" systems which utilize pervious or semi -pervious materials and the retention of natural vegetation which functions as a filter which minimizes the rapid release of pollutants to coastal waters through stormwater runoff. The general intent of the stormwater regulations will be to encourage the percolation of stormwater into the ground and avoid direct discharge of stormwater into the coastal waters. (3) The proposed centralized sewer system is supported as a means to eliminate runoff of surfaced effluent from malfunctioning or inadequate on -site septic systems. (4) Stormwater management planning can best be handled on a river system drainage basis. The Town of Calabash supports the preparation of a regional comprehensive stormwater management plan for Southwest Brunswick County. (5) The Town of Calabash supports the maintenance of the Caw Caw Drainage system by Brunswick County. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: The Town of Calabash will continue to enforce its building code regulations which pertain to stormwater control. The Town will determine whether these regulations need to be revised to conform to the North Carolina Stormwater Control and the State Sedimentation and Erosion Control policy. The proposed centralized sewer system will reduce pollution from surfaced effluent. The existing stormwater drainage system will be evaluated. The Town of Calabash will support efforts to conduct a regional stormwater management plan. ' 50 ' 7 Marina Bulkhead and Floating Structure Development The development of bulkheads, private boatslips, and marinas ' are permitted uses in the Town's zoning ordinance and must meet LAMA regulations. Damage to existing marshes by bulkhead installation or replacement, groins, or seawalls will not be ' permitted. According to the CAMA guidelines T15A:07H.0208, marinas are defined as any publicly or privately owned dock, basin or wet boat storage facility constructed to accommodate more than 10 boats and providing any of the following services: permanent or transient docking spaces, dry storage, fueling facilities, haulout facilities and repair service. Excluded from this definition are boat ramp facilities allowing access only and temporary docking facilities which do not have any of the ' preceding services. In order to minimize environmental impact, the Town of Calabash prefers dry -boat stacking storage rather than wet slip marinas. ' According to CAMA guidelines T15A: 07M .0602, floating structures are defined as any structure, not a boat, supported by a means of flotation, designed to be used without a permanent foundation, which is intended for human habitation or commerce. A structure will be considered a floating structure when it is used for human habitation or commercial purposes for more than ' 30 days in one location. A boat may be deemed a floating structure when its means of propulsion has been removed or rendered inoperative and it contains at least 200 square feet of living space. ' In Calabash, the issue of floating structures has not been a significant problem and the Town has never adopted any ordinances ' or regulations regarding floating structures. The Town is supportive of the State's policies on floating structures and believes that they should not be allowed within the Town's Public ' Trust Areas, 8. Industrial Impacts on Fragile Areas ' There are two industries now located within the Calabash Planning Area. .Both of these industries are located some distance from any Areas of Environmental Concern. Industrial use is not a permitted use for any zoning district containing AEC's in the Town's zoning ordinance. Consequently, the Town does not anticipate any negative impacts by industrial use on the Town's fragile areas. 9 Development of Sound and Estuarine Svstem Islands ' There are no estuarine system islands in Calabash's jurisdiction. 51 10, Rising Sea Level The Town of Calabash will closely monitor research on sea level rise and its effects on coastal areas. It is the policy of the Town to consider any State or Federal policies prior to issuing specific statements regarding sea level rise and restriction of development in potentially susceptible locations. Specifically, development within areas up to 5 feet above sea level may be prone to sea level rise and wetland loss. ' B. RESOURCE PRODUCTION AND MANAGEMENT In most coastal counties and towns, "resource production and ' management" usually relates to agriculture, forestry, and mining activities as well as recreational and fisheries resources. For Calabash, only recreational and fisheries resources pertain since there are no major commercial agricultural, forestry, or mining resources within the Planning Area. 1. Recreational and Fisheries Resources POLICY IDENTIFICATION: In resort communities such.as Calabash, the abundant water and marsh areas become the predominant resource supporting recreational and fishing activities. The Town recognizes the value of water quality maintenance in terms of protecting commercial and recreational fishing resources and providing clean water for other recreational purposes such as swimming, water skiing, and boating. A portion of the marshes within Calabash are designated as Primary Nursery Areas by the North Carolina Division of Marine Fisheries as shown on Map 4. The Calabash River system and marshes are also classified as Areas of Environmental Concern previously discussed. The Calabash River and the Intracoastal Waterway are classified as SA waters. For these reasons, Calabash recognizes that by protecting the water quality within its jurisdiction that it is also protecting its economic base. POLICY STATEMENTS: (1) The Town of Calabash encourages the protection and enhancement of North Carolina's sport and commercial fisheries industry. Any development or activity which will profoundly affect coastal and estuarine waters will be discouraged. Only development consistent with 15 NCAC 7H and the Town's building and development ordinances will be allowed to be placed adjacent to coastal and estuarine waters. In the design, construction, and operation of water dependent structures, efforts must be made to mitigate negative effects on water quality and fish habitat, as determined by 15A NCAC 7H, the Division of Environmental Management, and the Coastal Resources Commission. The developer and/or owner will bear the cost of any such mitigation. ' 52 ' (2) Calabash supports the NC Division of Marine Fisheries in their development of regulations and policies, including those on ' trawling and gill netting in ocean and estuarine waters. (3) In order to expand Calabash's sport and commercial fishing, Calabash will permit private and public dredging ' activities which will positively affect those industries. It is recognized that in dredging and stabilization activities, some fish habitat damage may occur. Only those projects which have a ' reasonable likelihood of providing greater benefits than damage for marine life will be supported. All dredging and stabilization projects must be performed in order to minimize any unavoidable damage to fish habitat. (4) Calabash supports projects which increase the productivity of coastal and estuarine waters. Projects such as ' oyster reseeding programs and properly constructed artificial reef construction have proved successful in the past, and therefore, will be supported in the future. ' POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: The Town of Calabash supports current State and Federal ' programs designed to enhance the proper utilization of water resources. The CAMA major and minor permitting program will be enforced to protect these Areas of Environmental Concern. ' Establishment of a centralized sewer system and effective stormwater management will help to maintain water quality in Calabash. ' 2. The Impact of Residential and Commercial Development on Natural Resources Calabash's waters are used for all types of recreation, including fishing for pleasure. These water resources are vital to the community's "Seafood Capitol" tourist economy. The Town ' of Calabashis committed to the protection and enhancement of its waters. The land use controls of Calabash are and will continue to be written and enforced to insure that proper and adequate measures are incorporated into the design, construction, and ' operation of residential and commercial development so that any substantial negative impact to the unique coastal ecosystem is minimized. ' C . ECONOMIC AMID COMMUNITY DEVELOPN�N'P ' POLICY IDENTIFICATION: The Town of Calabash experienced rapid growth during the 1980's and early 19901s. Growth will continue during the next 5 to 10 years as a result of new residential construction as well as the possible extension of the town corporate and extraterritorial limits. During this planning process, there has ' been much discussion about what type of growth should occur. The 53 ' consensus of the public meetings and the April 1994 survey was that Calabash should remain a low -scale retirement community with ' predominantly single-family housing. The prospect of either high-rise residential or commercial development is widely viewed as a threat to the "fishing village" image of the Town. Most survey respondents supported additional single-family, shopping, ' and recreational development but thought that