Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLand Use Plan Update-19931 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 DCM COPY R`Y'A ` DCM COPY lease do not remove!!!!! Division of Coastal Management Copy 1993 Update s BRUNSWICK COUNTY LAND USE PLAN 1993 UPDATE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Donald E. Warren, Chairman Tom B. Rabon, Vice -Chairman Jerry W. Jones Wayland Vereen Marvin Donald Shaw Jr. PLANNING BOARD John L. Barbee, Chairman Troy L. Price, Vice Chairman Thomas F . Gray John W. Thompson Marion R. Warren Jerry W. Jones, Ex-Officio BRUNSWICK COUNTY PLANNING DEPARTMENT John Harvey, AICP, Planning Director Don Eggert, AICP, Planner II GLENN HARBECK ASSOCIATES Planning and Public Involvement Wilmington, NC J This plan was prepared in accordance with T15A: 078.100 Land Use Planning Guidelines under the I Coastal Area Management Act of 1974, as amended. FINAL PUBLIC HEARING ON AUGUST 16, 1993. PLANNING BOARD ADOPTION ON AUGUST 18, 1993. FINAL ADOPTION BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON SEPTMOM 7, 1993. ADOPTION BY THE N.C. COASTAL RESOURCES COMMISSION ON SEPTEMBER 24, 1993. U) 0 m m m m m Brunswick County Land Use Plan Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 ' 1. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS 8 1.1 Establishment of Information Base 8 , 1.2 Present Conditions 9 1.2.1 Population and Economy 9 1.2.2 Existing Land Use Analysis 28 ' 1.2.3 Current Plans, Policies and Regulations 34 1.3 Constraints, Land Suitability 48 1.3.1 Physical Limitations for Development 48 1.3.2 Fragile Areas 52 ' 1.3.3 Areas With Resource Potential 58 1.4 Constraints, Carrying Capacity Analysis 62 1.4.1 Potable Water System 62 ' 1.4.2 Sewer and Storm Drainage 65 1.4.3 Transportation 66 1.4.4 Law Enforcement 1.4.5 Fire and Rescue 69 69 ' 1.4.6 Schools 70 1.4.7 Library System 75 1.4.8 Parks, Recreation, and Waterfront Access 76 1.4.9 Solid Waste Management 77 , 1.5 Anticipated Demand 78 1.5.1 Permanent and Seasonal Populations 78 1.5.2 Future Land Use Needs 80 ' 1.5.3 Community Facilities Demands 83 2. POLICIES FOR GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT 84 Introduction to the Policies 84 ' 2.1 Resource Protection Policies 86 2.1.1 Constraints To Development 86 2.1.2 Areas of Environmental Concern 86 2.1.3 Other Hazardous or Fragile Land Areas 89 ' 2.1.4 Hurricane and Flood Evacuation 94 2.1.5 Protection of Potable Water Supply 94 2.1.6 Package Sewage Treatment Plants 95 ' 2.1.7 Stormwater Runoff 96 2.1.8 Marina and Floating Home Development 97 2.1.9 Industrial Impacts on Fragile Areas 97 2.1.10 Development of Sound and Estuarine System Islands 98 ' 2.1.11 Development Near Sea Level 99 2.1.12 Upland Excavation for Marina Basins 100 2.1.13 Marsh Damage from Bulkhead Installation 100 ' 2.2. Resource Production And Management Policies 102 2.2.1 Productive Agricultural Lands 102 2.2.2 Commercial Forest Lands 102 2.2.3 Mineral Production Areas 102 ' 2.2.4 Commercial and Recreational Fisheries 103 2.2.5 Off Road Vehicles 104 2.2.6 Development Impacts 104 2.2.7 Peat or Phosphate Mining Impacts 104 ' 2.3 Economic And Community Development Policies 105 2.3.1 Types and Locations of Industries Desired 105 2.3.2 Provision of Services to Development 106 ' 2.3.3 Urban Growth Pattern Desired 107 2.3.4 Redevelopment, including Relocation of Threatened Structures 107 2.3.5 Commitment to State and Federal Programs 108 ' Brunswick County Planning Board Glenn Harbeck Associates I I BrunswKx County Land Use Plan Contents ' 2.3.6 Channel Maintenance and Beach Renourishment 109 2.3.7. Energy Facilities 109 ' 2.3.8 Tourism 110 2.3.9 Coastal and Estuarine Beach Water Access 111 2.3.10 Residential Development 113 2.3.11 Commercial Development 113 2.3.12 Beautification 114 ' 2.3.13 Airports 114 2.3.14 Education 115 2.3.15 Retirees 116 ' 2.3.16 Waste Management 117 2.3.17 Growth and Development Controls 118 2.4 Public Participation Policies 120 ' 2.5 Storm Hazard Mitigation, Post -Disaster Recovery and Evacuation Plan 122 2.5.1 Storm Hazard Mitigation 124 2.5.2 Post Disaster Reconstruction 127 ' 3. LAND CLASSIFICATION 135 3.1 Purpose of Land Classification and Relationship ' to Policies 135 3.2 Overview of Land Classification System 135 3.3 Descriptions of Individual Land Classes 136 3.3.1 Developed 136 3.3.2 Urban Transition 137 ' 3.3.3 Limited Transition 138 3.3.4 Community 140 3.3.5 Rural 140 ' 3.3.6 Rural -Industrial 141 3.3.7 Rural with Services. 142 3.3.8 Conservation 142 ' 4. INTER -GOVERNMENTAL COORDINATION AND MUNICIPAL LAND USE PLANS 145 4.1 Inter -governmental Coordination 145 ' 4.2 Municipal Land Use Plans 145 5. SUMMARY OF PUBLIC PARTICIPATION 148 ' 6. ACTION AGENDA FOR THE BRUNSWICK COUNTY LAND USE PLAN 155 I APPENDICES After Page 176 Brunswick County Planning Board Glenn Harbeck Associates Executive Summary Brunsw& Cou= Land Lise Plan 6ecutive Executive Summary ' Need For Brunswick County's growth rate continues to outpace most areas of Planning the country. The attractiveness of the county's natural features, ' combined with higher levels of disposable income in the nation as a whole, greater emphasis on the importance of leisure time, and growing elderly population, has created a tremendous boom in ' growth and development in the county. As the county becomes more generally developed, however, new problems must be faced, including: land use conflicts, traffic congestion, ever-growing public expenditures for the services and facilities required by this new growth, and possible degradation of ' the very features that have been so instrumental in attracting large numbers of people to Brunswick County. The intent of the Land Use Plan is to anticipate and plan for this growth. Such planning should work to protect and enhance the quality of life of area residents and should also wisely manage the ' natural resources with which the county has been blessed. At the same time, advanced planning and foresight can help minimize increases in the local tax burden, through sound public and private ' investment decisions. The North Carolina General Assembly recognized these issues when it passed the Coastal Area Management Act of 1974, which requires local governments in the ' coastal area to develop land use plans and update them every five years. The first Brunswick County Land Use Plan was adopted in 1976, with updates following in 1981 and 1987. This update refines ' the 1987 plan to address current conditions, issues and trends in the county. 'Functions of the The Land Use Plan performs several important functions for local Plan governing bodies and the general public; these functions are briefly described below: ' • Source of Information - The plan's technical studies provide information on a number of topics, including the local economy, ' population, environmental features, land use trends and community facility needs. • Guidance for Government Decisions - Once the governing body adopts the plan, it then has a foundation for guiding future decisions on budgets and ordinances, including zoning and subdivision ' regulations. • Preview of Government Action - Decisions of the public in general, and developers in particular, are easier to make when the probable I Brunswick County Planning Board page 1 Glenn Harbeck Associates outcome of governmental decisions is understood; the adoption of a land use plan, increases the predictability of government actions. • Public Participation in Managing Growth - Public meetings and hearings held during the plan's preparation help to insure that the plan reflects, to the extent possible, the specific nature of the current growth issues facing the county. Ingredients of Several major steps were involved in preparing the Brunswick the Plan County Land Use Plan. First, a number of technical studies were made of past and present conditions in the county. From these initial studies, forecasts for future growth and development of the area were summarized. Finally, policies and a land classification map were devised to address present and future needs. Technical Studies A number of basic studies are required so that a solid information base can be established for sound policy decisions. These basic studies include the following subjects: • Population and Economy • Impact of Seasonal Population • Existing Land Use Analysis • Current Plans, Policies and Regulations • Evaluation of Previous Land Use Plan Effectiveness • Physical Limitations for Development • Fragile Areas • Areas with Resource Potential • Water Supply • Sewage Treatment and Storm Water Runoff • Transportation Facilities • Police • Fire and Rescue • Schools • Parks and Recreation • Solid Waste • Population and Economic Projections • Future Land Use Needs • Community Facility Demands Collectively, these studies summarize past and present conditions, while providing the basis for estimating future conditions. The results of these studies are contained in full in Section 1 of the Brunswick County Land Use Plan. In addition, detailed mapping of existing land use is available for inspection at the offices of the Brunswick Cou:, Planning Department. LI I Brunswick County Planning Board page 2 Glenn Harbeck Associates ' Brunswick County Land Use Plan Executive Summary 7 L II Highlights of the Technical Studies Population During much of the 1950's, the population of Brunswick County was less than 20,000 and growth was negligible. During the 60's, the county's population increased by about 20% to a little over 24,000. During the 1970' and 80's, however, the population exploded by 48% and 43% respectively. The 1990 Census counted over 50,000— up from 36,000 just a decade earlier. The year round county population is expected to reach approximately 66,000 persons by the year 2000, and 80,000 by 2010. Economy The economic analysis included the following trends for Brunswick County: • A continued decline in agriculturally -based employment. • A continued decline in seafood and fisheries -based employment. • A relative decline in manufacturing employment as a percentage of total employment, compared to service and trade employment. • A continued increase in the volume of travel and tourism related expenditures as a percentage of the total local economy. • A continued increase in the so-called "mailbox" economy of the county's rapidly growing retirement population; i.e., transfer payments. Land Use ' The analysis of existing land use revealed several significant land use trends and problems: • Scattered, unattractive development along beach roads creating a poor image. • Sprawling subdivision activity which is difficult to serve. • Initiatives underway to create small area sewage treatment systems. • Continued rapid growth along the county's water -oriented edges. ' Water Supply The main source of water for the County system was changed in the early 1980s from groundwater to the Cape Fear River. Since the system was established, over 100 subdivisions have installed and dedicated water distribution systems to the County. Some 10,000+ lots in the county are currently served by the water system. In September of 1990, work was completed on a new Water ' Distribution System Master Plan which analyzed the current distribution system, projected future water consumption, and recommended improvements to the system for action by 1991., 1995 and 2010. This plan is being carried out. I Brunswick County Planning Board page 3 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Executive Summary Waste Water Disposal The suitability of area soils for septic tanks continues to be one of the primary constraints on the future growth and development of the county. Despite the apparent need for centralized sewage treatment. the county's sparse development patterns make the provision of a single, central sewage treatment system unworkable. Areas where there are concentrations of small lots or higher density development (such as near the beach communities) offer some possibilities, however. As a result, there are several local area initiatives underway which would seek to address this need. Transportation Facilities The four-laning of US 17 through the county is doing much to alleviate congestion on this major traffic artery. In addition, the completion of a by-pass around Shallotte and another by-pass around Bolivia will further enhance the flow of traffic through the county. Secondary roads and bridges leading to several of the county's ocean beaches continue to present a problem on peak summer weekends. Policies For The technical reports described above were geared to gathering and Growth and summarizing information related to the growth of the planning area. Development Building upon this information, a number of policies were prepared by the County Planning Board for consideration by the Brunswick County Board of Commissioners. The policies presented in this document are the result of weighing factual information with public input about growth issues; as officially adopted policies of the County, they will serve as the basis for future decisions on capital improvements, ordinances, zoning decisions, subdivision approvals, and other similar matters. Land Classification Map Some of the policies make reference to specially mapped areas; the Land Classification Map contained in the Land Use Plan illustrates these areas. The seven land classification categories (Developed, Urban Transition, Limited Transition, Community, Rural, Rural - Industrial, and Conservation) were adapted from the Coastal Area Management Act's land use planning guidelines. By assigning the land classes to specific parts of the county, the map shows visually where and at what density growth should occur, and where significant natural resources are to be carefully managed. In addition, incorporated communities not included in the County's land classification system are simply shown as Municipal on the land classificaticn mn p. The various mapped areas may be summarized as follows: Brunswick County Planning Board page 4 Glenn Harbeck Associates I Brunswick Courny Lmnc Use Plan Executive Summary ' Municipal The towns of Belville, Bolivia, Boiling Spring Lakes, Calabash, ' Caswell Beach, Holden Beach, Leland, Long Beach, Navassa, Oak Island, Ocean Isle Beach, Shallotte, Southport, Sunset Beach, and Yaupon Beach are covered by plans prepared independently of the ' County Plan. For the purpose of the County plan, all are shown on the land classification map as Municipal. The reader is referred to each Town's plan for specifics on each community's land classification system. Developed ' = The purpose of the Developed class is to provide for continued intensive development and redevelopment of existing cities, towns and their urban environs. The three communities of Sandy Creek. ' Varnamtown and Bald Head Island, while not part of the unincorporated area of Brunswick County, are included under the general purview of the County Plan until such time as they may prepare their own plan. Of the three, Bald Head Island and ' Varnamtown have been designated in the Developed class. (Sandy Creek is addressed under the Community Classification). ' Urban Transition The purpose of the Urban Transition class is to provide for future urban development on lands that are most suitable and that will be scheduled for the provision of a full range of public utilities and services within the ensuing 10 years. Included in the Urban Transition class are areas generally within the vicinity of an existing municipality and/or areas being considered for the provision of some form of centralized sewer facility. Limited Transition The purpose of the Limited Transition class is to provide for future development on lands that are suitable and that will be scheduled for ' the provision of a limited range of public utilities and services within the ensuing 10 years. Included in the Limited Transition class are areas generally not likely to see the provision of centralized sewer ' facilities for the foreseeable future. They are, however, either currently being served or planned to be served by the County water ' distribution system. Community The purpose of the Community class is to provide for clustered land ' development to help meet housing, shopping, employment, and public service needs within the rural areas of the county. This class incluc+P.q, for example, the communities of Maco, Mill Creek, ' Ash/Waccamaw, Bell Swamp/Winnabow, Grissettown, Sandy Creek, Supply, and Piney Grove. ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 5 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Executive Summary Rural The purpose of the Rural class is to provide for agriculture, forest management, mineral extraction, and other low intensity uses. Residences may be located within Rural areas where urban services are not required and where natural resources will not be permanently impaired. This land class occurs extensively on the north and west sides of US 17. Rural -Industrial This is a special subclass of the more general Rural classification. It is designed to recognize areas currently developed for large scale industrial type uses, and lands that have been identified as particularly appropriate for future industrial development. Generally, industries locating to these areas might be considered inappropriate for location in a more densely developed, mixed use urban setting. The rural -industrial land classification has been applied, for the most part, to several relatively large land areas with convenient access to the shipping channels of the Cape Fear River. Other land areas are largely adjacent to these existing industrial operations. Conservation The purpose of the Conservation class is to provide for effective, long-term management of significant limited or irreplaceable areas. This management may be needed because of its natural, cultural, recreational, productive or scenic values. By definition, this class includes but is not limited to all Areas of Environmental Concern (AECs), all 404 wetlands, and all critical habitat areas. Major Changes Transition Area Redrawn and Divided Into Two New From the 1987 to Categories the 1992 Updated Plan The boundaries of Transition areas identified on the Land Classification Map have been redrawn to reflect the most up to date information on the probability of providing water and sewer services to development in the next 10 years. Two new sub -categories of the general Transition class have been created as described above: Limited Transition and Urban Transition. New Industrial Land Class Established The new rural -industrial land class was created to allow for special recognition of areas in the unincorporated county either currently in use for industrial purposes or particd:z�i'7 well suited for such use. (See description above) Brunswick County Planning Board page 6 D I Glenn Harbeck Associates ' I Brunswidk County Land Use Plan Executive Summary ' New, freestanding section on implementation actions created. ' A new section of the land use plan has been created which brings together in one place all suggested implementation actions designed to carry out the policies. Rather than scattering these actions ' throughout the text of the Policies, this section provides an appropriate means of clearly organizing all potential actions for convenient review and use. A further benefit of this approach is that ' the action section may be updated on a regular basis (e.g. annually in conjunction with the County's budget process) without changing . the policy portion of the plan. If the document is maintained in a _ three ring binder for frequent users of the plan, the previous year's action agenda may be simply removed and a new section inserted. This approach should make monitoring of the plan's implementation ' easier as well. P Brunswick County Planning Board page 7 Glenn Harbeck Associates - 1. Data Collection and Analysis Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis C 1. Data Collection and Analysis 1.1 Establishment of Information Base Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA) guidelines for preparing land use plans in the coastal area of North Carolina require that an analysis of existing conditions and future trends be performed prior to policy development. The intent of this requirement is to insure that the policies as developed respond as closely as possible to current problems and issues facing the county. Key components of the analysis may be - described in four categories: 1) present conditions, including population, economy, existing land use, and current plans and regulations; 2) land suitability constraints, including physical limitations for development, fragile areas, and areas with resource potential; 3) community facility and service constraints, including water, sewer, transportation, police, fire, schools, parks and recreation, and solid waste; and 4) anticipated demand, including population and economic projections, future land use needs, and community facility demands. Collectively, these studies establish the information base necessary to make policy choices about future land use and development in the county. The following Sections 1.2 through 1.5 set forth the findings of this information base in greater detail. Brunswick County Planning Board page 8 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis 1.2 Present Conditions 1.2.1 POPULATION AND ECONOMY 1.2.1(a) Population From the time of the first US Census in 1790 until the 1960 Census, Brunswick County grew at a relatively slow rate. In fact, during this 170 year period, the population grew by a total of only about 17,000 people (3,000 to 20,000). Beginning in the 1960's, however, the county began a period of unprecedented growth. During the 1960's, for example, the County's growth rate was nearly twice that of the State of North Carolina. In the 1970's, the County grew at a rate three times faster than that of the State. And, during the 1980's, Brun-swick County grew at more than triple the State's growth rate. According to statistics compiled by the Office of State Budget and Management, Brunswick County continues to be the second fastest growing county of all 100 counties in the State of North Carolina. POPULATION GROWTH Brunswick County State of North Carolina Year Population % Increase Population % Increase per decade per decade 1930 15,815 — — — 1940 17,125 13.4 — — 1950 19,238 12.3 4,052,795 — 1960 20,278 5.6 4,556,155 12.4 1970 24,223 19.5 5,084,411 11.6 1980 35,777 47.7 5,881,766 15.7 1990 50,985 42.5 6,628,637 12.7 Source: U.S. Census Bureau Population levels change in three different ways: natural increase (births minus deaths), in -migration (people moving into the area), and out -migration (people moving out of the area). Before 1960, nearly all the county's population increase could be attributed to natural increase. In fact, the county experienced net out -migrations during the 30's, 40's and 50's. From sometime in the 1960's to the present, the county has witnessed steady increases in the number of newcomers. During the 1960's, newcomers accounted for only about one third of the total population increase of the county. By the decade of the 80's, newcomers represented almost 85% of the total population increase. Brunswick County Planning Board page 9 Glenn Harbeck Associates J Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis POPULATION GROWTH DYNAMICS ' Decade +or- Natural Net Increase migration ' 1930-40 + 1,310 2,709 -1,399 1940-50 +2,113 3,509 -1,396 1950-60 +1,040 3,752 -2.712 ' 1960-70 +3,945 2,524 +1,421 1970-80 +11,554 2,897 +8,657 ' 1980-90 +15,208 2,499 +12,709 Source: US Census and NC Debt. of Human Resources. Division of Vital Statistics IPopulation Distribution ' As the following table indicates, not all parts of Brunswick County have grown at an equal rate. During the 1980's, the Shallotte and Lockwood Folly townships in the south and central portions of the county, respectively, grew at rates which exceeded the county average. This continues a trend established during the 1960's and 70's- ' that of large numbers of people being drawn by the ocean and intracoastal-oriented areas of the county south and east of U.S. 17. ' POPULATION GROWTH BY TOWNSHIP 1980-1990 ' INCREASE Township 1980 1990 Number Percent ' Lockwood Folly 7,361 10,705 3,344 45% Northwest 6,136 7,454 1,318 21 Shallotte 6,542 11,818 5,276 81 Smithville 6,838 9,488 2,650 39 ' Town Creek 6,878 9,269 2,362 35 Waccamaw 2,022 2,260 238 12 TOTAL 35.777 50,985 15,208 43 ' Source: US Censuses, 1980 and 1990 The population growth statistics for the county's census tracts provide a slightly ' different perspective on the distribution of the county's population growth. The county's three census tracts which front on the ocean and intracoastal waterway, tracts 203, 204, and 205, grew at rates substantially higher than the non -water oriented ' tracts of the county. I Brunswick County Planning Board page 10 Glenn Harbeck Associates -- ------ - - - --- -.w - - --"'-___g-- Brunswick County Planning Board page 10a Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis n F J POPULATION GROWTH BY COMPARABLE CENSUS TRACT 1980-1990 INCREASE Tract 1980 1990 Number Percent 201 7,297 8.879 1,582 22 202 4,510 5.926 1,416 31 203 6,895 9.623 2,728 40 204 4,746 7.263 2,490 52 205 7,061 12,404 5,343 76 206 5,261 6,917 1,656 31 TOTAL 35,777 50,985 15,208 43 Source: US Censuses , 1980 and 1990 A review of population changes at the municipal level provides yet another perspective on where the county's population growth is headed. The beach communities. for the most part, continued on a consistent, fast paced growth trend. Of the non -oceanfront communities, the town of Calabash grew at an astounding 845% during the 1980's. Much of this growth can be attributed, however, to the reorganization of that town's government and area of jurisdiction during the 1980's. At the same time, Shallotte grew at a very respectable 42% during the decade, a reflection of the overall attractiveness of this part of the county to new development. MUNICIPAL POPULATION GROWTH 1980-1990 CHANGE ' Municipality 1980 1990 Number Percent Bald Head Island` N/A 78 N/A N/A ' Belville 102 46 (56) (55) Boiling Springs Lakes 998 1,672 674 68 Bolivia 252 226 (26) (10) Calabash" 128 1,189 1,061 829 ' Caswell Beach 110 155 45 41 Holden Beach 232 642 410 177 Leiand' N/A Long Beach 1,844 1,785 3,816 N/A 1,972 N/A 107 Navassa 439 433 (6) (1) Ocean Isle Beach 143 534 391 273 Sandv Creek' N/A 271 N/A N/A Shallotte 680 976 296 44 Southport 2,824 2,359 (465) (16) Sunset Beach 304 321 17 6 Varnamtown' N/A 434 N/A N/A Yaupon Beach 569 764 195 34 TOTALS 8,625 15,701 7,076 82 'Incorporated between 1980 and 1990. ' "During this period, the incorporated area of Calabash was significantly enlarged by a major restructuring of the town's municipal government including the town limits. ' Source: US Censuses, 1980 and 1990 IBrunswick County Planning Board page 11 Glenn Harbeck Associates i Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis 1 . 1 -1. 1 e � • 1 t0 � 1 1 211 O y �j C 1 Q: � d W1 W J „• . d V t � � I�I��I'lll 1 1 17 ` � 9p� O V 1 1 Brunswick County 1 Census Tracts 1 1 1 1 Brunswick County Planning Board page 11 a Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis The municipal growth rates noted above are also reflected in the overall percentages of total county population in incorporated versus unincorporated areas. In 1980, over 75% of the total county population was living in the unincorporated parts of the county. By 1990, this ratio dropped to about 70%. It remains to be seen how the introduction of centralized sewage treatment systems and the continued expansion of the County's ' water distribution system may effect this overall growth distribution pattern. POPULATION IN INCORPORATED VERSUS UNINCORPORATED AREAS ' 1980-1990 Numbers % of County Population 1980 1990 1980 1990 Incorporated Areas 8,615 15,644 24% 30% Unincorporated Areas 27,109 35,341 76 70 TOTAL COUNTY 35,777 50,985 100 100 ' Source: US Censuses, 1980 and 1990 ' Census Tracts and Block Groups Brunswick County and the US Census Bureau together developed splits of certain fast growing 1980 Census Tracts for the purposes of conducting the 1990 Census. In addition, a series of Block Groups were developed within each Census Tract. A significant amount of information is being made available from the 1990 Census at this ' block group level. Further, the Census Bureau then divided each Block Group into numerous blocks. Again, significant information has been made available at the block level. This detailed information has been used in projecting future needs of the County water ' system and in revision of the electoral districts for the County Commission and the Board of the Elections, to achieve proportionate representation. ' Population and Housing Numbers of housing units in Brunswick County have increased at a faster rate than the overall population growth. This is to be expected, given the continued national declines in average household size during the 1980's and the relatively large numbers of seasonal housing units built in the county. (For more information on ' seasonal units, see Section 1.2.1 (c) Impact of Seasonal Population. I Brunswick County Planning Board page 12 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis HOUSING GROWTH BY TOWNSHIP 1980-1990 ' HOUSING UNITS INCREASE Township 1980 1990 Number Percent Lockwood Folly 5,636 10,084 4,448 79% Norinwest 2,451 2,917 466 19 Shallotte 4,701 10,826 6,125 130 Smithville 5,450 8,506 3,056 56 ' Town Creek 2,574 3,844 1,270 49 Waccamaw 747 937 190 25 TOTALS 21,559 37,114 15,555 72 ' Source: US Censuses, 1980 and 1990 ' HOUSING GROWTH BY COMPARABLE CENSUS TRACT 1980-1990 ' HOUSING UNITS INCREASE Census Tract 1980 1990 Number Percent ' 201 2,881 3,495 614 21% 202 1,709 2,548 839 49 203 5,919 9,198 3,279 55 204 4,240 8,082 3,842 91 ' 205 4,902 11,065 6,163 126 206 1,900 2,726 826 43 TOTALS 21,559 37,114 15,555 72 ' Source: US Censuses, 1980 and 1990 ' Age Breakdown Age characteristics are important because they give an indication of likely future ' school enrollments, future housing needs, and the anticipated market for certain retail goods and various other community facilities. Overall, the table below indicates the following trends: ' -From 1950 to 1990 there was a continued decline in the pre-school, early school, and teen years population sub groups of the county as a percent of the total. ' -At the same time, the primary labor age group and the mature labor age group showed steady increases, reflecting the movement of the baby boom generation through the life cycle. ' -Most significant, however, is the overall increase in the retirement population of the county. From 1940 until 1990, the percentage of the total population 65 years and over more than tripled. This is especially significant when compared with the same age group percentages for the state of North Carolina. Brunswick County continues ■ to draw a significant share of elderly as new residents to the area. Brunswick County Planning Board page 13 Glenn Harbeck Associates I Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis ' PERCENT OF TOTAL POPULATION AGE GROUPS IN BRUNSWICK COUNTY AS A ERCEN ' 1940-90 ' Age Group 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 Under 5 (Preschool) 11.6% 13.1 % 12.0% 9.6% 7.3% 6.5% 5 through 14 (Early School) 24.8 23.2 24.1 21.5 17.4 12.9 15 through 19 (Teen Years) 11.4 9.9 9.5 9.6 9.0 6.8 ' 20 through 24 (College & New 9.0 7.3 5.5 7.6 7.6 6.0 Labor) 25 through 44 (Primary Labor) 25.0 25.9 23.7 22.7 27.0 28.8 ' 45 through 64(Mature Labor) 13.7 14.7 18.0 20.6 21.0 24.4 65 and over (Retirees) 4.5 5.9 7.2 8.4 10.8 14.7 ' TOTAL 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% POPULATION 17.125 19,238 20,238 24.223 35.777 50,985 ' Source: US Censuses ' PERCENT OF COUNTY POPULATION 65 YEARS & OVER Brunswick County and the State of North Carolina ' 1970, 1980, and 1990 % OF TOTAL POPULATION ' Year No. of Persons 65 In Brunswick years & over in County Compared to the State of North Brunswick Co Carolina 1970 1,728 7.1% 8.1 % ' 1980 3,835 10.8 10.2 1990 7,494 14.7 12.1 ' Source: US Censuses, 1970, 1980 and 1990 ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 14 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis Racial Composition The continued rapid influx of primarily White residents, is reflected in the consistent decline of the Black population as a percentage of total county population from 1950 to 1990. While more than 1 in 3 residents were Black in 1950, at present there are fewer than 1 in 5 Blacks in the total county population. RACIAL COMPOSITION OF BRUNSWICK COUNTY AS A PERCENT OF TOTAL POPULATION 1950-90 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 White 63.4% 64.6% 69.3% 76.3% 81.1 % Black 36.6 35.4 30.7 23.7 18.1 Other — — — — .8 TOTAL 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% Source: US Censuses Education Changes in the educational characteristics of Brunswick County residents are available statistically, but are not easy measures from which to draw conclusions. This is because the rapid in -migration of new residents provides no baseline from which to measure educational improvement. In the area of "median years of school completed", for example, the statistics would seem to indicate that Brunswick County has improved in this category quite significantly. However, given the fact that 85% of the county's population increase is attributable to new residents moving in from outside the area, this figure may be misleading. Further, improvements in the drop -out rate also receive mixed reviews from some educators. While some educators argue that keeping students in school is a very important objective, others argue that keeping unmotivated students in school is disruptive and counterproductive to those students who really do want to learn. MEDIAN YEARS OF SCHOOL COMPLETED Selected Counties 1970, 1980 1970 1980 % Increase Brunswick 9.7 12.0 23.7% New Hanover 12.0 12.5 4.2 Columbus 9.6 11.3 17.7 Wake 12.2 12.9 5.7 North Carolina 10.6 12.2 15.1 % Source: Statistical Abstract of NC Counties, 1991 C L F Brunswick County Planning Board page 15 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis 7 C� i� AVERAGE DROP -OUT RATE (% OF TOTAL ENROLLMENT) Selected Counties, Region 0 1981 and 1988 1981-82 1987-88 AVERAGE 1981-88 Brunswick 11.70% 8.70% 8.72% New Hanover 8.65 6.81 7.91 Columbus 11.06 10.91 10.62 Pender 9.92 7.52 9.17 State of NC NA NA NA Source: NC Dept. of Public Instruction An evaluation of local expenditures for schools can also be misleading, but is presented below for the purpose of providing some insights into the County's overall commitment to education. The table indicates that despite the County's concerted efforts to improve the educational system over past years, the percentage of total local financial resources allocated to local schools is the lowest of a 4-county region in Southeastern North Carolina. It should be also noted that from a local contribution standpoint, Brunswick County ranks below the average for the State and for New Hanover County, but ahead of Bladen, Columbus and Pender Counties. LOCAL EXPENDITURES FOR SCHOOLS Selected Counties and State of NC 1987-88 % of Local Total Expenditures, ,Local per pupil cost Financial Resources 1987-1988 1989-90 (Millions of Ss) ($'s) Bladen 31.26% $3.3m $725 New Hanover 33.78 18.7 947 Columbus 37.78 5.6 575 Pencler 27.82 2.8 586 Brunswick 24.74 .9 870 State of NC 42.78 — 931 Source: Brunswick County Schools Survey Report, 1990-91, NC Department of Instruction Brunswick County Planning Board page 16 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis 1.2.1(b) Economy Economic Sectors and E*oyment ' Consistent with trends across the nation and in Western Europe, employment levels in ' the manufacturing sector of the local economy have stagnated compared to the rapid increases in non manufacturing employment. Much of the manufacturing base of the United States has shifted to third world countries, where low labor rates, working ' conditions and environmental standards are less stringent. The impact of this shift in the economy of Brunswick County can be seen in the following tables. MANUFACTURING VERSUS NON -MANUFACTURING EMPLOYMENT BRUNSWICK COUNTY Selected Years 1970-90 ' Year Total Manufacturing Non- manufacturing ' 1970 5,130 1,690 3,440 1975 8,830 3,320 5,510 1980 1985 11,250 3,210 13,960 2,770 8,040 11,190 ' 1989' 17,020 2,680 14,000 Source: NC Employment Security Commission ' For 1989, the most current year for which figures were available, total employment was counted according to county of residence, while manufacturing employment was counted by place of work As such, the estimates of non - manufacturing employment and manufacturing employment may not add to the total. ' The above noted trend away from manufacturing and toward services is further refined in the tables below. While the percentage of employment in manufacturing has , steadily declined since 1979, employment in trade has increased markedly. At the same time, the continued rapid growth and development of the county has nearly doubled the percentage of the workforce involved in construction. ' PERCENT OF WORKERS IN MAJOR EMPLOYMENT CATEGORIES BRUNSWICK COUNTY ' 1979,1984,1989 Year Total Insured Manufacturing Transportation, Trade Construction Workers (%) Communication, (%) (%) ' and Utilities (%) 1979 6,228 52% 21% 21% 6% , 1984 7,571 34 26 26 9 1989 8,302 32 24 34 11 ' Source: NC Employment Security Commission Brunswick County Planning Board page 17 Glenn Harbeck Associates 1 I Brunswick County sand Use Plan Data Collection and Analys It is significant that those sectors of Brunswick County's economy that pay the highest wages have stagnated in terms of employment (manufacturing and TCU), while employment categories that pay the lowest wages have increased most in terms of overall numbers. This trend does not bode well for the economic health of the county. The leadershi, interviews, conducted for this plan, suggest strategies for turning this situation around. These will be discussed later in this document. ' It should also de noted that the average weekly wage for manufacturing and transportation. communication and utilities may appear high to some observers. Such high average weekly wages are not the norm for most industries in the county; rather, ' they are the result of two or three industries which employ a large number of workers at significantly higher than average wages for the region and state. These industries include CP&L. Cogentrix, Dupont, etc.) ' AVE. WEEKLY WAGE BY MAJOR EMPLOYMENT CATEGORY BRUNSWICK COUNTY 1979, 1984, 1989 Year Average Wage Manufacturing Transportation. Trade Construction ' Cverall Communication. and Utilities ' 1979 S244 $341 $227 $121 $154 1984 347 493 552 160 228 1989 394 601 644 179 272 1990 420 612 696 177 309 Source: NC Employment Security Commission A comparison of Brunswick County's employment by major category with that of the state reveals several noteworthy points. First, the dominant influence of the Carolina Power and Light Company Nuclear Plant and the Sunny Point Military Terminal are reflected in the high percentage of the county's employment in Transportation, ' Communication and Utilities. If either of these operations should ever be eliminated or scaled back, the impact on the county's economy could be dramatic*. ' Secondly, the lower percentages of employment in wholesale and retail trade, and services compared to the state of North Carolina, reflects the leakage of purchasing dollars to commercial and service centers in Wilmington, Myrtle Beach and Whiteville. ' While continued commercial growth in Shallotte may act to reduce this leakage, it may take several years for the full impact to be realized. ' Regarding the elir,- -,ation of the CP&L plant in particular, some would say :nat it is not a question of if but when, since the facility cor.;inues to age closer to its scheduled life span. ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 18 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis I INSURED EMPLOYMENT BY MAJOR CATEGORY BRUNSWICK COUNTY AND NORTH CAROLINA 1983 AND 1990 1983 1990 Category County State County State Agriculture, Forestry & Fishing 0.3% 0.7% 0.6% 1.0% Construction 5.9 4.7 7.0 5.3 Mining - 0.2 - 0.3 Manufacturing 33.7 33.7 18.0 28.3 Transportation, Communications and 15.5 4.8 14.8 4.9 Utilities Wholesale & Retail 14.1 21.6 20.3 23.0 Finance, Insurance and Real Estate 2.4 4.0 5.3 4.3 Services 7.8 13.9 14.1 17.4 Government 20.3 16.4 19.8 15.5 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% Source: NC Employment Security Commission Brunswick County has consistently exhibited a higher unemployment rate than both neighboring New Hanover County and the State of North Carolina. The leadership interviews conducted for this plan provided some insights into the reasons why Brunswick County's unemployment rate is so high. Those reasons included: -The presence of a disproportionately large "underground economy", (relative to other counties of similar size) which does not lend itself to traditional reporting by state/federal employment and taxing agencies. -The influx of a large retirement population entering the labor force after arriving in the area. -The county's fast rate of population growth outpacing the ability of the local economy to provide jobs. -The apparent myth that because Brunswick County is growing so fast, there must be jobs for the taking. As a result, many people move in with the belief that they'll find a job once they get here. It should also be noted that a large number of jobs in the county are held by residents of New Hanover County. For example, there are a high number of workers at the CP&L Plant in Southport who commute daily from the Wilmington area. As used in this report, the term "underground economy" refers to a variety of business activities, both legal and illegal, which involve the exchange of money for goods and services for which no records of the transaction are kept for tax purposes. Activities may include, for example, part-time commercial fishing (legal, except for non-payment of taxes) and the importation and distribution of drugs (illegal). In discussions with the planning board, it was noted that while the board does not condone such illegal activities, they are nonetheless an economic reality in many coastal areas today. H n runswick County Planning Board page 19 Glenn Harbeck Associates ' Brunswick CountyLand Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis Y UNEMPLOYMENT RATES Brunswick and New Hanover Counties, and State Averages ' 1987-1991 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 Brunswick County 9.4% 7.6% 7.6% 8.0% 11.7% New Hanover Cty. 6.2 4.6 4.0 4.2 5.9 ' State of NC 4.5 3.6 3.5 4.6 — Source: NC Employment Security Commission ' Per capita incomes in Brunswick County have been well below state and national averages for the past several decades. Differences in per capita incomes also may be attributed to several of the factors mentioned above, including especially the ' underground economy. Those factors aside, there is no denying that wage rates in Brunswick County are not on a par with wage rates in other parts of the state and nation. The mere fact that the County's industry hunters are still using low wage rates ' as a drawina card for new industry confirms this situation. PER CAPITA INCOME ' Brunswick County 1970, 1980, and 1989 ' 1970 1980 1989 Brunswick County. $2,363 $5,981 $1 1.303 State of NC 3,220 7,780 15,287 ' United States 3,943 9,919 17,592 County Income as a 73.4% 76.9% 73.7% % of State Income County Income as a 59.9% 60.3% 64.3% % of U.S. Income ' Source: US Dept. of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis Percentage changes in gross state sales and use tax collections fluctuate more widely in Brunswick County when compared to the state of North Carolina. This is to be expected when comparing a smaller economy with a larger economy. It is significant to note, however, that beginning around 1980, Brunswick County's annual increases in state sales and use tax collections consistently outpaced percent increases at the state level. I Brunswick County Planning Board page 20 Glenn Harbeck Associates 3runswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis GROSS STATE SALES AND USE TAX COLLECTIONS Selected Periods 1970-90 % CHANGE Period Brunswick State of North County Carolina 1969-70 8.48% 10.69% 1974-1975 (9.14) 6.67 1979-1980 26.69 9.42 1984-1985 26.18 17.03 1989-1990 3.67 2.45 Source: NC Employment Security Commission Agriculture The table following illustrates the continuing decline of agriculture in Brunswick County's overall economy. While the amount of acreage in cropland has fluctuated somewhat from year to year, the overall trend toward declining acreage is quite clear. Even more dramatic is the decrease in total income derived from agriculture. This is especially significant given the increases in the price of agricultural products over the same period of time. It should be noted that the overall decrease in farms is part of a national trend. This is due in some measure to the consolidation of smaller farms into larger farming operations. Also, in coastal -oriented Brunswick County, there continues to be substantial conversions of former agricultural land into more profitable residential development. In addition, the United States is increasingly becoming an importer of foods and other farm products, such as fibers and wood. AGRICULTURAL INCOME AND HARVESTED CROPLAND Brunswick County 1980-1989 TOTAL CROPLAND TOTAL INCOME 1000's of Acres Millions of $'s 1980 28.5 33.0 1981 30.3 36.3 1982 34.1 25.4 1983 23.4 20.3 1984 25.3 19.0 1985 30.1 20.8 1986 25.8 17.4 1987 21.7 19.0 1988 18.6 17.9 1989 21.1 20.2 Source: USDA and Brunswick County Extension Service I Brunswick County Planning Board page 21 Glenn Harbeck Associates Water Quality and Stream Classifications TIDAL SALT WATERS FRESH WATERS All significant tidal salt waters within the geography of Brunswick County All signi; cant fresh water creeks within the geography of Brunswick have been aassified SA by the NC Department of Environment. Health Countv rave been classified C Sw by the NC Department of Environment, and Natural Resources, with the exception of the following, which have Health and Natural Resources. Class C waters are of lessor quality than been designated SC: Class B or other higher quality classifications and are not suitable for water suoolies or for primary recreation The Sw code further identifies SC Waters these waters as swamp waters. 