duplexes, multi- family, mobile home, and industrial development should be discouraged. Nearly 71 percent of the survey respondents ' considered that the rate of growth was about right while about 19 percent thought that the rate of growth was too high or that the Town had enough growth. The summer seasonal and tourist population was considered about right or low compared to other coastal towns by 77 percent of all the survey respondents. The Town of Calabash recognizes that improperly managed growth can actually harm or "destroy" the very appeal which attracts new residents and seasonal visitors to the area in the first place. Therefore, the Towns overall attitude toward ' growth is expressed in the following policy choices. POLICY STATEMENTS. ' (1) Growth Management a. To manage and direct the Towns growth and development in ' balance with the availability of public services. b. To protect the Town from adverse development and growth by considering these factors when considering land use: ' * the suitability of land to accommodate the use; * the capacity of the environment; * the compatibility of the land use with the goals and objectives of the Town; * density of the development and the proposed height ' of the structures; and * the availability of support facilities and services. c. To prepare for a continuing population growth. d. To institute continuous land use planning and growth direction by enforcing the relevant ordinances. ' e. To guide new development away from Areas of Environmental Concern (AECS) and other special and sensitive areas, as reflected in the policies for Resource Protection and Resource ' Production and Management. f. To guide new development away from hazardous areas where there ' is a tendency for septic tank problems and flooding. g. To institute annexation proceedings and the extension of the ' extraterritorial limits in a timely manner in order to guide 171 54 growth of ETJ areas within the current town boundaries and in the surrounding areas adjacent to Calabash. h. To retain a 35 foot height limitation for residential, commercial, and institutional structures. The Board of Commissioners will study the feasibility of requiring that the building height restrictions can only be changed by a public referendum. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: The Town of Calabash will administer its development ordinances such as zoning and subdivision regulations with these above policies in mind. Improvements to the Town's infrastructure will be done as needed in order to provide adequate services as demand from population growth increases. As new development occurs in the areas surrounding the town limits, Calabash will evaluate the feasibility of annexation and the extension of the Town's extraterritorial limits. The above statements reflect the Town's general attitude towards.growth. Additional policy issues required to be addressed by the CAMA Planning Guidelines as well as additional locally recognized issues are addressed below. POLICY STATEMENTS: (a) It shall be the policy of Calabash to encourage the development of a variety of housing types to meet the needs and desires of current and future citizens through the following: * To maintain areas exclusively for conventional single-family dwellings for the growing population. * To provide areas for mobile home parks and manufactured housing development. * To allow multi -family and condominium development within certain zoning districts. (b) The Town wishes to enhance and promote quality commercial development through the following: * Calabash's economic base consists mainly of services pertaining to tourism as the "Seafood Capitol of the World". ' 55 ' * The Town will continue to enforce its current development ordinances and local building permit process in order to achieve a desired balance between commercial and residential development. ' Adequate buffering between residential and commercial development will be required. ' * The appearance of commercial development will be enhanced by the enforcement of zoning sign and landscaping regulations. ' * The Town of Calabash will support efforts to landscape public areas and to encourage beautification of commercial areas within the Town. ' * The Town of Calabash should consider the feasibility of developing additional sources of public revenues from tourist - related activities. ' * The Town of Calabash shall encourage US 17 to be developed as a highway commercial area and for NC 179 to be a commercial area with small-town character. 1 * The feasibility of providing sidewalks and ornamental lighting in the Central Business District in conjunction with the ' widening on NC 179 will be evaluated. INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT ' The Town of Calabash does support light industrial development in the outlying ETJ areas. Zoning restrictions requiring buffering with some adjacent land uses will be ' enforced. INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT with the exception of churches, institutional use in Calabash is now limited to those government and utility sites necessary to provide adequate services to the Town and its ' Planning Area. This land use pattern will continue. The Town of Calabash shall encourage land use compatibility between institutional development and neighboring residential and/or ' commercial development. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: The Town of Calabash will continue to enforce its zoning and subdivision ordinances and that the zoning building height limit will be restricted to 35 feet in all zoning districts. The Board of Commissioners will study the feasibility of requiring that the building height restrictions will only be changed by the approval of a public referendum. The Town will continue to enforce the ' State CAMA permit process. The Town will also support the State Health regulations regarding septic tank placement until such time that a central sewer system may serve the entire Town and ' Planning Area. 56 3 Capacity of Existing Facilities and Local Commitment to Providing Services to Development POLICY IDENTIFICATION: The capacity of community facilities was discussed in Section IV, pages 33-39, of this report. Carolina Blythe and the Brunswick County Water System will have sufficient capacity to serve the projected 1999 peak seasonal residential population of 5,109. The sewage system may be built by 1997 which is eventually planned to serve the entire Planning Area of Calabash. Population growth of Calabash is anticipated to have minor impact upon school enrollment in Brunswick County. Two road improvements are recommended to improve traffic flow and public safety in Calabash: the scheduled widening of NC 179 in 1995 and the installation of a traffic light at the intersection of NC 179 and Country Club Drive. Calabash will ensure that its private contractor for solid waste collection has the capacity to handle the peak seasonal population in 1999. The Town urges Brunswick County to upgrade its landfill capacity to meet stringent federal and state regulations which will be effective by 1998. The Town of Calabash supports the recycling program of Brunswick County. The feasibility of establishing.either a sheriff sub -station or a local police department will be explored. Volunteer fire protection services are adequate. The Calabash Town Hall has been expanded to provide adequate space for town administrative services. A new Town Hall will be built within 5 years. POLICY STATEMENTS: (1) As areas develop, it is the policy of the Town that the developer/owner share in the financial responsibility of providing basic town services. (2) In order to protect the quality of its coastal waters, the Town of Calabash will pursue developing a centralized sewerage treatment and collection system. (3) In order to protect its coastal waters, the Town of Calabash will improve stormwater management. (4) To alleviate traffic congestion, the Town of Calabash supports the scheduled widening on NC 179 and the installation of a traffic light at the intersection of NC 179 and Country Club Drive. (5) To promote public safety, the Town of Calabash supports the installation of a traffic light at the intersection of Country Club Drive and US 17. (6) The Town of Calabash supports the development of a regional bicycle route system throughout Brunswick County and adjoining municipalities. 1 57 ' 7 The Town of Calabash is committed to acquiring land for ( ) � g recreational use. ' POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: The Town of Calabash will continually evaluate the provision of public services to determine whether there is sufficient capacity. As undeveloped areas of the Planning Area are ' developed, it is the policy of the Town that the developer/owner share in the financial responsibility of providing public services. 