1 Shallotte River above the Mill Pond to NC 130 in Shallotte. SPECIAL WATERS 2 Beavercam Creek above mouth of Polly Gully Creek 3 Dutchman's Creek above the CP&L Canal All SA waters in the county as well as the following C Sw and SC waters 4 Snow Marsh have been designated as HOW, meaning that they are rated as excellent 5 Waldor. Creek based on their biological and physical/chemical characteristics. They are likely to De either primary nursery areas or critical habitat areas. The SA waters are high quality waters suitable for shellfishing, primary names of these streams or stream segments are listed below and their recreation and other uses. SC waters are of lessor quality than SA or SB locations are noted on the map by their corresponding numbers: waters and are not suitable for shellfishing or primary recreation The locations of these streams or stream segments are noted on the map to Shallotte River from its source to NC 130 in Shallotte. below by their corresponding numbers. 2 Dutchman's Creek above the CP&L Canal 5 Waldon Creek fj N--•—•--- — — —.—•- j ,i 0 21 tle.,4, Nomm ON -1,51, ♦ lc�/ a L I M -'� Llmea;_ _ 2• 2 Existing Land Use Map I �;! H Vacant and Undeveloped Municipal (Not in Planning Area) •� ® Residential Office and Commercial - dip Industrial and Related Public and Semi -Public Including Conservancy -i_ Lands •� Note: Due to map scale, this existing land use map is necessarily generalized in nature. aril Is Intended for general planning purposes only. For more detailed information and mapping, please consult with the Brunswick County Planning (/) Department. 5 ;% Brunswick. County 4 LAND USE PLAN r a� ` 1993 Update w '�� �p ' .' . Glenn Harbeck Associates Planning and Public Involvement SCALE IN MILES N011TN e 1 2 3 4 Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis ' Another traditional, resource -based element of Brunswick Count 's economy is the Y Y seafood industry. The table below shows the dramatic decline in finfish landings from ' 1975 to 1991. Shellfish landings, on the other hand during this same period, seem to be holding fairly constant. As will be seen in Section 1.2.1 (c) Impact of Seasonal Population, seafood is nonetheless being outpaced by tourism -related industries in ' terms of its overall significance to the economy of Brunswick County. SEAFOOD LANDINGS ' POUNDAGE AND VALUE Brunswick County 1975-1991 FINFISH SHELLFISH Poundage Value Poundage Value ' (Millions of (Millions of (Millions of (Millions of Pounds) Dollars) Pounds) Dollars) 1975 59.0 $1.0 1.1 $0.6 1980 70.8' 3.8 1.7 2.7 1985 1.0 1.3 0.8 1.8 1990 1991 1.9 2.4 1.1 1.7 2.1 1.0 2.2 1.7 Source: NC Division of Marine Fisheries. Morehead City, NC Finfish figures for 1975 and 1980 reflect large volume catches of Menhaden, a non-food fish used for fertilizer and other commercial purposes. The rapid growth of Brunswick County is reflected well in the tax base figures during the period from 1970 to 1990. During this twenty year period, the county's tax base Increased by a factor of nearly thirty times. At the same time, the county's tax rate ' dropped by approximately two thirds. It should be noted that increases in property values during this period may also be attributed to the tremendous inflationary pressures present in the national economy during the 70's and 80's. ' BRUNSWICK COUNTY REAL PROPERTY TAX BASE 1965-90 ' Year Tax Base Tax Rate Tax Base (Millions of $'s) (per $100 (per capita) valuation) ' 1965 $76.6 $1.600 — 1970 135.1 1.800 $5,577 1980 1,683.4* 0.470 47,053 1985 2,213.2- 0.595 1990 3,976.3* 0.685 77,990 ' Source: Brunswick County Tax Department and Glenn Harbeck Associates *Assessment ratio increased from 50% to 100% of value for 1975 and all subsequent years. I Brunswick County Planning Board page 22 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Countv Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis In the table below, note the impact that Brunswick County's rather substantial tax base has on the ability of the County to generate considerable property tax revenues while holding the tax rate well below area norms. COUNTY -WIDE TAX RATES Selected Counties 1989 County -wide Tax Rates County -wide levy ($millions) Bladen $.7150 6.2 New Hanover .7200 34.4 Columbus .6800 8.7 Pender .6500 7.2 Brunswick .5950 24.6 Source: Statistical Abstract of North Carolina Counties, 1991 p. H-28 and 29 Brunswick County Planning Board page 23 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis c) Imp act act of Seasonal Population (P P ' Clearly, the impact of a large seasonal population has a profound impact on the county. Community facilities and services must be designed and operated to meet peak seasonal demand, in addition to the demand created by the permanent ' population. The first table below compares Census counts of the county's permanent population with estimates of the county's peak seasonal population during the 1980's. The second table shows the relationship between year round and seasonal housing ' units during the same period. Most significant, perhaps, is that the number of seasonal housing units as a percentage of total housing units declined slightly during the decade. This may be a reflection of the number of retirees moving to the county on a ' permanent basis. YEAR ROUND AND SEASONAL POPULATION GROWTH ' Brunswick County 1980-1990 ' Year Year Round Peak Season Ratio of Peak Population Population Season to (Estimate) Permanent ' Population 1980 35,777 107,000 3:1 1990 50,985 153,000 3:1 1980-90 15,208 46,000 — ' Increase — 1980-90 42.5% 43.0% Increase ' Source: US Censuses, 1980 and 1990, Brunswick County Planning Department and Glenn Harbeck Associates ' YEAR ROUND AND SEASONAL HOUSING GROWTH Brunswick County 1980-1990 ' Year Total Housing Units Year Round Seasonal Housing Seasonal % of all Housing Units Units housing units ' 1980 21,565 12,411 9,154 42% 1990 37,114 22,000 15,114 40% 1980-90 15,549 9,539 5,960 — Increase ' 1980-90 72% 77% 65% — % Increase ' Source: US Censuses, 1980 and 1990 I Brunswick County Planning Board page 24 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis Another way of looking at Brunswick County's dependence on tourism is to compare the volume of dollars spent on tourism relative to the total county population. The table below shows that four counties in the state, Dare, Moore, Carteret and Brunswick, are among the top twelve counties in terms of tourism dollars spent. These same four counties, however, do not appear among the top twelve counties in terms of population. Thus, these counties have a high volume of tourism expenditures when compared to the other ninety-six counties in the state of North Carolina. TOURISM DOLLARS SPENT VERSUS POPULATION Leading Tourism Counties County Tourism Rank Population Ranked in Dollars 1000's of Top 12 in 1000's of S's People Population (1988) (1990) Mecklenburg 1,049,550 1 511 1 Wake 565,585 2 423 2 Guilford 455,086 3 347 3 Dare 440,921 4 23 NO Buncombe 361,061 5 175 8 Forsythe 350,813 6 266 5 Durham 274,019 7 182 6 New Hanover 252,588 8 120 11 Moore 224,584 9 59 N O Carteret 171,326 10 53 NO Cumberland 166,443 11 275 4 Brunswick 145,695 12 51 N O Source: NC Division of Travel and Tourism and US Census 1 Brunswick County Planning Board page 25 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis ' The table followingillustrates how increases in travel expenditures during the mid P 9 1980's dramatically outpaced increases in total manufacturing wages in the county. ' As recently as February of 1993, the State Travel and Tourism Division ranked Brunswick County tenth in the State, with $123 million dollars in travel expenditures in 1991. This compares with a 1988 Tourism ranking of twelfth. (See previous page.) ' This is especially significant given the rapid expansion of the U.S. economy following the recession of 1982. If these trends continue, Brunswick County's reliance upon travel and tourism will soon far exceed any "traditional" economic and employment ' activities: ECONOMIC IMPACT OF TRAVEL EXPENDITURES BRUNSWICK COUNTY, 1982-1986 Year Travel Expenditures' Total Manufacturing ' Wages" 1982 23,480,000 68,870,444 ' 1983 35,083,000 72,861,498 1984 98,429,000 74,482,039 1985 104,212,000 74,491,363 1986 121,117,000 73,858,873 1987 134,287,000 73,316,849 ' 1988 145,695,000 77,277,060 1989 75,320,000"' 82,137,077 ' Sources: 'Travel and Tourism Division, NC Dept. of Commerce "Resources Development Commission of Brunswick County "'In 1989, the method of computing travel expenditures was changed, resulting in considerably lower figures for all counties in the state. Please note that there is no intent in this table to offer a direct dollar for dollar comparison between travel expenditures and manufacturing ' wages. Rather. emphasis should be placed on the relative magnitude of increase in dollar amounts between the two categories. I Brunswick County Planning Board page 26 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis ' The following table illustrates the highly seasonal nature of the r 9 Y e retail economy of Brunswick County. From a seasonal low of approximately $20 million during the months of December, January, February and March, the retail economy explodes to ' levels in excess of $30 million during the peak summer season. Thus, retail merchants in Brunswick County are far more sensitive to sales volume during the peak summer season, for example, than the more typical pre -Christmas season sales ' period associated with more traditional economies. In fact, Christmas sales are more apt to go to the regional commercial centers of Wilmington and Myrtle Beach. ' GROSS RETAIL SALES BY MONTH 1990 ' Month Sales in Millions of Millions of Dollars Dollars Above or Below Monthly Ave ' January $22.0 $(1.2) February 20.5 (2.7) March 20.5 (2.7) ' April 25.9 2.7 May 30.6 7.4 June 25.2 2.0 July 32.7 9.5 ' August 35.6 12.4 September 31.7 7.5 October 25.3 2.1 November 23.6 .4 ' December 20.0 3.2 Difference 15.1 — ' between February and Auaust , Monthly 2 3. 2 — Average ' Changes in Seasonal Population For a full discussion regarding the methodology employed to estimate changes in ' seasonal as well as permanent population levels in Brunswick County, the reader is directed to Section 1.5.1 (a) and (b) Permanent and Seasonal Population Estimates. H Brunswick County Planning Board page 27 Glenn Harbeck Associates I Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis I R 1.2.2 EXISTING LAND USE ANALYSIS 1.2.2(a) Current Conditions Purpose: An existing land use survey and analysis serves a number of useful functions. The primary function is to provide a "snapshot" of development patterns, and a basis for determining growth trends overtime. The survey, in map form, identifies where development has occurred, and what kind of development it is. When conducted at a high level of detail, the survey can also show the relationships between different kinds of land use and whether or not they are compatible. Up to date information on existing land use is fundamental to the preparation of a land use plan. Not only is the survey helpful in preparing growth and development policies, but it is also useful in identifying, for example, where it may be cost effective to provide public services, such as water and sewer. Accurate information on existing land use can also be helpful in making changes to an existing zoning ordinance, or in providing new zoning where there was none before. Because Brunswick County is presently in the process of preparing its first ever zoning ordinance, information on existing land use is particularly important at this time. Data provided by the survey is also useful to both the public and private sectors in considering specific development proposals. For the public sector, the land use survey can assist in siting a school or a park, while in the private sector, the information might be helpful in locating sites for future shopping centers or residential developments. Methodology: Since 1985, the Brunswick County Planning Department has conducted a number of surveys of existing land use in Brunswick County. Periodically, information on existing land use in all of the municipalities in the County has also been collected. Municipal level land use information, however, is not included on the existing land use map found on the following page. For such information, the reader is directed to the individual land use plans of each of these municipalities. Also, for more specific information than is presented on the generalized land use map in this report, the reader is directed to the Brunswick County Planning Department, where existing land use maps at a scale of 1" = 400' are kept on file. Geographic Areas of Analysis Due to the relatively large size of Brunswick County (approximately 855 sq. miles) this analysis divides Brunswick County into six geographic sub -areas: Shallotte to the State Line Shallotte River to Lockwood Folly The Southport Oak Island Area The Leland Area Brunswick County Planning Board page 28 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis Town Creek/Winnabow/Mill Creek Ash/Waccamaw ' These six areas were selected due to their regional significance within the county, as well as their general level of name recognition by county residents. ' Area 1 Shallotte to the State Line During the decade of the 1980's, this area was the fastest growing part of Brunswick ' County. The area continued to experience the spillover effects from continued rapid growth in the Grand Strand/Myrtle Beach area of South Carolina. Before the 1980's, ' most development in this part of the county was either at the beaches, or immediately adjacent to the Intracoastal Waterway opposite the beach areas. During the past decade, however, this area has witnessed the introduction of ' numerous large scale golf course communities, which have collectively consumed a great deal of land. Examples of such large scale developments include: The Pearls, Sea Trails, Lion's Paw, Ocean Harbor, and Brick Landing. Accompanying this ' increase in large scale development has been a variety of convenience and specialty shopping as well as the introduction of mainstream commercial shopping. Examples of this include the Food Lion grocery store and Revco drug store at Seaside. Also, ' during the course of preparing this plan, a new South Brunswick Branch of the Postal Service opened at the Seaside location. , Over the past ten years, the Town of Shallotte has continued to strengthen its position 9 as a regional sub -nuclei of economic activity for this end of the county. Commercial services and office developments have clustered in the Shallotte area. Despite the ' recession of the past two years, demand for office developments stems from the growing employment ranks of realtors, medical personnel, attorneys, and insurance agents in the Shallotte area. Finally, there has been a continuation of the long , standing strip commercial development along NC 179 across from Ocean Isle Beach. Area 2 Shallotte River to Lockwood Folly River , During the 1980's, this centrally located, coastal oriented area was the second fastest growing section of Brunswick County. Similar to the Shallotte to State Line area, ' growth was initially concentrated, for the most part, at Holden Beach and along the Intracoastal Waterway immediately opposite the beach. Unlike Area 1, however, this area has historically been developed with very small (e.g. 50') lots and less expensive ' houses and manufactured homes. And, unlike the mixture of year round and seasonal homes of Area 1, this area has a heavy predominance of vacation and weekend homes. ' While the trend toward manufactured housing in this part of the county has continued, the last five years have seen the first planned golf course development arrive in the , area: Lockwood Links. It remains to be seen whether this is a foretelling of the character of future development in the area, or merely an exception to the rule. swick County Planning Board page 29 Glenn Harbeck Associates I Bn,nswick Courtly Land Use Plan 1. Data Collection and Analysis h/ illotte te_Lin maw Lei Town Cree Winnabov� Mill Creek) Sha otte Rive t Lo Qe Brunswick County Land Use Study Areas FA a IIUj Brunswick County Planning Board page 29a Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis F Scattered commercial development can be found at various locations in the area. Especially significant concentrations of commercial development are in the Varnamtown area along the west shore of the Lockwood Folly River, and at Supply, an unincorporated village located at the intersection of US 17 and NC 211. There is also a strip of commercial development dispersed along NC 130 immediately across from Holden Beach. Finally, for more substantial shopping needs, commercial services and retail outlets in the Town of Shallotte also draw from this area. Area 3 Southport/Oak Island This area has perhaps the most diverse collection of land uses of anywhere in the county. The area includes several major industrial uses, including the Carolina Power and Light Nuclear Plant, the former Pfizer Plant, and the recently added Cogentrix Cogenerating Facility. In addition, the Sunny Point Ocean Military Terminal consumes a large amount of acreage along the Cape Fear River. Residential development ranges from permanent housing concentrated in the Towns of Southport and Long Beach to more seasonal housing at Caswell Beach. To the interior of the area lies the sparsely developed City of Boiling Spring Lakes, with some 2,000 people living within this 17,000 acre planned community. Also added to this area in the past five years is the new St. James Plantation, which opened in the Fall of 1991. ' Unlike the beaches closer to South Carolina, the beaches in the Southport/Oak Island area are not as commercially oriented. Most commercial services are located on the mainland side on the Intracoastal Waterway. In addition, a moderate amount of ' commercial development is located within the Town of Southport and its extraterritorial jurisdiction (ETJ). Many of these are "mom and pop" type small businesses. ' Significant within the past five years has been the commitment of Yaupon Beach to a new sewage treatment system. Active planning is also underway for the creation of a sewer system by the Southeastern Sanitary District west of Southport and to the ' mainland side of Yaupon Beach. The possibility of an additional bridge to Oak Island toward the west central end of the beach is another infrastructure improvement which could radically alter development patterns in this part of the county. Prospects for the bridge currently remain unresolved. Finally, Long Beach Road (NC 133) from its intersection with NC 211 to the Oak Island ' bridge continues to present problems regarding commercial strip development and multiple driveway accesses onto this roadway. This problem is most pronounced during peak summer periods, when demand for travel to the beach is at a premium. ' Area 4 The Leland Area The general Leland Area actually encompasses the three communities of Leland, Navassa and Belville as well as significant development and land outside these municipalities.. In some respects, this area serves as a bedroom community for New Hanover County just across the river. In other respects, the presence of the Dupont IBrunswick County Planning Board page 30 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis manufacturing plant on the Brunswick County side of the river draws large numbers of employees from the Wilmington area. ' Recent developments in the Leland area include: the Old Forte Golf Course (reported to be a non -real estate, purely commercial course), a nursing home, condominiums ' and single family homes in the vicinity of Olde Towne, and Jackey's Creek Plantation —a golf course community in the Belville vicinity. Brunswick County's only industrial parks are also located in this part of the county. These industrial parks are ' served by the County's first sewage treatment plant, which has been open and operating for about five years. Other factors significantly affecting this area include the possibility of a sewer system ' serving the Leland Sanitary District and further progress on a sewage treatment plant for the Town of Belville. Area transportation planners also continue to consider the 'outer loop" as part of the Greater Wilmington Area Transportation Plan. If constructed, ' this major new roadway would pass above (and thus bypass) this part of Brunswick County, accommodating significant traffic flows around Wilmington as a new US 17. Area 5 Town Creek/Winnabow/Mill Creek ' This is essentially an ex urban. interior part of Brunswick County, split by US. 17.. The ' area draws its development strength from its reasonable proximity to the employment base of New Hanover County. The area has the advantages of low taxes, open country and some beautiful, undulating terrain —atypical of the broad, flat, pine- , covered coastal plain of southeastern North Carolina. Most development in this area appears to be springing up in the form of subdivisions either with direct access to US 17 or within a short distance of the US 17 corridor. There is no industrial activity in this , part of the county, and very little office or retail development. Residents who live in this area typically travel to New Hanover County, Shallotte, or Myrtle Beach for their shopping needs. ' Area S Ash/Waccamaw Area This rural part of Brunswick County has experienced the slowest growth rate of any ' area of the county for the past several decades. It is largely a resource -based area, meaning that it depends largely on farming and timber related activities for its , economic sustenance. Population levels and development densities in this part of the county tend to be very low. As a result, little activity is seen in this area. New subdivisions established in this area during the 1980's tended to be quite small, and ' with few public or private improvements and little, if any, amenities. One exception to the relatively dormant development character of this area is the ' presence of the Brunswick Community College, located on U.S. 17 in this part of the County. Since the time the last land use plan was prepared, the College has continued to grow with the addition of two new buildings and a new auditorium. The ' College is a significant land use activity and traffic generator in this part of the county. As plans for the continued growth of this important institution are refined, it will be important that such plans be coordinated as to their impact in this part of the county I and on U.S 17, in particular. Brunswick County Planning Board page 31 Glenn Harbeck Associates I Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis ' 1.2.2(b) Land Use Trends and Problems ' Based upon the foregoing discussion of development patterns in the six geographic areas of Brunswick County,. several land use trends and problems can be readily identified. These problems include: ' Scattered unattractive development along beach roads creates a poor ' image. Commercial development which has been scattered along the major roads from U.S.17 to the county's ocean beaches, foretells of the kind of commercial development ' = that could consume much of the road frontage in the county at some point in the future. This was identified as a major concern by residents at the public workshops and. fortunately, is something that can be addressed to some degree by a zoning ordinance. In addition to a poor image, such development results in multiple, uncoordinated driveway cuts, reducing the traffic carrying capacity and safety of the very roads most in demand for efficient traffic movement during peak summer periods. Scattered subdivision activity is difficult to serve. ' Brunswick County has experienced a wide range of relatively small-scale, scattered subdivisions in the past. Such scattered subdivision activity tends to disperse the population and makes the provision of services expensive and inconvenient, whether ' by the public or by the private sector. Examples include refuse collection and disposal and school buses. Also, the relatively large lots and homogeneous land uses associated with these developments encourage large lot sprawl, isolated from ' commercial services. As a result, all trips for personal services must be by individual automobile, to the exclusion of alternative transportation modes. Ultimately, this form of development overloads the county's road systems, especially during peak season ' summer months. Sewage problems/sewage solutions. The county is wrestling with what many local leaders see as the number one constraint to development— that of sewage treatment and disposal. The county's relatively ' sparse development patterns make the provision of a single, centralized sewage treatment system unworkable. Areas where there are concentrations of smaller lots or higher density development (such as near the beach communities) offer some ' possibilities, however. As a result, there are several local area initiatives underway which would seek to address this problem. For an overview of these activities, the reader is directed to the section of this plan which addresses Sewage Treatment, ' Section 1.4.2. Growth along the county's water -oriented edges. ' Just as the population of the United States has been moving steadily towards the coastal margins of the country for the past several decades, the new population of ' Brunswick County is also being drawn to the water edges of the county. These edges include, particularly, all of the Atlantic Ocean and Intracoastal Waterway, and those Brunswick County Planning Board page 32 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis sections of the Cape Fear River within a reasonable commuting distance of the City of Wilmington. While newer developments in the form of large scale golf communities have been moving inland to a degree, even these developments continue to reflect a strong bias toward proximity to the Intracoastal Waterway, the beaches and the river. Brunswick County Planning Board page 33 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis ! 1.2.3 CURRENT PLANS POLICIES AND REGULATIONS ! As a means of coordinating the various planning activities of Federal, State and Local governments in Brunswick County, a summary of important plans, policies and regulations is included here. ! 1.2.3 a Local Government ! Plans, Policies, and Regulations 1976 Brunswick County Land Use Plan —This was the first county -wide land use plan ! prepared under the guidelines of the Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA). The plan established the initial land classification system for the county, as well as a series of growth policies and implementation actions. 1981 and 1987 Brunswick County Land Use Plan Updates —These five-year updates to the original 1976 plan offered refinements to the growth policies and established a ! more systematic basis for decision making by both local government and the private sector. 1988 Brunswick County Thoroughfare Plan —In March of 1988, shortly after adoption of the last Land Use Plan Update, a Thoroughfare Plan for Brunswick County was adopted by the NC. Board of Transportation following local adoption by the County ! and its municipalities. This was a cooperative effort involving staff of the Thoroughfare Planning Unit, Planning and Research Branch, Division of Highways, NC Department of Transportation, and a County -wide Thoroughfare Plan Coordinating Committee, made up of representatives of numerous local governments and Chambers of Commerce in Brunswick County. A summary of the findings and recommendations of this plan is included in Section 1.4.3 of this report. ! 1991 Water System Distribution Master Plan —In September of 1990, work was completed on a new Water Distribution System Master Plan. Prepared for Brunswick ! County by the engineering firm of William G. Daniel and Associates, the report was based on the 1987 Land Use Plan and projections made jointly by the Planning Board and Utility Operations Board for a twenty year period. The report analyzed the current distribution system, projected future water consumption, and recommended improvements to the system for action by 1991, 1995 and 2010. A summary of the findings and recommendations of this plan is also included in Section 1.4.3 of this report. Subdivision Regulations —Brunswick County has had a subdivision ordinance in ! place since 1974; it was subsequently updated in June of 1980. This ordinance had few requirements or standards for development. Private, unpaved roads were permitted; no minimum lot size was specified. In early 1992, a new subdivision ordinance became effective, after a long, protracted process of review and approval. The new ordinance includes a requirement for paved 1 roads in major subdivisions —according to North Carolina Department of Transportation standards. There is also more involvement by the County planning I Brunswick County Planning Board page 34 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis staff in the review process and an earlier examination of subdivisions at the sketch plan stage. In this manner, the staff is in a position to give feedback to applicants ' before preliminary plat review. The ordinance also establishes minimum lot widths and setback lines, and a new 7,500 square foot minimum lot size. ,Zoning —(Despite the fact that Brunswick County is the second fastest growing county` ' of all 100 counties in the state of North Carolina, there is no zoning in areas of the county under the County government's jurisdiction. The lack of a zoning ordinance may change in the near future, however. In November of 1991, the zoning issue was put before the voters of Brunswick County in a non -binding referendum. The motion in favor of instituting zoning passed by a margin of 2-1 at the voting booth. As a result of this and other factors, the Brunswick County Commissioners gave a directive to the ' County's planning department to present a proposed zoning ordinance by June of 1992. At the time of this writing, the draft ordinance is under review by the Planning Board and County Commissioners. ' It should be noted that the need for zoning was identified at all the public workshops held during the early stages of the land use plan process, and was also mentioned ' consistently during the several leadership interviews for the land use plan. Site Plan Review —Since 1981, the Planning Board has had a policy calling upon persons who plan to construct larger commercial facilities or higher density/large scale residential projects to voluntarily submit their site plans for review and comment. This policy has not changed since the 1987 Land Use Plan. Submission of site plans is up ' to the discretion of the builder or developer; under this arrangement, only a building permit is necessary to begin construction. Despite the purely voluntary nature of this process. it is estimated that about 85% of all of these types of development proposals go through such review and comment. State Building Code Enforcement —In April of 1985, the Board of County ' Commissioners adopted ordinance No. 62 calling for a full program of administration and enforcement of all volumes of the state building code. This function was initially charged to the County Planning Department. In October 1987, a separate Building ' Inspections Department was created and there have been several Building Directors since that time. Responsibility for building code enforcement has subsequently been transferred to the County Engineer. At the present time, carrying out the program of ' building code enforcement involves four inspectors and two clerical support people, in addition to overall direction received from the County Engineer. Waste Water Treatment Regulation —The Environmental Health section of the County' Health Department administers and enforces state law regarding septic tank systems. The Environmental Management Division of the North Carolina Department of , Environment and Health exercises authority over other waste water treatment systems. * According to the US Census Bureau, Brunswick County's population increased from 35,777 in 1980 to 50,985 in 1990, for a percentage increase of 42.5%. This was second in the state only to Dare County (the Outer Banks), which had a 70.00 o increase over the same period. (Office of State Management and Budget) Brunswick County Planning Board page 35 Glenn Harbec k Associates ' Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis ' Federal Flood Insurance Pr r m—Also in April of 1985, Ordinance No. 62, passed by the Board of County Commissioners, started the County's administration of the Federal ' Flood Insurance Program regulations. Enforcement began in March of 1986, following receipt of an acceptable set of Flood Insurance Rate Maps from the Federal Emergency Management Agency. This program is administered and enforced by the ' Building Inspection Department, with the Planning Board serving as the appeal agency from decisions of the Building Director. If the structure is located in a flood prone area, certification of the structure's ground floor elevation is required. 1 7 I Brunswick County Planning Board page 36 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection ano Ana 1.2.3 (b) Federal and State Licenses and Permits In addition to the local plans, policies, and regulations identified above, there are a number of other regulatory programs administered at the Federal and State level which also exercise control over certain types of development activities. The following is a list of some of these regulatory programs and permits. For a more complete listing, and description of the specific activities controlled and permitting requirements, the reader is directed to the publication entitled NC Environmental Permit Directory, by the NC Department of Environment, Health. and Natural Resources, Division of Planning and Assessment, 1991. For each item which follows, the regulatory program or permit is first identified by its official name, the responsible agency name is then given, followed by a brief description of the activities controlled. A statutory reference is also provided. State Licenses and Permits AIR QUALITY PERMIT Division of Environmental Management. Air Quality Section, Air Permits Branch (or the appropriate Regional Office). Required for any person who establishes or operates any air contaminant source; equipment which may result in emissions of air contaminants or is likely to cause air pollution; or construction or installation of any air cleaning device. (15A NCAC 2H.0600-.0610; 15A NCAC 2D.0500-.1108) CAMA MAJOR DEVELOPMENT PERMIT NC Division of Coastal Management The Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA) stipulates that permits are required for all development or land disturbing activities within designated Areas of Environmental Concern (AEC's) throughout the 20-county coastal area. Areas of Environmental Concern include marshlands, tidelands. shoreline and waters of the estuarine system; beaches, dunes, and inlets of the ocean hazard area; public fresh water supply areas; and fragile natural and cultural resource areas. Development other than major, termed " minor development", requires a permit from the local government for work in an AEC. (15A NCAC 7H permit standards; 7J permit procedures; 7M general policies; 7K permit exemptions) COASTAL AREA MANAGEMENT ACT (CAMA) MINOR DEVELOPMENT PERMIT administered by Brunswick County under authority granted by the Coastal Area Management Act and standards adopted by the Coastal Resources Commission. Single family, oceanfront houses usually require a CAMA minor permit. Other examples of development requiring a minor CAMA permit would be single family houses along the shores of sounds and rivers, small private and commercial structures, and minor high ground grading or filling. (15A NCAC 7H permit standards; 7J permit procedures; 7M general policies; 7K permit exemptions.) Brunswick County has two Minor CAMA Permit Officers. Brunswick County Planning Board page 37 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection ana Analysis ' FEDERAL CONSISTENCY DETERMINATION NC Division of Coastal Management (DCM) Required for: 1) Federal agency activities, 2) activities requiring federal licenses or ' permits, 3) activities requiring Outer Continental Shelf (OCS) Licenses, and/or 4) activities involving federal assistance to state or local governments. (North Carolina General statute 113A-100 et seq. and Section 307 of the Federal Coastal Zone ' Management Act of 1972, as amended.) STATE DREDGE AND FILL PERMIT ' Division of Coastal Management Any project involving excavation and /or filling activities in estuarine waters, tidelands, ' marshlands, or state-owned lakes requires a permit. (15A NCAC 7J permit procedures) ' PERMIT FOR AQUACULTURE OPERATIONS Division of Marine Fisheries ' A permit is required for any aqua culture operation involved in the propagation of saltwater/marine species of fish, shell fishing and crustaceans. (15A NCAC 31 .0011) OIL REFINING FACILITY PERMIT Division of Environmental Management ' Required for construction or operation of an oil refining facility. (15A NCAC IE .0014) SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT PERMIT ' Division of Solid Waste Management Established for the proper management of solid waste, these facilities are categorically ' defined as Treatment and Processing, Transfer, and/or Disposal Facilities. In addition to these types of facilities, specific rules are established for the management of special waste types, i.e. septage, yard waste, medical waste, etc. Permits are Issued in two - parts; a permit to construct the facility precedes a permit to operate. (15A NCAC 1313) INJECTION WELL CONSTRUCTION/USE PERMIT, Division of Environmental ' Management, Ground water Section. Required of any person proposing to construct, alter, repair or abandon any injection well or owning, using, operating or proposing to use or operate any well for the purpose of injecting any substance to the subsurface or ground waters of the state. (15A NCAC 2C .0201 - .0214) I Brunswick County Planning Board page 38 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANK NOTIFICATION Division of Environmental Management Ground water Section North Carolina's Underground Storage Tank (UST) Rules, became effective on January 1, 1991. These rules establish performance standards and notification requirements for new and existing UST systems, set for release detection and reporting requirements, and establish procedures for the closure of UST systems and cleanup of releases. (15A NCAC 2N .0101 - .0805) WELL CONSTRUCTION PERMIT Division of Environmental Management Ground water Section Required for any person constructing a well with a design capacity of 100,000 gallons per day or greater, or of any well added to an existing well system if the combined system is 100,000 gallons per day or greater. (15A NCAC 2C .0100 - .0119) It should be noted that Brunswick County has no ordinance governing private wells. IMPOUNDMENT PERMIT Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources, Division of Environmental Health A permit is required prior to the construction or excavation of a basin or the obstruction of stream flow that would result in any body of water of 100 acres or more except when formed under natural conditions. (15A NCAC 18B .0300 - .0309) LOCATION AND PROTECTION OF PUBLIC WATER SUPPLIES Public Water Supply Section A public water supply system is any system which provides piped water for human consumption and the system has at least 15 service connections or regularly serves at least 25 individuals daily at least 60 days out of a year. (15A NCAC 18C, .0202, .0202, .0203) WATER SUPPLY SYSTEM PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS APPROVAL Public Water Supply Section, Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources Required for construction, alteration, or expansion of a public water supply system. (15A NCAC 18C, .0300, .0400, .0500, - .1000) DAM SAFETY PERMIT Division of Environmental Health Any person proposing to construct, repair, modify or remove a dam must file a statement concerning the proposed activity. A permit will be required prior to the initiation of such activity if the dam is 15 feet or greater in height (from top of dam to lowest point at downstream toe) and the impoundment capacity is 10-acre-feet or greater at the top of the dam. (15A NCAC 2K .0100 - .0408) 1 1 H Brunswick County Planning Board page 39 Glenn Harbeck Associates -runswick County Lana Use Plan Data Collection ana Analysis F 11 H GEOPHYSICAL EXPLORATION PERMIT Director of the Division of Land Resources A permit is required to conduct aeoloaical, geophysical. and other surveys and investigations including seismic 'meth o-as for the discovery of oil, gas, or other mineral prospects. (15A NCAC 5C .0001 - .0028) MINING PERMIT Division of Land Resources, Land Quality Section A mining permit is required for any land disturbing activity that affects one or more acres of land and is conducted to accomplish one or more of the following: breaking surface soil to extract or remove minerals, ores, or other solid matter; any activity or process to remove or to extract, minerals, ores, soils, and other solid matter from its original location; or the preparation, washing, cleaning or other treatment of such materials so as to make them suitable for commercial, industrial, or construction use. (15A NCAC 5B .0001 - .0012) PERMIT TO DRILL EXPLORATORY OIL OR GAS WELL Division of Land Resources, Geological survey Section A permit is required to conduct any exploratory drilling for oil and gas at any location in the state. (15A NCAC 5 D .0001 - .0011) SEDIMENTATION CONTROL PLAN Division of Land Resources, Land Quality Section An approved erosion and sedimentation control plan is required for any land disturbing activity which uncovers one or more contiguous acres of land. (15A NCAC 413 .0001 - .0027) In Brunswick County, written approval of any such sedimentation control plan must be verified before any local building permit may be issued. STATE CLEARINGHOUSE: INTERGOVERNMENTAL REVIEW PROCESS (IRP) State Clearinghouse, Department of Administration The State Clearinghouse primarily functions to maintain a state and local level review and comment system for the following: A. Notifications of intent to apply for federal assistance B. Direct Federal Development Activities C. Environmental Impact Statements (State and National) (1 NCAC 9.500, 1 NCAC 25) NORTH CAROLINA ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT State Clearinghouse, Department of Administration Any activity which involves the expenditure of public moneys, state actions (approvals), and which may significantly affect the quality of the environment, must comply with the provisions of the North Carolina Environmental Policy Act. (1 NCAC 25, 15A N CAC 1 C) Brunswick County Planning Board page 40 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana Use Plan Data Collemon and Analvsis ARCHAEOLOGICAL AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION - PERMIT REVIEW Environmental Review Coordinator. Division of Archives and History, Department of Cultural Resources Under state and federal regulations. the Division's Archaeology and Historic Preservation Section operates an environmental review and compliance program which reviews permit applications to determine if issuance will affect significant terrestrial or submerged archaeological, historical, or architectural resources. (NCAC T07: 04R .0200 - .0206) It should be noted that this review process is generally not required for projects not involving state or federal permits or financial assistance. PERMIT FOR EXPLORATION: RECOVERY OR SALVAGE Office of State Archaeology, Division of Archives and History Any person wishing to explore, recover or salvage an abandoned shipwreck or any underwater archaeological artifacts in state-owned bottoms of navigable waters must apply for a permit. (7 NCAC 4R .1000 - 1013) BRIDGE (OR OTHER STRUCTURES) EASEMENT OR LEASE (over navigable waters) Department of Administration. State Property Office Bridge (or other structures) easement over navigable waters and leases for oil and gas exploration and minerals. (1 NCAC 6B .0601 - .610, .0306) CABLE OR PIPELINE EASEMENTS (lands below navigable waters) Department of Administration, State Property Office Cable and /or pipeline corridors in or on lands below navigable waters. (I NCAC 61B .0601 - .0610) EASEMENT TO FILL (lands below navigable waters) Department of Administration, State Property Office Easements to fill are required for all filling activities in navigable waters where land is raised above the normal high water mark. The State claims title to all lands below the mean high water mark. Easements to fill are not required if the applicant has lost the area due to erosion during his period of ownership. (I NCAC 613 .0501 - .0512, .0601 - .0610) 401 CERTIFICATION Division of Environmental Management, Water Quality Section Any person engaged in an activity which may result in a discharge to navigable waters, defined as waters of the United States, and requires a federal permit, must obtain a certification that such discharge will be in compliance with applicable state water quality standards. (15A NCAC 2H .0500 - .0502, and 15A NCAC 2B .0109 and .0201 (b)). 1 Brunswick County Planning Board page 41 Glenn Harbeck Associates :3,unswicK County Lana Use Plan Data Coilection ano Anaivsis NPDES iNATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM PERMIT ' Division of Environmental Management. Permits and Engineering Unit. Water Quality Section. ' Permit is required for any project involving the construction, alteration. and/or operation of any sewer system. treatment works. or disposal system and certain storm water runoff which would result in a discharge into surface waters. (15A NCAC 2H ' 0100) Also, as of October 1, 1992. two additional types of projects require NPDES permits: construction sites that will disturb an area of more than five acres, and (2) industrial sites which fall within certain SIC codes. ' PERMIT FOR WASTE NOT DISCHARGED TO SURFACE WATERS (SANITARY SEWAGE SYSTEMS) ' Note: This type of activity is controlled by one of two agencies, depending upon the specific nature of the waste discharge: ' (1) Division of Environmental Management Permits and Engineering Unit, Water Quality Section ' Permits are required for review involving the following project types: sewers and sewer extensions; pumping stations, sludge disposal systems, ground absorption systems: spray irrigation or land application disposal systems and treatment works; and closed system or recycle disposal systems and treatment works. (15A NCAC 2H ' .0200) (2) Division of Environmental Health Prior to the construction of any residence, business, or place of public assembly, a ' permit must be obtained from the local health department for an approved sanitary sewage system unless the system is designed to discharge to the surface waters or land surface or unless the system Is owned and operated as a public or community system. These on -site sewage permits, issued by the local health departments, consist of improvement permits and system approval prior to construction. (15A NCAC 18A, 1934 to 1968) ' STORMWATER CERTIFICATION Division of Environmental Management, Water Quality Planning Section ' Storm water certification is required for all development in the 20 coastal counties that involves land disturbing activities on more than one acre of land and requiring a CAMA major permit or a sedimentation/erosion control plan. (15A NCAC 2H .1000 and ' 213 .0200) SURFACE WATER SUPPLY WATERSHED PROTECTION Department of Environment, Health and Natural Resources, Division of Environmental Management ' This is a relatively new, cooperative program of water supply watershed management and protection administered by local government consistent with minimum statewide ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 42 Glenn Harbeck Associates BrunswlCK County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis management requirements as established by the Environmental Management Commission (EMC) (15A NCAC 2B .0100, .0200. and .0300) No such watersheds have been identified in Brunswick County. Federal Licenses and Permits PERMITS TO CONSTRUCT IN NAVIGABLE WATERS The Army Corp of Engineers These are permits required under Sections 9 and 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 DREDGING AND FILLING ACTIVITY The Army Corp of Engineers These are permits required under Section 404 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1972. PERMITS FOR BRIDGES, CAUSEWAYS, PIPELINES OVER NAVIGABLE WATERS The US Coast Guard These are permits required under the General Bridge Act of 1946 and the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899. ENERGY RELATED PERMITS The Geological Survey, Bureau of Land Management (Department of Interior) These are permits required for off -shore drilling and approvals of outer continental shelf pipeline corridor rights of way. OTHER ENERGY RELATED PERMITS The Nuclear Regulatory Commission The Nuclear Regulatory Commission issues licenses for siting, construction and operation of nuclear power plants; required under the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, Title II of the Energy Reorganization Act of 1974. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission issues permits for construction, operation, and maintenance of interstate pipelines facilities required under the Natural Gas Act of 1938. The Commission also issues: orders for interconnection of electric transmission facilities under Section 202 (b) of the Federal Power Act; permits for abandonment of natural gas pipeline and associated facilities under section 7C (b) of the Natural Gas Act of 1938; and licenses for non-federal electric projects and associated transmission lines under Sections 4 and 15 of the Federal Power Act. U J Brunswick County Planning Board page 43 Glenn Harbeck Associates -runswick County Land Use Sian Data Collection ana Anawsis u 1.2.3 (c) Evaluation of Previous Land Use Plan Effectiveness The last update of the Brunswick County Land Use Plan was certified by the Coastal Resources Commission in December of 1987. The following is an evaluation by the County Planning Department as to how that plan addressed the major issues it identified and how successful the County has been in implementing the policies recommended. Also included are highlights of several specific implementation actions carried out in support of the 1987 Update —organized under each of the plan's major policy sections. As will be seen in the paragraphs which follow, some of these items are supportive of policies in more than one section of the plan. Section 2.0 Overall Guiding Policy Policy 2.0 of the 1987 update set the overall tone for the plan by stating the County's overall support for positive growth and development. In all activities of the County government, this basic policy has been the overriding factor in decision making. Thus, the County's action in support of. for example. road improvements, expansions to the County's water supply system, development of the County's industrial park, and better management of new development through improved development regulations, are all consistent with this objective. Actions in Support of Section 2.1 Resource Protection Policies Since the adoption of the last plan update in December 1987, the County has taken several specific steps in furtherance of resource protection within the county: New Subdivision Regulations —In October 1991, the County adopted a new, more stringent subdivision ordinance after a lengthy period of public debate. Zoning Ordinance Being Prepared —In November of 1991, the voters of Brunswick County went to the polls to decide upon a non -binding referendum for zoning. The motion passed by a better than 2-1 vote. The Board of County Commissioners then directed the County Planning Director to present a draft ordinance by June of 1992. Lockwood Folly River Basin Studies and Water Quality Monitoring —Due to the critical importance and strategic location of the Lockwood Folly River to the central part of coastal Brunswick County, the County has urged state and federal governments to undertake necessary studies to address the challenges of growth and development within this watershed basin. Water quality monitoring has been an on -going part of these studies. Reviews of Changes in Navigational Channels and Marina Proposals —The County has worked in conjunction with the State in commenting upon various proposals for changes in navigational channels and for marina proposals in various parts of the county. Each of the above actions demonstrate tangible efforts to improve the County's ability to direct growth, and thus better manage the area's valuable environmental resources. IBrunswick County Planning Board page 44 Glenn Harbeck Associates 1 Brunswick Countv Lana Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis Actions in Support of Section 2.2 Resource Production and Management I Policies On Goina Programs —Brunswick County has continued to fund various county level , programs in support of agriculture, forestry, mineral production and mining and fisheries. , Consideration of Resource Production Issues in New Zoning Ordinance— As the new zoning ordinance is developed, consideration is being given to the necessary conservation of key resource areas in the county for long term management ' and use. It is significant that the preparation of the ordinance will be occurring during the same period of time that the land use plan update is being prepared. It is the intention of the County that these two documents will work hand in hand. I Actions in Support of Section 2.3 Economic and Community Development' Policies Brunswick County fully endorses state planning guidelines emphasizing the close ' relationship between necessary infrastructure and growth. The County's industrial recruitment program is fully related to the necessary infrastructure for such land use activities. Some examples follow: ' Waste Water Treatment Plant —The County government's first waste water treatment plant is now open and directly supports the development of the two industrial parks in the Leland area. Zonina Ordinance —A primary consideration of the County's new zoning ordinance will be a close relationship between proposed zoning districts and the availability or proposed availability of necessary infrastructure. The ordinance will also serve to reinforce the economics of that infrastructure once put in place. Water Access Plan —Since the adoption of the 1987 land use plan, the County has seen to it that a water access plan was develop and adopted. This plan is considered important to plan for access to the county's estuarine waters by area citizens. Navigation Needs —The navigation needs of the county's residents have been emphasized to the State and the Corps of Engineers over the past five years, in studies related to Lockwood Folly in particular. The County also supports continuing and periodic improvements to the Cape Fear River channel for its regional economic development benefits as well as national security concerns. Energy Facilities —A relatively new cogenerating facility in the Southport/Oak Island area provides steam and surplus power to CP&L and the Archer, Daniels, Midland facility in that part of the county. The project is a major addition to the county tax base. n Brunswick County Planning Board page 45 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana Use Plan Data Colle=on and Analysis Subdivision Ordinance —The County's new subdivision regulations follow through on the commitment of the County to encourage better streets (especially pavea) and better standards for development ;n general. Clean County Program —Also since 1987. a clean county program has been established and staffing providea. Actions in Support of Section 2.4 Public Participation Policies With the most recent update to the County's land use plan, the County has continued its commitment to public involvement in plan development. In keeping with this policy, the County has again sought to hold public meetings in numerous locations in the county rather than requiring residents to travel, for example. to the county government center in Bolivia. In addition to the land use plan public involvement, there have also been numerous workshops, hearings and other types of public work sessions held in the various parts of the county on issues such as the subdivision regulations. solid waste management, parks and recreation, planning for the County water system, etc. Even so, the spread out nature of the county presents particular challenges for meaningful public involvement, and efforts must continue to find more and better ways to garner additional input. Actions in Support of Section 2.5 Storm Hazard Mitigation, Post Disaster Recovery and Evacuation Plan Since 1985, and for the first time in the history of Brunswick County, the County has actively enforced flood plain regulations, all volumes of the state building code, and has adopted the previously mentioned new subdivision regulations. In addition, it is expected that the new county zoning ordinance will work to guide new. intensive development away from hazardous locations in the county. Section. 3.0 Land Classification In keeping with the intent of the land classification system, the vast majority of all new development in the county since 1987 has occurred within the municipal, developed. transitional, and community land ciassification areas. While there are examples of several small subdivisions which have occurred outside these areas, particularly in the Ash-Waccamaw area, these developments have had little impact on regional population shifts or needs for infrastructure improvements. They are also generally well removed from any impacts on the fragile environmental resources of the county. ' In addition, the expansion of the County's public water supply system has been entirely consistent with the growth policies implied by the land classification map. It should.be noted that in the time frame since the last land use plan update was ' adopted (November 1987 through calendar year 1991), the County has reviewed some 193 subdivision plats totaling 12,077 lots and has issued a total of 8,155 building permits in the unincorporated county, as follows: 1 Brunswick County Planning Board page 46 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis Single Family Residential 813 Manufactured Housing Units (Mobile Homes) 4,135 ' Multi -family Units 50 Commercial 283 Industrial 5 ' Other 2,869 Improvements to the 1992 Update I Improvements to the 1992 Brunswick County Land Use Plan have focused primarily in I three areas: 1. The Land Classification Map has been refined, carefully examining the new land ' classification categories suggested by the state guidelines for their application in Brunswick County. 2. Policy statements have been refined, more accurately reflecting what are believed ' to be the prevailing wishes of the citizens in Brunswick County. This refinement required a careful examination of the issues identified at public meetings, as well as ' consensus building among the board members responsible for drafting and adopting the plan. 3. The County continues to emphasize and refine the relationship between ' infrastructure improvements and planned areas for growth and development. Brunswick County Planning Board page 47 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Coilection ana Analvsis I 1.3 Constraints; Land Suitability The State CAMA guidelines require that three factors be considered in land use plans regarding land suitability constraints. The factors are: (1) physical limitations for development, (2) fragile areas. and (3) areas with resource potential. While much of the information contained in this section is unchanged from the 1987 Land Use Plan, it has been updated where appropriate. 1.3.1 PHYSICAL LIMITATIONS FOR DEVELOPMENT ' Physical limitations for development involve areas where development would be costly or cause undesirable consequences. Included are hazard areas, areas with soil limitations, water supply sources. and areas where the slope exceeds 12%. 1.3.1(a) Natural Hazard Areas In Brunswick County, natural hazard areas are areas of shallow flooding as well as areas which are subject to wave velocity. The only ocean erodible area under County jurisdiction is the area of the Baptist Assembly Grounds. That particular area has ' experienced historical and unusual accretion rather than erosion of ocean front lands. It should also be noted that there is a seawall at this location. ' The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) has designated flood hazard areas in Brunswick County. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has prepared a map of Storm Surge Inundation Areas for Brunswick County. This map is based on the ' Special Program to List the Amplitude of Surge from Hurricanes (SPLASH) model. These maps are acceptable for general planning purposes. However, if a specific parcel of land is in doubt as to its location with regard to a flood hazard area, a ground ' elevation certification from a registered land surveyor is required before a building permit may be issued. ' A composite Hazardous Areas Map is presented on the following page. 1.3.1(b) Man -Made Hazard Areas ' In the Southport -Oak Island area there are several manmade hazards, including the Carolina Power and Light nuclear facility, the Sunny Point Ocean Terminal and its ' associated railroad corridor, and the Archer Daniels Midland Chemical facility. In the northeast area of the county is the Dupont Chemical facility. The three general purpose airstrips within the County also are potentially hazardous. These land uses are of significant economic benefit to Brunswick County and to all of southeastern North Carolina; even so, land uses locating near these facilities need to ' be sensitive to potential associated hazards. These manmade hazard areas are identified on the composite Hazardous Areas Map. ' Airstrip locations are also shown on the Community Facilities Map. tBrunswick County Planning Board page 48 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis Inadequate and unsafe road conditions, which generated considerable public comment in the 1987 Plan, did not receive the same level of attention in the 1992 round of public meetings. One exception is the new bypass around Shallotte, where a considerable number of serious accidents have occurred since the opening of this new roadway. The four-laning of US 17 is also expected to reduce traffic hazards on this major facility, especially at Grissettown and Supply. Also, NC Highway 133 is being widened and has had several bridges replaced since the last land use plan update. 1.3.1(c) Soil Limitations Soil limitations are characterized by poor drainage, foundation hazards, and septic tank unsuitability. Distinctions can be made between areas which are characterized as generally unsuitable, but within which small pockets of favorable soils do exist, as well as areas where serious limitations are common to most of the soils present. The U.S. Department of Agriculture and the Soil Conservation Service completed a detailed soil survey of Brunswick County several years ago. This soil survey is useful in providing easily accessible, detailed information on soils in the county. Unlike development patterns, soil types are not subject to change, except over considerable periods of time. Basic rating categories of soil associations found in Brunswick County are defined as follows: Slight: Soil properties are generally favorable for the stated uses, or limitations are minor and can be easily overcome. Moderate: Some soil properties are unfavorable for development but limitations can be overcome or modified by special planning, good design, and careful management. Severe: Soil properties are unfavorable and resulting limitations are too difficult to correct or overcome. Soil will require major soil reclamation or special design for stated uses. This rating, however, does not imply that the soil cannot be used. For more detailed descriptions of specific soil types in Brunswick County, including their suitability for septic tanks, roads, and building development, the reader is directed to the Brunswick County Soil Survey, available from the US Soil Conservation Service. The County has employed a staff person, based in the County Engineering Department, to serve as a Soil Scientist/Hydrologist. This person's duties include determination of soil characteristics in relation to development proposals and required permits. C u Brunswick County 9 Plannin Board page 49 Glenn Harbe& Associates I 11 Hazardous Areas Map Flood rone Areas' p Sunny Point Buffer Zone Ocean Hazard Areas Municipal(Not in Planning Area) Notes: ' There are two floockwons areas under the County's jurisdiction which are classified as'V-zones', meaning that they could be subject to high velocity wind and water damage during a mator storm event. These two areas are located on either side of the Lockwood Folly inlet at the mouth of the River. They are identified on Ine map in sold black. = Due to map scale. this hazardous areas map is necessarily generalized in nature, and is intended for general planning purposes only. Within some land areas, for example. there may be pockets of land which should be considered ftoodprone. Conversely, within the rxiodprone areas identified there may be pockets of high and dry and. In these situanons, more detailed, site specific information will lake prece- dence over the more generalized map, and the appropriate policies of the land use plan document will appry. Brunswick County LAND USE PLAN 1993 Update Glenn Harbeck Associates Planning and Public Involvement SCALE IN MILES 7ZmLJ NORTH 0 1 2 3 _':runswici County Land Use Tian Data Collection and Anaivsis Causes of Septic Tank Failure One of the most common causes of septic tank failures in Brunswick County is the installation of septic tank systems in soils which have seasonally high water tables. ' Another cause of failure is from the presence of an impervious soil layer which can become saturated following rainfall and retard the vertical movement of water. These ' layers may be hardpans, clays, sandpans, or organic soil horizons. In Brunswick County, these impervious layers are scattered in haphazard fashion and it is difficult to predict their spatial arrangement. Organic soil horizons are a particularly difficult soil ' structure to pinpoint because of uneven organic decomposition. As soil types, sub -soil types. and such factors as ground water tables vary, different sized lots or different dimensions of lots are necessary to address particular situations. A third cause of failures are those numerous instances where septic tanks and their filter fields have, over the years, been permitted for developments on inadequately sized lots (taking into consideration both total square footage and the outside dimensions of such lots). Prior to the NC Ground Absorption and Sewage Treatment Act of 1981 and resulting Administrative Law, many very small lots were platted in the county. That process changed materially following the 1981 law. The County's new subdivision ordinance now requires a minimum of 17,000 square feet of lot acreage if County water is ' available and an absolute minimum of 7,500 square feet, regardless of what utilities may be available. ' Land Suitability Analysis Of the County's total 558,720 acres of land (approximately 855 square miles) the ' following breakdowns have been tabulated from the land suitability analysis of the Brunswick County Soil Survey: ' CATEGORY ACRES % OF TOTAL 1. Soils with Limitations for 305,120 54.6% ' Septic Tank Systems 2. Soils with Limitations for the 233,520 41.8 ' Support of Building Foundations ' 3. Soils well suited for 247,000 44.3 Development ' 4. Soils well suited for 139,940 25.1 Agricultural Development i 5. Soils well suited for 325,200 58.2 Forest Protection Brunswick County Planning Board page 50 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis It should be noted that this analysis is very broad brush in nature; soils may be modified through site engineering, improved drainage, etc., thereby dramatically altering their suitability for development. Also, the percentages shown do not add to 1000%, due to the applicability of more than one category to a given parcel of land. Even so, the figures do give some indication of the general character of much of the land in coastal Brunswick County. 1.3.1(d) Potable Water Supply The County is a major provider of potable water, with an expanding piped water supply system serving both unincorporated and incorporated areas. Details of this piped water supply system are further outlined in Section 1.4.1 of this Plan. The piped water supply system is fed by a combination of treated surface and ground water. Even so, the majority of Brunswick County residents continue to rely on non -regulated, individual groundwater wells as a major source of potable water. Among problems associated with wells in low lying coastal areas are salt water intrusion, brackish water in heavy use areas, reliance upon septic tanks on the same small lots with individual wells. and competition for such ground water among industrial, agricultural, and residential users. Some engineering studies have predicted that salt water infiltration of the county's groundwater resources may occur as soon as the year 2000 in the area from the ocean to at least U.S. 17, and along the Cape Fear River north to the general area of the Dupont Plant. As a result, continued expansion of the County system would appear to be a prudent and necessary course of action. In the five years since the 1987 Land Use Plan was adopted, the County has provided water distribution lines to over 10,000 lots in the more developed, unincorporated areas of the county. 1.3.1(e) Areas Which Exceed 12% Slope There are no known areas in the unincorporated area of Brunswick County with slopes as extreme as 12%, excepting a ravine which is undevelopable near the Cape Fear River. Brunswick County Planning Board page 51 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Countv Lana Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis 1.3.2 FRAGILE AREAS Fragile areas are those areas which could be easily damaged or destroyed by inappropriate or poorly planned development. Some of these sensitive lands have been designated by the Coastal Resources Commission as Areas of Environmental Concern (AFC's). Special consideration is to be given regarding their use. This section of the Plan describes the significance and location of fragile areas located within Brunswick County's planning jurisdiction. These sensitive areas are identified on the Fragile Areas Map, which is presented on the next page. Policies regarding land use in, or adjacent to. fragile areas are outlined in Sections 2.1.2 and 2.1.3. Of speciai note in this round of land use plan updates is the availability of cost -share matching grant funds which may be available to local governments in North Carolina to finance inventories of natural areas and rare species. The funds are available throuah the North Carolina Heritage Program, administered by Planning Division, Division of Parks and Recreation. Raleigh. (Contact: Frank Boteler at (919) 733-7701. In addition, owners of fragile land areas may wish to take advantage of the tax benetits of donating land for conservation purooses. Senate Bill 405, ratified in 1989. increased the maximum income tax credit to 25% of the fair market value of the donated interest in the land, up to a maximum of $25,000. (previously limited to a maximum of $5,000). Complete information is available from the Wilmington regional office of the Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources (919) 395- 3900. ' Areas of Environmental Concern (AFC's) The Coastal Area Management Act of North Carolina calls for the identification of certain environmentally fragile and important land and water areas that are judged to be of greater than local significance. The Coastal Resources Commission, in cooperation with local governments in the 20-county coastal area, has developed a ' program of permit review and coordination within areas of environmental concern (AEC's), Essentially, special CAMA permits are required of all developments within desianated AEC's. The intent of the regulatory program is not to stop development, but rather to insure compatibility of development with the continued productivity and value of certain critical land and water areas. IThere are four broad categories of AEC's: - Estuarine Systems - Ocean Hazard Areas Systems - Public Water Supplies Natural and Cultural Resource Areas ' Each of these broad AEC categories is discussed in greater detail in the paragraphs that follow. ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 52 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis 1.3.2(a) Estuarine Systems AEC's The estuarine system of Brunswick County consists of all estuarine waters, coastal wetlands, public trust areas and estuarine shorelines. In general, the estuarine system is defined by all of the salt and brackish inland waters and adjacent land areas of the County. Coastal Wetlands AEC's These are the marshes, subject to regular or occasional flooding by tides, including normal wind tides. Brunswick County contains numerous salt water marshes and brackish marshes along its rivers and along the Intracoastal Waterway. It is the objective of the State and County to safeguard and perpetuate the biological, social, economic, and aesthetic value of these marshes as a natural resource essential to the functioning of the estuarine system. Accordingly, State administrative law defines suitable and unsuitable uses. Estuarine Water AEC's Estuarine waters have previously been defined as "all the water of the Atlantic Ocean within the boundary of North Carolina, and all the water of the bays, sounds, rivers, and tributaries thereto, seaward of the dividing line between coastal fishing waters and inland fishing waters." (15 NCAC317.0200) Another way of defining estuarine waters is to say that estuaries are semi -enclosed coastal water bodies having free connection with the open sea and within which seawater is measurably diluted with fresh water drained from the adjacent land. The estuarine water AEC's of Brunswick County are associated with the Intracoastal Waterway and the southern sections of the Cape Fear, Shallotte, and Lockwood Folly rivers. Public Trust AEC's Public trust AEC's are all waters of the Atlantic Ocean and the lands thereunder, from the mean high water mark to the seaward limit of State jurisdiction; all natural bodies of water subject to measurable lunar tides and lands thereunder to the mean high water mark; all navigable natural bodies of water and lands thereunder to the mean high water level or mean water level, as the case may be, except privately owned lakes, to which the public has no right of access; all water in artificially created bodies of water containing significant public fishing resources or other public resources which are accessible to the public by navigation from bodies of water in which the public has rights of navigation; and all waters in artificially created bodies of water in which the public has acquired rights by a prescription, custom, usage, dedication, or any other means. In considering development on any body of water in Brunswick County, it is best to presume that the water is in the public trust unless otherwise specifically documented. The Intracoastal Waterway is the major Public Trust AEC in Brunswick County. Development which would block or impair existing navigation channels, increase shoreline erosion, deposit spoils below mean high tide, cause adverse water I n E Brunswick County Planning Board page 53 Glenn Harbeck Associates Fragile Areas Map Estuarine & Freshwater Systems ® Green Swamp Wildlife Management Areas Bear Sanctuary Ocean Hazard Areas Municipal(Not in Planning Area) Note: Due to map scale, this map is necessarily generalized in nature, and is Intended for general informational purposes only. Brunswick County LAND USE PLAN 1993 Update Glenn Harbeck Associates Planning and Public Involvement SCALE IN MILES 0 7�-.� NORTH 0 1 2 3 4 =runsvncrc County Lana Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis 1 circulation patterns, violate water quality standards, or cause degradation of shellfish waters is considered incompatible with public trust areas. Estuarine Shorelines Estuanne shorelines, aithougn treated ostensibly as dry land, are considered a component of the estuarine system because of the close association with the adjacent estuarine waters. Estuarine shorelines are those non -ocean shorelines which are especially vulnerable to erosion. flooding. or other adverse effects of wind and water, and are intimately connected to the estuary. This area extends from the mean high water level or normal water level along the estuaries, sounds, bays, and brackish waters for a distance of 75' landward. It is useful to emphasize that where the range of saltwater influence on freshwater streams ends is also the approximate location where the estuarine shoreline AEC also ends. Because of the direct proximity. development in this area has a great influence on the quality of the estuaries and is also subject to the damaging processes of shoreline erosion and flooding. Accordingly, the State has defined standards for development which take into consideration the dynamics of the shoreline and the resources associated with estuarine waters. These standards are to insure that development does not have an adverse impact on the estuarine system. 1.3.2(b) Ocean Hazard Area AEC's These are natural hazard areas along the ocean shoreline where, because of their special vulnerability to erosion or other adverse effects of sand, wind, and water, uncontrolled or incompatible development could unreasonably endanger life or property. Such areas include beaches, frontal dunes, inlet lands, and other areas where there is a substantial possibility of excessive erosion or flood damage. It is the objective of the State and County to provide management policies and standards for such areas that serve to eliminate unreasonable danger to life and property. A balance must also be achieved among the financial, safety. and social factors involved in this type of development. Types of Ocean Hazard Areas Are: Ocean erodible areas —these are areas in which there exists a substantial possibility of excessive erosion and significant shoreline fluctuation. ' High hazard flood areas —this is the area subject to high velocity waters in a storm having a one percent chance of being equalled or exceeded in any given year, as identified as Zone VI-30 on federal flood insurance rate maps. ' Inlet hazard areas —these are areas with a substantial possibility of excessive erosion, located adjacent to inlets. The State sets use standards for ocean hazard areas by ' administrative law. The State further: requires erosion control activities. dune establishment and stabilization, sets standards for structural accessways, and new/substantial construction standards in ocean hazard areas. ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 54 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Countv Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis The Ocean Hazard Areas designated within Brunswick County are, for the most part, within the municipalities' jurisdictions. The only exception to this is the extreme eastern tip of Oak Island. This area contains Fort Caswell and is owned by the North Carolina Baptist Assembly. Only limited public access is allowed. 1.3.2(c) Public Water Supply AEC's Small Surface Water Supply Watershed AEC's Small surface water supply watersheds are catchment areas situated entirely within the coastal area, classified by the North Carolina Environmental Management Commission as Class A-11, which means that the maximum beneficial use is that of a public water supply. Classification of streams and rivers is an ongoing process by the State. When a stream is Class A-11, no ground absorption sewage disposal systems may be located within 100 feet of the water, a National Pollution Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) is required, and the standards of the North Carolina Sedimentation Pollution Control Act of 1973 must be met. There are no such designated areas in Brunswick County. Public Water Supply Weil Field AEC's Public water supply well fields are areas of well -drained sands that extend downward from the surface into shallow ground water supplies. The North Carolina Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources has identified such areas. There are standards to be met on any development over such a well field. There are no such designated areas in Brunswick County. 1.3.2(d) Natural and Cultural Resource AEC's This fourth category of AEC's covers areas containing environmental, natural, or cultural resources of more than local significance. State Administrative Law (15 NCAC 7H.0503) provides a nomination and designation process for any site to be declared this type of AEC. H H 0 Coastal Complex Natural Areas and Coastal Areas that Sustain Remnant I Species AEC's Coastal complex natural areas are lands that support native plant and animal ' communities and provide habitat qualities which have remained essentially unchanged by human activity. These areas function as key biological enclaves for a variety of natural species. They may be surrounded by landscape that has been ' modified but does not drastically alter conditions within the natural area. Coastal areas that sustain remnant species are areas that support native plants or , animals determined to be rare or endangered. The objective is to protect habitat Brunswick County Planning Board page 55 Glenn Harbeck Associates ' Brunswick County Lana User;a- Data Collection ano Anaivsis 1 I I I� E L L conditions necessary to *he continued survival of threatened and endangered native plants and animals. Although no areas in Brunswick County have been officially designated in this category of AEC, there are many such areas in the County. Several years ago the Norm Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development, (now the Department of Environment. Health. and Natural Resources) Division of Parks and Recreation, National Heritage Program compiled detailed information on these areas. a summary of which is available at the Brunswick County Planning Department. Unique Coastal Geologic Formation AEC's No unique coastal geological formations have been identified by State geologists in Brunswick County. Significant Coastal Archaeological Resource AEC's Significant coastal archaeological resources are sites. objects. or features evaluated by the NC Historical Commission that have more than local significance to history or prehistory. Brunswick County has a large number of archaeological sites. The great majority of these sites have not been excavated nor has the county been systematically surveyed. However, 172 prehistoric sites have been identified and entered into the State's prehistoric file inventory maintained by the Department of Cultural Resources and the Archeology Branch section. The majority of these sites consist of surface scatters whose cultural affiliation has not been identified. A number of midden mounds, which were areas of discard and refuse. have also been noted. In addition to the prehistoric sites, there are a number of known shipwrecks in the Cape Fear River. Significant Coastal Architectural Resources The following inventory includes a description of the more significant historic sites found throughout Brunswick County (not including Southport, for which a separate inventory has been compiled). HISTORIC SITES/FRAGILE AREAS 1. Williams House 2. Belvedere Plantation 3. Railroad Hotel 4. Winnabow Plantation 5. Clarendon Plantation 6. Olde Town Plantation 7. Pleasant Oaks Plantation Brunswick County Planning Board page 56 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis 8. Orton Plantation 9. Brunswick Town (Fort Anderson, St. Phillips Church) 10. Battery Lamb and Saltworks 11. Price's Creek Lighthouse 12. "The Rock's" (structure gone) 13. Quarantine Station (structure gone) 14. Fort Caswell 15. Gause's Tomb ' 16. Hickory Hall 17. Bald Head Lighthouse 18. Cape Fear Lighthouse Complex ' 19. Goodman Family House 20. W. H. Walker House 21. Zion United Methodist Church Cemetery 22. Concord Methodist Church ' 23. Sunny Side School 24. Bethel United Methodist Church , 25. USCG Station at Oak Island Many of these structures no longer stand. The old USCG Station at Oak Island is ' presently scheduled to be demolished. Some of the plantations ceased activities 150 years ago. Detailed descriptions of some of the more significant sites are available from the Brunswick County Planning Department. ' 1.3.2(e) Fragile Land Areas Areas listed in this section include important natural or manmade sites which do not ' conveniently fit into previously listed AEC categories, yet are still deemed to be development constraints because of their importance. The County regards these , areas to be no less significant than those officially designated. Freshwater Swamps and Marshes , Brunswick County has thousands of acres of private and public freshwater swamps and marshes. Most notable is the Green Swamp, which is the predominant land/water ' feature in the north central area of the county. Other important swamp and marsh areas which should be protected are the Big Cypress Bay and Ponds, Orton Pond, Spring Creek Pond, and numerous swamps and marshes associated with the Cape Fear, Town Creek, Lockwood Folly, Shallotte, Calabash and Waccamaw Rivers. Maritime Forest I While there are no traditional maritime forests located in that portion of the unincorporated area under Brunswick County's jurisdiction, some sections of land on ' the north side of ;he intracoastal waterway have elements of maritime forest, related perhaps, to the period of time before the intracoastal waterway separated these areas from their adjacent oceanfront land areas. Brunswick County Planning Board page 57 Glenn Harbeck Associates I �-unswick County Lana Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis U 1.3.3 AREAS WITH RESOURCE POTENTIAL Areas with resource potential include productive and unique agricultural land, valuable mineral sites, private sanctuaries. public recreation lands. and other non - intensive recreational uses. 1.3.3(a) Productive and Unique Agricultural Land The Governor's Executive Order 96. Conservation of Prime Agricultural and Forests, sets forth the State's policy of providing for the conservation of soil to promote the efficient production and utilization of soil ... and to conserve natural resources. The order directed each county's Soil and Water Conservation Commission to work closely with the respective county Soil and Water Conservation Districts to develop a map of prime agricultural and forest lands in their respective jurisdictions. Soils that should be considered prime farmland, soils which are locally important. and soils that are unique to specific locations have been identified for Brunswick County; this information is available from the S & W Conservation District Soil Scientist in map form. ,. Prime farmland contains soils best suited for producing food, feed, fiber, forage and oilseed crops. They are economically productive for all major crops common to the ' county. They are not excessively erodible or saturated with water for long periods of time. Soils categorized as prime in Brunswick County are Foreston. Goldsboro. Johns. Norfolk, and Onslow. Locally important farmland has characteristics which cannot meet the reouirements of prime soil designation but may produce economically satisfactory results, depending ' on their setting and the management practices employed. These soils may be naturally wet and lack adequate internal drainage. Soils falling into this category are Baymeade. Blanton, Croatan, Grifton, Lynchburg, Pactolus. Pantego, Rains. ' Tomahawk, Torhunta, Wando, and Woodington. In addition, certain soils have been designated as unique. This farmland is sometimes ' used for the production of a specific crop that may not be produced on a general basis in the area. Blueberries are a crop with special soil requirements that are unique to the county. The soils with these qualities are Leon Fine Sand and Murville Mucky Fine Sand. Brunswick County Planning Board page 58 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Anal sis AGRICULTURAL LANDS PRIME FARMLAND SOILS Foreston 26,692 acres Goldsboro 29.830 acres Johns 3,116 acres Onslow 3,439 acres Norfolk 12.521 acres 75,598 acres LOCALLY IMPORTANT FARMLAND SOILS Baymeade 55,973 acres Blanton 16,127 acres Croatan 3,533 acres Grifton 22,023 acres Lynchburg 19,991 acres Pactolus 47,771 acres Pantago 8,305 acres Rains 35,619 acres Tomahawk 4,975 acres Torhunta 3,994 acres Wando 12,176 acres Woodington 29,703 acres 260,190 acres UNIQUE LAND SOILS Leon Fine Sand 45,611 acres Murville Mucky Fine Sand 39,490 acres Total 85,101 acres It should be noted that these figures tend to exaggerate the amount of land actually available for farming in Brunswick County. Many of these soils are located in areas which are impractical to farm because of access, high water table levels, or other reasons. 