4. Desired Urban Growth Patterns As it is very important that the "fishing village" ' atmosphere be maintained, Calabash is not interested in promoting high-rise development within its Planning Area. Residential development is considered as desirable as long as there is no major or irreversible damage to environmentally sensitive areas. It is the Town's intentions, as reflected in its zoning ordinance and zoning map, to allow a mixture of residential development in a balanced manner throughout its Planning Area. ' 5. Redevelopment of Developed Areas As the structures begin to age in Calabash, additional redevelopment of residential and commercial buildings may occur, especially in the "Mixed District" of "Old Calabash" which has restaurants, dwellings, and mobile homes as well as in some of ' the older mobile home areas in the ETJ. Calabash supports redevelopment activity as a positive re -use of land resources which enhance the Town as a whole. Such redevelopment may be ' permitted as long as the activity complies with the spirit and intent of existing regulatory requirements. It is the Town's policy that density allowances for redevelopment areas conform to ' existing Town building and zoning regulations. 6. Commitment to State and Federal Programs ' Calabash is generally receptive to State and Federal programs, particularly those which either enhance or improve the Town's facilities. Examples of State and Federal programs which are important to and supported by the Town include: CAMA major and minor permitting program; dredging, channel maintenance, and 404 wetlands permitting by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers; the EH Coastal and Estuarine Water Access Program; the NCDOT ' improvements to NC 179, and Federal and State projects which provide efficient and safe boat access for sports fishing. W. ' Proper maintenance of channels, particularly the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway, is very important to Calabash because of the impact of commercial and recreational fisheries and general ' boating. Calabash is supportive of the Corps of Engineers maintenance of the Calabash River and the Intracoastal Waterway. ' 8. Energy Facility Sitirtg and Development 11 11 n 11 The Town of Calabash discourages offshore continental drilling for gas and oil. Also, the location of support facilities for offshore drilling at Calabash would be inappropriate and is strongly discouraged. As the "Seafood Capitol of the World", the Town of Calabash draws most of its livelihood from tourism, golfing, marine recreation, and fishing activities. The Town supports the continuation of these activities. The Town of Calabash should consider the feasibility of developing additional sources of public revenues from tourist -related activities. 10. Coastal and Estuarine Beach Access and Parkincr POLICY IDENTIFICATION: Relatively free and open access to the waterways is an important consideration for any waterfront community. POLICY STATEMENT: The Town of Calabash is committed to the public having access to public trust land and waters, provided that such means do not conflict with the rights of residents for the use and enjoyment of their property. Calabash supports the utilization of state and federal, as well as local resources, to develop public access areas. POLICY IDENTIFICATION: Calabash recognizes that an important element in developing and implementing any local policies or plans is the involvement of its citizens. Public involvement with this LAMA Land Use Plan Update started in February 1994 as the planning process began. Monthly meetings with the Calabash Planning Board composed of ten members were held. Public meetings which were advertised in the Brunswick Beacon, on notices posted in key locations throughout the Town, and mailed to 25 neighborhood property owner associations were held on March 9, May 16, and June 9, 1994. 1 59 Approximately 27 people attended the March 9th meeting. In order to identify major planning issues in the Town, each ' participant was given the opportunity to state issues most important to them and 29 issues were identified. Then each person was given 5 "stars" and each participant put a star by the ' 5 most important issues to them. A summary of these issues and their ranking is included in Appendix 1. ' A survey of 325 Calabash town and ETJ property owners and businesses was conducted in April, 1994. Of these 200 were sent to town property owners and 100 were sent to property owners living in the Town's extraterritorial jurisdiction. The questions on the survey addressed issues identified in the March 9th meeting as well as concerns of the Planning Board and Town Administration. By the April 27 deadline, 169 out of the 325 ' questionnaires which had been mailed had been received for a total response rate of 52 percent. This is an excellent response rate given that most mail surveys usually have a response rate of ' 30 to 35 percent. It should be noted that the survey elicited a voluntary response and therefore, is not considered a scientific, random survey. However, the survey was a valuable form of input, especially since it gave non-resident property owners a chance to ' state their opinions. A detailed summary of the survey results is also included in Appendix 1. r� 11 The May 16 public meeting was attended by 40 participants. At this meeting, the planning consultant gave a brief presentation about the issues identified at the March 9th meeting and the April survey results. The preliminary population projections and major planning issues were also presented. Inadvertently, the May 16th meeting was not advertised in the Brunswick Beacon as stipulated by the Town's Citizen Participation Plan. Consequently, this meeting was repeated on June 9th with proper notice being given in the Brunswick Beacon and 5 participants attended. A joint planning workshop with the Calabash Planning Board and Board of Commissioners was conducted on August 2nd to review the preliminary land use plan update. The draft was revised accordingly and the public was notified by a classified newspaper advertisement that the preliminary plan was available for review at the Town Hall. A public hearing concerning the preliminary draft plan was held on September 13th prior to the submission of the update to the Coastal Resources Commission in September 1994. Throughout the plan updating process, Calabash has demonstrated its desire to keep citizens informed of the planning process by giving them opportunities to provide public input and thereby participate in the decisionmaking process. W 11 POLICY STATEMENT: Calabash believes that its Planning Board which has regularly scheduled meetings, all of which are open to the public, provides opportunities for citizens to air their views and concerns about planning matters. The Planning Board will continue to be the primary vehicle for citizens, input. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: The Town will continue to use published public notices in the local newspaper to inform citizens of pending decisions involving land use planning matters in order to provide opportunities for input. As of 1994, Calabash does not have a locally adopted Storm Hazard Mitigation, Evacuation, and Post -Disaster Recovery Plan and relies solely upon the Brunswick County Storm Hazard Mitigation, Evacuation, and Post -Disaster Plan. The Town of Calabash is developing a Hurricane Evacuation Plan and an Emergency Response Plan with County and State assistance. Although Calabash is not an oceanfront community, the Town ' is located sufficiently inland so as not to feel the direct effects of a hurricane or northeaster. Calabash has fared relatively well since Hurricane Hazel in 1954 which did damage the waterfront restaurant area. However, it is important for the ' Town not to be lured into a false sense of security, especially since recent hurricanes such as Hugo and Andrew did so much damage to inland communities. 1. Storm Hazard Mitigation POLICY IDENTIFICATION: There is potential for flooding in the VE and AE zones bordering the Intracoastal Waterway and the Calabash River. These flood hazard areas are subject to a number of local, state, and federal standards which limit the placement of structures. POLICY STATEMENTS: In order to minimize the effects of a hurricane or other major storm, Calabash endorses the following: (a) High Winds Calabash supports enforcement of the NC State Building Code. The Town will continue to enforce the State Building Code on wind resistant construction with design standards of from 120 to 150 mph wind loads. 61 11 fl 1 L1 Calabash is an active participant in the National Flood Insurance Program and is supportive of hazard mitigation elements. Calabash is participating in the regular phase of the insurance program and enforces a Flood Damage Prevention Ordinance. Calabash also supports continued enforcement of the CAMA and 404 wetlands development permit processes in areas potentially susceptible to flooding. • •� t WERF• - - • • Calabash is supportive of the CAMA development permit process for estuarine shoreline areas and the requisite development standards which encourage both shoreline stabilization and facilitation of proper drainage. The Town of Calabash shall continue to discourage high - intensity uses and large structures from being constructed within the 100 year floodplain, erosion -prone areas, and other locations susceptible to hurricane and flooding hazards. The Town of Calabash shall consider acquisition of parcels located in hazard areas or rendered unbuildable by storms or other events, for the purpose of public water access and conservation of open space. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: (1) All new development must meet as a minimum the provisions of the North Carolina Building Code. (2) The Town's zoning ordinances set out requirements for low density residential development by setting standards for lot sizes, building heights, and building setbacks. (3) The Town's policies are in support of and consistent with State policies and regulations for development in Areas of Environmental Concern. (4) The Town's flood plain development policies conform with all Federal and State requirements and are enforced by the Town Administrator and/ or zoning officer. (5) Most of the mobile and manufactured homes in Calabash are located outside the 100-year floodplain. New manufactured homes are required to be tied down and blocked to meet North Carolina design -wind requirements for this area. 62 ' The Town of Calabash enforces these stated policies through its zoning ordinance, the Flood Ordinance, North Carolina Building Code, and the CAMA minor development permit process. Through these policies and equipped with these tools for enforcement, Calabash is dedicated to the mitigation of future storm damage. 2. Evacuation POLICY IDENTIFICATION: Calabash participates in a regional evacuation planning process administered by the Brunswick County Office of Emergency Management. Adequate shelter for evacuees is present inland at designated shelters. Total evacuation to these shelters is the safest procedure for Calabash to follow when a significant storm ' is imminent. Calabash does not have a warning system, therefore, evacuation efforts as directed by the Brunswick County Sheriff Department will be done by use of a public address system or by ' sending personnel door-to-door. POLICY STATEMENT: ' Calabash will provide for an orderly and timely evacuation of town residents and visitors during a declared emergency by following established procedures set forth by the Calabash ' Evacuation Plan and by the Brunswick County Emergency Management Agency. ' POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: Town officials will implement the County Evacuation Plan if an evacuation is ordered during a Hurricane warning. Town ' officials recognize that evacuation time is dependent upon the number, of visitors and residents. The lead time for an evacuation will be greater if a hurricane occurs during a peak ' period. 3. Post Disaster Recovery and Reconstruction Policies POLICY IDENTIFICATION: Until such time that a town disaster and reconstruction plan is adopted, the following reconstruction policies outline the procedures for allowing residents to return to their properties, the issuance of building permits, and the restoration of public ' facilities. POLICY STATEMENTS: ' (1) After a hurricane strikes, the Mayor of Calabash shall appoint a "Post -Disaster Recovery Task Force" and this team may include the following: the Town Clerk or Administrator; the Town ' Building Inspector; Board of Commissioners members; and other II u 63 ' representatives deemed appropriate. The Recovery Task Force will be responsible for overseeing the reconstruction process and any ' policy issues which may arise after a storm disaster. (2) Generally, reconstruction shall be held at least to the same development standards as before the storm in accord with the ' NC Building Code, the Calabash Zoning Ordinance and Flood Plain Management Regulations, and CAMA regulations and setback requirements. However, destroyed structures which did not conform to these development regulations must be redeveloped according to those policies. In some instances, this may.mean relocation of construction or no reconstruction at all. Building permits to restore destroyed or damaged structures which were ' built in conformance with the Town's building code and storm hazard mitigation policies, shall be issued automatically. All structures suffering major damage will be repaired according to ' the Town s building code. All structures suffering minor damage, regardless of their location, will be allowed to be rebuilt to the original condition prior to the storm. ' (3) Because of the density of development at Calabash and the possible extensive damage caused by a major storm, it may be necessary for the Town to suspend all redevelopment activities ' for a certain period of time after a storm. This "moratorium" could allow the Town time to carefully assess all damage in view of existing policies, building regulations, and ordinances in ' order to help determine whether existing policies should be revised to mitigate similar damage from future storms. The intent of such a moratorium would be to learn all the lessons possible and try and determine what steps and precautions the ' Town can take to rebuilding so as not to suffer damage to the same extent. If a moratorium is established, the time frame will be commensurate with the extent of the damage. The actual time frame will be determined by the Board of Commissioners. (4) In the event of extensive hurricane damage to public ' utilities requiring replacement or relocation of these utilities, efforts shall be made to locate damaged utilities away from hurricane hazard areas or to strengthen their construction. (5) Priority shall be given to the repair of public utilities which will restore service to as many persons as soon as possible. ' (6) The Board of Commissioners may request that a new assessment of hazard areas be performed, depending upon the extent of flooding and the changes to shoreline and inlets caused ' by the hurricane. (7) Public expenditure of funds for the repair or ' reconstruction of any private road or vehicular easement which is damaged or destroyed as a result of an intense storm event shall not occur, except in the conjunction with the repair of 1 64 ' town utilities. All other private roads will be the responsibility of the individual property owners. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: (1) The Town of Calabash shall closely monitor all ' construction efforts involving both public and private utilities, including roads, to provide for less vulnerable redevelopment after a storm. After a major storm, reconstruction and/or ' relocation of structures must be consistent with the NC Building Code, the Calabash Zoning and Flood Plain Management regulations, and CAMA regulations and setback requirements. ' (2) The Town of Calabash shall continue to support these policies for evacuation, recovery, and reconstruction as well as support planning efforts by the Brunswick County Emergency ' Services Agency. M The land classification system provides a uniform way of looking at how the use of land interacts with environmentally sensitive areas and with the development needs of a particular locality. It is not a strict regulatory device in the sense of a zoning ordinance or a zoning map. It represents more of a tool to aid in the understanding the relationships between various land use categories and how these relationships shape local policy. Particular attention is focused on the intensity at which land is used and the level of services needed to support that intensity. The regulations for the Coastal Area Management Act state: "The land classification system provides a framework to be used by local government to identify the future use of all lands. The designation of land classes allows the local government to illustrate their ' policy statements as to where and to what density they want growth to occur, and where they want to conserve natural and cultural resources by guiding growth." (7B.0204) (b) "By delineating land classes on a map, local government and its citizens can specify where certain policies (local, state, and federal) will apply. The land classification system is intended to be supported by zoning, subdivision and other local growth management tools and these local tools should be consistent with the classification system as much as possible. Although specific areas are outlined on a land classification map, it must be remembered that land classification is merely a tool to help implement policies and not in the strict sense of the term a regulatory mechanism." (7B.204) (a) The seven alternative land classifications authorized by 7B.204 (c), along with the Land Classification Map, are therefore intended to serve as a visual representation of the policies stated in Section V of this plan. The map depicting these classifications must be as flexible as the policies that guide them. (See the attached Map 5: Land Classification Map for the Town of Calabash.) Only three of the Coastal Resources Commission's seven types of land classifications are relevant to Calabash. The developed, urban transitional, and conservation classes are further identified and described below. L m A. DEVELOPED According to the CAMA planning regulations, the developed class of land provides for continued intensive development and redevelopment of existing cities, towns, their urban environs. Areas meeting the intent of the developed classification are currently urban in character where minimal undeveloped land remains, or are scheduled the timely provision of public services such as water, sewer, streets and roads, police and fire protection. Urban in character includes mixed land uses such as residential, commercial, institutional, and other uses. (7B.0204) (d) (1) and for Within Calabash, the areas complying with the above definition include the existing residential and commercial