1.3.3(b) Valuable Mineral Sites No known valuable mineral deposits exist in Brunswick County. Sand and coquina is sometimes extracted for construction applications. There are some scattered deposits of gravel, but the feasibility of mining is not known. 1.3.3(c) Private Sanctuaries The Nature Conservancy owns 15,814 acres of land within the Green Swamp. The Conservancy is a private organization dedicated to the preservation of unique natural areas. It is the intent of the Conservancy that the area will remain free from development . �J Brunswick County Planning Board page 59 Glenn Harbeck Associates ?runswicK Countv Lana Use Plan Data Collection ana Analysis '1 Various large private landholdings are 'de facto" gamelands by virtue of their isolation and general inaccessibility. (These areas are mainly owned by timber companies). The Orton Plantation and Pond is another major private landholding in Brunswick County which contains natural areas uniquely salted for wildlife habitat. While clearly not a private sanctuary, the community of Boiling Spring Lakes (17,000+ acres) has much of its territory taken up by land .vhich is not suited for development. The State has also designated a Game Land/Bear Sanctuary within Brunswick County. The Bear Sanctuary is one of 28 designated areas within the State designed to promote the preservation of the species. Bear hunting is prohibited inside the Sanctuary. Major private sanctuaries are identified on the Fragile Areas Map. 1.3.3(d) Public Recreation Land The area north of the municipal limits of Bald head Island to the New Hanover County line is owned entirely by the State of North Carolina. This land form separates the Cape Fear River from the Atlantic Ocean. (The word "land" is somewhat misleading as the areas consists of marsh, water, and small isiands). Within this area are several different management and administrative jurisdictions. The area adjacent to the New Hanover County line is now part of the National Estuarine Sanctuary Program. This is a federal program (Section 315 of the Coastal Zone Management Act) which provides the acquisition, development or operation of areas "to serve as natural field laboratories in which to study and gather data on the natural and human processes in the coastal region and man's effect on them." ' The Zeke's Island sanctuary is located in New Hanover and Brunswick Counties, encompassing approximately 1.165 acres of upland, intertidal, and shallow water areas. 178.8 upland acres of the site were donated to the State of North Carolina in ' 1981 as the initial component of North Carolina's National Estuarine Sanctuary. The area is managed primarily as an educational and research site. though compatible recreational uses are allowed. For further information regarding the Zeke's Island sanctuary, contact the Marine Sanctuary Program, Division of Coastal Management in Raleigh. ' The area south of Zeke's Island sanctuary consists of about 10,000 acres of marsh and approximately 1,000 acres of upland. At last report, this area was being administered by several State agencies. The majority of this area is administered by the Department of Parks and Recreation. The Wildlife Resources Commission and the Division of Marine Fisheries combine regulatory and enforcement jurisdiction. ' Battery Island and Striking Island have been leased by the State to the Audubon Society for fifty year periods. ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 60 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis The spit of land above New Iniet is located in Brunswick County and is part of the Fort Fisher State Historic Site. This area is administered by the Department of Cultural ' Resources and regulations are enforced by the Division of Parks and Recreation. 1.3.3(e) Other Non -intensive Recreational Uses , All or he navigable waters in the county are publicly owned. (Hence, their designation as Public Trust Waters.) They are used for commercial and recreational fishing, ' swimming, and boating. Also. ail the beach below mean high tide is owned by the State, as is any land raised I througn beach nourishment projects. In recent years, numerous semi -private and private golf courses have been developed in Brunswick County. Nearly all of these courses are being built in the area of the county between U.S. 17 and the intracoastal waterway. Most have been built in conjunction with single family residential developments. There are currently twenty or ' more 18-hole or larger golf courses in Brunswick County, with more under construction. U Brunswick County Planning Board page 61 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis J 1.4 Constraints; Carrying Capacity Analysis As discussed in the preceding section, the suitability of land for development presents one set of constraints on the future orowth of Brunswick County. These mostly natural constraints are largely beyond the control of man, without considerable and often costly modification of the land resource. A second set of constraints, however, has to do with local governments' ability to provide and pay for community facilities and services in the face of continued growth. While such ability is linked to some degree to the natural systems upon which certain facilities (such as water) depend, the provision of such facilities and services is more a function of conscious decisions on the part of local governments as to whether such services are needed, who will pay for them, how and when. 1.4.1 POTABLE WATER SYSTEM After years of study, the County entered the water business on a fairly large scale in 1974, establishing a water treatment plant served by a well field. located about two miles west of the Southport -Oak Island area, on NC 211. Trunk mains were provided so that this plant served the Southport area. the rapidly develooing unincorporated area related both to Southport and to Oak Island, and Caswell Beach, Long Beach and Yaupon Beach on Oak Island, and then via trunk main under the Lockwood Folly Inlet to Holden Beach. That system was upgraded in 1980 so that the so-called "NC 211 " plant is today ' capable of producing six million gallons of potable water per day. Starting in 1981, a major expansion of the system began, funded by a $37 million general obligation bond approved by the County's voters. Initially trunk mains. with necessary booster pumping stations and water tanks, were extended northerly from Holden Beach via NC 130 through the heavily developed area between the Lockwood ' Folly and Shallotte Rivers to and through Shallotte. From Shallotte, the lines continued on via NC 179 through the rapidly developing southwestern sector of the County all the way through Calabash to a point just shy of the South Carolina state line. Today, ' the County system serves the Towns of Shallotte, Ocean Isle Beach, Sunset Beach, Holden Beach, Yaupon Beach, Long Beach and Caswell Beach. ' It should be noted that the main source of water for the County system was changed in the early 1980s. The County made an "up front" loan of $7,000,000 to the Lower Cape Fear Water and Sewer Authority to permit that agency to undertake a regional project. ' As a result, the principal source of water became the Cape Fear River, from an intake located above Lock No. 1 in Bladen County. From there, raw water is pumped through a 48" trunk main through Columbus County into Brunswick County, where it connects with the main water treatment plant in the northwest area of the County. This 24 million gallon per day water treatment plant opened at Hoods Creek in 1989 with an extensive additional network of trunk mains. From this 24 MGD plant (capable of expansion to 48 MGD), 48" trunk mains extend, then 42", then 36", and in some cases, then down to 24", running in varying directions. ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 62 Glenn Harbeck Associates Prunswick Countv Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis 1 These trunk mains cut through the northeastern portion of the county and provide a connecting point for the Leland Sanitary District on Mount Misery Road. They then run via the Sunny Point Railroad right-of-way, then southwesterly on U.S. 17 to connect into the system in Shallotte, and southerly to connect into the original plant on NC 211 in the Southport -Oak Island area. In addition, the County adopted a Water Distribution Systems Policy regarding new developments in 1984. As a result, over 100 subdivisions have installed and dedicated to the County, water distribution systems to serve these new areas. Some 10.000+ lots in the County are currently served by the Water System. In July of 1989, the total median daily demand from all customers tied into the County system was 3.7 million gallons of a total system capacity of 30 million gallons. By 1993 median daily demand had increased to 10 million gallons per day. This represents a 33% utilization. (p. 6, Water Distribution System Master Plan, Brunswick County, 1990 and telephone conversation with a representative of the County Engineering office.). Plans for Expansion In September of 1990, work was completed on a new Water Distribution System Master Plan. Prepared for Brunswick County by the engineering firm of William G. Daniel and Associates, the report analyzed the current distribution system, projected future water consumption, and recommended improvements to the system for action by 1991, 1995 and 2010. The following are relevant excerpts from the System Master Plan, for each of the target years, in reverse order: Year 2010 System Recommendations For the year 2010, a 24" line is recommended along NC 133 from Leland Industrial Park to NC 87 just above the Sunny Point Pump Station. It should connect to the existing 36" line below the Leland tank via US 74/76. A line along NC 211 between the 211 Water Plant and US 17 is proposed. This line's diameter is 24" at the plant but can be reduced to 16" at Midway Road (SR 1500). A 16" line connecting NC 211 with Long Beach is also recommended. A 12" line along Stone Chimney Road (SR 1115) from NC 211 to the existing line in Sabbath Home Road (SR 1120) is necessary. The final waterline proposed for this portion of the County is a 16" line from US 17 to NC 130 storage tank near the intersection of NC 130 (Holden Beach Road) and Sabbath Home Road will be needed to supplement the existing Holden Beach tank. The portion of the County below Shallotte will require several new waterlines. One is a 24" main along US 17 from Shallotte to Ocean Isle Beach Road (SR 1184) which continues on down US 17 to Thomasboro as a 20" diameter line. South from Thomasburo along SR 1165 to Clariday Road (SR 1164), a 20" line is recommended. From there a 16" line is proposed for Clariday Road, where it will connect with the existing main in NC 179. It is also recommended that a new 12" line be installed parallel to the existing 8" line in NC 179 down to Pump Station No. 5. Finally, two 1 7 LJJ Brunswick County Planning Board page 63 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis connections between US 17 and NC 179 will also be necessary, a 20" line along ' Ocean Isle Beach Road (SR 1184) and a 12" one down NC 904. In addition to the proposed lines through this portion of the County, a 0.5 million gallon elevated tank should be erected in the vicinity of the NC 904/NC 179 intersection. ' (Note: Reference to the above -proposed tanK is in addition to the tank to be completed on NC 179, approximately half way between Ocean Isle ar.a Shallotte.) 1995 System Recommendations If Brunswick County's population increases as anticipated. the following portions of the ' proposed 2010 improvements will be required by 1995: —The 12" line down Stone Chimney Road (SR 1115) from NC 211 to the existing 12" waterline in Sabbath Home Road (SR 1120). —That portion of the 16" waterline down NC 211 from US 17 to the above line in Stone Chimney Road. —The 16" line from US 17 to NC 130 via Mt. Pisgah Road (SR 1130) and Civietown ' Road (SR 1132), and —A 20" waterline between US 17 anc NC 179 along Ocean Isle Beach Road (SR 1184). ' No new booster pump stations or storage tanks will be required in 1995. Please note that the above recommendations assume that those facilities in the ' Shallotte to Calabash area (proposed for construction in 1991) are already in service. These will be discussed in the following section. ' 1991 System Recommendations The proposed US 17 line will become the main artery for serving the beach front areas ' via connections to NC 179 along Ocean Isle Beach Road, NC 179, and Thomasboro Road. If Pump Station No. 4 is left in operation, it will reduce the amount of water carried down NC 904 and Ocean Isle Beach Road by raising the pressure along NC ' 179. The additional water which will be conveyed down NC 179 from Shallotte as a result of No. 4 remaining in operation vVill create large friction losses above No. 4 and cause significantly lower pressures through that reach. Therefore, system performance ' will be enhanced by Pump Station No. 4 being off-line. The engineers then considered several different scenarios for system improvements in conjunction with the above recommendations. The proposed "Alternate 5" was then selected and is described as follows: ' -Construct the US 17 line to Thomasboro, continue with a line to Calabash along Thomasboro Road, also install the line from US 17 to NC 179 down NC 904, and reverse Pump Station No. 5, but do not build an elevated tank. •Construction of the recommended 1991 improvements is underway. ' •Major water system trunk lines, both existing and proposed, are shown on the Community Facilities Map found at the end of this section (page 77a). IBrunswick County Planning Board page 64 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis F 1.4.2 SEWER AND STORM DRAINAGE Brunswick County is wrestling with what many local leaders see as the number one constraint to development, that of sewage treatment. The county's relatively sparse development patterns make the provision of a single, centralized sewage treatment system unworkable. Areas where there are concentrations of small lots or higher density development (such as near the beach communities) offer some possibilities, however. As a result, there are several local area initiatives underway which would seek to address this problem. While these sewage treatment systems do not fall under the planning jurisdiction of Brunswick County, considerable information has been collected and summarized below to provide a general picture of what is going on. Calabash and the Town of Sunset Beach recently completed studies to evaluate the feasibility of centralized sewage facilities to serve their respective areas. An outcome of the studies was a recommendation that the communities jointly develop a combined sewage treatment system. As a result, they have formed the South Brunswick Water and Sewer Authority. A planned phase one plant would treat up to 2 million gallons per day. It is hoped that the facility would become operational in three to four years. pending approval of funding. The Town of Shallotte is planning to expand its sewage treatment capacity from 208 thousand gallons to 500 thousand gallons per day. (The system is presently operating at about 65 % of capacity.) At Ocean Isle Beach. a relatively new sewer system is currently in service. In December of 1992 bids were opened to increase the Ocean Isle Beach wastewater treatment system by one third to a capacity of one million gallons per day. Holden Beach has studied the issue for several years but has apparently not been able to reach a consensus on the subject. Yaupon Beach recently developed its own system which is reportedly under construction. The Town of Southport expanded its sewage treatment plant during the past five years and has plenty of capacity available at the present time. Just west of Southport, the Southeastern Sanitary District is moving actively toward a 400 thousand gallon per day centralized sewage system for that part of the county. Future system capacity could be as much as 1 million gallons per day. The District has received a $2.1 million grant from FmHA and has passed a general obligation bond for $1.2 million. The system is scheduled to become operational in the Fall of 1994. In the northeast part of the county, the Towns of Leland and Belville are each working toward sewage treatment systems for their respective areas. Finally, the County undertook its first activity in the provision of a public waste water treatment plant and service about five years ago. This was in connection with a new county -owned industrial park. The plant was completed and placed in service in 1987. It should be noted that the County sewer system at the Leland Industrial Park is a modular, package system capable of easy expansion. The treatment plant is located adjacent to the receiving stream, the Cape Fear River, provides 24-hour hydraulic detention time for the 250,000 gpd design flow, and is capable of meeting the 30 mg/effluent limits for biochemical oxygen demand and suspended solids respectively. The system has a 4.5 mile 8" sewer main. It is currently (1992) operating at about ten percent of capacity. Each of the various sewer service areas, whether existing or proposed, is shown on the Community Facilities Map, found at the end of this section (page 77a). Through its water management program and, more particularly, through its newly revised subdivision review and approval program, the County has recently improved its capabilities regarding the proper design of new storn, drainage facilities. However, no comprehensive storm water management master plan has been prepared for the County to date. As certain portions of the County become more densely developed, and adverse impacts on the County's estuarine waters increase, a comprehensive storm water master plan may be necessary. In this regard, an initiative is underway to seek state funding of an environmental management plan specifically addressing storm water runoff in the Lockwood Folly River basin. 1 1 Brunswick County Planning Board page 65 Glenn Harbeck Associates Prunsmck Cc;:nry Land Use Plan Data Collection ana Analvsis developed. and adverse impacts on the County's estuarine waters increase, a ' comprehensive storm water master plan may be necessary. 1.4.3 TRANSPORTATION ' 1.4.3(a) Public Roads ' Brunswick County had 620 miles of paved public roads and 156 miles of unpaved public roads as of January 1991 (the most recent date for which figures were available). For comparison, at the time of the last Land Use Plan Update in 1987, there ' were 587 miles of paved public roads and 166 miles of unpaved public roads in the County. There is a considerable undetermined amount of unpaved private subdivision roads that have yet to be upgraded and added to the state secondary road system. During public meetings, a continuing concern voiced by County residents was the numerous inadequate and unsafe roadways within the County. Because of the high volume of seasonal visitation to the beach areas. certain roads are carrying excessive amounts of traffic. ' In October and November of 1987, just prior to certification of the last Land Use Plan Update by the CRC, a new Thoroughfare Plan for Brunswick County was adopted by the County and its municipalities. Following local adoption, the plan was then adopted ' by the NC DOT in February of 1988. Preparation of the plan involved a cooperative effort of the Thoroughfare Planning Unit, Planning and Research Branch, Division of Highways, NC Department of Transportation, and a County -wide Thoroughfare Plan ' Coordinating Committee, made up of representatives of numerous local governments and Chambers of Commerce in Brunswick County. The following are excerpts of the major findings and recommendations of the Thoroughfare Plan: Maior Objectives ' The highway system in Brunswick County has primarily two important functions; they are as follows: ' 1. To serve the ever increasing north -south traffic through the county. 2. To serve the increasing demand for access to the beach areas. Road Capacity Problems: An analysis of highways in Brunswick County was made to determine if the projected 1 traffic (year 2005) would exceed the practical capacity of the system. Comparing the projected traffic to available capacities, it was anticipated that the following roads would be experiencing capacity related problems within the design period (1988- ' 2005): 1. US 17 - from NC 87 (Bell Swamp) to NC 211 (Supply). 2. US 17 - from Supply to South Carolina County Line. 3. US 17-74-76 - from New Hanover County Line to Brunswick River. 4. NC 133 - from Oak Island Bridge to NC 211. Brunswick County Planning Board page 66 Glenn Harbeck Associates ?runswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Anaivsis ' 5. NC 133 - from NC 211 to NC 87. 6. NC 87 - from NC 211, 87 (Southport) to Sunny Point Access Road. ' Highway Improvement Priorities Beyond simple capacity deficiencies, the Thoroughfare Plan also evaluated roads in I the county according to a variety of economic. environmental, cost, and overall system contribution factors. As a result of this full analysis, the Plan recommended fifteen road ' improvement projects, as listed in the table which follows. These fifteen were then placed in three priority groups in order of probable need. By way of an update, the status of each project is shown in the column to the far right of the table. ' _ ROAD IMPROVEMENT PRIORITIES AND COST ESTIMATES (1987 DOLLARS) 1988 THOROUGHFARE PLAN I BRUNSWICK COUNTY ROUTE AND SECTION RECOMMENDED CROSS TOTAL ; Transportation SECTION COST Improvement ($1,000) Plan STATUS` (1993-1999) PRIORITY 1 1. US 17 - Bell Swamp to Supply 4 Lanes Divided. Rural 21,300. Complete 2. US 17 - US 74, 76 to Bell 4 Lanes Divided. Freeway 12,800. Complete Swamp 3. US 17 - Supply to Shallotte 4 Lanes Divided. Rural 8,400. Under Contract j Bypass 4. US 17 - Shall otte--Bypass ; 4 Lanes Divided. Freeway 13,300. ; Complete 5. US 17 - Bolivia Bypass 4 Lanes Divided. Freeway 19,500. Complete 1 6. US 17 - Shallotte Bypass to 4 Lanes Divided. Rural 15,300. i Under Contract S.C. Line 7. US 74, 76 - New Hanover Co. 6 Lanes Divided. Rural 15,000. Not in TIP Line to US 17 Freeway 8. 1-40 Loop Extension 4 Lanes Divided. Freeway 39,800. Construct Start 1996 PRIORITY 2 9. NC 211 - NC 133 to NC 211/87 4 Lanes Divided. Urban 2,700. Not in TIP Junction Boulevard 10. NC 133 - Dosher Cutoff 4 Lanes Divided. Urban 2,000. Not in TIP Relocation Boulevard j 11. NC 87 - SPAT. Access Rd. to 15 Lanes, Urban 3,800. Not in TIP NC 211/87 Junction PRIORITY 3 j 12. SR 1122 Connector to 2 Lanes, Rural 15,000. Not in TIP Southport i 13. SR 1500 Connector to SR 2 Lanes, Rural 8,900. Not in TIP 1190, Long Beach 14. SR 1163 Connector to NC 17912 Lanes, Rural 4,900. Not in TIP 15. NC 179 Reali nment i 2 Lanes, Rural 800. Not in TIP 1 h J Note: Cost values are estimates used in the planning stage and are not to be used as actual construction costs. ' 'Source: Annual Report, NC DOT Transportation Improvement Program 1993-99, plus personal and telephone interviews with DOT officials in Wilmington and Raleigh, September 4,1992. Brunswick County Planning Board page 67 Glenn Harbeck Associates runswick Countv Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis BRIDGE DEFICIENCIES AND REPLACEMENT PRIORITIES ' actors which are indicative of bridge sufficiency include. structural design adequacy and safety, traffic safety, serviceability, location of structure, functional obsolescence ano essentially for public use. The 1988 Thoroughfare Plan identified some 46 deficient bridges located on routes ' included in the plan (pp. 39-40). Of these 46 bridges, the Plan identified 15 for priority improvement. The locations, estimated costs and status of each of these projects is shown in the table following. ' - IMPROVEMENT PRIORITIES FOR DEFICIENT BRIDGES IN BRUNSWICK COUNTY IDENTIFIED IN 1988 THOROUGHFARE PLAN PRIORITY I ESTIMATED REPLACEMENT COST (in 1987 dollars) Transportation Improvement Plan STATUS' (1993-1999) 1. SR 1435 @Sturgeon Creek 447.000 Construct in 1998 2. SR 1426 @ Hook Creek ; 310,000 Construct in 1998 3. NC 130 Bear Branch 157.000 Construct in 1995 4. SR 1521 @ Rice's Creek —Big 193.000 Construct in 1993 i 1 5. NC 211 @ Branch of Swamp 172,000 Not in TIP 6. NC 130 Wet Ash Swamp i 183,000 Construct in 1997 7. SR 1500 @ Br. River Swamp 158,000 Not in TIP 18. SR 1500 @ River Swamp Creek 286,000 Not in TIP 9. NC 904 Sci peo Swamp 249,000 Construct in 1997 10. SR 1432 Mill Creek 202,000 Not in TIP 11. SR 1411 @ Br. Town Creek i 267,000 Not in TIP 12. SR 1411 @ Town Creek 267,000 Not in TIP i 13. SR 1410 9 Lewis Creek 112,000 Not in TIP 14. SIR 1518 @ Mills Creek 162,000 Not in TIP 15. NC 211 Branch of Juniper Creek 172.000 Not in TIP i TOTAL, $3,337,000 'Source: Annual Report, NC COT Transportation Improvement Program 1993-99, pius personal and telephone interviews with DOT officials in Wilmington and Raleigh, September 4.1992. OTHER ISSUES ' In addition to the above mentioned bridge replacement priorities, discussions continue regarding: (1) the need for a new high-rise bridge at Sunset Beach to replace the existing older bridge and (2) the need for an additional bridge serving the SouthMest ' end of Oak Island. Also, at the time of this writing, (9/22/92) design modifications and improvements to the new bypass around Shallotte have been approved, due to a number of accidents having occurred there since the facility was opened. ' The County has consistently supported these three needs. ' The Community Facilities Map shows existing thoroughfares within the County as well as proposed major thoroughfare improvements recommended in the 1988 Thoroughfare Plan. ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 68 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Countv Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis 1.4.3(b) Air Transportation There are two publicly owned general aviation airports in the county. One is known as the Brunswick County Airport. It is operated by the Airport Commission, whose membership is named by the County Commissioners and several municipal Town Boards. This facility is situated on the mainland across from Oak Island. During the early 1980's, a Master Plan for this airport was developed, and approved by the County, by the North Carolina Aeronautics Council, and by the US Federal Aviation Administration. Significant improvements have been provided with County funding, and a new terminal building has been built. Also in the early 1980s, the County Planning Department prepared an Airport Zoning Ordinance, which was adopted and is being enforced through joint actions of the Airport Manager and the County's Building Inspections Division. The Ocean Isle Beach Airport, owned by that municipality, is located on the mainland across from that island. During the 1980s, an Airport Zoning Ordinance was prepared by the County Planning Department and is in effect, being enforced jointly by the Town Airport Commissioner and the County's Building Inspections Division. An updated Master Plan for that facility was completed in 1987-88. The Ocean Isle Beach runway was recently widened and an additional airplane parking area has been installed. There are several privately owned airstrips in different locations around the County, the largest being the Vinnabow International Airport." It has less than ten home - based aircraft, and a large paved and lighted runway. Most other airstrips are grassed rather than paved facilities. The County is an active supporter of the two publicly owned general aviation facilities in the County, both by financial participation and through the development of plans and ordinances. The locations of the three major airstrips within the County are shown on the Community Facilities Map. 1.4.4 LAW ENFORCEMENT Law enforcement for Brunswick County is provided by the County's Sheriff's Department and local municipal police forces. The Sheriff's Department currently has 24 hour service with 49 personnel and 37 vehicles. As the county's population continues to increase, it is anticipated that the resources of this vital public service will also be increased. 1.4.5 FIRE AND RESCUE For many years, the County has been the prime source of funds for operation and maintenance of some 20 fire departments and 9 rescue squads, both in the unincorporated areas and also in municipalities. For example, as early as the 1960s, the County underwrote the mortgages these agencies took on for purposes of erecting buildings. n Brunswick County Planning Board page 69 Glenn Harbeck Associates I -7 Brunswick Countv Lana Use Plan Data Collection ana Analvsis The current FY 91-92 County budget provides further evidence of this commitment. For each of the 20 fire departments totally within the county, whether they limit their service to their municipality, provide service only to a specified unincorporated area, or provide a combined service. a $13.500 direct grant is provided (up from $10,000 in 87- 88). In addition, on the basis of the five Electoral Districts, $50,000 in each of the five such Districts is set aside for fire and/or rescue services, individual judgments to be made during the course of the fiscal year by the Board of County Commissioners as to distribution of those funds. An additional fire department, whose service area is 90% in Columbus County and ' 10% in Brunswick County, was granted $2,500 and also is eligible to seek some share of the $50,000 set -aside funds in that Electoral District. Further, each of the 10 rescue squads in the county received a $13,500 appropriation ' (also up from 10,000 in 87-88), and they also are eligible to seek some snare of the set -aside funds. ' Fire and rescue services, service areas, and operations are coordinated by the County Fire Marshal. who is also the Emergency Management Coordinator. The result is a ' coordinated, unified network, all of which is related to and part of the communication/telephone system at the County Government Center. It should be noted that as of April, 1992 a new 911 system came on line, with all major emergency service communications housed in a single new building. The County continues to work with these various departments and squads towards ' possible future adjustments, all with the idea of providing improved service. in 1987, service area distances officially acknowledged at the State level for fire departments ranged from 1.5 miles to 3.0 miles. With the County water system in place, however. some of these service areas have been extended to serve a five mile radius, and ' consolidation/merger of some of these departments is a long-range goal. It should also be noted that some developing areas, such as St James plantation, for example. ' will require the establishment of a new fire station in the future. 1.4.6 SCHOOLS ' In most land use plans, coverage of "schools" normally focuses on the condition and need for improvements to school facilities. However, during the initial round of public input meetings for this update to the Brunswick County Land Use Plan, concern over the quality of the county's overall educational system was identified very strongly. In fact, the quality of education in the county's schools was among the highest concerns ' identified in three out of five regional meetings held for the plan. In addition, the Leadership Interviews conducted for the plan also gave heavy emphasis to doing something about education. Therefore, this land use plan will go beyond coverage of ' school facilities only, and will seek to address the quality of education in the county from a broader perspective. ' In September 1991, the "Brunswick County Schools Survey Report" was completed by the North Carolina Department of Instruction, Division of School Planning. While the Report gives greatest treatment to the condition and capacity of the County's school ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 70 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis facilities, it also includes findings and statistics regarding the County's overall commitment to education, relative to other counties in the region and state. Excerpts of some of the report's findings and recommendations follow: SUMMARY OF FINDINGS (Excerpts) Community —The 0-18 population in Brunswick County increased from 11,430 in 1980 to 1.2,671 in 1990. —There are three primary indicators by which the wealth of a county can be measured: (1) Per Capita Income —In 1989, Brunswick County's per capita income was $1 1 ,303 or 73.9 percent of the North Carolina average. (2) Per Capita Retail Sales— In 1989-90, Brunswick County's per capita retail.sales was $6,594 or 72 percent of the state average. (3) Per Pupil Property Valuation— In 1989-90, Brunswick County had a Der oupil valuation of $491.763 or 226 percent of the state average. achoot System —The Brunswick County School System operated 11 schools in 1990-91. —According to pupil population projections, the total school -age population will increase by 10.5 percent from 1989-90 to 1994-95. Schooi Finance —During the 13-year period 1973-74 through 1985-86, Brunswick County spent over $12.6 million on capital improvements to schools. This represents an investment of local moneys of 6.31 percent of all the dollars available to the county during that period. This is lower than the four surrounding counties. —The quality of the educational programs in a school system is dependent upon the amount of local funds that the unit received from the county. Local current expense funds are used to employ staff members above the state allocation. There is generally a relationship between the number of locally paid teachers and the strength of art, music, guidance, media and vocational programs. In 1989-90. the Brunswick County School System emploved 31 teachers from local funds representing 5.7 percent of their total staff. The state average percentage of local staff employed from local funds for the same year was 6.1. —In comparing the local efforts to support schools through the local per pupil costs for current expense, it should be noted that the North Carolina average for 1989-90 was $931.43 while Brunswick County's was $870.20. n D 7 1 r—, L Brunswick County Planning Board page 71 Glenn Harbeck Associates BrunswicK Countv Land Use Plan Data Collection and Anaivsis SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS ' After analyzing the data regarding grade organization, pupil population projections, geographic distribution of students. facility evaluations and economic capability of the ' Brunswick County school district, the following long-range plan was developed for consideration by the board of education. ' Bolivia Eiementary —Work to reduce the membership at Bolivia Elementary School to within its capacity of 432 students. ' Lincoln Primary —Convert Lincoln Primary from a K-3 school to a K-5 elementary school and reduce ' the membership to approximately 700. Phase out building 07 which is currently used for special programs; however, the committee recommends that as soon as possible the regular first grade classroom housed in building 07 should be located into the main building and if students have to be housed in building 07 that it be ' used as a resource facility. Additionally, the kindergarten classes at Lincoln should be reiocated into the purpose designed kindergarten classrooms. Southport Elementary —Reduce the student population of Southport Elementary to a 700-student school to fully accommodate the Basic Education Plan once the new elementary school at Supply is completed. Construct a new dining facility and convert existing dining facility/kitchen into instructional space. Remove mobile units. ' Union Primary —Convert this facility to a K-5 school and reduce the membership to approximately ' 700. Phase out and replace building 04 classrooms and building 05 music modular building. Remove mobile units. Provide additional toilet facilities in media/cafeteria building. Combine kindergarten classrooms to provide adequately -sized ' classrooms and/or build additional kindergarten classrooms. Waccamaw Elementary ' —Convert from a K-8 to a K-5 schooi. Adjust the attendance line to assign additional K-5 students to bring the membership up to approximately 450. ' Leland Middle —Convert this school from a 4-8 to a 6-8 facility. Adiust the attendance lines to bring membership in line with recommended size standards. ' Shallotte Middle —Convert Shallotte Middle School from a 4-8 to a 6-8 school and bring membership ' in line with recommended size standards. South Brunswick Middle ' —Construct eight additional teaching stations and remove mobile units. IBrunswick County Planning Board page 72 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis West Brunswick High —Build eight additional teaching stations and remove mobile units. ' New Elementary Schools —Construct an additional K-5 elementary school in North Brunswick County with a ' capacity of 700 students. —incorporate into long-range planning a new K-5 elementary school in the Calabash area to house between 600 to 700 students. New Central Office Complex —Construct a new central facility at the county office complex. ' Facility Improvements and Costs I Subsequent to the preparation of the Brunswick County Schools Survey Report, a ' specific Long Range Plan for Brunswick County Schools was prepared, dated November 22, 1991. The specific improvements along with their estimated costs are as follows: LONG RANGE PLAN BRUNSWICK COUNTY SCHOOLS ' SOUTHPORT PRIMARY SCHOOL: Construct new cafeteria and kitchen wing. Renovate existing kitchen to provide additional instructional spaces and EMH/TMH spaces. Convert existing EMH/TMH areas to resource rooms. Construction budget: $681,000 ' Survey, borings 6,000 Professional fees 56,000 ' TOTAL COST: 743,000 NEW CENTRAL OFFICE: ' Construct new central office on land in the County Complex in Bolivia. Include central offices, AV suite, and public meeting space. Projected ' area: 16,000 sq. ft. _ Projected cost/sq. ft. (w/parking) $70 Construction budget 1,120,000 ' Survey, borings 10,000 Professional fees 80,000 Contingencies (2.5% of budget) 28,000 ' TOTAL COST: 1,238,000 WEST BRUNSWICK HIGH SCHOOL: I Construct 9 additional teaching stations with support areas, new administration area, art, band room, and computer room. Renovate existing offices. Brunswick County Planning Board page 73 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana Use Plan Data Collection and Anaivsis Projected area: 24,206 Proiected cost/so. ft. $68 ' New Construction budget 1,646,008 Renovation of existing offices (lump sum, 50,000 -otai construction budget 1,696,008 Survey, borings 15,000 Professionai fees 110,240 Contingencies (2.5% of budget) 42,400 ' 7 TAL COST: 11863,648 ' - NORTH BRUNSWICK HIGH SCHOOL: Construct 6 additional teaching stations with support areas. new administration area. art. land room. and computer room. Renovate existino offices. Projecteo area: 20.696 Proiected cosusq. ft. $68 I N w construction oudget renovation of existina offices (lumo sum; -407.328 50,OOC Total construction budget ; .a57,328 Survey, borings 15,000 ' Professional fees 96.183 Contingencies (2.5% of budget'• 36,433 TOTAL COST: 11,604,944 NEW ELEMENTARY SCHOOL. WES T AREA Construct new elementary school in north area of county for 600 students. Projected area: 75,000 Projected cost/sq. ft. Construction budaet $65 4,875,000 Survey, borings 15,000 ' Professional fees (repeat North school) Contingencies (2.5% of budget) 200,000 121.875 :.: S i . COST: ' Land acquisition costs: 40 acres @a 2,500/acre 100,000 TOTAL COST: 5,311,875 ' NEW ELEMENTARY SCHOOL; NORTH AREA Construct new elementary school in north area of county for 600 students. ' Projected area: 75,000 Projected cost/sq. ft. $65 Construction budget 4,875,000 Survey, borings 15,000 Professional fees 273,000 Contingencies (2.5% of budget) 121375 Land acquisition costs: 40 acres @ 2.500/acre 100,000 Brunswick County Planning Board page 74 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis 40 acres @ 2.500/acre TOTAL COST: 100,000 5,384,875 SOUTH BRUNSWICK MIDDLE SCHOOL: Add 8 new teaching stations, special ed. facilities, and resource rooms. Projected area: 18,000 Projected cost/sq. ft. $68 Construction budget 1,224,000 Survey, borings 15,000 Professional fees 83,232 Contingencies (2.5910 of budget) 30,600 TOTAL COST: 1,352,832 RECAP: Southport Primary Schooi $743,000 New Central Office 1,238,000 West Brunswick High School Addition 1,863,648 North Brunswick High School Addition 1,604,944 New Elementary School: West 5,311,875 New Elementary School: North 5,384,875 South Brunswick Middle School Addition 1,352,832 GRAND TOTAL PROJECTED COST $17,499,174 1.4.7 LIBRARY SYSTEM Until recently, library facilities in the county were administered by a Library Commission made up of volunteers (appointees) from each of the small towns in the county. During the course of preparing this plan, the County established a new department within County government and the County Commissioners appointed a newly structured Board of Trustees specifically to take over several existing libraries. Permanent library buildings exist at Southport and Shallotte. There is also a trailer type facility in Leland. Durina 1993, it is expected that new libraries will be constructed on Oak Island and in Leland. While there is no master plan on the books, a potential future library site has been discussed for location in Calabash. H I Brunswick CountyPlanning Board I g page 75 Glenn Harbedc Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan, Data Collection and Analvsis 1.4.8 PARKS, RECREATION. AND WATERFRONT ACCESS ' On the basis of a plan prepared by the County Planning Department as an addendum to the 1976 CAMA Land Use Plan, the County has implemented a program of ' providing recreational parks and services at various sites throughout the county. During the decade of the 1980s. the County built a series of area parks— one in the general Leland area, one in the Southport -Oak Island area, one in the Mill Creek- , Winnabow-Town Creek area, one at Shallotte, one at Supply, and one in the Ash- Waccamaw area. Community ceners have been built in two of these parks, and three other centers have been built as separate operations in the Cedar Grove -Holden ' - Beach area, the Northwest Community -Sandy Creek area, and in the Town of Leland. Each of these County park facilities is shown on the Community Facilities Map, found on page 77a. Major amenities at each of the above -mentioned county parks are as follows: BRUNSWICK COUNTY AREA PARKS" CURRENT AMENITIES Supply I Shallotte Ash- Southport Mill Creek -I Leland I Waccamaw Oak Island Winnabow. area ' To wn Cr. ) (Lockwood (Shallotte (Waccamaw (Smithville (Town Cr. Northwest Folly Township) Township) Township) Township) Township) Township) Concession 1 1 1 1 1 1 Stand wiRest rooms Little League 2 1 Fields Tennis Courts 2 2 2 2 2 ' 4 Picnic Shelters 2 3 1 2 1 4 Softball Field 1 1 2 2 4 Basketball 1 1 1 2 Court Multi -purpose 1 1 1 1 Field Community 1 1 1 Building Playground 1 1 1 1 1 Area ' In addition, the County Parks and Recreation Department maintains and operates a number of other smaller park and recreation facilities, and has maintenance service agreements for certain facilities within the County school system. IBrunswick County Planning Board page 76 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana Use Plan Data Collec.:on and Analysis A new major park in the Shallotte_area, specifically oriented for the senior citizen population of the area, was requested but not included in the County budget for the 1992-93 fiscal year. 1.4.9 SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT Brunswick County recently implemented a move to a privatized solid waste collection system. As of March 1, 1992, Waste Management Industries assumed responsibilities for waste collection and hauling previously handled by the County. It is a 5 year contract. Brunswick County has been moving steadily toward improvements in the way in which trash collection and disposal is handled. The former 53-acre County landfill, for example, recently underwent a major expansion in acreage, effectively extending the life of the facility for several years. As of May 1993, the facility had about 460,000 tons of capacity left, or enough space to handle the County's needs until January of 1998. At that time the County is planning on shifting its solid waste disposal needs to a new, artificially lined facility. A consultant has been hired by the County to locate a new site for the facility. It is centrally located just off U.S. 17 near NC 211, and is shown on the Community Facilities Map found on the next page. An effort has been underway for several years to reduce the number of green boxes scattered around the county. From a total of about 200 such boxes in 1987, there are today only about 75-80 located at an estimated 65 sites in the county. The County has three transfer stations, located in the Ocean Isle/Shallotte, Southport/Oak Island, and Leland/Navassa vicinities, respectively. There has also been a concerted effort to create convenience centers, where recycling can occur. At the time of this writing, there is one active convenience center at the intersection of Mount Pisgah Road and Highway 130. A second convenience center is under construction on Highway 904, and a third is planned for the near future on Highway 211. All three are to be manned facilities to encourage recycling and facilitate proper use. All three are to have compactor boxes for efficient handling of waste materials. n 7 J Brunswick County Planning Board page 77 Glenn Harbeck Associates Community Facilities Map ® Sewage Service Areas Water System Trunk Lines Future ACounty Water Trunk Lines Parks Airstrip Hospital F-1 Sanitary Landfill Municipal (Not in Planning Area) Brunswick County LAND USE PLAN 1993 Update Glenn Harbeck Associates Planning and Public Involvement O"ta' "s NORM 0 1 2 3 4 :3runswicK Countv Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis 1.5 Anticipated Demand ' The purpose of this section is to anticipate how future population projections may impact upon the need for additional developable land and community facilities in ' Brunswick County. These projections have a direct bearing on the amount of land allotted, for example, to the Transition and Developed Classes of the Land Classification Map. This is more fully explained in the paragraphs that follow. 1.5.1 PERMANENT AND SEASONAL POPULATIONS 1.5.1 (a) Permanent Population As noted earlier under Section 1.2.1, the population growth of Brunswick County was ' fairly modest until about 1970. During the decade of the 70's, however. the County's population increased by almost 48 percent. During the 1980's, this growth pattern continued at only a slightly less rapid rate, adding another 43 percent to the County's population. As a result, the permanent population of Brunswick County more than doubled (from 24,223 to 50,985) in just two decades, 1970 to 1990. ' The Office of State Budget and Management is charged with responsibility for making future population projections for all counties in North Carolina. The Coastal Area Management Act land use planning guidelines further require that these projections ' be accepted and employed in preparing land use plans, unless better evidence and information can be provided by the local government. The following compares the State's population projections as prepared in 1987 with those prepared in October of 1991. Population Projections ' PROJECTED POPULATION ' Year Estimate prepared in 1987 Estimate prepared in1991 2000 75,471 66,171 ' 2010 86,755 79,866 2020 N/A 92,623 ' Source: Mr. Bill Tillman, Office of State Budget and Management, and 1987 Brunswick County Land Use Plan. Follow up discussions with the representative of the Office of State Budget and Management revealed that the above projections are based primarily on trend lines from the recent past. Thus, the lower than expected 1990 census count for the County ' had the effect of dampening previous, larger estimates of future population. The representative also indicated that any special demographic studies prepared for the County might very well be more accurate than those of the State. The explanation ' given was that the State's projections must rely upon known, factual information from the past and extrapolations therefrom, as opposed to more locally specific conditions and trends. Finally, the representative also indicated that the more recent projections Brunswick County Planning Board page 78 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Countv Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis may, in his opinion, be larger than what is reasonable to expect, based on the probability that Brunswick County will not be able to sustain the rate of growth (percentage -wise) experienced during the 70's and 80's. At the same time, local officials are of the opinion that the 1990 Census resulted in an undercounting of the permanent population (i.e. they believe that at least 4,000 residents were not counted). The County's experience in reviewing subdivision plats, issuing building permits, water taps, etc. leads local officials to believe that the latest projections may be too conservative. In light of these differing views. and in recognition that the State feels that the current projections may in fact be larger than justified, this plan recommends that the most recent projections be accepted and employed in the 1991 Land Use Plan Update, as a suitable compromise between State and Local government. 1.5.1 (b) Seasonal Population As was the case for the 1987 Land Use Plan Update, peak seasonal population is projected at two overnight visitors for each permanent resident, on the basis of experience to date and volume of tourist housing. By the year 2000, therefore, a peak day total population of about 200,000 is expected and, by 2010, that figure is projected to grow to about 240,000. ESTIMATED PEAK DAY TOTAL POPULATION* Brunswick County Year 2000 198,513 Year 2010 239,598 The above figures include peak day estimates for the incorporated beach communities of Brunswick County. The Brunswick County Planning Department has estimated that peak to permanent population ratios run as high as seven to one in some beach areas of the County. Also, please note that no estimate for year 2020 Peak Day population is provided, given the unpredictability of the permanent resident/seasonal resident split some 30 years hence. 1.5.1(c) Economic Projections /Prospects The economic analysis included as part of Section 1.2 of this Plan documents the following economic trends for Brunswick County. 1. A continued decline in agriculturally -based employment. 2. A continued decline in seafood and fisheries -based employment. 3. A relative decline in manufacturing employment as a percentage of total employment, compared to service and trade employment. 4. A continued increase in the volume of travel and tourism related expenditures as a percentage of the total local economy. 5. A continued increase in the so-called "mailbox" economy of the county's rapidly growing retirement population; i.e., transfer payments. 1 h LJ 0 Brunswick County Planning Board page 79 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Countv Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis 1 In addition, the Leadership Interviews conducted as part of the early public input for this Land Use Plan offered several important insights into the future of Brunswick County's economy. These insights describe several variables within the control of Brunswick County residents that can have a marked impact on the future course of the local economy. These variables include: 1. Education: The greater the commitment to improved elementary/high school education, the greater the chances of attracting new business and industry to the County for the benefit of local residents. 2. Infrastructure: While not a panacea, the County's continuing commitment to provide -- potable water for urban and urbanizing areas and, perhaps equally important, a multi -jurisdictional commitment to centralized sewage treatment systems, can have a positive influence on new economic development. (The four-laning of US Highway 17, while not under the control of the County, will also have a strong influence on growth through improved access.) 3. Image: The ability of the County to institute new or improved development controls (zoning, subdivision regulations, sign control, landscaping, buffering and tree preservation, etc.), especially long the County's major roadways, will influence the quality of development (and hence people —particularly tourists and wealthy retirees) coming to the area. 4. High Caliber Tourism: The County needs to encourage high caliber tourism over tourism which involves lower per capita tourism expenditures. By this strategy, the tourism industry can provide higher paying visitor industry jobs, rather than minimum wage, lower paying service jobs. Summary Finding As stated in the Summary of Leadership Interviews, Section on Economic Development: "The future of real economic development, outside the tourism industry, remains unclear. So long as the County's infrastructure and services are limited, and the educational system remains poor, it may be an uphill battle getting attractive, clean industry to locate in the county". 1.5.2 FUTURE LAND USE NEEDS ' The State's coastal land use planning guidelines require that estimates be prepared showing how the land classification map compares with projected land use needs of the county over the planning period. In the case of Brunswick County, this requirement rests primarily with the needs and projections of the Limited Transition and Urban Transition areas. (The Community Class simply reflects existing enclaves of residents, the Developed Class is confined to the incorporated municipalities, the Conservation ' Class recognizes areas which should receive little or no growth, and the Rural Classes are essentially the residual areas not assigned to any other class.) Brunswick County Planning Board page 80 Glenn Harbeck Associates °runswick Counry Land Use Plan Data Collection and Anaivsis Calculating Land Use Needs This plan uses a combination of population and housing projections, both permanent ' and seasonal, to determine the need for future land in the Urban and Limited Transition Land Classes. The methodology for this determination follows. ' Population Proiections 1980 1990 i 2000 1 % 1980 i °01990 1 %2000 Municipalities ! 8.615 15,644 ! 19.851 " I 24% 1 30% 1 30% Uninc. Area 27,109 35.341 ! 46.320* I 76% ! 70% I 70% Total ! 35.777 150,885 166.171 1 100% 100% 1 100% LI 'Population projection applies to areas within 1990 municipal/unincorporated boundaries —does not account for population shifts due to new incorporations or annexations. ' Source: U.S. Census, Office of State Budget and Management and Glenn Harbeck Associates. The above table assumes that the percentage of new dwelling units within the ' County's 1990 municipal/unincorporated areas will hold constant. This can be justified due to the fact that the apparent municipal population gains during the 1980's were due, in large measure, to new incorporations rather than appreciable in- ' migrations to existing towns. Housina Proiections i 1980 1990 12000 % 1980 1 %1990 %2000 Permanent 112,411 122,268 133,086 58% 60% 60% Seasonal 1 9,154 114,846 122,057 42% 40% 40% Total 121,559 137,114 155.143 100% 100% 100% Source: U.S. Census and Glenn Harbeck Associates Year 2000 Housina Units By Incoroorated Versus Unincoroorated Areas Totals Within Within % % % Munici- Uninc. alities Area Permanent 133,086 1 60% Within i 9,926 30% Municipalities Within Uninc. 23,160 70% Area Seasonal 122,057 1 40% Within 11,029 50% Municipalities Within Uninc. 11,029 50% Area Totals 55,143 120,955 134,1891 100% 100% 1 100% Brunswick County Planning Board page 81 Glenn Harbeck Associates I Brunswick County t_and Use Plan Data Collection and Analvsis P Therefore, there will be a need to accommodate a total of 34,189 existing and new housing units within the unincorporated area by the year 2000. Assuming that: (1) 90% of these units would be located in Transition areas, and (2) that Brunswick County's dispersed development patterns continue at an average net density of 2 units per acre (half acre lots) this would require an estimated 17,100 total acres of developed land within the Urban and Limited Transition areas. Major factors contributing to this low overall density include the previously mentioned dispersed development patterns. the preponderance of golf course communities in the County, and to a large extent, the widespread occurrence of wet soils, Carolina Bays. etc. throughout the County. The Land Classification Map for Brunswick County proposes the following distributions of land into each of the several land classes as follows: Land Class Number of Square Miles Percentage of Total County Land Area Developed/Municipal 93.5 10.9% Urban Transition 68 8.0% Limited Transition 71 8.3% Community 11 ! 1.3% Rural Industrial 35 I 4.1 % Rural 497.5 58.2% Conservation' 79 9.2% Total 855 1 100% 'This figure is actually a small percentage of the total land area allocated to the Conservation Class. This is because this number does not include the extensive areas of the County in public trust and estuarine system waters as well as all 404 wetland areas scattered throughout the County, and incorporated by reference into the Conservation Class. LIMITED TRANSITION ACREAGE CALCULATIONS For the Limited Transition area, an estimated 80% of the total acreage assigned to this class will be either undeveloped, in golf courses, or within the County's extensive wetlands in the year 2000. Of the remaining developed acreage, some 25% will be consumed by streets and utility easements. This results in the following calculations: 71 miles x 640 acres per sq. mile = Less 80% undeveloped Less 25% in streets and utilities Net acreage developed in lots 45,440 acres -36.352 9,088 -2.272 6,816 acres IBrunswick County Planning Board page 82 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Data Collection and Analysis URBAN TRANSITION ACREAGE CALCULATIONS In the case of the Urban Transition area, some 65% of the total acreage assigned to this class will be either undeveloped, in golf courses, or within the County's extensive wetlands in the year 2000. Of the remaining developed acreage, some 25% will be ' consumed by streets and utility easements. This results in the following calculations: 68 miles x 640 acres/sq. mile = 43,520 acres , Less 65% undeveloped-28.288 15,232 Less 25% in streets and utilities -3.808 , Net acreage developed in lots 11,424 acres Total land developed in lots within Limited and Urban Transition areas: 18,240 acres ' Reconciling projected land needs with the land classification map: Thus, the land classification map anticipates a total of 18,240 acres of developed land ' within the two transition land classes of the unincorporated area. This compares with the estimated need for about 17,100 acres of developed land necessary to ' accommodate the projected housing needs within the same area over the same period of time. The approximate 1000 acre difference between the two numbers is deemed inconsequential given the magnitude of the acreages involved and the ' assumptions made. 1.5.3 COMMUNITY FACILITIES DEMANDS I For the sake of uninterrupted analysis and continuity of presentation, a discussion of community facilities demands is included in each of the community facility evaluations conducted in Section 1.4 of this Plan. Brunswick County Planning Board page 83 Glenn Harbeck Associates I i I � i 2. Policies For - Growth and Development . h ?runswick County Land Use Plan Policies For Growth and Development 2. Policies for Growth and Development INTRODUCTION The data collection and analysis described in Section 1 of this plan TO THE was geared to gathering and summarizing information related to the POLICIES growth of Brunswick County. Building upon this information, a series of official local government policies are hereby set forth. As officially adopted policies of the Brunswick County Board of Commissioners, they serve as the basis for future decisions on land use, development and capital improvements. ' Polccy Format u In addition, Section 6 of this Plan, entitled the Action Agenda, includes a number of Implementation Actions designed to carry out the Polices of the Land Use Plan over the next five years. It is important to understand that the narrative (discussion) is not Policy, and does not carry the same degree of importance as the actual policy statements. The narrative Is designed to provide background and rationale for the ensuing policy statement. In most instances, the discussion serves to identify a problem or issue, and may present a summary of findings from other technical studies. There is no intent to establish policy within any discussion section. More detailed discussions of issues related to policies are found in the earlier information sections of the Plan. The policy statements, on the other hand, must be viewed in a wholly different light. As statements of local government principle. the policies should remain substantially unchanged during the five year planning period. Frequent changes to the polices would undermine their effectiveness in achieving intended goals and objectives. Indeed, the policies are designed to maintain a consistent and predictable direction for local government decisions affecting local growth and development during the planning period. In reviewing the Brunswick County Planning Board page 84 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana Use Sian Policies For Growth and Deveiooment pages that follow. the reader is asked to focus greatest attention on he policies, while relying upon the discussion primarily as ' explanations `as to intent. As in the 1987 Plan, Brunswick County feels it would be appropriate ' o begin the policy section by affirming the County's overall guiding policy regarding future growth and development. It is recognized that rapid growth has occurred and will continue to occur in Brunswick ' County due to its coastal location. This growth is predominantly in the form of a growing tourism economy, rapidly rising seasonal and permanent populations and related residential and commercial , development. This growth, if properly guided, is deemed to be beneficial and, in most respects, is encouraged. Policy 2.0 Brunswick County supports..the::currerit growth: trend being experienced. and;: to . the.. extent msib'Ee, will plan for and accommodate future growth:': while simultaneously ' maintaining and:: improvingthe quai!ty::of. life.:*: for: current> and future residents. 1 H Brunswick County Planning Board page 85 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Cour^/ Land Use Plan Policies For Gromn and Development 2.1 RESOURCE ' PROTECTION POLICIES ' 2.1.1 Development activities in Brunswick County are constrained by a Constraints To variety of natural and manmade limiting factors, as discussed in Development Sections 1.3 and 1.4 of this plan. Of the various natural limitations on ' development in the County, the suitability of soil for septic tanks is, by consensus, the single most significant constraint presently facing the area. Citizen comments at all five public input meetings for the land ' use plan, as well as input received during the leadership interview process, confirmed the analytical findings of the soils evaluation. In both instances, the public felt that if the county is going to be able to ' sustain additional growth and development, concerted efforts toward the provision of centralized sewage treatment systems would be necessary. (More on this in sections 2.1.6 and 2.3.2.) ' Another natural constraint to development in Brunswick County. though less pervasive than the septic tank suitability problem, is the occurrence of areas prone to flooding. Flood prone areas have been identified by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), FLOOD INSURANCE RATE MAPS (FIRMs). and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Special Program (SPLASH). The composite natural hazards map found in the back of this plan, identifies flood prone areas in Brunswick County. Considering the total amount of acreage ' in unincorporated Brunswick County, there is a relatively large percentage of land area in the County that is free from the effects of flooding. I Policy 2.1.1(a); u Brunswick County Planning Board page 86 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Policies For Growth and Deveboment Detailed descriptions of all eight AEC's found in Brunswick County are located in Section 1.3.2 of this plan. Each AEC category is briefly summarized below with the applicable policy statement immediately following. The reader is urged to consult with the full definition and state -promulgated use standards of each AEC category before contemplating development in these areas. 2.1.2(a) Coastal These are marshes, subject to regular or occasional flooding by tides, Wetland AEC's including normal wind tides. In Brunswick County, these are predominantly salt water marshes and brackish marshes along the county's rivers and the intracoastal waterway. Pot[cy : 2:7:2(a) Eifarts to protect and preserve the envlronmenta! Value:.'ofi .. coastal wetland AEC`s shatf be supported Siuch protectfon shall be balanced with the ..economic and community values>of piers, docks, and marinas which serve. the,: public, whether they be p�biicly : Qr... plrivatety.. owned. 2.1.2(b) Estuarine waters are found in semi -enclosed water bodies having Estuarine Water free connection with the open sea and within which sea water is AEC's measurably diluted with fresh water drained from the adjacent land. In Brunswick County, estuarine waters are found in the intracoastal waterway and in the southern sections of the Cape Fear, Shallotte, and Lockwood Folly Rivers. i PoIlby:: 2:Z 2(b) Developments and mrtlgation aciuttiss wh>Ich support the function; :. clesntcness, salinity, and circulation >of estuarine . water.: resources.: are .aupported 2.1.2(c) Public Public trust waters are all ocean and inland waters from the mean Trust Waters high water mark to the seaward limit of state jurisdiction. Unless the AEC's body of water is a private lake with no public access, it is safe to assume that the water is in the public trust, unless otherwise specifically documented. One issue of special concern in Brunswick County is the trend toward longer piers extending out into the County's estuarine waters. As prime waterfront sites— those with deep water close to shore —have become developed. remaining waterfront sites must build longer piers to reach water of adeqate depth for boat dockage. While state regulations require that such piers do not block stream channels, the net effect in many instances is to inhibit the movement of watercraft in the estuary. This is particularly evident at high tide when small boats, which would normally have free movement through the estuary, must constrain their navigation to limited pockets of open water, essentially fenced in by these long pier lengths. In the case of small sailing craft, the presence of these long piers may totally prevent the craft from sailing through the affected body of water. The County recognizes that this is a complex issue, requiring a careful balance between the rights of the public and the CI 1� 7 Brunswick County Planning Board page 87 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Policies For Growth and Development rights of the waterfront property owner. Nonetheless, the County recognizes that the weight of the argument must rest ultimately in favor of the rights of the public to the reasonably unobstructed use of public trust waters. Policy 2.1:2(c:) ' 2.1.2(d) Estuarine shorelines are non -ocean shorelines extending from the Estuarine mean high water level along the county's estuarine sounds bays and Shoreline AEC's brackish waters for a distance of 75 feet landward. Where the range ' of salt water influence on fresh water streams ends is also the approximate location where the estuarine shoreline AEC also ends. ' i, Policy 2.1 2..(d),. 11 7 3runswick> County..supports.. the protection and preservatior estuarine shorelines, particularly regarding :those usf standards: contained. in T15A.07H 0209 (e)`" 2.1.2(e) Ocean These are natural hazard areas along the ocean shoreline which are Hazard Area especially vulnerable to the effects of sand, wind, water and erosion. AEC's Nearly all ocean hazard areas in Brunswick County are located within the incorporated beach communities. The only exception is the extreme eastern tip of Oak Island and part of Bird Island. Policy 21.2 3runswEck County upports state and: federal guideUnes tesigned to manage development Jn the ocean ;haze d 4ECs under the County's planmrtg �urlisd><ction the Bap#ist assembly: grounds:: and part. d `B.ird :: sland.. 2.1.2(f) Public This category consists of small surface water supply watersheds and Water Supply public water supply well fields. There are no such designated areas AEC's in Brunswick County. 2.1.2(q) Natural Within the system of Natural And Cultural Resource AEC's there are and Cultural five distinct sub -categories: Resource AEC's 1. Coastal Areas That Sustain Rare Species —areas that support native plants or animals determined to be rare or endangered. 2. Coastal Complex Natural Areas —lands that support native plant and animal communities and provide habitat qualities which have remained essentially unchanged by human activity. Brunswick County Planning Board page 88 Glenn HarbecJk Associates BrunSMCK Countv Land Use Pian Policies For Growth and Develoomert 3. Unique Coastal Geological Formations —sites that contain geological for that are unique or otherwise significant components of coastal systems. or that are especially notable examples of geologic formations or processes in the coastal area. 4. Significant Coastal Archaeological Resources —these are areas that contain archaeological remains (objects, features, and or sites) that have more than local significance to history or pre -history. 5. Significant Coastal Historic Architectural Resources --defined as districts. structures, buildings, sites or objects that have more than local significance to history or architecture. Currently, there are no natural or cultural AEC's located in the unincorporated area of Brunswick County. Nonetheless. there are many such areas county which may be deserving of such designation. (See section 1.3 for details) It should be noted that the protection of wildlife and natural resources was identified as a priority issue at all five public meetings held early in the planning process for the land use plan. Policy 2.1.2(g)l Brunswick County ;supports the select tue...desianat>lan of. appropriate areas as nafurail and cultural resource AO's. (Coastal Complex Natural Areas, Coastal Areas That SustainRemnant Species, uniique GeologEc tr rmatlons=` . Sfgnifi�cant Goastat; Arcitaeologllc.a Resources and Si nificant ..Coastal;: Histor€cal. Archiiecturai.t?esources). . 2.1.3 Other According to a June 1991 article in North Carolina Wildlife ("Stew in Hazardous or Brunswick", by Lawrence S. Earley) Brunswick County is one of the Fragile Land most biologically diverse areas in the State of North Carolina. The Areas article quotes Alan Weakley of the North Carolina Heritage Program as saying 'Brunswick County has, by far, more records of rare plants. Introduction animals and significant natural communities than any other county in the state". More specifically the article continues, Brunswick County has ... "more than 500 'natural heritage elements', or populations of rare plants and animals and high quality natural communities. Only three other counties have more of these elements of natural diversity Brunswick County is the only county with more than 100 rare plant records." In addition Brunswick County is the only county with more than 20 natural areas of national and statewide significance. As compiled by the State's Heritage Program, several of the most notable natural areas include the following: H r 1 H d Orton Pond Millpond and surrounding uplands provide breeding habitat for ' anhinga, osprey, fox squirrels, alligators, red -cockaded woodpeckers Brunswick County Planning Board page 89 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Pian Policies For Growth and Development and a rare snail (Planorbella magnifica). The Natural Heritage ' Program rates this site as having national significance. Boiling Spring The largest group of pocosins. Carolina bays and savannas in private Lakes Wetland ownership. Severai rare plants have been found here, including the ' Complex rough -leaf loosestrife. National significance. ' Military Ocean The 12,000-acre military base contains a large number of limesink Terminal' Sunny ponds, longleaf pine forests and pocosins which provide habit for Point many rare and endangered plant and animals species. National significance. Waccamaw River The habitats associated with the Waccamaw River contain rare plants, Aquatic Habitat including the disjunct Plymouth gentian, and several rare fish and shellfish. National significance. ' Bald Head Island Diversity of high -quality maritime communities, including the largest remaining maritime forest in the county. The island also hosts the state's only locations of cabbage palm (Sabai palmetto). Large numbers of loggerhead sea turtles nest on the island's beaches. ' National significance. ' Green Swamp -Preserve Owned by The Nature Conservancy, the 15,700-acre Green Swamp Preserve consists of an extensive pocosin wetland system associated with probably the best remaining longleaf pine savannas in the state. Provides unique habitat for 14 insectivorous plants and a variety of wildlife, including the black bear, American alligator and red - cockaded woodpecker. National significance. Battery Island The maritime forests on this natural island in the lower Cape Fear River host the state's largest breeding colony of herons, egrets and ' ibises. More than 5,500 nests have been counted. National significance. ' Brunswick/ -Cape Fear River The extensive freshwater tidal marshes in this area support one of the largest populations of alligators of any North Carolina river or estuary. Marshes Statewide significance. ' Sunset Beach, In late summer, these ponds are visited by post -breeding wood storks Wood Stork from Florida and Georgia. The ponds are the northernmost localities Ponds on the Atlantic coast used by wood storks. Statewide significance. Bryant Mill Located along the southern shore of the Cape Fear River, this bluff (Greenbank) contains a variety of wet and dry habitats sheltering several unusual ' Bluff plant species, including large -leaved grass -of -Parnassus. National significance. Brunswick County Planning Board page 90 Glenn Harbec k Associates -^,:nswicK Ccunty Lana Usa Plan Policies For Growth and Deveiooment Zeke's Island Complex of islands, marshes, tidal flats and shallow estuarine water Estuarine on the northern end of Bald Head Island. An important nesting site for Sanctuary loggerhead sea turtles and colonial nesting waterbirds. Statewide significance. The article notes that most of the county's 20 significant sites are either privately owned or have extremely limited access. Most of the areas identified fall into one or more of the following specific fragile land area categories suggested by the Coastal Area Management Act Land Use Flannina Guidelines. 2.1.3 (a) According to generalized soils mapping, Brunswick County contains Freshwater literally thousands of acres of fresh water swamps and marshes, Swamps, including pocosins and 404 wetlands. While many of these areas Marshes, have been specifically identified as described in the introduction Pocosins, and above. there are many thousands more throughout the length and 404 Wetlands breadth of the county. This situation goes hand in hand with the county's problems in identifying suitable lands for septic tank use. This land use plan seeks to direct urban level development to specific geographic areas of the county where adequate services can be provided. Even within the designated growth areas, the county recognizes that there may be extensive areas of fresh water wetlands that cannot be developed without great economic and environmental costs. Therefore the County has adopted a policy of directing development first, to general geographic areas and secondly, to specific "dryer sections" within the borders of these areas. 21:3 : (a) Brunswick Cou'. CAMA program perml;tting proc water -swamp::: r 2.1.3(b) According to a report published by the North Carolina Division of Maritime Forests Coastal Management in November of 1988 (An Assessment Of Maritime Forest Resources On The North Carolina Coast. Michael J. Lopazanski, et al) maritime forests are the woody plant communities that develop as an end result of primary succession on coastal dune systems. The report further notes that maritime forests are generally restricted to the coastal barrier islands. (Lopazanski, p. 1) For Brunswick County, this means that most maritime forests fall within the planning jurisdiction of the incorporated beach communities along the county's ocean shore. In their 1988 report, Lopazanski, et al compiled "a complete inventory of all maritime forest tracts remaining in North Carolina greater than 20 acres in size". According to the report, the only remaining maritime F11 L Brunswick County Planning Board page 91 Glenn Harbec k Associates Brunswick County Lana Use Plan ?olicies For Growth and Development IPolicy 2.1.3 b n C� forest areas in southeastern North Carolina meeting this size requirement are located on Bluff Island, Middle Island, and Bald Head Islana. Middle and Bald Head are within the planning jurisdiction of the Village of Bald Head Island, while Bluff is a publicly owned nature preserve witnin the planning jurisdiction of Brunswick County. Even so, at feast one other source (Earley, 1991) has noted the presence of some maritime forest habitats along the tidal creeks and ridges on the northern bank of the Intracoastal waterway in Brunswick County. Maritime forests in Brunswick County shall receive a hiigh level of environmental: protection when considering.:public and private sector•, uses. When development is considered, preferred usage: shallbe for low intensity or clustered. development forms. 2.1.3.c) There are currently no Outstanding Resource Waters identified within Outstanding the planning iurisdiction of Brunswick County. Lockwood Folly River Resource Waters was at one time up for consideration as an ORW, but was removed (ORW) from the list of potential ORW's due to periodic high bacterial levels. The NC Division of Environmental Management has reported that failing septic tanks and storm water runoff from subdivisions along the river are the most likely causes of high counts of fecal coliform in the river. High fecal coliform counts have required the closing of shell fishing beds over widespread portions of the river. As recently as 1988, for example, it was reported that 71 % of the shell fishing areas in the river had to be closed, the largest percentage of waters of any shell fishing area in the state. In June of 1989 the State published a report on Lockwood folly which documented many of these findings. Since that time, the State has continued to monitor fecal coliform levels in the river on a weekly basis. Funding in support of the monitoring program is expected to run out before the end of 1992. While no specifics were offered, a State official involved in the program indicated that major sources of fecal coliform contamination were being identified. Recommended actions to be taken to correct these problems would be the next logical step. Brunswick County officials have continued to express their support for a specific management plan to restore the river's water quality, including possible future reconsideration as an ORW. j < Policy 21.3: (c) Brunswick. County;upports he efforts<:of the. State to restore the water:4uality of the Lockwood. .Folly;Rlver, as well as other estuarine: waters in the county,. to:: -.a water quality. level deserving of� ORW designation. J Brunswick County Planning Board page 92 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana Use Plan Policies For Growth ana Deveiooment L 2.7.3(d) Water As noted in sections 1.3 and 1.4 of this report, Brunswick County is Supply Areas. moving rapidly away from well water as its orimary source of potable water. The County's relatively new piped water system relies primarily upon surface water from the Cape Fear River upstream of the area of salt water influence. While the County's water system continues to draw from a series of ground water wells west of Southport, plans are in place to phase out this element of the county's water supply. There is some concern that if present trends continue, saltwater intrusion will become a major problem for wells located anywhere generally east of US 17 in the County. In fact, engineering studies prepared as early as the late 1970's, first identified saltwater intrusion as a real threat to the long term potable water supply of County residents. Nonetheless, for many rural area residents, ground water is the only source of potable water for their homes. At the same time, the County is aware of the vulnerable position in which it has placed itself when relying upon a surface water supply source whose quality is dependent upon the duty and care of upstream water users. This issue has become particularly evident with the advent of major hog slaughtering facilities upstream, the possibility of inter basin water transfers, and increasing levels of upstream development. Therefore, the only prudent course of action is to see that both sources of water receive careful attention and protection for their long term use. Policy 2.1`.3(d) The:::county's :ground water ;reso>urces, especially those . ,.:areas*.::. not..subject of saltwater irirusfan, shall be . I,.reco,anizdd,:':�as:::a:::va.uable secondary source cf public and private.::potable ;water snd shalt receiiue a .high :level tf rotection when considerin .4ev61 00irneft0ro' owls 2.1.3(e) Cultural As noted in section 1.3.2, the State Division of Archives and History and Historic has stated that there are no fewer than 172 prehistoric sites and 25 Resources significant historic architectural structures and sites in the unincorporated areas of Brunswick County. The State has also noted that there are in all likelihood other properties and sites of prehistoric. architectural and/or historical significance of which they are unaware. Further, the State office has observed that areas along the county's sound shorelines, stream and river shorelines, and some high ground areas within or around low lying marsh land have a higher than average probability for containing archeological sites. Support for the protection and enhancement of cultural and historic resources has been strong among some segments of Brunswick County society, as evidenced by historic preservation efforts in Shallotte. Southport, Brunswick Town and elsewhere. H Brunswick County Planning Board page 93 Glenn Harbeck Associates - nsv�cK Ccun,v Lana Use Pian=ciimes For Growtn ana Deveioomern u Policv 2.1.3(b)l Brunswick County supports::the : protection of: other»:cultural and . historic. resource . areas::>(beyond-.-Ahose:: designated:: as AEC's) to:. preserve:; their cultural,: educatlonai: and:.aesthetici values and: dualities. 2.1.3(f) As disc::ssed more fully under section 1.3.1(b), Brunswick County Manmade contains several sizable manmade hazards including: Carolina ,Hazards Power _and Light Nuclear Facility, the Sunny Point Ocean military terminal (and its associated railroad corridors), the Archer Danieis Midlana Chemical Facility and the DuPont Chemical facility. In addition. the two general purpose airports within the county are also potentially hazarcous. Eacn of these tacilities is an important economc asset tc the Countv and, therefore, deserve ail due consideration in avoidina the placement of new cievelooment wnicr. would lead to immediate or Iona term land use conflicts. As the areas impactea directly oy these facilities Involve the planning jurisdictions of the Town of Ccean Isle Beach and the Southeastern Sanitary District. continueo inter -local coordination will be necessary. Throuan the County's Planning Department and Emergency Services Department, the mechanisms are already in place to achieve this coordination. ' Policy: Z.13 0 Brunswick County will seekto .minimize: potential nand ::use confCicts and:: hazards development- In ereasnear 9 existing -hazardous:: facilities. ; 2.1.4 Hurricane Section 2.5 of this plan deals exclusively with the subject of storm and Flood hazard mitigation. post disaster recovery and evacuation. The reader Evacuation is referred to that section, which includes several oolicy statements on hurricane and flood evacuation. 