areas including those developed portions of the extraterritorial jurisdiction. Lots in these areas are nearly completely developed, and the undeveloped acreage could be developed by or before the year 2004. According to the CAMA planning regulations, the purpose of the urban transition class is to provide for future intensive urban development on lands that are suitable and that will be provided with the necessary urban services to support urban development. Areas meeting the intent of the urban transition classification are presently being developed for urban purposes or will be developed in the next five to ten years. These areas are in, or will be in an urban "transition" state of development going from lower intensity uses to higher intensity uses and as such will require urban services. Examples of areas meeting this class are lands included within the municipal and extraterritorial planning boundaries. This classification should not be applied to any Areas of Environmental Concern, lands of special value such as those containing archaeological sites or wildlife habitats, or areas subject to frequent flooding. (7B.0204) (d) (2) The lands in Calabash which are classified as urban transitional are those vacant land areas adjacent to currently developed areas including the extraterritorial jurisdiction. This includes some areas where lots have been platted as well as large tracts of unsubdivided land. Both the Marsh Harbour and Ocean Harbour golf courses are included in the urban transition class because it is anticipated that these developed golf courses will further be subdivided for residential development over the next ten years. L 1 67 rThe relationship between the "developed" and "urban transition" classification is an important one to ' understand. The first class is meant to define the already intensively developed areas and/or those areas where intensive development urban -type development is likely to occur. Urban transitional lands are those where public investment decisions will be required to provide the ' necessary urban services. These become important areas to monitor. ' The Coastal Resources Commission has further clarified this relationship. The Developed and Urban Transition classes should be the only lands under active consideration ' by a local government for intensive urban development requiring urban services. The area within these classes is where detailed local land use and public investment planning will occur. State and federal expenditures on projects ' associated with urban development such as water, sewer, and urban street systems will be guided only to these areas. ' Most of the urban transition lands of Calabash, including those in the extraterritorial area, already have access to either the Brunswick County Water Service or Carolina Blythe's water and sewer system. It is also anticipated ' that land classified as "urban transition" will be served by a centralized sewer system within the next 10 years. Other urban services such as solid waste collection are only available to those areas within the corporate limits who ' want such services. The development of primarily single-family structures ' and golf course development is likely to continue in Calabash and its extraterritorial jurisdiction. The developed and urban transition classes were specifically designed to accommodate these more intensive developments and. land uses. This may include commercial, community facilities, and transportation facilities. Hazardous or ' offensive uses such as power plants, heavy industries, airports, and storage facilities will not be included in these classes. Where identified constraints such as poor soils, AIWW easements, or other fragile areas occur within ' these classes, the areas will not be considered as Developed or Urban Transition. ' C. CONSERVATION The purpose of the Conservation class is to provide for the effective long-term management and protection of significant, limited, or irreplaceable areas. Areas meeting the intent of this classification include Areas of Environmental Concern such as coastal wetlands, estuarine ' waters and shorelines, and public trust areas as well as other unique lands that may not be afforded protection by another agency but are known for their natural,- scenic, ' historical, cultural, or hazardous nature. M Because of their unique, productive, cultural, or natural features, lands within the Conservation class should not be developed at all, or if developed, done so in an extremely limited and cautious fashion. Urban services, public or private, should not be provided in these areas as a catalyst to stimulate intense development. In most cases limited on site services will adequately support any limited development within this class and will also protect the very features which justify the area's inclusion in the Conservation class. It should be understood that even though AEC standards occasionally permit urban development on a lot by lot basis within the various AECS and that services are occasionally provided, this is the exception rather than the rule, and the primary intent of the conservation class is to provide protection for the resources included therein. (7B.0204) (d) (7) In Calabash, the lands described as the following Areas of Environmental Concern are listed in this classification: coastal wetlands, estuarine waters and shorelines, and public trust areas. k = m m = m m m m = m m = m = m = = m m TOWN OF CALABASH, N.C. 1994 LAND USE PLAN UPDATE PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PLAN Subchapter 7B of the N.C. Administration Code, CAMA Land Use Planning ' Guidelines, requires that the plan update process be conducted in the public arena. It is, therefore, the responsibility of the local government to involve, inform, and educate a broad cross-section of ' the population. There should be a continuous structure in place which both reaches out and invites diversified segments of the community to participate within its jurisdictional boundaries. ' The Town of Calabash is aware of this responsibility and will seek to carry out this obligation throughout the updating of its 1994 Land Use Plan. ' The following steps will be taken in order to provide information to the public and to maintain citizen involvement throughout the process: 1. Designation of Principal Local Board and Planner -in -Charge Ms. Margaret H. Hayes of the firm Hayes & Associates will serve as the Planner -in -Charge and will supervise the project. Mr. Bruce Kibblehouse and Mr. Al Smith will serve as the preliminary contacts between the Town of Calabash and the Planning Consultant. The Calabash Planning Board will be the principal local board directing ' the 1994 Land Use Plan Update with the Mayor and Board of Commissioners being involved. ' 2. Public Information Meetings Included as part of this plan is a schedule of events to inform and ' receive input from the citizens as well as from Town officials. The schedule includes three (3) public meetings and a survey of town and ETJ residents. The March 1994 Public Meeting will focus on the ' identification of planning issues and an explanation of the CAMA Land Use Planning Process. A survey of 300 town and ETJ residents will then be conducted in April 1994. The May 1994 Public Meeting will focus on the survey results, the presentation of data analysis and the existing land use map, and an assessment of the Town's land use policies. In June 1994, the draft policies, draft land classification map, hurricane mitigation and post disaster recovery policies, and plan sections will be presented to the Mayor, Board of Commissioners, and Planning Board in a joint planning workshop. Copies of the preliminary plan will then be available for public review during July ' 1994. The final public meeting will be conducted on August 1994 prior to the submission of the preliminary plan to the Coastal Resources Commission. In addition to the meetings outlined above it is anticipated that the Planning Consultant will meet at least monthly ' with the Town of Calabash Planning Board. These meetings will be open to the public and will be conducted on either the first or third Monday evenings of each month from February 1994 through September ' 1994. Public Notification of the Land Use Plan Update Meetings ' The public will receive notice of all its opportunities for input through the legal advertisement of the public meetings in the ' Brunswick Beacon, the local newspaper which is widely read by many of Calabash residents. Announcements concerning the public meetings will also be posted at the Calabash Town Hall as well as other key locations throughout the Town. Citizens will also be notified about ' the land use plan update through the Survey Questionnaire. All economic, social, ethnic, and cultural viewpoints will be considered in the development of the land use plan update. I1Q4AL:&QA-4 Adopted this the V day of ; 1994 by the Board of Commissioners of Calabash, North Carolina. By: 5;��� X-I�, Town Seal Title: Mayor 11 I r 0 F�A CORPORATE S SEAL : w :'�G % CITIZEN PARTICIPATION PLAN ' SCHEDULE OF EVENTS 1994 TOWN OF CALABASH LAND USE PLAN UPDATE TENTATIVE DATE* EVENT January 25, 1994 Board of Commissioners approves planning contract with Hayes & Associates. February 22, 1994 Board of Commissioners adopts Citizen r Participation Plan. March 9, 1994 Public Meeting: Assessment of Land Use Issues for Calabash April 1994 Citizen Survey Questionnaire distributed to sample of 300 Calabash Town and ETJ households. May 16, 1994 Public Meeting: Assessment of current land use policy statements, discussion of survey results and March public meeting, and presentation of data analysis and existing land use map. June 13, 1994 Joint planning workshop with Board of ' Commissioners and Planning Board to develop policy statements. July, 1994 Draft plan available for review in Town Hall and Brunswick County Planning Department. September 12, 1994 Public Meeting: Calabash Board of Commissioners approves submission of Draft Final Plan to the Coastal Resources Commission. * Actual dates subject to change as needs and circumstances dictate. 