2.1.5 Protection 1981 marked the first year of a major commitment by Brunswick of Potable Water County to develop a regional water supply system for the County. Supply Since that time, the County has been moving aggressively away from ground water and toward surface water as its primary source of potable water supply. Engineering studies have predicted that saltwater intrusion will become a growing problem in the county's groundwater, especially in the increasingly populated areas near the county's ocean coastline. The County's system draws its raw water supply (through the Lower Cape Fear Water and Sewer Authority) from a point just above Lock and Dam Number One on the Cape Fear River. This location is above the point of estuarine salt water influence reaching up the river from the mouth of the Cape Fear. In recent years, considerable concern has focused on the impact of upstream developments and uses on the quality of the water in the Brunswick county Planning Board page 94 Glenn Harbedk Associates =.;1nswIcK CcL;;^;v Lana Use Tian Policies For Growtn ana Development I Cape Fear. By the time it reaches the Authority's water intake, the river has received urban and agricultural area runoff, various oollutants, and effluent discharges from an area which encompasses a large area of the interior of the State of North Carolina. At the same time. there is a continuing concern that interbasin transfers could occur upsteam, thereby diminishing the flow volume of the river, and further concentrating pollutants in the stream. In other words. Brunswick and New Hanover Counties are at the end of the pipe, in a manner of speaking, with regard to the quantity and quality of the water in the Cape Fear River. More particularly, the recent development of a large hog slaughtering facility on a site in Bladen County within the Cape Fear basin has served to amplify the issue. Protection of the County's raw water supply therefore ranks as a very hiah priority concern for the future growth and development of Brunswick County, ana the whole lower Cape Fear region. The County is vitally interested in seeing applicable state and federal agencies carefully monitor and control upstream development activities so as not to irreparably damage the very future of the County. Policy 2.1.5(a)l Brunswick County supports all s#ate; and federal eif#orts to ,protect the qualify of wafer. to ftte Cape Fear Rlvar, whether i sUch pro#eciion >invohres ccntr+�ts otrar point source_ .:: idischarges' , surface. ru`Hoff,or...;inter::fsasin:..water .transfers..... Policy. 2. .5(b) Brunswick County wilt. contrnue irnprovernents to and expans1 of the area's central, piped water su t PP Y system r Policy:: 21.5(c) Brunswick County suppprts the reguiattah of oxEc waste and€ other harmful ma�erca[s whfci� could reach surfaco or ground>water. resources, as wet[ as impraveci startn water mane ement:..and:. erasionlsecftmentatlon.::controls.< 2.1.6 Package As discussed previously, extensive areas of soils unsuited for septic Sewage tanks are a major constraint on future growth and development in Treatment Plants Brunswick County. Until such a time as centralized sewage treatment, facilities are put in place, new developments in the county will have to rely upon either septic tanks or package sewage treatment plants for ' their sewage disposal needs. Several trends have emerged which lead the County to be supportive of the use of package sewage treatment plants. These trends include:, ::nswicK ; nN Lana usa Plan=ciicies For Grc:vtn ana Develooment 1. newer development occurrina increasingly on marginally suitable sciis. ' 2. a tignteninc of regulations concerning the siting ang operation of conventional septic tanks. ' 3. an Identifies need for a greater variety of housing types in the county —including multi -family cluster development ana other forms of innovative residential development. ' 4. the scarcity of state and federal funding sources for the construction of municipal sewage treatment facilities. ' Currently, Brunswick County has no plans to build publicly financed and operated sewage treatment plants in the foreseeable future. While several other smaller area initiatives are underway, there is ' little doubt that the private sector will have to play an increasing role in the provision of sewage treatment facilities in the county. For all a- the reasons outlined above, package sewage treatment olants will ' continue io present a viable option for domestic and commercial sewage disposal in unincorporated Brunswick County. ' Policy 2:y:fi Until such; time:: that district sewage:; treatment systems: are feasible and available, Brunswick County shall encourage ! the: use o#: private, smallpackage sewage treatment plants #or ;appropriately scaled.. developments,..: especially...In those ' ; areas .:w�ih:: a>il: [imitations for.. septjc >fank . use. _ ' 2.1.7 Noted North Carolina hydrogeologist Ralph C. Heath. when. soeakinc Stormwater about the coastal area of North Carolina. has stated that the... Runoff "construction ... of multi -story condominiums, motels and other vacation facilities, with their parking lots, tennis courts, and swimming pools. is resulting in the creation of large expanses or impervious areas. Disposing of the runoff from these areas during storms in a manner ' that is not detrimental to the adiacent sounds and ocean is among the most pressing water management problems now confronting the developer and the public officials in this area." (News: Water ' Resources Research Institute of the University of North Carolina. November 1986). ' The construction of large, impervious surfaces associated with major commercial and residential development, accelerates the rate at which rain waters reach the estuarine sound waters. This rapid influx ' of fresh water can change the natural salinity of the sound water and disrupt the biological balance of the natural system. The water can also carry higher than normal levels of nutrients and other ' biodegradable materials that can create excessive oxygen demand for decomposing the material. ' Much of what is described above can be witnessed in the continued rapid development of the unincorporated area of Brunswick County. The widespread closing of the county's estuarine waters for Brunswick County Planning Board page 96 Glenn Harbeck Associates ::runswicK County t_ana Use rat yc!icies For Growth and Develooment I sheilfishing is but one symptom of a much larger problem. While it ' rnav be too late to turn matters completely around, it is commendable - that BrunswicK County currently requires a storm water management plan be submitted as part of any development proposal. The county ' intends to give greater attention to this element of plan review, with the intent of more carefully controlling storm water runoff into the estuary. ' Policy 2:1.7 Brunswick county encouragesaii = land: use activ1tles employ effective storm: water management practides to protect>the: quality; of-:ahe county`s streams;: rivers, :marshes , and estuarine systems. I is..."any , 2.1.8 Marina According to CAMA guidelines, a floating structure structure and Floating not a boat. supported by a means of floatation designed to be used Home without a permanent foundation, which is used or intended for human ' Develoloment habitation or commerce. A structure will be considered a floating structure when it is inhabited or used for commercial purposes for more than 30 days in any one location. A boat may be deemed a ' floating structure when its means of propulsion has been removea or renaered inoperative and it contains at least 200 square feet of livinc space area." ' Policy... ZA, 8(a) Floating home development is not seen by the Brunswick County Planning Board as having any significant benefit to the county. The ' environmental, aesthetic and public trust area problems associated with such development are deemed to far outweigh any potential economic benefits gained. ' Regarding marina development, the County believes that the state's use standards for marinas as specified in T15A:07H.0200 offer ' sufficient standards and safeguards for future development of such fariiities_ Brunswick County discourages tloatmg nome aevc�wp!:!!F � anywhere �r>E the -waterways, public trust waters, and along the. shorelines of:the couniys #n titsxtont regulated ay the . PaEicy ..2 .8(b)'' Srunsw.tck Cohn y enc>aura-9. enu�rvnmentatty ras ons>Ibte manna development n accordance with ell . State LAMA t :...:..<=:.:::::> ii :` :;ii ;i ::>:;.... I::<::i? ?<: ::>::. ... standards»:for:; AECa..:: :: <.;.: 2.1.9 Industrial Impacts on Fragile Areas The topic of industrial impacts oi, fragile areas brings to the forefront two major growth issues in Brunswick County. First, the majority of all, land in the county is environmentally fragile, and is therefore readily susceptible to destruction. Second, the county has a strong industrial ::,:;des For Grcvnn ana oevenoment tax case for a resident poouiaiion of its size and, from an economic ' U�eveiopment oersoeciive. .vouici like to encourage more industrv. Of course, the couniv wouid Dreier that industrial deveiooment not :oca:e in frame areas: nowever :re county recognizes inat the ' :oca::onai needs of many indusmes are dependent ucon proximiiv .o aii. air, and highway transooriation and the availability of utilities. ' `re couniy's iand classification mao, which is an integral Dart of the poiicv section of this plan. nas identified several areas of the county that are suitable for industrial development. The map also reserves a large area in the general "Rural" class which may also be appropriate for certain types of industry. ' At the same time, the map identifies several areas that are clearly not suitable for industrial development. These areas include. for ' examoie. the Green Swamo. certain large Carolina bays. and most c- ,he county's regularly flooded wetlands. ' Bven so, the county will consider all industrial location decisions on a case by case basis. When the economic benefits of a new industry outweigh their potential environmental impacts, the county will worK ' with the industry to see that such impacts are mitigated to the maximum extent possible. ' Policv 2.1.91 Economically beneficial industries will be allowed. to: locate: in: fragile areas if' environmental: impacts can be mitigated. ' 2.1.10 There are many small sound and estuarine system islands in Development of Brunswick County which are privately owned. Among these, the most Sound and well known include Bird Island, wnich falls primarily (95%) within the ' Estuarine extra -territorial planning jurisdiction of the Town of Sunset Beach, and System Islands Sheep Island, near the Town of Long Beach. ' Plans and discussions regarding the fate of the 85 acre Bird Island are continuing as this lard use plan is being prepared. In mid 1.992, the owner submitted plans to the State to build a bridge and ' causeway to the island, plus a pier with space for six boats, and a i 5- lot subdivision. Officials with various state and federal agencies have been reviewing the request, which has generated considerable ' interest among local area residents. Concerning Sheep Island, the Town Board of Long Beach in April of ' 1992, made an official determination that Sheep Island not be part of the Town: rather the island is to be considered part of unincorporated Brunswick County, and therefore under the County's planning ' jurisdiction. Brunswick County Planning Board page 98 Glenn Harbeck Associates nswicsc Ccun v nano Use rian Policies For Growth ana Development I While these islands (and other smaller. unnamed ones similar to them) have extremely fragile environmental conditions. it is the County's position that so Iona as these islands are under private ownership, they should be allowed to develop in accordance with private croperty rights enjoyed by other property owners in the county At the same time. if the owner(s)of these islands should decide to build upon them. the County would strongly encourage the property owner to develop such islands in an environmentally sensitive manner. Policy 2.1.10I 2.1.11 There has been considerable discussion and debate over the past Development decade about the influence of sea level rise on beach and shoreline Near Sea Level erosion along North Carolina's coast. In the case of Brunswick County, all areas subject to this debate fall within the planning jurisdictions of the incorporated beach municipalities along the county's ocean coast. Nonetheless, there are some developments occurring along the northern shore of the intracoastal waterway, within the unincorporated area, that could eventually be effected by sea level rise. For this reason, some discussion is in order. The County's flood plain regulations typically require that development in floodprone areas be elevated above the 100 year flood plain. In addition, the estuarine shoreline AEC standards discourage new development from occurring too close to a threatened shoreline. Generally, the County supports a policy of prudent initial development with full recognition oT the risks and consequences of building in such areas; that failing, structures should be required to retreat when threatened —rather than hardening the shoreline. Policy Z :'t.i:f' Development w�thEn areas suscep#Eble to sea' evei rEs ? shorellrie erosion, andfor wetlantf loss, should talcs In#o co lderatrorr such conditions upon al development In> the event such develcptnerit �s later threatened by shoreline logs, the count wait not"Perm it efforis #o harden #he...shore tiine : ci:", rcrteict.::ianwisi :.d'l vela` menu.>:......, . 1 1 7 E.unsWICK Courts UMO Usa rig. ciyes For Growtn ana Demooment ' 2.1.12 Upland As the immediate coastal area of BrunswicK County. indeed the State Excavation for of Nortn Carolina. has become more intensiveiv developed for Marina Basins shoreline uses. natural sites for oeep water marinas have become increasingiy scarce. State reoulations which justifiably discourage or prohibit the destruction of wetland habitats, primary nursery areas and other important. environmentally sensitive estuarine areas. have made opportunities for new marina developments difficult. Nonetneless. as the coastal pooulation of Brunswick County grows. demand for manna facilities grows commensurately. ' State CAMA standards (15-NCAC 7H.0208(6)(5) set forth the following four alternatives. in orcer of priority, for the development of ' new marinas: upland site, no wetland/habitat alteration, good water circulation. ' 2. upland site. dredging only for access. minimal damage to fisheries or wetlands. deep water site. not in primary nursery area. not requiring excavation or wetland alternation. 4. open water site, excavation of unproductive areas no ' deeoer than depth of connecting channels. Thus, the State has declared upland sites to be the preferred alternative for new marina development. As a result, excavation for ' marina basins in upland sites becomes an attractive option from a permitting perspective, especially where no wetlands/habitat alteration is involved and where good water circulation can be ' achieved. ' Policy :2.t.12 ; Brunswick County supports the: development of marina. i basins In:.:...upland: cites in<:accairdance :wilth .::CA standards: set. forth in:: 15=NCAC 7H 0208(6)(5) ' 2.1.13 Marsh Generally,Y PP Brunswick Count supports the standards for bulkheads Damage from and rip rap as identified in T15A:07H.1100 regarding the general Bulkhead permit for the construction of such structures in estuarine and public Installation trust waters. To meet the requirements of the general permit, proposed bulkheads and/or rip rap can be placed only along ' shorelines either (1) void of wetland vegetation —including marsh grass and wooded swamp, or (2) where all construction is to be accomplished landward of such vegetation. (.1105 specific ' conditions) While Brunswick County supports these standards. it also recognizes ' (as does the State) that in some instances it may be necessary to use bulkheading or rip rap materials to stabilize a channel leading from an upland marina to a deep water channel. In such instances, the Brunswick County Planning Board page 100 Glenn Harbeck Associates =r:nswicx Cc r.r� �a^o User ==^iicies For Growth ano Deveioomem County supports aopticable state and federal regulations concerning , the minimization of such channels and the mitigation of such impacts on wetlands destroyed by such structures. Policv 2.1.13 Brunswick County supports state and: federal :standards::. which seek to --prevent: or mini mize.:marsh:damage: from bulkhead- or rip. rap...-. insiallatlon. The County ;.recognizes, however-: that some:lim'ited marsh damage may be: necessary to::: provide-: for:< otherwise environmentally sound: development.- n 1 _ , nswicK C:,unty Lana Use Pian=^iicies For Growin ano Oemoomerf 7 2.2. RESOURCE PRODUCTION AND %IANAGEMENT POLICIES 2.2.1 Productive Statistics comoiled fcr Section 1.2.1(b) of this plan (Economy), reveai Agricultural a continuing cecline Tor agriculture in Brunswick County's overall Lands economy. While the amount of acreage and cropland has fluctuatea somewhat from year to year, the overall trend toward declining acreage is quite clear and, compared to some inland counties. Brunswick County's sandy, low nutrient coastal soils have not traditionally generated high agricultural yields. ' Policy 2 2:1 During the leadersnio interviews conducted for this plan. the term "subsistence ievei farming" was used frequently to describe the historic character of farming in Brunswick County. Over the past ten years. the County has experienced the conversion of substantial amounts of agricultural lands into more profitable residential and commercial development. i'he continued agrlculturat use .of the Brunswick County's:. Ire`tttair>E ng farm[ands..'s#tall be encouraged. ' 2.2.2 While there are no official current estimates of commercial forest Commercial acreage available, the Brunswick County Planning Board in 1987 Forest Lands estimated that approximately two thirds of all land in BrunswicK ' County was in commercial forest land. Forest lands for paper production are a very important land use in the county. i Policy 2.22 The most significant environmental impact regarding commercial forestry activities centers on the large drainage ditches oftentimes employed on such lands. The construction of major systems of drainage can radically alter the environmental character and wildlife habitat of these extensive land holdings. Further, such ditches can accelerate the speed at which storm water reaches the estuary, thereby changing the salinity of the estuary. At the same time, drainage can reduce the amount of rain water being recharged to the ground water resource, potentially increasing the speed at which salt water intrusion effects the potable ground water supply. girunswcck :County suppor s cammeir..al tares#ry as a tttajor land use, provided sIgnifrcant adverse impacts an na#ural rasource; sys#ems. ara ::minimized. . 2.2.3 Mineral Mineral production and mining activities in Brunswick County involve Production primarily borrow pits for the extraction of sand and gravel. There are Areas known deposits of sand and gravel and coquina scattered throughout Brunswick county Planning Board page 102 Glenn Harbeck Associates ::,unswicK CCunty Lana Use P'=_n Policies For Growtn and Development' the county. At the present time, extensive borrow pits are located ' alona Todd Road and in the Shallotte point area. The County's proposed zoning ordinace is expected to contain provisions which would offer a greater measure of local control over such activities. Policy 2.2.3 Mineral: production: and: nfinmg activities. wdi be::.:considered on a:::case by case review: ot: economic:: benefits :.:and environmental and land . use.: impacts.... 2.2.4 Commercial and recreational fishing are an integral part of the Commercial and economic, social and cultural heritage of Brunswick County. As Recreational discussed in section 1.2.1(b) Economy, levels of commercial fishing Fisheries activity have remained steady or declined slightly over the past 25 years. At the same time, interest in recreational fishing has increased enormously. Commercial fish landings, however, are not the sole indicators of tie impact of the fisheries resource on the overall economy of BrunswicK County. Much of the county's tourism -driven economy is oerived from both the real and perceived image of an area with close ties to sea. During the early public meetings held for the land use plan, this concern was most apparent in the amount of support given to the protection of wildlife habitats and the proper management of the county's natural resources, including the fisheries resource. State law prohibits local governments from regulating the marine fisheries resource, which is considered to be held in the public trust. The Marine Fisheries Commission and Division of Marine Fisheries, however, welcome the input of local governments and residents in decisions regarding marine fisheries regulations. Also, the County does have the ability to control land side development to minimize adverse impacts on water quality in the estuary, and particularly primary nursery areas and shell fish areas. In addition to naturally occurring fisheries resources, aquaculture, (which may be defined as the controlled growth of fish, shell fish or marine plants for economic benefit) has gained interest in coastal North Carolina in recent years. Such aquaculture facilities can include both landside containments as well as open water marine sites. Principle species with high potential for aquaculture development in the coastal waters of North Carolina include hard clams, soft shell crabs and oysters (Aquaculture Development Plan for North Carolina, Governors Task Force on Aquaculture, December 1988). The relatively poor quality of the county's estuarine resources, however, may preclude open water marine sites. Public concern continues that the county's waters are being over - fished and that the fisheries resource is being rapidly depleted. The I H E fl E..:nswicx Courts Lana Use r-an =ciicies rcr Growtn ana Deveimment County would therefore like to see better fisheries management ana enforcement occur in its waters. 'Brunswick County supports efforts: to.. maintain: and: I entrance the fisheries resource:: of its:?.waters*,.. includin ' 9 � better fisheries. management..and.-:-. enforcemen#; and j i aquaculture development activities... I ' 2.2.5 Off Road Concern for the environmental impacts of off -road vehicles in coastal Vehicles North Carolina is primarily oriented toward beach and near beach ' dune areas. Such beach areas in Brunswick County occur within the incorporated beach communities along the county's ocean shore. Nonetheless. off -road vehicles have been known to traverse the ' countv's wetlands and other fraoile areas at locations further inlana. In such areas, off -road vehicle traffic can easily destroy fragile wetland vegetation as well as other naturai habitats upon which the ' county's wildlife depends. Policy 2.2.5 I Brunswick County discourages. the -use::: of off -road... vehicles ' i in all fragiie : areas: because of potential adverse environmental: impacts. ' 2.2.6 All of the county's major development impact issues. such as Development industrial development, expanding residential development. and Impacts storm water runoff, etc. are covered under specific policv headinas ' various parts of this plan. The table of contents provides a means a; quickly identifying the location of policies concerning particular development types. ' 2.2.7 Peat or While peat and phosphate mining have been an issue in other Phosphate coastal counties of North Carolina, opportunities for peat or ' Mining Impacts phosphate excavation in Brunswick County are speculative at best and would have to be considered at the time any such proposal should arise. For this reason, the reader is referred to the general mining policy set forth previously under section 2.2.3. Brunswick County Planning Board page 104 Glenn Harbe& Associates �E,unswick Lana Use Plan SECTION 2.3 ECONOMIC AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT POLICIES �'-clides For Growtn ana Develooment Introduction This poiicy section is concerned with those issues associated with the, deveiopment and redevelopment of Brunswick County. Among the several issues discussed are the types and locations of desired development, the willingness of the County to provide public services for development, the desired pattern of development, local support for state and federal programs influencing development, and the provision of access to public open space and land and water recreational areas. , 2.3.1 Types and The leadership interviews conducted early in the planning process. Locations of combined with discussions at the Planning Board level, provided ' Industries usefui insiahts into the challenges concerning economic development Desired in Brunswick County. Much of the area's present attitudes about growth stem from the economic history of the county over the past 100' years. Prior to the 1 960's, most Brunswick County residents lived under a basic, subsistence -level, resource -based economy (i.e. farming and fishing). And, despite the tremendous industrial growth ' experienced during the 60's and 70's, the county continues to have an unemployment rate consistently higher than surrounding areas. ' Thus, many residents continue to place a high priority on economic growth and better paying jobs. At the same time. the educational system remains behind state norms.' causing local area workers to have a difficult time competing for job openings. As a result, there is concern among county residents that new industries brought to the county will simply bring employees from outside the area to fill the new positions created. There is a strong feeling among local residents that new industries brought in should ' use local talent (or re-trained local talent) rather than hiring people from outside the county. Otherwise, the new industry does not represent economic development, but rather, just economic growth for' growth's sake. Regarding the issue of "clean" vs. "dirty" industry, Planning Board , members felt that such industries were difficult to characterize in today's rapidly changing national and global economy. The point was also made that Brunswick County presently generates a large amount of waste from its existing industrial base, and it therefore has a responsibility to address the difficult issues of disposal of hazardous waste materials. ' Finally, the issue of tourism as an industry is discussed later under section 2.3.8. ' ,s•'. -K Ca-- - - - ss -cr uave+oc7-= ' Policy 2.3.11 Brunswick County encourages. the development of industry throughout the county, provided -such such development is compatible with surrounding land uses and that potential ' environmental impacts can be- effectiveiv mitigated. 2.3.2 Provision Brunswick County sumpons CAMA's renewed emphasis on the of Services to-eiationsnip between future grovitn and the provision of services to Development s.;poc - -hat gre�:: n. This re!ationsnip is reflectea most scecifically the Jana classification map which accompanies this plan. The lana ' c,asslfication map clearly icentifies those parts of Brunswick County that the County believes can be adequately serviced within the next ten years. Services provided to these areas wiil include. first and ' foremost. the county's piped water system. Since 1981. Brunswick County has been aggressively pursuing the development of a centrai piped viater supp y system to ail developing pars of the county. l� iJue to the large eeograpnic size of Brunswick County and its reiativeiv scatterea. sparse aeveiopment pattern. a large centralizec. interccnnecting sewage collection and treatment system would not ce feasible for many years to come. For this reason. it is more likely that several smaller systems could be developed to serve, in particular, the barrier island beach communities and the near shore mainland areas just across the intracoastal waterway. The county remains flexible as to whether these sewer service districts might be handled by the municipalities themselves. by sanitary districts or by some combination of the two. In any event, the County would be willing to participate in a local intergovernmental effort to coordinate research and development of the various authorities or municipalities in setting up such sewage service districts. Regarding other services, the County's commitment to law enforcement through the Sheriffs Department. and to emergency services through 'he Emergency Services Department, and through financial and other support for the volunteer fire departments and rescue squads, is quite clear (See Sections 1.4.4 and 1.4.5). Also. the County's substantial dollar investments in water system infrastructure, and the fairly significant investment in parks facilities. is the best evidence of the County's strong commitment to providing the necessary services to support new growth. Solid waste management, including recycling and disposal, another key service of the County, is discussed specifically in Section 2.3.16 of this plan. Policy 2.3.2 ! Brunswick County will strive, to :the.:.best extent possible, to facilitate the:: expansion of: public.; servides:: and-:: facilities- to. meet. the needs of existing . and:: future_ populations.. Brunswick County Planning Board page 106 Glenn Harbeck Associates ,unswick Cccnty Lana Use Plan Policies For Growth ana Development I 2.3.3 Urban Brunswick County's urban growth pattern is strongly influenced by its Growth Pattern relationship to the Atlantic Coast, the Intracoastal Waterway and, to a Desired lesser extent, the Cape Fear River. The growth tendencies for various parts of the county are documented in some detail in section 1.2.2 of this report. Suffice it to say that the strongest urban level growth has been occurring and continues to occur in that part of the county between US 17 ano the intracoastal waterway. This is particularly evident at the end of the county closest to the South Carolina State line, within striking distance of the Grand Strand. The location of distribution lines for the County's piped water system in future years will serve to reinforce this pattern. At the same time, Section 1.3.2 documented the many fragile natural areas of the county and their general distribution in relation to these growth areas. It is therefore in the best economic and environmental interest of the county to reinforce the existing urban growth pattern. In fact, a review of the entire plan will reveal that the various actions of the county are all designed to reinforce this pattern, whether it be the County water system, road improvements, solid waste recycling centers, fire protection, or initiatives to develop sewer treatment districts. The combination of all the factors noted above is clearly reflected in the land classification map. The land classification map, in turn, is to be further reinforced by the proposed county zoning ordinance. It is through the effective use of policies and the land classification map, combined'with growth management tools like the new zoning ordinance and the updated subdivision regulations, and with a commitment to provide services to these areas, that the desired overall urban growth pattern of the county can be achieved. I P'o icy 23�3` 2.3.4 The 1987 update to the land use plan noted that... "beyond scattered Redevelopment, historic home restoration, there is little restoration or redevelopment including activity occurring in the unincorporated areas of Brunswick County" Relocation of (page 86). For the 1992 update, Planning Board members noted that. Threatened as the county is maturing, there are a high number of substandard Structures houses throughout the county in need of rehabilitation. The County believes that the best way to insure that these structures will be either removed or rehabilitated is to provide for good jobs and higher incomes to the permanent residents of the county. With regard to structures which may be threatened by major storm events or shore line or beach erosion, most of these situations occur U L :_-''UnSWICK CcunN Lana use Flan :-oliaes Fcr Growin ana Deveimmeni within the Incorporated beach municipalities of t h e county. The ' County's policies concerning such situations are presented fully in Section 2.5 concerning Storm Hazard Mitigation, Post -Disaster Recovery, ana Evacuation. Policv 2.3.41 Brunswick. County supports: and.:. encourages-.:. the restoration of. =significant : and::: arch %tecturally imp;ortant::;:historin: structures.. Redevelopment of:::tubstandard:::structures ' within the county shall'be supported' through public and.. private::.. sector.::.: in I ti at Ives.:-: f or.-r the:.:economil c:::betterment of : ' area: residents.;.. 2.3.5 LAMA guidelines suggest that local governments address local area Commitment to commitment to state and federal programs including items such as State and erosion control, public access, highway improvements, port facilities. Federal dredging, and military facilities. Brunswick County acknowledges ano ' Programs supports all such applicable state and federal programs which work to improve the quality of life and economic development opportunities for county residents. The County attempts to cooperate and assist in ' the implementation of these programs whenever possible. As identified elsewhere in this plan, many roads and bridges in the county are in need of improvement. At the same time, the protection and enhancement of the county's estuarine water resources and waterborne transportation systems are vital to the long term interests ' of the County from both an economic and tourism standpoint. For these reasons, programs of greatest significance to BrunswicK ' County include those federal and state programs which would support improvements to the county's road system and to the county's water transportation system. Protection and enhancement of water ' quality and the fisheries resource are also considered to be top priorities. The County especially supports the efforts of the US Army Corps of Engineers for the maintenance of the intracoastal waterwav ' and the Cape Fear River channel. as well as proposed demonstration work on the eastern channel of the Lockwood Folly River (More on this under 2.3.6 below). Obviously, the North Carolina Department of ' Transportation's ongoing transportation improvement program is also of considerable significance to the County. Policy< 2 35 Brunswick County Planning Board -- page 108 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana Use P;n-n Policies For Growth and Develooment I 2.3.6 Channel As noted immediately above, Brunswick County's waterways are vital Maintenance to the long term vitality of the county's commercial commerce as well and Beach as recreational economy. Efforts to maintain the county's waterways Renourishment are therefore supported to the maximum extent possible, including activities necessary to provide for the provision of borrow and spoil areas and the provision of easements when necessary to accomplish the work. The maintenance dredging of the Shallotte River and the Lockwood Folly Rivers, in particular, continue to be a priority. One project of particular interest to the County is the proposed "demonstration work" related to the opening of the eastern channel of the Lockwood Folly River. Discussions with a representative of the US Army Corps of Engineers' revealed the following summary and status report: The Water Resources Development Act of 1992 included a demonstration project to dredge a 100 foot wide (bottom width), six foot deep (8 foot overdepth) channel for this location. However, no specific funding was attached to the project. Rather, the project must compete nationally with other projects included in the same bill. At the time of this writing (October 26,1992), the Wilmington office of the ACOE was within one week of submitting a study plan and cost estimate" for the preparation of environmental work and engineering design for the dredging. Preliminary cost figures for the initial dredging , exclusive of the engineering work, have been estimated at one to two million dollars. The ACOE representative could offer no specifics on the probability that even the preliminary engineering work would be funded, or when. A specific implementaion action is included in this plan calling upon the Federal government to pursue this project with all due speed. Telephone consultation with Tom Jarret, Chief, Coastal Engineering Branch, US Army Corps of Engineers, Wilmington, NC Office, October 23,1992. Brunswick County's beaches, while located entirely within the incorporated areas of the beach towns, nonetheless have a spill over economic impact to the balance of the county. Regarding beach renourishment activities, the county recognizes that there can be a reciprocal and supporting relationship between beach renourishment and channel creation and maintenance. The County therefore supports efforts to coordinate the disposal of spoiled materials, if appropriate, on to area beaches in their renourishment. PoiJc 2...3.fi Blrunsw�ck Count su orts fife ciontlnu+d tna>Intenanc>� of y PP t>Gavigatiie channeis t�lnd. Ir;Etefs attcf >: j<he.. r n+pulrf .. p .........: :.. %e count 's .a�eaches fn a: fittie! oordinate:d...fiasis aR.> ........ 1 H E Ii 2.3.7 Energy CAMA guidelines suggest that each local government include specific Facilities policies related to energy facility siting and development. Specific ' subjects under this heading include electric generating plants, inshore and outer continental shelf exploration or energy development, possibilities for onshore refineries, storage, and trans- , ...r.s•.r.cx ,.c...... _.:..., .,sue - �., Fc- Gromn ana Oeveioomen- 0 nioment. aind the ootentiai negative environmental effects from c.tentiai c:owouts. Mills. etc. -here are currently two maior energy proaucing incustries in Brunswick "ounty-Carolina Power Light and Company and the Cocentrix aereratine Plant near Soutnport. :_3-.th of these industries are vaivaole economic assets to the county. Future enerov aciiities locating Brunswick County, whether onsnore or offshore. :viii be recurred to meet or exceeo the standards of design and operation ceino used by existing energy facilities. It will be the buraen of anv sucn energy facilities as well as any other major industries.:o prove that their design and operations will have no significant adverse impacts on the environment or the County's communities ana oeopie. Policy 2.3.71 Any new major energy facilities to be located in Brunswick I County shall, prior to. approval,. make a full disclosure of aill costs and benefits associated with the project, and will 1 further mitigate all potential adverse impacts of the proiect.l ' 2.3.8 Tourism The subject of tourism as an economic development industry was a focal point of discussions during the ieadersnip interviews. as well as ' during Planning Board discussions in the early stages of !ana use plan preparation. 7 he central issue of discussion revolved arouna to e type of tourism that the County wishes to promote. Fundamentally, it ' was agreed that the County neeas to encourage tourism that generates higher expenditures per tourist visitor. The benefit of such a strategy is that more dollars will be in into the local economy for the benefit of year round residents. while minimizing the number' of visitors it takes to generate a similar level of economic impact. Ultimately. "wear and tear" on the county's natural environment will ' be minimized, while the economic benefits of tourist dollars will continue to flow into the county. ' Contrary to conventional wisdom, the tourism industry can offer high paying jobs if the tourism market sought after is of high caliber. This requires restaurants and accommodations otfering nigher value ' services. In turn, the amenities aeveloned (e.g. golf courses, marinas. ocean front resorts, equestrian facilities, etc.; must be of a quality to enhance the tourism potential of the county. Policy 2.3.8 Brunswick County encourages: the development of a high;:: quality; purism trade as a >prlmary.eiement of he cow�ty!S economic future.:. Investments:; in.. services.:fadi[it[e growth-..-:. management -. shall' be, employedn .furtherance of:` this objective. H Brunswick County Planning Boaro page 110 Glenn Harbeck Associates =runswicK Countv Lana Use Plan Policies For Growth and Develooment 2.3.9 Coastal Brunswick County has in place a recent (1990) Shoreline Access and Estuarine plan which is comprehensive in scope. As stated in the Plan's Beach Water introduction,`..." [tJhe primary purpose of the plan is to identify sites. set Access priorities for possible site development, and clarify County policy on shoreline access, taking into consideration a need to balance orov!sion of shoreline access ov both the public sector and private sector'. 11990 Brunswick County Shoreline Access Plan. Brunswick County. NC, page 2.) The following is a summary of the policy section as set forth in the shoreline access plan: F— L Waters covered-- ' In addition to ocean and estuarine waters, access should also be provided to fresh water rivers and lakes. Jurisdictional coverage- 1 he plan addresses all unincorporated areas of the county plus ;he Town of Sunset Beach, which agreed to be included in the Alan's provisions, inaddition to creating their own access plan. Government involvement in providing shoreline access— ' The plan acknowledges that the private development sector oftentimes provides the greatest measure of shoreline access. The plan suggests that the county's "bigger" needs, not met by the private sector, should be addressed by the state and federal government. The County's involvement, at least from a financial standpoint, will be considered on a case by case basis. No Exercise of Eminent Domain— ' Powers of eminent domain shall not be used to acquire any interest in land necessary for shoreline access. User Fees— I The County supports the employment of user fees to recover the cost of providing shoreline access facilities and for their I operation and maintenance. Forms of Shoreline Access— ' The plan listed the following forms of shoreline access for which no need was identified, at least within the County's unincorporated jurisdiction: oceanfront, swimming, pedestrian,' sailing, and bicycle access. Forms of shoreline access for which the County felt the private ' sector should be responsible included: boat berthing and dock/pier access. =_..C:eS Fc. Gr:nvrn Ann 17ava,nmmnnr Shoreline access facilities for which a need was identified and `or wnlcn the County should actively support firancialiv or otherwise. incluaed: fishina reefs, visual access (espec!aliv to rivers), and boat ramps. including specific recreational amenities such as picnic benches and taoles. Snelters. an �a c;aygrcuna equipment. -he plan further stated that while each of the first mentionea tzoecific access facilities were ruled out for Counr✓ support. the County did feel that such amenities might be developed in conjunction with boat ramp sites as an incidental recreational use. No Pubiiciy Owned Shorelines To Be Sold or Leaseo— All current publiciv owned shoreline lanes shou!a be retained ,or some form of public use and enlovment. rather than be!no soil off for private aeveioprnent. Maintenance, Poricino of Shoreline Access Fac:ritles— The pian calls upon various involved state agencies to do ' better icb of maimainina their existing boat ramp facilities in the County. ' Better Utilization of Existing Access Grounds — The plan calls for the expansion of existing boat ramp facilities ' within existing sites where adequate space is available. Shoreline Plan as an Element of the Countv's Comorehensive Plan — The 1990 Brunswick County Shoreline Access Plan is one element of Brunswick County's Comprehensive Plan, of wh!cn the CAMA land use plan is also a Dart. ' Need for Flexibility — The plan emphasizes the need for flexibility with regard to ' specific sites or future access opportunities not vet identified. Relationship to Major Thoroughfare Plan — The plan suggests that access opportunities be sought as all elements of the major thoroughfare plan are executed. ' The plan also includes a total of 43 existing or potential snoreline access sites identified in map form. ' On January 25, 1990, a work session was held with the County Commissioners and County Planning Board to discuss 14 of the sites for possible first phase development access. The previously mentioned policy statements for the access plan were adopted by the Countv on February 5. 1990 with adoption of the entire draft occurring on February 19, i 990. Brunswick County Planning Board page 112 Glenn Harbeck Associates :r,;nswicx C,:unry Lano Use r:e.^. :�ciicies For Growtn ana Deveiooment I Policy t Brunswick County encouragesefforts:: to:::provide reasonable publlc. access::to the::.: county's :;beaches, shares, and :waterfronts, .in ac.cordanca'.with: the ;County's:'.:shoreline access plan which is adopted.':: herein .. by. reference. . 2.3.10 As noted in section 1.2, Brunswick County issued approximately ' Residential 5.000 building permits for residential structures between November Development 1987 and the end of calendar year 1991. Of this total, over 4,000 permits were issued for the placement of manufactured housing ' (mobile homes). At the same time, the County reviewed some 193 subdivision piats involving over 12,000 lots. While these numbers do not include permits issued within the incorporated municipalities of the county, they reveal the magnitude of growth, especially regarding new mobile home placements in the county. The County therefore supports efforts to diversify its housing stock to include more single family and multi family homes in a variety of deveiopment densities and types. The County is especially interestec' in seeing such development directed toward areas where urban services are presently in place or can be in place within the next 10 years. These areas are identified on the land classification map as ' urban transition and limited transition areas.(See Section 3 for more details.) _ Poilc 2.Z.1.01 A; varlety of resi+ withinahose arei: approprtate by 'ti with the arov�sio 2.3.11 Section 1.2.2 summarized the situation regarding commercial ' Commercial development in Brunswick County. As residential development has Development spread throughout the County, so too has commercial development. This is most evident along the more highly traveled roads leading ' from US 17 to the County's ocean beaches. Such stripping of the roadway provides maximum exposure to the traveling public and allows developers to pick scattered sites where real estate prices are , less competitive. Unfortunately, strip commercial development has many public costs: ' (1) The use and efficiency of the highway is diminished by the number of driveway cuts and turnouts Into the highway. This can ' cause an unpredictable flora of traffic, resulting in congestion and increased accidents. In most instances, it eventually results in the loss of the highway for its originally intended purpose, that of moving' traffic through the County. Parallel roads must then be built at additional public expense —at a time when public coffers are straining to meet competing demands. I 7 _ �svrcx :�ciicies For Growin ano i;eveioomert (2) Tnis stria commercial development oattern is also more costly to ' service with regard to the extension of water and sewer lines. police ano „re orotection. and trash co,lection. �) grip commerciaiization ineviiabiv leads to visual blignt due to a zroiiferation of sans. variable Seibacl<S. unplanned narking areas :vith Minimai landscaping, etc. ' Such S rio commercalization was identified as a maior concern by residents at the oublic workshocs. Fortunately, it is also something_ that can be addressed by a zoning ordinance— if adequate and enforceable provisions controlling strip commercialization are orovieed. it remains to be seen now effective the County's uocoming zonin.d ordinance may be in this regard after it emerges from the ' oublic and political review process. ' Policy 2.3.11 1 Brunswick County encourages commercial development in appropriate locations throughout: the County; the County discourages commercial strip_ development. 2.3.12 Closeiv related to controlling commercial strip development along the Beautification county's highways. is the issue of beautification. In large measure, ' Brunswick County's highways. whether US 17 North and South or the several highways leading to the county's beach communities, are what most travelers see when visiting the county. If the county is to be ' successful in recruiting a higher caliber visitor to the area. thereby increasing the economic condition of county residents providing services to the visitor, then the issue of highway beautification must ' take on a high level of importance. Policy 2.3.12 Brunswick County .shall >employ a:.comb>Inatron:>of incentives, and:::controls >:toencourage beau tiffcatiort measures which preserve the natural amenities: of the; cvmmunitys especially:.as-::::seen from-: the county's.. main highways: and roadways:. leading to: the beaches: 2.3.13 Airports Brunswick County has two general purpose airports. (identified on the ' community facilities map) with no commercial carrier service. Ocean Isle Beach Airport is located within the extraterritorial planning jurisdiction of The Town of Ocean Isle Beach. Brunswick County Airport is located within the planning jurisdiction of the Southeastern Sanitary District; the County's previously prepared airspace zoning ' will continue to be enforced by the County. Both facilities have prepared Master Airport Plans which have been accepted by the FAA and the State aeronautics board. Air service expansion is seen as ' necessary to improve both traditional industrial development as weil as tourist and second home visitation. It is essential that land uses adjacent to airport development and expansion areas be compatible ' with this most important service. Brunswick County Planning Board page 114 Glenn Harbeck Associates Ll 2.3.14 Education Of all the policy categories contained in this plan. education is the category least related, in a traditional planning sense, with the preparation of a land use plan. In fact, in most land use pians, education would not even be included as a subject for policy development. In the broadest context of Brunswick County. however. education is at the very heart of the community's future. Few other factors, including transportation, utilities, land suitability, etc. can compare with the influence that education has over the area's prospects for positive economic development. P`oiicy 2.3.'f'4{a)' P�oiiCy 13 14(b)` In today's industrial recruitment world, it comes as no surprise that a strona educational system is critical in attracting new industries to an area. One of the major factors that a company considers when making a relocation or expansion decision is not only the work ethic of the local labor force, but also the level of educational attainment and perceived trainability of area workers. With rapidly changing technologies, it is important that employees be able to adapt to these situations and to progress as technologies change. As first noted in the leadership interviews conducted during the early stages of this plan, Brunswick County's hopes for economic development are being stymied by a labor force which iacks the basic educational skills necessary to survive in the increasingly technical workplace of the 1990's. Despite efforts to improve the local school system over the past decade or more, leaders interviewed were discouraged that Brunswick County ranks near the bottom of the state which, in turn, ranks at the bottom of the nation in terms of education. Generally, the County's school facilities (i.e. buildings) are good, and the County has shown a commitment to maintaining its rapid pace of new facility construction to keep up with Brunswick County's incredible growth rate. Unlike many other counties also ranked poorly in education, Brunswick County does not appear to be lacking the financial resources necessary to support a quality school system. (See Section 1.2.1) The attainment of a quality e�ivatanat s}►stem shag recagc>iued as $ cr�tica faciar in the future econom>r ;:.:.. deveiapment:.of<Btunswtck.:;.aurrty....; Zlunswicrc County Lana Use r;?n=-!icies Fcr Growth and Development ' Policy 2.3: 14(c)] appropriate: educatlonat- and---:: training programs.:- shall.ltae encouraged.. to:: help:: unemployed: and: underemployed [ocai residents take advantage: of business expansion.., to ;stay. abreast of new.: technologies.: 1 2.3.15 Retirees The influence of retirees on the economy and quality of life in ' Brunswick County was a central item of discussion during the !eaeershio :merviews conducted for the land use oian. The explosion of the retiree population in Brunswick County in recent years brings certain bless;ngs to the area. For example, retirees oftentimes bring sizaoie banK accounts, and increase the tax base by the cost of the ' real estate assets they secure. The money they spend is also less sensitive to recessions, in that thev tend to be on fixed incomes -inaffemed cy swings in the national economy. Retirees also brmo rnanv talents with them whicn have the potential `or great ' soclalicuitura! impact if brought to bear. On the other nand, there are some ootential downside factors which ' can also be associated with retirees. First. while manv retirees do bring sizable monetary assets with them. otners may come with relatively limited resources— being able to afford only modest ' housing on a relatively inexpensive lot. As a result. the limited property assets of some retirees may simply require more In County services than they can provide in local tax dollars. Second, relatively wealthy retirees are retiring younger in the belief that they have sufficient nest eggs available to ' carry them through their retirement years; unfortunately, many of these retirees have not been able to anticipate the exorbitant increases in medical costs which can quickly consume their savings. It is known, for example, that as the County's retirement population has grown, so too has the number of retirees applying for aid from the County's Social Service programs. ' Third, it has been mentioned that retirees bring many talents with them; retired executives could offer their talents, for example, to the ' development of small businesses. They could also help out in the public schools, at hospitals, libraries, etc. In light of these needs, more area retirees should come forward to apply their talents in Brunswick County. Finally, while retirees place no strain on the iocal schools. this population group is also not quick to support measures to improve the schools, particularly when it involves taxes. They may feel as if they have already paid for the education of their own grown children, and do not wish to pay for the education of yet another generation. A county that has a very large retirement population may, therefore, find itself in a situation where it is very difficult to get a school bond Brunswick County Planning Board page 116 Glenn Harbeck-Aasociat unswicK Cc::nry Lana Use Pian policies rcr Growtn and Deveiooment referendum passed. Over the next ten years, Brunswick County may ' approach a retirement population which could exact such pressure on ' Brunswick County's already much -maligned school system. Policy. 2.3:151 HiKunswick<Caiunty hatlencourags >retiree: recruitment. . ' .programs -..-which are:::designed to .attract a h[gher. income;» j more highly: educated>::poputation subgroup.::..- j 2.3.16 Waste Waste Management, including all forms —human, animal, solid. Management industrial, construction materials, etc. was identified as one of the ' highest priority issues during the public input meetings held during the early stages of plan preparation. Residents of the County apparently recognize that the manner in which wastes are collected life in ' and disposed will have a long term impact on the quality of Brunswick County. deserve attention. , Several specific waste management issues special First, the issue of sewage treatment, previously addressed under its own section. is foremost in the minds of many residents. So long as ' the County is primarily dependent upon individual septic tanks for its sewage treatment and disposal, many feel that economic development prospects for the County and environmental quality of ' the County's water resources will continue to suffer. Second, animal waste has been identified as a concern, due to the ' emergence of livestock operations of increasingly large scales in many parts of the state. , Third, solid waste continues to be a big issue, given the environmentally fragile nature of most of the county's land area. Opportunities for regional cooperation in solving the solid waste ' management issue may be especially beneficial to Brunswick County. particularly if the County continues to grow at the rapid pace of the last two decades. , Brunswick County industries generate huge amounts of industrial waste, the disposal needs for which are handled largely by the ' industries themselves. As such they are less apt to be a subject of general public knowledge, but the waste is being generated and disposed of nonetheless. ' Finally, the disposal of construction related materials is a problem which is somewhat unique to Brunswick County, given the high levels ' of construction activity occurring in this rapidly growing county. The County's collection stations, for example, have in the past been overwhelmed by the actions of contractors unloading huge amounts ' of construction materials at a single collection point, thereby usurping the ability of local residents to dispose of household trash at that location. ' ^rurswIcK County Land Use Plan policies Fcr Growtn ana Deveiooment Policy 2.3.16(a) Local area: requirements for solid:: waste disposal facilities i shall.: continue to be -anticipated. -..:.through advanced... planning; facilities:- shall be located.: and: designed so as not. to:adversely impact significant::natural or manmade; ;sources.. - Policy 2.3.16(b) , Brunswick: County recognizes-. the :need:::for a. regional-: solution to. the solid waste issueand. will support efforts toward that: end. Policy 2.3.16(c) Research and development of recycling and resource i recovery programs, whether public or private, shall ` be encouraged:: and supported. ' 2.3.17 Growth For the past several years. Brunswick County has been in the process and of revising. improving and. in some instances. creating new land use Development controls. Several development trends in the area are causing the Controls County to reassess the acequacy of its existing regulations to guide and control future development. For example, the rate of placement of mobile homes in the County has exploded in recent years. far ' outdistancing the pace of conventional single family construction in the area. ' Whereas early development in the County was most often concentrated on the best available soils in terms of the septic tank suitability and drainage. newer developments have been moving into ' marginally suitable soils. There is also increasing recognition of the problem of previously platted lots in private ownership. Many of these lots are known now to be unsuitable for development. At the early public meetings regarding the development of the land use plan. the need for improvement in the County's existing land use controls, particular the need for zoning, was evident from the comments received from area residents. Comments included the need to require larger lot sizes, to adopt stricter design criteria, to ' prevent objectionable commercial uses from moving in immediately next door to residences, to better manage mobile home placements, and to haft the hodge podge of commercial strip development which has proliferated along the County's major roadways. AS noted during the leadership interviews, Brunswick County's ' economic future is based in no small measure on the kind of physical environment and image which, ultimately, will determine the quality of industries and the caliber of tourist and retiree drawn to the area. US t 17 and the roads leading to the County's beaches are especially important corridors which will require careful land use planning and zoning controls. :,:; Brunswick County Planning Board s page 118 J,; enn. Harbedk, ales ::r;;nSWICK C;=ry Lana Use Plan Policies For Growin ana DeveloDment' From anotner perspective, peome are unwilling to invest sizable dollars in real estate with little or no assurance that an old mobile home. junkyard. or repair garage, for example, could move in next door. The County Commissioners, through their directive to the County Planning Director to prepare a new zoning ordinance, have expressed their desire to institute some form of zoning in the near future. It will not be an easy task, and there will no doubt be pressure to water down or discard the proposed zoning ordinance altogether. For all of the reasons identifies above, this plan recommends that every effort be made to establish zoning and that a deliberate, extensive public education program be initiated to make the public aware of its advantages. Policy 2.3.17 _J 3runswicx Counry Lana Use Plan policies For Growth ana Develooment 2.4 PUBLIC ' PARTICIPATION POLICIES The public participation plan and program for the Brunswick County iand use plan is discussea fully in section 5 of this document. For the sake of completeness, however, a summary of the importance of ' public participation in the Brunswick County land use plan is included here. Since its inception, North Carolina's Coastal Area Management Act land use planning program has placed a high level of emphasis on public participation in the development of local use plans and ' policies. The intent is to insure that the resulting pian and policies reflect, as closely as possible. the will of the people in the community. Two key elements must be included in any effective public ' participation program: (1) public education. and (2) public invoivement. The most effective format for public participation involves two wav communication between citizens and locai plannlna ' officiais. ` The public participation strategy employed in the development of the ' Brunswick County land use plan involved a variety of activities. Included were a series of town meetings heid in five different locations in the County for the convenience of the attending public. ' Numerous meetings with the County Planning Board, all advertised and open to the public, focused the Board's attention on the plan ana its policies. It should also be noted that the Planning Board was ' pleased at the level of newspaper coverage given to the development of the plan including, particularly, frequent articles appearing in the BrunswicK Beacon, the Mvrtle Beach Sun News. the State Port Pilot ' and the Wilmington Star News. Random feedback receives during the course of the plan's preparation revealed that several of these well written and timely news articles were effective in catching the ' attention of the interested pubiic. CAMA planning guidelines suggest that public participation policies ' be discussed in three categories; (1) public education, (2) citizen input in developing policy and (3) ongoing public participation and planning. The following policies are designed to address these ' suggested headings. 17 <Polic , : 7 41 >... .-. W -Brunswick County Planning Board- __ _ _ � 120 ', } . r .. Glann Harbedk Asaocazea ?runswiCK County Lana Use :�olides For Growin ana DeveloomenT I Policy 2.4.1 (b)l Policy 2.4.1 (c)I Citizen.. input- in the :development of: growth policies shall:;■ be supported: through . attentiom. given to::the issues and;:: priorities which -the: public ideMiffed::during: ,early:::::`input meetings. Following: plan. adoption, Brunswick: County:shall :employ frequents constructive:: and:: open .regular.: meetings -,:of..:the Planning Board and County Co hmissioners as :<the pcimary- vehicle. for engaging-.,- .publicarticipation: in : on going , 'planning issues and. development :projects. L ?runswiCK Counry Lana use Tian olicies rcr Growth ana Oevelooment 2.5 STORM HAZARD ' MITIGATION, POST - DISASTER RECOVERY AND EVACUATION ' PLAN Introduction Brunswick County, like so many other coastal counties, is especially vulnerable to the damaging effects of hurricanes Because of this . vulnerability, the county must devise means by which development can be managed to mitigate the hazards associated with hurricanes. ' To achieve this objective, hazardous areas must be mapped to assess the county's vulnerability to damage. Further. existing mitiaation measures must be reviewed and oerloalcally improved. Description of the Effects of ' Coastal Storms Flooding Flooding is a hazard along the many rivers in unincorporated ' Brunswick County, as well as in the area immediately adjacent to the Intracoastal Waterway. Since much of this area is attractive for residential development, there is considerable private investment in ' these flood Drone areas. FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Maps identify those areas of land with a ' one percent chance of flood inundation in any given year. Flooding in areas closest to the ocean can be the result of high waters associated with storm surge, i.e. water that is pushed upstream by strong winds ' off the ocean. Some flooding on small tributaries. however, can also be attributed to heavy rainfall over a short period of time. ' Storm Surge The potentiai for storm surge flooding in Brunswick County has been and Wave Action studied by the US Army Corps of Engineers. Developed areas in Brunswick subject to the destructive effects of storm surge and wave action are County located within the incorporated beach communities of the county. The Special Program to List the Amplitude of Surge from Hurricanes (SPLASH) model was used to map Storm Surge Inundation Areas so ' that evacuation studies could be made. The SPLASH map shows surge levels based on class one through five hurricanes. By using these maps, local emergency management authorities can plan ' evacuation routes based on anticipated inundation levels. The SPLASH map is available for inspection at the Brunswick County Planning Office. The most populated unincorporated, areas of the county are generally not subject to flooding or storm surge. These areas include: the _ Brunswick County Planning Board : , , page 122 , .. Glenn Harbeck Asaogates I - ❑nSWICK CC::-:V Lana use Pian =�,i�cies r-cr uro.-rr. Z-a Deveioomem Lelano area. the area between Southport and Oak Islana. and much of the area near --,a Intracoastal Waterway from the Lockwood Folly =liver westward -c -he South Carolina state line. _ands immediately abuttina ,ne waterway near the Lockwood Folly River inlet are subject to "veIocity-type V-zone) flooding, however. as identifies on the Hazaracus Areas ',lap. These comprise a very small percentage of the total deveiocea area of the unincorporated county (See Map). Winds Hurricane force grinds and wind blown debris can cause serious damage to buildings and other possessions as well as damage to overhead utilities. Brunswick County is located in a zone identified by the State Building Code as having a reasonable expectation of having 110 mph �.vinds from a hurricane. The State Building Code requires that any new structure built in the county be able to withstand winds of 110 mph. The Building Code sets standards for design, anchorage and tie downs for structures. Composite The Composite r--zards Map includes areas identified or. the FEMA Hazards Map Flood Insurance -=ate Mao as being within the 100 year flood zone and areas identified by the Storm Surge Inundation Areas Map. It serves as a general guide as to where flooding could occur: however. it should not be used for site specific land use interpretation since detailed elevation information is not provided. Existing Development in Brunswick County has historically taken place in a Development at sweeping pattern that runs east of NC 87 in the northeast. and south Risk of US 17 along the ocean shore of the county. For the past ten years, the greatest amount of development has been occurring in those areas adjacent to the beach communities, the Intracoastal Waterway and the rivers. This growth is reflected, in large measure. by summertime populations rather than permanent populations. As stated earlier. ;here is considerable development at risk located within the flood hazard areas of the incorporated beach communities. There are. however, no recurring flooding problems on the mainland. Highway 17 in the Winnabow area has in the past. been subject to flooding during extreme rainfalls. It is hoped that recent improvements to this road will have alleviated the problem. There are other isolated drainage problems that usually are associated with small area drainage basins. None of the potentially hazardous industries located in Brunswick County (Sunny Point Army Terminal, which stores and transfers hazardous materials, Carolina Power and Light nuclear facility, and Arthur, Daniels, Midland Company which produces citric acid) are located in flood hazard areas. These facilities are all located on Highways 87 ano 133 near Southport. I� �runswICK County Land Use Plan =oiiaes For Growtn and Develooment In terms of residential development, it is no coincidence that the same ' environmental conditions and geographic locations that make the County so susceptible to nurricanes, also make the County very attractive for seasonal. second home and permanent populations. ' Lana development in flood prone areas will continue to occur as the tourism retirement economy of Brunswick County continues to expand. The County estimated that in 1985 there were residential ' structures valued at approximately $41.2 million within flood prone areas. By 1987 Planning Department estimates indicated the value of all structures within flood prone areas to be nearly $58 million. By extrapolation, it could be estimated that the total value of such structures in 1992 is over $100 million. 2.5.1 Storm Storm hazard mitigation involves "activities which reduce the Hazard probability that a disaster will occur, and minimize the damage Mitigation caused by a disaster. Such activities can range from the establishment of a nationwide hurricane tracking system to the adoption of local land use regulations which discourage residential construction in flood prone areas. Mitigation activities are not geared ' to a specific disaster, they result from a long-term concern for avoiding the damages of future natural disasters". (McEiyea, et al. Before The Storm: Managing Development to Reduce Hurricane Damages, ' 1982). Current Regarding applicable land use and building regulations, current ' Measures storm hazard mitigation measures are incorporated in various County and State ordinances and guidelines including the following: ' - Brunswick County Flood Damage Prevention Ordinance. - Brunswick County Building Code Ordinance. - Brunswick County Subdivision Ordinance. ' - Brunswick County Flood Insurance Rate Maps. - CAMA Guidelines for Areas of Environmental Concern. - NC Residential Building Code. ' Flood Damage Brunswick County regulates development in flood hazard areas Prevention primarily through the flood plain management regulations which are ' Ordinance outlined in Article 5, Articles A-E in Ordinance No. 62, An Ordinance Enacting a Building Code for Brunswick County, North Carolina. ' CAMA All development occurring in AEC areas must conform to state Guidelines for guidelines, which serve to discourage inappropriate development AEC's forms in these areas. Brunswick The Brunswick County Building Code Ordinance, enacted April, 1985, County Building contains an element entitled "Provisions for Flood Hazard Reduction, ' Code Ordinance (Article 5). This section cites the requirements for new construction or Brunswick county Planning Board pagq.124 :._---Penn Harbeck �lesocates _ 7-. sVi;CK C.:_n7, Lana ;..-a .;,;a^ I'-5cies For Grc,.vtn ana Cevebomem substantial improvements in areas of special flood hazard. A summary of these requirements `glows: General Standards: All structures snail be anc-cred to prevent flotation. Collapse or iaterai movement. Construction materials ana utility equipment must be resistant to flood damage. Construction shall be by methods and practices that minimize flood damage. All new replacement water supply systems shall be designed TO minimize or eliminate infiltration of flood waters into the system. New and replacement sanitary sewage systems shall be designed to minimize or eliminate infiltration of flood waters into the systems and discharges from the systems into flood waters. On -site waste disposal systems (e.g. septic) shall be located and constructed to avoid impairment to them or contamination from them during flooding. Specific Standards: Residential structures shall have the lowest floor, including basement, elevated no lower than (1) foot above flood elevation. Non-residential structures shall be either elevated no lower than (1) foot above the 100 year base flood elevation or be flood proofed. A registered professional engineer or architect must certify compliance with these standards. No mobile home shall be placed in a floodway or coastal high hazard area, except in an existing mobile home park or existing mobile home subdivision. All mobile homes shall be anchored to resist flotation, collapse, or lateral movement by providing over -the -top and frame ties to ground anchors. In new mobile home parks and subdivisions. stands or lots must be elevated on compacted fill or on pilings so that the F L 1-1 Erunsw= County Lana Use Plan Policies For Growth ana Devetooment lowest floor of the mobile home will be at or above the base flood level. The design and installation of anchorings and pilings must be ' certified by a registered professional engineer or architect. No alteration of frontal dunes or use of fill for structural support shall occur in the V zone, except as may be specifically allowed under applicable CAMA regulations. — Open space or breakaway walls (e.g. lattice work) must be used below base flood elevations in V and A zones. Brunswick The Brunswick County Subdivision Ordinance, which was first County adopted in 1980, was until recently little more than a registration Subdivision ordinance for new divisions of land. It contained few specific design ' Ordinance criteria for the approval or disapproval of new subdivisions. Only streets that.were to be dedicated to the State required design and construction standards. In 1991, however, the ordinance was ' substantially revised to include specific development standards, including specific requirements for drainage. Administration of the ordinance has included the incorporation by reference of Section 1-4- ' 69, the Revised Codes of Brunswick County, Standards For Subdivision proposals, including specific provisions to minimize or eliminate flood damage. ' NC Uniform The North Carolina Uniform Residential Building Code is the tool that Residential the County uses to manage development to minimize potential wind ' Building Code damage. The County does not have the authority to modify the Building Code to better meet its needs. Under the laws of the State. each county must enforce these uniform regulations. ' Zoning and Brunswick County does not yet have a zoning ordinance in effect in Growth the unincorporated area. Without a zoning ordinance, the County Management does not possess the primary means available to local governments for controlling the location and design of different land uses and development forms. ' It is apparent that the zoning ordinance is a major remaining need of the County, in relation to storm hazard mitigation, as well as a number ' of other development issues. County -wide zoning could serve as an effective tool to guide growth and development to areas which would be less susceptible to storm hazards. t Brunswick. County Planning Board _ Page 126 Glenn Harbeck Associates =runswicx Ccur^ _ar,a �_; �;,n-_rcies rcr Growtn ana tDeveiocmen Storm Hazard Mitigation Policies Policy 2.5.1(a)l Policy 2.5.1(b) Policy 2.5.1(c) Policy 2.5.1(d) Policy 2.5.1(e) 2.5.2 Post Disaster Reconstruction Brunswick County shall discourage high intensity uses and large structures from being constructed;: within the 100=year floodplain, erosion -prone:;; areas,; and other locations susceptible to hurricane and: flooding- hazards-. Brunswick Countyshall not: participate: in the purchase: of land parcels located:; in: hazard:: areas or: rendered unbuildable by storms or. -:other events, -for -the purposes of shorefront access.. Brunswick County shall:continue; to: enforce the North. Carolina building 'code,. particularly those. provisions: which require construction standards to.-: meet. resistive factors: i.e. design, wind velocity-.*- Brunswick County encourages the: placement of utilities underground for all:" new:: development: Brunswick: County shall em io p y growth management .: techniques to.. facilitate effective emergency> evacuation :. The County shall also:. cooperate on a. regional bass wiith emer enc evacuation lannin g Y p g::: :. Post disaster reconstruction policies are required as part of the land use plan to guide development during the reconstruction period following a disaster so that the community, as it is rebuilt, is less vulnerable to coastal storms than it was before the disaster. section In accordance with CAMA Land Use Planning Guidelines, this discusses post disaster reconstruction policies according to the following five categories: 1- The County Emergency Management Plan, especially the preparation and response sections. ' 2- Local policies which will direct reconstruction over a longer period of time. , 3- The establishment of a "recovery task force" to oversee the reconstruction process and any policy issues which might arise after a storm disaster. , 4- The establishment of a schedule for staging and permitting repairs, including the imposition of moratoria, according to established priorities assigned to the restoration of central services, minor repairs, major repairs and new development.' 3runswicx Cc::nty Lana usa Tian Policies For Growth ana Deveboment 5- The establishment of policies for repair and or replacement ' of public infrastructure including relocation to less hazardous areas. ' Emergency Given the large number of incorporated towns in BrunSWICK County, a Management primary concern immediately following a major storm event is county - Plan wide coordination of post disaster reconstruction activities. This is ' especially important for the beacn communities, given the vulnerability of their position along the oceanfront. To insure that there is coordination between the various municipalities and county Government, the County Emergency Management Coordinator acts as a liaison between the County and other local governments on emergency preparedness matters. As noted in the CAMA guidelines. it should not be the intent of this olan to reiterate Brunswick County's Emergency Management Plan. However, it may be useful to review current procedures for assessing damages immediately following a storm. These procedures provide the framework within which officials must carry out recovery activities. The major federal legislation geared towards disasters is the Disaster Relief Act of 1974. The steps to be taken after a major storm event are as follows: ' 1- Local damage assessment teams survey the effected areas to determine the extent of storm damage within the ' community. 2- Damage information is compiled and the nature and extent of damage is reported to the North Carolina Division of ' Emergency Management. 3- The DEM evaluates the damage information and advises the governor of the seriousness of the situation. 4- The Governor may declare a state of emergency and put the state's Disaster Relief and Assistance Plan into effect, as well as direct state resources as needed. ' 5- If it is determined by the governor that the severity of the situation exceeds the capabilities of state and local government, the Governor may ask the President, via FEMA ' to declare an "emergency" or "major disaster'. 6- Federal relief assistance given to a community after a declaration of an emergency usually ends one month after ' the initial Presidential declaration. Federal assistance for emergency work after a major disaster has been declared typically ends six months after the declaration and federal assistance for permanent work ends after eighteen months. From the County's perspective, one of the most important local ' government responsibilities is the coordination of a local damage assessment team. This team must necessarily be comprised of individuals capable of giving reliable estimates on the original value Brunswick County Planning Board - page 128 Gl _, ,- , -. -. -_ enn Harbedc Associates �unswicx County Lana Use r - c:es Fcr Grcvn n ana Deveioor en of structures. tie value amount of damages sustainee. and an account of reoa:rs. Due to the vast amount of land ana structures foune -n the un:ncorporated area. this calls for the organization of sever -a: assessment teams. The following are recommended team memcers as ceimeatea in the Brunswick County Disaster Relief ana Assistance P!ar. 1- Plan Property Survey Team Building and Grounds arks anc Recreation Department Representative Building Standard and Code Enforcer Architect 2- Bus:ness ana Industry Survey Team "ax Collector Building :nspector Realtor Volunteer Fireman 3- Private Dwei!ings Survey Team -ax Supervisor Volunteer Fireman Realtor Architect 4- Private Dweilings Survey Team Building Contractor Civil Engineer Realtor Architect 11 7 H It is extremely important that the status of damage assessment teams , be upcated on a frequent basis to maintain an accurate file. Damage Damage assessment is a rapid means of determining, to the best Assessment extent aossible. an estimate of the amount of damage caused by Procedures and either a natural or man made disaster. In the event of a major storm. it Requirements is expressed in terms of: 1- The total number of structures damaged ' 2- The extent of damage by type of structure 3- The estimated total dollar loss 4- The estimated total dollar loss covered by insurance. ' During the assessment. damaged structures should be classified in accordance to the following suggested state guidelines: ' Destroyed repairs that would cost more than 50% of the structures value. ' Major repairs that would cost 30% of the structures value. Minor repairs that would cost less than 30% of the structures value. but the structure is presently uninhabitable. ' -^ rsvtcx County Lana Use Plan Pci caes For Growtn ana Deveioomem 1 Habitable minor damage. with repairs less than 15% of the structures value. The damage assessment team will color code tax maps accordina to ' the camage ciassification scheme outlined in the preceding paraorapn. Destroyed red; Maior orange; Minor yellow; ' Habitable green. In the second phase of the damage assessment operation, estimates of the value of sustained damages would be calculated. This phase ' would be completed in the Office of Emergency Management under the supervision of the Emergencv Management Coordinator. ' The information on the value of damages sustained should be derived througn the following recommended mettiodoiogy. ' 1- The number of businesses and residential structures that have been damaged within unincorporated areas of the ' county should be summarized by damage classification category. 2- The value of each damaged structure should be obtained ' from a market set of tax maps and multiplied by the following percentages for appropriate classification category. Destroyed - 100%; major damage - 50%; minor damage - 25% and habitable - 10%. ' 3- The total value of damages for unincorporated areas of the county should then be summarized. ' 4- The estimated value loss covered by hazard insurance should then be determined (a) estimating full coverage for all damage structures where the average value of such ' coverage exceeds the amount of damage to the structure and (b) multiplying the number of structures where damage exceeds the average value of insurance coverage by the ' average value of such coverage. 5- Damage to public roads and utility systems should be estimated by utilizing current construction costs for facilities ' by linear foot (e.g. 10' water line replacement cost = xs/l.f.) The procedures recommended above provide a relatively time ' efficient and uncomplicated means by which to estimate overall property damage. For this method to be used, however. it is necessary that flood insurance information be obtained and that the ' value of each structure be placed on tax maps. .,,Brunswick County Planning Board -- page 130 Glenn Harbeck Associates nSWICx n^✓ us- Oclices rer Growin ano Caveiecma- ' Local Policies to Nilliam D. McElyea. et ai, in heir booklet "Before the Storm: ' Direct Managing Deveiooment to Recluce Hurricane Damages" discuss 'deconstruction manv of the Issues that local covernments must confront in setting coiicies for reconstruction foliowing a major storm event. The authors ^ote that reconstruction strategies pursued by community are too ' often poorly definea. For this reason, it is suggested that eacn community ask itself a series of questions when planning fer long term reconstruction: ' - Should there be changes ;,-, land use? ' When particular sections of a community are severely damaged by a disaster, land use decisions are the most important ones a local government can face. For this reason it is suggested that the local ' government prepare a set of cost disaster land development guidelines before disaster strikes to help the community resolve these issues beforehand. make quick and sound decisions immediately ' after the disaster, and recover smoothly from the damages. 2- Should there be changes i,^ the building code? ' A natural disaster provides the opportunity for testing whether or not the community's building code is adequate to reasonably protect ' residential, commercial, and public structures. As with land use changes, building code decisions need to be made quickly (or if possible, before the disaster) if they are going to have any effect on the community's future safety. 3- Should there be a concerted effort to make the community more ' efficient and more attractive? This issue is closely related to the land use and building code issue ' and arises where extensive damages create the possibility for relocating or redesigning transoortation and utility networks and residential and commercial structures. Because such post disaster ' improvements will take place incrementally and will be molded by compromise, large scale master plans in advance are not recommended. ' 4- Should there be compensation or special financial assistance for I private property losses? In most instances, guidelines and stipulations for reconstruction ' grants and low interest loans are controlled by the federal, state, and other outside agencies providing the funds; the local government is not typically heavily involved in this aspect of reconstruction. ' 3runswick Counry Lana Use Plan Policies For Growth and Develooment F 5- How should increased local public expenditures be financed? The repair and reconstruction of damaged roads. utilities and public buildings after a disaster will substantially increase local government expenditures while property damages and reduced business activity will decrease the flow of local tax revenues. This situation may require a wholesale reconsideration of revenue generating sources. including special assessments, special tax districts, user fees, etc. Also regarding land use controls, most communities already have ' guidelines for reconstruction in their land use regulations and building codes. These guidelines apply to "non -conforming" land uses and to structures which were built before the building code was ' adopted. Communities need to pay more attention to such common tools in adopting measures to reduce future damages. In summary, the author's note that recovery efforts will be enhanced if key issues are resolved before the disaster strikes. Establishment of State guidelines suggest that a recovery task force be appointed to Recovery Task guide restoration and reconstruction activities during the post Force emergency phase. This task force may be active from a period of a few weeks up to one year. The responsibilities of this group will be as ' follows: ' 1. Develop a restoration schedule. 2. Set priorities concerning restoration. 3. Obtain a pre -disaster agreement between the localities and ' the County that covers the role of local officials and County officials during a disaster. 