11 11 TOWN OF CALABASH . PUBLIC MEETING A public meeting will be held Wednesday, March 9th at 7:00 pm at the Calabash Fire Station concerning the 1994 CAMA Land Use Plan Update. The objective of the meeting is to assess land use issues for the Town of. Calabash and its extraterritorial jurisdiction. The public is invited to attend. Brunswick Beacon, :arch 3, 1994 TOWN OF CALABASH CAMA LAND USE: PLAN UPDATE PUBLIC MEETING A public meeting. will be held on Thursday, June 9, at 4:00 pm at the Calabash Town Hall. The objective of the meeting is to present the survey results and dis- cuss the major planning issues for the Town of Calabash and its extraterritorial jurisdiction. The same information will be presented as was discussed at the public meeting held on May 16. The public is invited to attend. 3runswick Beacon, June 2, 1994 TOWN OF CALABASH PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE 1994 CAMA LAND USE -PLAN UPDATE - CALABASH TOWN HALL TUESDAY,' SEPTEMBER 13;199417:00 PM The Town of Board of Commissioners will conduct a public. hearing to solicit comments regarding the Draft CAMA Land Use Plan Update prior to submitting the draft plan for state review. Copies of the plan are available in the Town Hall during regular office hours. Rr riswi _k Beacon, August 259 1994 11 I NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING The Town of Calabash will hold a public hearing on Tuesday, February 28, 1995 at 6:00 pm at the Town Hall of Calabash. PURPOSE: To hear and receive written comments on the proposed CAMA Land Use Plan Update prior to the Town Board of Commissioners adoption and submission of the plan to the Coastal Resources Commission for certification. All citizens are invited to attend. The plan is available for review at the Town Hall of Calabash during regular office hours Monday thru Friday from 8:30 am to 4:30 pm. The plan is also available for review at the Brunswick County Planning Department located at the Brunswick County Courthouse/Government Complex in Bolivia during regular office hours. The plan is being considered under the 5-year update requirements of the NC Coastal Area Management Act. Janet Thomas, Town Clerk Town of Calabash Brunswick Beacon, January 19, 1995 SUMMARY OF PLANNING ISSUES IDENTIFIED AT THE MARCH 9, 1994 TOWN OF CALABASH MEETING ' RANK* ISSUES (1) 16 No more commercial rezoning along NC 179 ' (2) 13 Need centralized sewer in areas not currently served (3) 12 Unify Town limits by annexing areas within town ' boundaries (4) 11 Need New Town Hall ' (5) 10 Need Police Protection 7 Need Town Manager 7 Put stoplight at NC 179 and Country Club Drive ' 7 Keep ETA as is -- No more annexations outside current town limits ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 6 Better enforcement of current laws 6 Develop Public Waterfront Park 6 Do more beautification of commercial areas ' 6 ------ BrunswickCountyshouldprovide more services to ETA - - - 5 Pave roads in ETA 5 Stop pollution of Calabash River -- Keep river pristine ' 5 relations between Town and ETA --------- ------Develop-better 4 ----------------------------------------------- Extend County water to areas not currently served --------------Limit 4 Growth'-- Keep -Calabash -as is 3 Minimize tax rate increases 3 Preserve and enhance small town character ' Dredge -------3------- 2 -Calabash -River ---------------------------------- Reduce Storm Water Runoff 2 More land for commercial use ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 Protect Ground water 1 Recycling ' 1 Install Directional Signs 1 Provide Sidewalks and Gutter Downtown 1 Annex ETA 0 Better utilization of waterwa s for recreation 0 Do not need town manager ' * Rank indicates number of meeting participants who cited issue as problem ' TOWN OF CALABASH SURVEY APRIL, 1994 ' Dear Fellow Residents of Calabash and the Greater Calabash Area: The Town of Calabash is in the process of updating its 1989 CAMA ' Land Use Plan which identifies issues and policies regarding land development over the next 5 to 10 years. Your involvement in this process by completing the following questionnaire is considered vital. ' All responses are confidential. Please return the questionnaire in the enclosed pre -addressed and stamped envelope by April 27th. Questionnaires are being mailed directly to Hayes & Associates, the ' planning firm which is preparing the land use plan update, in order to facilitate processing and ensure confidentiality. Thank you! Sincerely, George Anderson ' Mayor ' 1. How long have you lived in Calabash? Two years or less Two to five years Five to ten years ' More than ten years Native of the Calabash Area ' 2. Which of the following best describes your relationship to the Town of.Calabash? Permanent resident of the Town ' Permanent resident of the Extraterritorial Jurisdiction (ETJ) Non-resident property owner/seasonal visitor of Town ' Non-resident property owner/seasonal visitor of ETJ Owner/operator of business in Calabash area Other (please specify) 3. What, in your opinion, is the most important problem facing Calabash that the Town can do something about? 4. If you are a permanent resident, what was the major reason why you ' choose this area as your home? To enjoy the quiet family atmosphere Proximity of ocean and waterway ' Golfing facilities Low taxes Climate ' Employment/ Business Opportunity All of the above Other ' 2 5. If you are a non-resident property owner, what was the major reason why you acquired your property? ' For rental purposes/investment property For your family's enjoyment of the ocean /waterway Low taxes Golfing For future use as a retirement home All of the Above Other ' 6. In future years, would you like to see Calabash develop as: A Retirement Community Seafood and Restaurant Center/ Fishing Village A Golfing Resort Community All of the above Other: ' 7. Do you feel that Calabash is growing . . . Too fast ' Too slow Just about right Calabash has.had enough growth 8. Do you feel that the summer seasonal and tourist population . Exceeds Town's capacity Is about right ' Is low compared to other coastal towns 9. What type of development should be encouraged or discouraged? ' TYPE OF DEVELOPMENT ENCOURAGED DISCOURAGED Single-family residential ' Duplexes Multi -family residential Mobile homes Shopping facilities Industry ' Recreational Use 10. a. At the present time, many areas do not have a sewer system. ' Should the Board of Commissioners work towards establishing a community -wide sewer system? Yes No ' Not Sure No opinion ' b. If yes, should the Town provide sewer by: Participating in the South Brunswick Water & Sewer Authority Purchasing and expanding the Carolina Blythe Sewer System Other: Not Sure ' 3 11. What do you think are the most important issues now facing Calabash? Rank each item below according to the following scale: ' 2= Major Issue; 1= Minor Issue; 0= Not an Issue Preserve and enhance small town character Improve street lighting Upgrade all housing to minimum building code standards Limit commercial rezoning along NC 179 ' Annex unincorporated areas which are within the current town limits Annex ETJ areas outside of existing town limits Hire Town Manager Provide sidewalks and gutters in Restaurant/Commercial Area Expand and/or Build New Town Hall Provide stoplight at NC 179 and Country Club Drive ' Improve enforcement of existing ordinances and land use regulations Develop public waterfront park ' Pave dirt roads Improve street maintenance Provide boat and water access along Calabash River Do more beautification of restaurant/commercial area Improve water quality of Calabash River Improve stormwater management Minimize tax rate increases ' Protect groundwater Keep Calabash River navigable by dredging ' COMMENTS: 12. a. Is police (sheriff) protection in Calabash adequate? Yes No Not Sure/ No Opinion b. If no, how should the Town provide additional police protection? Establish Town of Calabash Police Department ' Contract with the Brunswick County Sheriff Department to provide local sheriff sub -station Other: ' 13. Do you feel that the existing land use ordinances are sufficiently protecting your property interests? ' Yes No, Why not No opinion ' 4 14. Are you currently satisfied with the following public services available in Calabash? If no, why not? ' YES NO SERVICE IF NO. WHY NOT? Town Administration ' Planning Building Inspection ' Brunswick County Sheriff Protection ' Volunteer Fire Protection Volunteer Rescue Services ' Trash Collection Water System (1) Brunswick County (2) Carolina Blythe ' Street Lighting Street Maintenance ' Street Paving Traffic Control ' Storm Drainage Town Cleanliness Mosquito Control ' Evacuation Planning 15. I would be willing to pay more taxes for the following: NO vQe Wn nn u More recreational facilities ' Fire Department Rescue Squad Police Department Water System ' Sewer System Street Improvements Drainage Improvements ' Public Garbage Collection Preservation of River Waterfront Park Development ' Others (Please Specify) ' 5 Thank you for your participation. In closing, the following information will be helpful in evaluating the results of the survey. Your responses will be kept confidential and will not be used for any other purpose. 16. What is your age group? ' Under 30 30 - 49 50 - 64 ' Over 65 17. What is the size of your household? ' 1 person 2 Person 3 person or more 18. Which best describes the type of residence? - Conventional Home Pre-fab Home ' Mobile Home Condominium ' 19. Do you own or rent the house in which you live? Own home Rent Own undeveloped lot(s) I 20. How many months of the year do you live at your Calabash residence? Year-round resident 6 - it months 3-5 months less than 3 months 21. What is the work status of the head(s) of household? Retired Working 40 hours week Working part-time 22. My family income is approximately: Under $10,000 $10,000 - $29,999 $30,000 - $49,999 Over $50,000 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: After completing the survey, please mail the questionnaire in the enclosed pre -stamped and self-addressed envelope. The questionnaires are being mailed directly to Hayes & Associates in order to facilitate processing and to insure confidentiality. PLEASE MAIL THE QUESTIONNAIRES TO THE HAYES & ASSOCIATES NO LATER THAN APRIL 27, 1994. THANK YOU! 1 RESULTS OF APRIL 1994 SURVEY 1994 CALABASH CAMA LAND USE PLAN UPDATE QUESTION Number of Surveys Sent Number of Surveys Received Percent Return TOTAL TOWN ETJ BUSINESS 325 200 100 25 169 127 35 7(5)* 52$ 64%- 351; 28%- ' * 5 Town residents who responded were also business owners in Calabash. These responses were included in the business section. LJ 1. How long have you lived in Calabash? 2 years or less 16 11 3 2 2 to 5 years 36 28 7 1 5 to 10 years 51 38 it 2 More than 10 years 58 42 13 2 Native of Calabash Area 8 3 1 4 2. Relationship to Town Permanent Resident of Town 131 121 - 10 ETJ Permanent Resident 32 - 31 1 Town non-resident property owner 2 2 - - ETJ non-resident property owner 3 - 3 - Operator of Business 1 - - 1 4. Permanent Resident: Major Reasons Live in Calabash Family Atmosphere 89 62 25 2 Ocean and Waterway 90 68 21 1 Golfing Facilities 69 57 11 1 Low Taxes 82 61 18 3 Climate 90 70 18 2 Employment/Business Opportunity 13 8 3 2 All of Above 26 23 1 2 Native of Area 7 3 - 4 5. Seasonal Residents: Major Reasons Choose Calabash Rental Purposes/Investment 3 1 1 1 Ocean and Waterway 4 1 2 - Low Taxes 4 1 2 1 Golfing 3 2 1 - Future Retirement Home 4 1 2 1 All of Above - - - - 6. In the future, Calabash should develop as: Retirement Community 45 33 12 - Seafood Restaurant/Fishing village 25 17 5 3 Golfing Resort Community 19 15 4 1 All of Above 84 61 16 7 QUESTION TOTAL 7. Do you feel that Calabash is growing Too fast 19 Too slow 16 Just about right 116 Calabash has had enough growth it TOWN . 13 8 90 6 ETJ BUSINESS 4 2 7 1 19 7 5 0 8. Summer seasonal population is: Exceeds Towns capacity 35 20 12 3 Is about right 91 69 16 6 Low compared other coastal towns 29 24 4 1 9. What type of development should be encouraged or discouraged? (Responses reported as encouraged/discouraged) Single-family residential 151/3 113/2 33/1 11/0 Duplexes 28/90 20/70 5/19 3/1 Multi -family residential 17/109 9/87 4/20 4/2 Mobile Homes 16/114 9/87 6/19 1/8 Shopping Facilities 100/44 69/36 24/7 7/1 Industry 33/94 22/72 7/18 4/4 Recreational Use 112/19 80/16 25/3 7/0 10a. Should Town establish sewer system? Yes 121 85 27 9 No 15 12 3 1 Not Sure 24 19 3 2 No Opinion 6 5 1 - b. Town should provide sewer by: Participate in South Brunswick Water and Sewer Authority 49 28 17 4 Purchase Carolina Blythe 56 52 3 1 Not Sure 38 25 9 4 11. Summary Ranking of Major Issues 235 Preserve and enhance small town character 233 Minimize tax rate increase 227 Provide stoplight at NC 179 and Country Club Drive 217 Protect groundwater 208 Improve enforcement of existing ordinances and land use regulations 203 Upgrade all housing to minimum code standards 193 Limit commercial rezoning along NC 179 187 Improve stormwater management 184 Improve water quality of Calabash River 183 Improve street maintenance 170 Annex unincorporated areas which are within the current Town limits 164 Keep Calabash River navigable by dredging 157 Do more beautification of restaurant/commercial area 156 Pave dirt roads 146 Improve street lighting 136 Expand and/or build new Town Hall 118 Develop public waterfront park 115 Provide sidewalks and gutters in Restaurant/Commercial area 101 Annex ETJ areas outside of existing town limits 94 Provide boat and water access along Calabash River 71 Hire Town Manager QUESTION TOTAL TOWN ETJ BUSINESS 12a. Is police (sheriff) protection adequate? Yes 55 42 9 4 No 66 48 16 2 Not Sure/No Opinion 38 26 8 4 b. If no, how should Town provide additional protection? Establish Town Police Department 11 5 4 2 Co. provide sheriff sub -station 74 54 15 5 ' 13. Do you feel that existing land use ordinances protect your property interests? Yes 85 70 11 4 No 18 12 5 1 No Opinion 48 29 15 4 i14. Are you currently satisfied with the following public services available in Calabash? ( Yes/No) QUESTION TOTAL TOWN ETJ BUSINESS Town Administration 109/19 90/11 12/5 7/3 Planning 101/13 85/4 9/6 7/3 ' Building Inspection 106/19 85/11 16/4 5/4 Brunswick Co. Sheriff Dept. 83/59 66/43 13/12 4/4 Fire Protection 145/5 Rescue Services 140/11 111/4 106/9 26/17 26/2 8/0 8/0 Trash Collection 107/21 92/11 7/8 6/2 Brunswick Co. Water Service 60/10 36/9 16/0 8/1 ' Carolina Blythe 83/25 76/20 5/3 2/2 Street Lighting 110/28 94/14 12/8 3/6 Street Maintenance 101/33 80/26 17/3 4/4 Street Paving 96/31 79/21 14/6 3/4 Traffic Control 70/51 55/41 13/5 2/5 Storm Drainage 74/44 62/31 11/7 1/6 ' Town Cleanliness 87/39 Mosquito Control 54/59 68/32 41/45 14/5 9/10 5/2 4/4 Evacuation Planning 74/20 60/16 10/1 4/3 ' COMMENTS ABOUT PUBLIC SERVICES: TOWN ADMINISTRATION Argue too much, too much infighting All Yankees! Extremely rude and hard to deal with! Poor attendance and have accomplished little. Still fighting Northerners! PLANNING Too haphazard. ' Have not heard enough of Planning Board, where are they? Needs to be more independent. Give Planning Board more authority. Needs to be more independent with Businesses trying to direct people to their business with signs. ' BUILDING INSPECTION Inconsistent/ Too autocratic The worst! Should be even-handed and inspector should know what he is doing. A good friend of mine has been misused by Inspection. BRUNSWICK COUNTY SHERIFF DEPARTMENT 2- Need more sheriffs. We pay high taxes, why not more protection? 4-Too long to get here/ too far to travel. 4- Need substation. Only available on call. Break-in/Robberies. ' FIRE PROTECTION Very good/ excellent. Need more volunteers. ' RESCUE SERVICES 2- Need faster response ' Need more volunteers Need more training requirements 911 is poor ' TRASH COLLECTION 4-ETJ- What trash collection? Business Response:Has been disbanded to reduce Yankees taxes. ' More dumpsters needed. Fee is too high. 2- Need dumping station to be opened each day. ' BRUNSWICK COUNTY WATER SERVICE Needs to be available for all. We have well water, county water not available. ' County can do more. CAROLINA BLYTHE WATER SYSTEM Stale at times. Water charge for non -house use should not be so high. Water too high-priced. ' 2- Water tastes bad. Must use bottled water for cooking and drinking. STREET LIGHTING Need more in Carolina Shores. (ETJ) None available unless we pay for our own. Don't have any. 2-Need more at intersections, crossroads, etc. STREET MAINTENANCE AND PAVING Poor patching 4- Some streets need paving Roads too narrow/ too long to repair potholes Could be better Problem with drainage and ditches ' TRAFFIC CONTROL 6- Need stoplight at NC 179 and Country Club Drive NC 179 too crowded to US 17 ' 3- There is no traffic control 3- Some intersections need stoplights Slow down traffic on Country Club Drive STORM DRAINAGE 3- Too much water in ditches Needs to be controlled more ' Water from uphill washes me away 2- Inadequate for growing area Sections of NC 179 and Carolina Shores needs improvement TOWN CLEANLINESS 2- Businesses can do better job Disappointed that local businesses seem to think, "Let Elks do it!" Cover all trash bins Dirty roadsides Create volunteer groups Culverts, Ditches - litter is bad MOSQUITO CONTROL 5- Do we have any? Need to do more than just Carolina Shores 2- Too much standing water Difficult to control safely Do more often in summer EVACUATION PLANNING ' What road should I take? 3- What plan? Not aware of any. ' 15. I would be more willing to pay more taxes for the following: QUESTION TOTAL TOWN ETJ BUSINESS (Yes/No) Recreational facilities 20/97 12/79 4/15 4/3 Fire Department 56/64 39/52 12/10 5/2 Rescue Squad 57/61 40/49 13/9 4/3 Police Department 54/24 41/12 11/10 4/2 Water System 38/78 24/65 8/11 6/2 Sewer System 46/71 29/62 11/9 6/0 Street Improvements 38/72 26/60 10/10 2/2 Drainage Improvements 44/58 34/49 6/8 4/1 Public Garbage Collection 22/96 7/80 12/12 3/4 Preservation of River 44/59 34/46 5/11 5/2 Waterfront Park Development 27/64 21/53 4/7 2/4 DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS TOTAL TOWN ETJ BUSINESS 16. What is your age group? Under 30 0 0 0 0 30 -49 8 6 1 1 50- 64 51 31 14 6 Over 65 100 82 15 3 17. What is the size of your household? 1 person 21 13 6 2 2•persons 121 96 21 4 3 persons or more 17 9 4 4 IDEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS TOTAL TOWN ETJ BUSINESS 18. Which describes your type of residence ' Conventional home 145 117 18 10 Pre-fab Home 4 1 3 Mobile Home 9 2 7 - ' Condominium 1 1 - - 19. Do you own or rent the home in which you live? - ' Own home 158 Rent 1 121 - 27 1 10 Own Undeveloped Lot 2 2 20. How many months of the year do you live at your Calabash residence? Year-round Resident 148 112 28 8 ' 6 - 11 months 5 5 3- 5 months 1 0 1 - less than 3 months 1 - - 1 21. What is the work status of the head of household? Retired 121 100 20 1 ' Working 40 hours a week 27 15 5 7 Working part-time 18 10 6 2 ' 22. My family income is approximately . Under $10,000 3 2 1 - ' $10,000 - $29,999 46 29 15 2 $30,000 - $49,999 57 46 7 4 Over $50,000 31 25 2 4 ' COMMENTS/OPEN-ENDED QUESTIONS 3. What is the most important problem facing Calabash that the Town ' can do something about? SEWER ' 38 - Sewer or Water and Sewer County should do sewer 4 - Prefer buying Carolina Blythe and letting Sunset Beach go their own way ' Resolve sewer issue practically, not politically We need sewer more than anything else because Calabash is growing too fast and our land can only take care of so much. ' Go forward with Regional South Brunswick Resolving the water sewer problem in the best interest of Calabash 1 ' SEWER. continued Face up to the fact that we are a small town. Let professionals extend water and sewer service (Carolina Blythe) - with 2/3 ' of the Town adequately covered why risk going into debt when Carolina Blythe can and is willing to extend service into unserved areas. We are too small to be major backer of new sewer authority. ' Carolina Shores has water and sewer. Town was offered several times the opportunity to hook up and they refused! ' Therefore, Carolina Shores should not be taxed for town sewers. APPEARANCE 3 - Prevent the look of North Myrtle Beach - tacky. ' Continue to clean-up the river front. Area behind dockside restaurant could be a small park. The development of Rt. 179 (must eliminate the US/17 Myrtle Beach type of development.) ' Improve appearance of downtown. 4 - I like Calabash the way that it is. ' 3 Keep it quiet. - Maintain quaint reputation as seafood capital of South, not honky tonk commercialism 2 - Cheap businesses operating- Gambling casinos, Wings, Eagles,etc. 2 - Don't want town to lose small. town look ' 5 - Enforce clean-up of property (trash, abandoned cars,etc.) Removal of unoccupied, dilapidated, unsafe housing Make businesses clean-up and paint. "Looks like hell" ' Pick-up trash. 2 - Beautify waterfront/waterfront development. 2 - Too commercial/Limit commercialism in Town. ' Clean-up waterways. No lighted signs. Mobile homes and selling wares beside them. Some commercial areas are a mess. Enforce regulations to make ' them presentable. Empty or not used lots should be cleaned, landscaped, and improved at owners' expense. The restaurants should take pride in the improvement of its area and pay for it. Parts of the original town are not kept to minimum standard, cleanliness, and some order of acceptability for tourists. Don't stick noses in business owners' business as long as ' business is kept respectable. Architecture on NC 179 should be quaint, no Wings! ' GROWTH/ANNEXATION 4 - Planning/Zoning. 2 - Too rapid and uncontrolled growth/Growth. ' Too many restrictions - want too much to control people - wanting to change Town to New York. Minimize strip commercial zoning - takes away from small town feel. ' Minimize multiple housing. Mobile homes should be done away with. Biggest drawback of Town. ' Cooperative understanding of the future of the Town. ' GROWTN/ANNEXATION, continued Quit trying to change everything. I moved here because I like it the way it is. If someone wants to live in a metropolitan area, let them move. Control of growth. We do not need hi -rise condos, another Barefoot Landing, shopping malls, more restaurants, or topless bars. ' Zoning trailers. Strictly enforce health codes, building codes. Calabash is a quiet, peaceful town and we like it that way. It's getting too crowded with people building, not being ' satisfied with the building, and then building over again. This represents a full menu to be sure, but with careful planning we can see it all happen in its own good time. Limited space should take care of overdevelopment. Calabash is a wonderful area and great care should be exercised before "change for changes sake" takes place. We need to work together. ' Pay for professional planning services. Protecting the waterfront & surrounding marine life for both the ' original residents and those of us who are "newcomers." I think Calabash Acres and some other surrounding areas should be annexed into the Town. If the people outside the City limits don't want to be annexed then leave them alone. ' Annex satellite areas. I don't think annexing areas outside of Town is good. If force annexation, then there will be hard feelings. Areas will ' come when they want to. Keep Calabash small town - no annexation of ETJ! ' PUBLIC SERVICES/TOWN ADMINISTRATION 2 - Get more people involved in town affairs in order to unify Town. More information made public on board meeting decisions. Education. Clean water. 2 - Hire independent, experienced town manager to keep us out of ' financial difficulties, yet show progress towards reasonable goals. Sometimes doing nothing on many issues is the best thing for taxpayers. Improve and maintain storm water trenches or we all will die of ' malaria. With sewers, the dredging of the Calabash River is a must and will help remove pollution. Important that taxes are controlled, because not to control brings fraud. A pure water system that can be affordable and meet future needs ' of community. Town employees are not lifetime residents and are very rude and nasty. Give positions to locals who are not retired from the North. Cut growth in drainage ditches. 6 - Pave roads/ road improvements. ' 4 - Sidewalks/bike paths along NC 179 and perhaps Country Club. ' PUBLIC SERVICES/TOWN ADMINISTRATION, continued 4 - Need Calabash Police Department. Push County for park near here. ' Keep Raleigh politicians out of businesses unless we request. 3 - Runoff/Storm drainage. Make sure property assessments are correct. Should be market value, not replacement value. ' Since new government took over, no new services at all but pay taxes so Yankees live comfortably. 2 - Dredging of Calabash River. ' No county water some places. People putting garbage on undeveloped land beside property. Taxes high enough. Cut welfare and put people to work in county ' jobs. Concerned about crime. Can't handle with current sheriff system. Un-merge Town with Carolina Shores. TRAFFIC CONTROL 7 - Put stoplight at NC 179 and Country Club Drive. Be careful of number of drives opening unto Highway 179. 2 - Traffic control. Improve traffic control during summer. Roads and traffic conditions around Persimmons Road, Thomasboro Rd., and Pinewood Drive. THER 2 No supermarket. Control American Golf from ruining value of homes in Carolina Shores. Treat Acreage as equal to Carolina Shores. Calabash too small for snowbirds. 5 - Stop infighting between Carolina Shores and Old Calabash - the world doesn't revolve around Carolina Shores. Golfing relations. As a member of the clergy, I do appreciate the opportunity to participate and want the best for both the old and new residents. Surveys of this nature are useless if our elected officials do not act upon them as we have directed.. Good survey! Will the results of this survey be made public? rl C A I!\ YA Map 3: Flood Hazards in ZONE X ZONE AE (16EL) �. Iwrw• Lois r• I — IZONE VE (16 EL)J � I I ` bash'Planning Area.' �i - ,\ Y �/ Source: Firm Maps (Exact Areas Must Be Determined By Official Firm Maps) CALABASH North Carolina ®ZONE AE - 100 YEAR FLOOD ZONE WITH BASE ELEVATIONS DETERMINED ZONE VE - COASTAL FLOOD AREA WITH - VELOCITY HAZARD (WAVE ACTION) ZONE X - AREAS OF 500 YEAR FLOOD ZONE ZONE X - AREAS OUTSIDE 500 YEAR FLOOD ZONE SCALE 1" - 1200' THIS MAP WAS PREPARED BY THE DIVISION OF COMMUNITY ASSISTANCE FOR THE TOWN OF CALABASH, NORTH CAROLINA. Source: Brunswick County Tax Maps, Map Date: 1994 rIIrASA:I,X Of 7H,.S RAP WAS tINANCID IN FAST THOUGH A GIANT FROVIDID BY TNI NORTH CAROLINA COASTAL NANACDQNT ISOGIAA. TIBOUCN rL'NDS ?NOV IDID TNI COASTAL ZONI K4XAGMaNT ACT Or 1972, AS ANINDID, VNIC11 IS ADNINISTINID ET TRI OFFICI OF OCIAN AND COASTAL IISOVSCI NANAGatINT, NATIONAL OCLWIC AND ATNOS►NIIIC ADNINISTIATION. 2: alabash J Use Map 1994 ry INA. DHD BY THE NORTH PREPARATION OF THIS PLAY MAJ r in^^"' THROUG• UGH FUNDS _PROVIDED THE COASTAL ZONE CAROLINA COASTAL MANACEMENT PROGRAMS T COASTAL R.ESOURCEPMANAOEMENT1972, AS ,NATIONAL OCEANICNDED, WHICH IS AAND NATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION.ISTERED BY THE OFFICE or AND I