4. Determine the need for outside assistance and request such ' assistance when it is needed. 5. Keep state officials abreast of conditions through the use of Situation and Damage Reports. 6. Maintain accurate records of activities and expenditures through the use of standardized forms that will be available at the Office of Emergency Management. ' 7. Pronounce a local "State of Emergency" if such a determination is warranted. 8. Authorize debris removal and restoration of public utilities. ' (In the case of private utility companies, the Task Force will act as coordinator for restoration activities.) 9. Commence the repair and restoration of public facilities and ' services in order of need. 10. Keep an up-to-date listing of various types of federal and state assistance that may be available to private businesses ' and individual property owners. Brunswick County Planning Board page 132 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana User;an ?olicies For Growth and Deveboment 11. Organize personnel to assist disaster victims understanding the different types of assistanc e Because of the variety of duties that this Task Force must perform, it is , necessary that it be composed of a cross section of the public. The Task Force should include the following persons: Chairman of the Board of County_ Commissioners Brunswick County Manager Emergency Management Coordinator County Tax Appraiser County Finance Director County Building Inspector County Engineer Minor CAMA Permit Officer Finally, State and Federal agencies will need to confer with the State Major CAMA Permit Officer during local recovery planning efforts. Schedule for It is not possible to devise a rigid schedule for local recovery Staging and decisions before a storm occurs due to the unpredictability of those Permitting events. The amount of time that it takes to assess storm damages and Repairs make reconstruction decisions directly correlates with the level of damage caused in the community. It is possible, however, to establish a sequence of activities that the County will need to follow in assessing damages and granting permits for repairs and reconstruction. The sequence of activities that follows should be reviewed by the recovery task force and be adjusted as necessary after damage assessment operations have been completed. The larger the storm, the more likely the time frame will have to be extended. ACTIVITY 1. Complete Initial Damage Assessment 2. Begin repairs to Critical Utilities and Facilities 3. Assess, Classify and Map Damages 4. Summarize Reconstruction Priorities and Develop Master Reconstruction Schedule TIME FRAME Immediately after storm is over As soon as possible after storm is over Complete by second week after the storm Complete one week after second phase damage assessment is completed H P- I Brunswick County Planning Board page 133 Glenn Harbeck Associates I3runswic►c County Lana Use Plan Policies Fcr Grcvan and Deveiooment ' Repairs/Replace Foilowing a major storm event, damages to public infrastructure may ment of Public be extensive. This may require the replacement and or relocation of ' Infrastructure roads. water and sewer facilities. and other utilities. Relocation of these capital facilities may be necessary to place the facilities in a less hazardous location, or to better serve a land area which has ' been re configured by storm erosion or accretion. in any event, the provision. extension and timing of public utilities such as piped water and sewer can be an effective growth management and storm hazard ' mitigation tool by encouraging redevelopment to occur on lands better suited for urban level growth. ' Post -Disaster Reconstruction Policies Policy 2.5.2(a) ;The Board of: County Commissioners>:of Brunswick County shall be ultimately responsible :for supervising the . ' implementation of polices .and procedures contained in, the i disaster relief and.. assistance plan, and -the post. -disaster recovery policies of the land use plan. I- Policy 2.5.2(b) Polic 2.5.2(c) I - Policy: 2.5.2(d) : p , 011icT 2.5.2(e 77 J u In: the:.event of extensive hurricane damage to public utilities requiring replacement or..::.'relocation of these utilities; efforts shall be: made to>iocafe damaged utilities away from hurricane hazard:: areas or to strengthen their construction: Priority, will be::given to those.,repairs:#hat will restore service to asmany persons as:::soon as» possible. The:. Board. of.:County Commissioners :may; declare a: moratorium of up.:to y80. days on the permitting of.. any new construction.:ncluding. crew utility hookups;. or- redevelopment construction that:.,would.. increase the:. intensity of the.:.:, land:.,:. uses existing: before: the hurricane. Brunswick County shall continue to :work :closely. With:- . emergency: management. agency personnel ` in::: the:: .preparation of the County's evacuation Plan. The,..:County shall also: continue:: to.>press<for necessaryimprovements for effective evacuation of:::: threatened areas. IBrunswick County Planning Board page 134 Glenn Harbeck Associates 3. Land Classification OA f t I i ,Jrswrx Ccunty La:-c Use Pa.- _ano Classification E 1 3. Land Classification 3.1 Purpose of A land classification system has been developed to assist in the Land implementation of the policies set forth in Section 2 of this Plan. By Classification delineating lano classes on a map, areas can be identified where and Relationship certain policies (local, state and federai) will apply. The land to Policies classification system is intended to be supported and complemented by zoning, subdivision and other local growth management tools; these local tools should be consistent with the classification system as much as possible. Although general areas are outlined on a land classification map, it must be remembered that land classification is merely a tool to help implement policies and is not, in the strict sense of the term, a regulatory mechanism. The land classification map for Brunswick County is provided at the back of this document. The general geographic application of each land class in the county is also provided as a part of each categorical description below. The designation of land classes allows the County to illustrate its policy statements as to where and at what density growth should occur, and where natural and cultural resources should be conserved by guiding growth. 3.2 Overview of The basic land classification system (as presented in the State Land guidelines for land use planning) includes seven classes: Developed. Classification Urban Transition. Limited Transition, Community, Rural, Rural with System Services, and Conservation. The guidelines allow local governments to subdivide these classes into more specific subclasses if they choose. In keeping with this provision, Brunswick County has elected to create a special sub -class of the Rural classification entitled Rural - Industrial, as explained later in this section. Some classes may not apply to each local government. For example, in the case of unincorporated Brunswick County, no Developed areas are designated. Rather, these areas are more properly reserved to the more densely developed and serviced incorporated municipalities of the County. Similarly, the Community or Rural class, used extensively in the unincorporated area, may not apply in several of the incorporated municipalities. The State guidelines also encourage local governments to make some distinction between Urban Transition areas, which are intended to reflect intensely developing areas with the full range of urban services anticipated, and Limited Transition areas that are less intensely developed, may have private services, and are frequently Brunswick County Planning Board page 135 Glenn Harbeck Associates �mnswcK County Land Use Plan Land Classification located in a rural landscape. Both of these classes have been employed in Brunswick County. ;n creating the land classification map, this plan has given particular attention to how, where and when certain types and intensities of development will be encouraged or discouraged. As stated previously, urban land uses and higher intensity uses requiring the full range of urban services (i.e. Developed areas) have been reserved to the planning areas of the county's incorporated municipalities. Areas developing or anticipated to develop at urban densities, eventually requiring urban services, have been classified as Urban Transition or Limited Transition. Low density development in settlements which will not require sewer services has been classified as Community. Agriculture, forestry, mineral extraction and other similar low intensity uses, including very low density, dispersed residential uses, have been classified Rural. Additionally, certain land areas, which would otherwise qualify under the general Rural classification, have been specifically earmarked as Rural -industrial, in recognition of their general use or suitability for industrial development. Finally, areas generally known to be regularly flooded or containing areas of significant or valuable natural resources, have been designated Conservation. Detailed descriptions of each land class, in accordance with the general guidelines found in T15A: 07B .0200 of the North Carolina Administrative Code, follow. 3.3 Descriptions of Individual Land Classes 3.3.1 (A) Purpose. Developed: The purpose of the Developed class is to provide for continued intensive development and redevelopment of existing cities, towns and their urban environs. (B) Description and Characteristics. Areas meeting the intent of the Developed classification are currently urban in character where minimal undeveloped land remains and have in place, or are scheduled for the timely provision of, the usual municipal or public services. "Urban in character" includes mixed land uses such as residential, commercial, industrial, institutional and other uses at high to moderate densities. Services generally include water, sewer, recreational facilities, streets and roads, police and fire protection. In some instances, an area may not have all the traditional urban services in place, but if it otherwise has a developed character and is scheduled for the timely provision of these services, it still meets the intent of the Developed classification. Areas developed for 7 Brunswick County Planning Board page 136 Glenn Harbeck Associates hnswcK Ccurry_,-ane use Plan ; and Classification rj predominantly residential purposes meet the intent of this classification if they exhibit: i . a densitv of 3 or more dwellina units per acre: or 2. a majority of lots of 15,000 square feet or less, which are provided or scheduled to be provided with the traditional urban services: and/or 3. permanent population densities which are high and seasonal populations which may swell significantly. (C) Application in Brunswick County This land class is reserved to the incorporated municipalities of the County. With three exceptions (Bald Head Island. Sandy Creek, and Varnamtown), all incorporated communities located in Brunswick County have their own land use plans, and therefore, make their own policv decisions reaardina the use of this land class. Of the three incorporatea communities within the Jurisdiction o; the County:s ianci use plan, Bald Head Island and Varnamtown have been designated in the Deveiooea class. (Sandy Creek ;s addressed elsewhere under the Community Classification). 3.3.2 Urban (A) Purpose. Transition: The purpose of the Urban Transition class is to provide for future intensive urban development on lands that are suitable and that wil! be provided with the necessary urban services to support intense urban development. (B) Description and Characteristics. Areas meeting the intent of the Urban Transition classification are presently being developed for urban purposes or will be developed in the next five to ten years to accommodate anticipated population and urban growth. These areas are in, or will be in an urban "transition" state of development, going from lower intensity uses to higher intensity uses and, as such, will eventually require urban services. ' Other specific characteristics of Urban Transition areas Incluae the following: ' 1. Areas classified Urban Transition will provide lands for intensive urban development when lands in the Developed class are not sufficient to accommodate growth. Urban transition lands must be able to support urban development by ' being generally free of physical limitations and currently servea or readily served by urban services. Urban development ' includes mixed land uses such as residential, commercial, institutional, industrial and other uses at or approaching high to moderate densities. Urban services include water, sewer, Brunswick County Planning Board page 137 Glenn Harbeck Associates _:JnSWCKCOUMV t-:--rb Use Plan sand Classification streets and roads, police and fire protection that will be made available at the time development occurs or soon thereafter. Permanent population densities in this class will be high and the seasonal population may swell significantly. Urban Transition land ' 2. in choosing land for the class, such should not include: areas with severe physical limitations which would make the provision of urban services difficult or impossible. lands which meet the definition of Conservation, lands of special value (unless no other alternative exists) such as productive and unique agricultural lands, forest lands. ' potentially valuable mineral deposits, water supply - watersheds, scenic and tourist resources including archaeological sites, habitat for important wildlife species, areas subject to frequent flooding, areas important for environmental or scientific values, lands where urban development might destroy or damage natural systems or processes of more than local concern, or lands where intense development might result in undue risk to life and property from natural or existing manmade hazards. 3. It should be understood that even though AEC standards occasionally permit Urban Transition type development on a lot by lot basis within the various AEC's, this classification should ' generally not be applied to any AEC. 4. Areas that are predominantly residential meet the intent of this class if: a. they are approaching three dwelling units per acre, or ' b. a majority of the lots are 15,000 square feet or less and will be provided with essential urban services to ' support this density of development, or c. are contiguous to existing developed municipal areas. (C) Application in Brunswick County The Urban Transition classification has been applied to those parts of the unincorporated area where either: (1) authorization for centralized sewer service is already in place or (2) where initiatives are underway which have a significant probability of establishing authority for centralized sewer service within the next five years. These areas include, principally, developable areas adjacent to the incorporated areas or extraterritorial jurisdictions of the Towns of Leland, Navassa, Belville, Southport, Long Beach, Holden Beach, Ocean Isle Beach, , Sunset Beach, and Ca;abash. 3.3.3 Limited (A) Purpose. Transition: The purpose of the Limited Transition class is to provide for development in areas that will have some services, but are suitable Brunswick County Planning Board page 138 Glenn Harbec k Associates :. swrcCCUMVL-no use POn snd C'assTicc cn for lower densities than those associated with the Urban Transition ' class, and/or are geographlcaily remote from existing towns ana municipalities. t (B) Description and Characteristics. Areas meeting the intent of this ciass will experience increasea development during the planning period. They will be in a state of ' development necessitating some municipal type services. These areas are of modest densities and often suitable for the provision of closed water systems rather than individual wells. ' - Areas classified Limited Transition will provide controlled development with services, but may not be on lands that are suitable ' for traditional higher intensity urban development normally associatea with sewers or other services. These may be lands with physical limitations or areas near valuable estuarine waters or other fragile ' natural systems. Sewers and other services may be provided because such services are already in the area or readily available nearby, because the iands are unsuitable for septic tanKs or the cumulative impact of septic tanKs may negatively impact significant public resources. ' The Limited Transition class is intended for predominately residential development with densities of three units per acre or less, or the majority of lots 15,000 square feet or greater. In many areas, lower densities may be in order. Clustering or development associated with planned unit developments may be appropriate in the Limited Transition class. Areas which meet the definition of the Conservation class should not be classified Limited Transition. ' (C) Application in Brunswick County The Limited Transition classification has been applied to those parts ' of Brunswick County that exhibit three main characteristics: (1) they are currently serviced by the County:s centralized, piped water distribution system, (2) they are in areas that are either developed or are developing at a density and character not in keeping with the ' character of a rural area and, (3) they are not presently authorized nor anticipated for centralized sewer service in the next ten years. The County has several specific objectives in applying this class within certain parts of the unincorporated area. First, there is a need to recognize the availability of tha County water distribution system, ' and the beneficial impact this system can have in relieving pressure on the County's ground water aquifers. Second, the presence and continued trend toward the development of numerous large, planned ' golf course communities is an economic force in the county that must Be acknowledged. Third, the County recognizes that these same Brunswick County Planning Board page 139 Glenn Harbec k Associates '_:�,%nswickCcLrvt_am Use Plan Land Classifi=,cn n areas will not likely receive centralized sewer service within the 10 year pianning period, and are therefore not candidates for the Urban Transition classification. 3.3.4 Community (A) Purpose. The pumose of the Community class is to provide for clustered, mixed land uses at low densities to help meet the housing, shopping, employment and other needs in rural areas. Due to the small size of most communities, they will appear as small areas in a dispersed pattern on the County's land classification map. This class illustrates small, dispersed groupings of housing and commercial land uses in a rural landscape. (B) Description and Characteristics. Areas meeting the intent of the Community class are usually associated with crossroads in counties. They may be developed at low densities which are suitable for private septic tank use. These areas are clustered residential and/or commercial land uses which provide both low intensity shopping and housing opportunities and provide a local social sense of a "community". Very limited municipal - type services, such as fire protection and community water, may be available, but municipal type sewer systems are not to be provided as a catalyst for future development. In some unusual cases, sewer systems may be possible, but only to correct an existing or projected public health hazard. Areas developed in a low density fashion in small, dispersed clusters in a larger rural landscape with very limited or no water and sewer services meet the intent of this class. (C) Application in Brunswick County The Community classification has been applied to those relatively small, predominately unincorporated communities in Brunswick County that exhibit many or all of the characteristics described above. Included in the classification are several small communities that, while they may or may not be incorporated, are commonly recognized as having some sense of identity and association with a particular part of the county. This class includes but is not limited to the communities of: Northwest, Sandy Creek (incorporated), Maco, Clarendon, Bell Swamp/Winnabow, Mill Creek, Piney Grove, Kingtown, Ash/Waccamaw, Longwood, Grissettown, and Hickman's Crossroads. 3.3.5 Rural: (A) Purpose. The Rural class is to provide for agriculture, forestry, mineral extraction and other allied uses traditionally associated with an agrarian region. Very low density dispersed residential uses on large lots with on -site water and sewer are consistent with the intent of the Rural class. Industries may also locate in the Rural area or, in the case of especially large industries, may wish to seek special I H I n J Brunswick County Planning Board page 140 Glenn Harbec k Associates _,un swcK Ccunw Lam Use Pan Lana Classrfication designation as a Rural -Industrial area. Generally, development in this class should be as compatible with resource production as possible. (B) Description and Characteristics. Areas meeting the intent of this classification are appropriate for or presently used for agriculture. forestry. minerai extraction and other similar uses. plus industries not wishing to locate in an urban setting. Very low density dispersed, single family residential uses are also appropriate within Rural areas where lot sizes are large and where densities do not require the provision of urban type services. Private septic tanks and wells are the primary on -site services available to support residential development, but fire. rescue squad and sheriff's protection may also be a available. Population densities are generally very low. (C) Application in Brunswick County The Rural class is the broadest of the several general land classes and thus constitutes the maior land class on the BrunswicK County Land Classification Map. The vast majority of all interior land areas. away from the ocean and intracoastal waterway, have been designated Rural. 3.3.6 Rural- (A) Purpose. Industrial The CAMA Guidelines allow local governments to subdivide the program's general land classes into sub -classes to better illustrate where certain specific activities might best occur. For Brunswick County, this plan has created a special Rural -Industrial sub -class of the general Rural classification. Its purpose is to accommodate and encourage industrial development on appropriate sites within speciaily designated land areas. (B) Description and Characteristics. Lands designated for the Rural-Industriai sub -class include areas currently developed for large scale industrial type uses, and lands containing sites that are particularly appropriate for future industrial development'. Generally, industries locating within these areas might be considered inappropriate for location in a more densely developed, mixed use urban setting. (C) Application in Brunswick County The Rural -Industrial land classification has been applied. for the most part, to several relatively large land areas with convenient access to the shipping channels of the Cape Fear River. Existing industries located within these areas include, for example, Dupont, the Sunny Point Military Terminal, the Archer Daniels Midland Plant, the CP&L .As is the case with virtually all lands in Brunswick County, there will be areas unsuited for development within the broader geographic areas designated for Rural -Industrial. This requires site specific investigation in relation to concrete development proposals. Brunswick County Planning Board page 141 Glenn Harbeclk Associates 9nmswrK County Lar o Use Plan Land Classification Nuclear Power Plant, and the Cogentrix Cogenerating Plant. Other land areas which have been included are largely adjacent to these existing industrial operations. It should be noted, however, that the County would seek to employ the Rural -Industrial class in the future as may be advantageous to recruit new industry to other appropriate !ocations within the broader Rural land area. 3.3.7 Rural with (A) Purpose. Services. The Rural with Services class is intended to provide for very low density land uses including residential uses where limited water services are provided to avert an existing or projected health problem. Development within this class should be low intensity in keeping with a rural character. Rural water systems, such as those funded by Farmers Home Administration, may be appropriate in these areas due to the need to avert poor water quality problems. -These systems, however, should be designed to serve a limited number of customers and should not serve as a catalyst for future higher intensity development. (B) Description and Characteristics. Areas meeting the intent of this class are appropriate for very low intensity residential uses, where lot sizes are large, and where the provision of services will not disrupt the primarily rural character of the landscape. Private wells and septic tank services may exist, but most development is supported by a closed water system. Other services such as sheriffs protection and rural or volunteer fire protection and emergency rescue etc. may also be available. (C) Application in Brunswick County This class is intended to be applied when and if the County (or other agency) ever provides very limited water services to avert a known or anticipated health problem in a predominantly larger agrarian region. Currently, no such situation is known to exist in Brunswick County; however, the Rural with Services land class is included here so that in the event need arises, prompt action can be taken to address the problem area. 3.3.8 (A) Purpose. Conservation The purpose of the Conservation class is to provide for the effective long-term management and protection of significant, limited, or irreplaceable areas. Management is needed due to the natural, cultural, recreational, scenic or natural productive values of both local and more than local concern. As such, the Conservation class should be applied to areas that should be either not developed at all (preserved), or if developed, done so in an extremely limited and cautious fashion. Urban services, public or private, should not be provided in these areas as a catalyst to stimulate intense development. In most cases, 11 �I iJ Brunswick County Planning Board page 142 Glenn Harbec k Associates unswicx Cc;;nty L.=.-)o Use Flan _end Classification limited on -site services will adequately support any limited development within this class and will also protect the very features which justify the area's inclusion in the Conservation classification. It should be understood that even though AEC standards occasionally ' permit urban tvpe development on a lot by lot basis wimin the various AEC's and that services are occasionally provided. this Is the exception rather than the rule: the primary intent of the Conservation class is to provide protection for the resources it contains. (B) Description and Characteristics. ' Areas meeting the intent of this classification include: 1. AEC's. including but not limited to, public trust waters, estuarine waters, coastal wetlands etc. as identified in 15A NCAC 7H. 2. other similar lands, environmentally significant because of their natural role in the integrity of the coastal region and which include. but are not limited to: bottom land hardwoods, pocosins. swamp forests, areas that are or have a high probability of providing wildlife habitat, forest lands that are essentially undeveloped and lands which otherwise contain ' significant productive, natural, scenic, cultural or recreational resources. ' (C) Application in Brunswick County For Brunswick County, the Conservation class includes: ' 1. all AEC's as defined in 15A NCAC 7H and as further summarized in Section 2.1 of this Plan, ' 2. all wetland areas under the jurisdiction of the US Army Corps of Engineers' 404 wetlands Permit Program and ' 3. any existing and future critical wildlife habitat areas as may be designated by the State Natural Heritage Program. For further information on the specific types of uses allowed within each of the three categories which comprise the Conservation Class, the reader should consult with the applicable policies of Section 2 of ' this plan. (i.e. marina development, location of industries, development of estuarine system islands, etc.) The reader should also refer to 15A NCAC 7H of the North Carolina Administrative Code ' fcr allowable uses within Areas of Environmental Concern). With regard to use standards for critical habitat areas, the County will ' support the specific state management plans for each area, provided that any such plan is prepared with considerable input and in close coordination with area residents and County government. Brunswick County Planning Board page 143 Glenn Harbeck Associates amnswcK County Land Use Plan Land Classification Mapping of AEC's, 404 wetlands, and critical habit areas in the Conservation class on the Land Classification Map is accomplished with the uncerstanding that these areas are more accurately defined by their characteristics in their respective management policies and ' plans. and :,;erefore, the map only indicates approximate locations of these areas. Oftentimes, the scattered, widespread nature of such areas (e.g. 404 wetlands) precludes their mapping except at a very ' generalizea revel of detail. In such instances, the standards of the Conservation class and its three primary components shall be applied in accordance with the site specific information made available during ' the land development process. As with the 1987 update to the County's Land Use Plan, the County specifically reserves the option to assist industry in accommodating their access needs to the shipping channels of the Cape Fear River. Due to the presence of fragile land and water areas along most of the River's shoreline, the unavoidable need for industrial access through Conservation areas along the Cape Fear is acknowledged. The County will encourage desired industries to develop such access ' facilities in a manner which mitigates, to the extent possible, environmental impacts. Brunswick County Planning Board page 144 Glenn Harbeck Associates i 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 f 1 1 Land Classification Map Municipal in Planning (Not Area) Developed ® Urban Transition ■ Limited Transition Community Rural Industrial Rural Conservation Note: Due to map scale, this land classification map Is necessarily generalized in nature, and Is intended for general planning purposes onry. Within some classlhca- tions. for example, tnere may be pockets of Jana which should be considered Con- servation. Conversely, within the Conservation class there may be pockets of high and dry, non -Sensitive land. In these situations, more detailed, site specilic informa- tion will take precedence over the more generalized map. and the appropriate poli- cies of the land use plan document will apply. Brunswick County LAND USE PLAN 1993 Update Glenn Harbeck Associates Planning and Public Involvement SCALE IN MILES 7� NORTH e t p 3 4. Inter Governmental Coordination and-! Municipal i p Land Use Plans "'runswicK County Lana Use P;an ntera^vernr - Ta! Coormration and Municioai_Lana Use Plan!; 1 4. Intergovernmental coordination 1 and Municipal Land Use flans 1 ' 4.1 Inter- The Brunswick County Land Use Plan. including the policies for governmental growth and development and the land classification map. will serve to Coordination coordinate numerous policies, standards, regulations, and other 1 governmental activities at the local. State and Federal levels. Such coordination is achieved in three ways: 1. State and Federal government agencies are required to review - local land use plans when considering any actions or activities under their jurisdiction. Their actions are to be consistent. 1 whenever possible, with the intent of the local land use plan. 2. The policies and land classification system described in the land use plan provide a basis for planning and budgeting for the 1 provision of public facilities and services such as water ana sewer systems, roads and schools. 3. The Countv land use plan can serve as a coordinating instrument 1 in helping to bring together the various regulatory policies and decisions of the local government into one document. ' The preparation of the Brunswick County Land Use Plan and Policies has proceeded in a manner which recognizes the planning activities of other local government jurisdictions, and State and Federal 1 agencies. In preparing the plan. copies of other local government land use plans (in the County ana adjacent to it) were reviewea. Ir addition, certain relevant State plans and studies, such as the NC 1 DOT Transportation Improvement Program were reviewed. State representatives involved in population projections, marine fisheries, water quality monitoring, and historic and archaeological preservation 1 were also consulted. Federal authorities in charge of channel maintenance and flood insurance were contacted and interviewed. Further, within Brunswick County government, representatives of the 1 following local government functions were consulted: county manager's office, economic development. emergency services, engineering, health, parks and recreation, planning, and social 1 services. Need for intra- Within Brunswick County there are sevent,3en incorporated 1 county local municipalities; having more towns than any other county in North government Carolina. These towns are also scattered over a broad geographic planning and area, given that Brunswick County is the eighth largest county of the ' coordination State's one hundred counties. Citizen comments received at more than one public input meeting held for the land use plan reflected on the difficulty in reaching consensus among so many fragmented 1 Brunswick County Planning Board page 145 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana Use Plan '^-eraovernmental Coorcination and Municioai Land Use Plans ' jurisdictions. Even the fact that the County is located in several different telephone calling zones makes convenient communication , from one end of the county to the other challenging. -he difficulty in accomplishing necessary change in such an ' environment came to the forefront during public discussion of the need for county -wide coordination of sewage treatment planning and implementation. There was general consensus that in addition to , concerns about sewage treatment, there is also need for continued improvements in coordinating the "delivery" of emergency services, education, solid waste management, and planning services, to name ' just a few. This plan therefore includes a specific implementation action calling upon the area's legislative delegation to the NC General Assembly to sponsor a special study to determine the most ' effective form of local government for intra-county cooperation. Such a study might involve employing the resources of the Legislative Services Bureau and the Institute of Government. ' 4.2 Municipal Of the seventeen towns in the County, fourteen have prepared or are Land Use Plans preparing their own independent CAMA land use plan. This is in ' accordance with 113A-110 of the Coastal Area Management Act. These municipalities are as follows: , Belville Long Beach Boiling Springs Lakes Navassa Bolivia Ocean Isle Beach ' Calabash Shallotte Caswell Beach Southport Holden Beach Sunset Beach , Leland Yaupon Beach The reader should consult with the appropriate local government land ' use plan on matters involving activities within each of the communities identified above. As noted previously, these municipalities are shown on the County's land classification map in ' the municipal land class, with an accompanying note to review their independent plans for matters involving these areas. The three remaining municipal governments in Brunswick County, not having their own independent land use plans, are listed on the following page, along with certain basic statistics describing their size ' and character: F F Brunswick County Planning Board page 146 Glenn Harbeck Associates ^unswK�x County Land Use Plan Intergovernmentai Cooremation ano Municipal Land Use Plates ' Community 199.0 Total Percent i , Lacking i Civilian i Per Median Name ! Popuiation Housing i Complete I Labor Un- Capita Household I (Year incorporated) Units Plumbing i Force employed: Income Income 'Aoril '90) Bald Head 7e 398 0 35 0.0% $57.148 $108.616 Island i 985) I Sandv Creek _ 2; 1 90 0 136 5.9% 310.339 $33,250 (1988) Varnamtown 434 253 2 184 8.20% $10.22d i $25,714 (i988) Source: 1990 Census _ For CAMA land use planning purposes, the communities of Bald Heao isianc and Varnamtown are shown on the County's land classification map in the developed land class. In the case of Sandy Creek. that community's incorporated area has been shown as community on the land classification map. In all three communities. any Areas of Environmental Concern (AECs) that exist within these ' municipaiities are considered to be in the conservation land class. As is the case throughout the county, the conservation land class acknowieciaes that the use and performance standards developed by the North Carolina Coastal Resources Commission for AECs, as well as all applicable regulations for wetland protection, will be applied to development proposals within each area so designated. As such. these minimum standards for AEC and wetland protection will be used by the appropriate permitting authority in issuing CAMA development permits. ' Also, in the case of Bald Head Island, the Village enacted a zoning ordinance in 1991 which largely reflects the overall Land Use Plan of the developer on the Island. The Village has considered the possibility that a portion of the maritime forest could be sola and/or donated to the State of North Carolina to be preserved in its natural state. It is the policy of the Village to support and encourage this acquisition by the State. ' Accordingly, the Village adopted an overlay district in the 1991 Zoning Ordinance to identify the Bald Head Island Maritime Forest in its entirety and set standards for its development compatible with the environmentally sensitive nature of the Bald Head Island and Middle Island Forests. Each of these communities received a draft of this section of the County land use plan and was asked to comment. Official letters of concurrence were subsequently received from Baia Head island aiid Varnamtown, and are included in the appendix to this plan. While Sandy Creek did not respond in writing, the County Planning Director indicated that the community agreed at the beginning of the planning process to allow the County to exercise planning authority for the !and use plan within it's planning jurisdiction. IBrunswick County Planning Board page 147 Glenn Harbeck Associates 5. Summary of - Public Participation ?runswick County Lana :;se Plan Summary Of Public Particioation 1 1 5. Summary Of Public Participation Introduction Since its inception. North Carolina's Coastal Area Management Act ' Program has placed a high level of emphasis on public participation in the development of local land use plans and policies. The intent is to insure that the resulting plan and policies reflect, as closely as 1 possible, the will of the people in the community. Meaningful public involvement was an important element in 1 preparing an updated land use plan for growth and development in Brunswick County. For the public involvement program to be effective, two key factors were included: 1) public education and 1 2) public input. 1 The most effective format for public involvement includes this two- way communication between citizens and local officials. 1 The public involvement strategy employed for the Brunswick County Land Use Plan provided numerous opportunities for effective communication. First and foremost was the appointment of the ' County Planning Board as the Steering Committee for the Plan. This 6-member board (5 regular members plus 1 County Commissioner) is appointed by the County Commissioners and represents various 1 interests and geographic areas of the county. The Planning Board had an active, leadership role throughout the ' preparation of the Land Use Plan. The Committee's role was particularly critical during the formulation of the Growth Policies and the Land Classification Map. In this capacity, the Planning Board 1 offered local perspectives, providing input on the accuracy of information gathered, and feedback on the recommendations given. All Planning Board meetings were open to the public and several, 1 jointly hosted with the County Commissioners, were designed specifically to garner public input in an organized, constructive fashion. ' The following is a summary of program phases and key meetings for public involvement in the preparation of the Brunswick County Land 1 Use Plan: 1. Strategy The first priority in carrying out the public participation strategy for the 1 Development/ Land Use Plan was to meet with key local officials to discuss and Public receive approval of the planning process for citizen involvement. Participation During this phase, the planning consultant, the County Staff, the 1 Plan Planning Board and the County Commissioners each had a constructive role in preparing, reviewing, and approving the proposed planning and public involvement strategy. Also, State 1 Brunswick County Planning Board page 148 Glenn Harbeck Associates BrunswicK County Lana Use Plan Summary Of Public Participation concerns. suggestions, and requirements for the planning process were conveyed to the County staff and elected and appointed t officials during a special workshop held with a representative of the Division of Coastal Management at the County Government complex in Bolivia. , Public Meetings Held During This Phase: September 18. 26, October 16. , November 20. and December 18. 1991 County Planning Board October 7, December 2, 10, and 16, 1991 Board of County Commissioners ' December. 1991 DCM Workshop 2. Issue Issue identification for the Brunswick County Land Use Plan , Identification by consisted of a series of five public meetings held at strategic the Public locations in various parts of the county. A concerted eftort was made to cluster the meeting dates within a two week period to maximize , public exposure and media attention. Each of these meetings was jointly hosted by one member of the Planning Board and one , member of the Board of County Commissioners. A mailing list was compiled and special invitations and announcements were prepared and mailed to over 100 residents of the county, known to represent a ' wide cross section of interests. Announcements were also sent to local news media. The purpose of these meetings was to provide the public with the opportunity to make their concerns known about growth and development issues facing the county. The intent was to accomplish this task as early as possible in the planning process, so that these ' concerns might be recorded and used as a foundation for the preparation of the Plan. ' The specific involvement technique used to solicit public input was a modified nominal group process using index cards and display sheets. Following the identification of issues, the relative priority of ' each issue was identified by a simple voting process. After the entire series of meetings was completed, all growth issues were typed up ' exactly as recorded and sorted into policy categories consistent, to the extent possible, with categories suggested in the CAMA guidelines. The complete listing and ranking of all issues as identified at the meetings was then presented to the Planning Board ' for discussion and review. This written tabulation of growth issues was also made available for public inspection and review. ' Public Meetings Held During This Phase: January 7, 1992 Public Input Meeting No. 1 Jones Byrd Clubhouse January 9, 1992 Public Input Meeting No. 2 Southport -Oak Island ' Chamber of Commerce January 14, 1992 Public Input Meeting No. 3 Town Creek Community Building ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 149 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Lana Use Plan Summary Of Public Particioation L .1 January 15. 1992 January 16. 1992 January 21. 1992 Public Input Meeting No. 4 Public Input Meeting No. 5 Discuss public input Leland Community Building Lockwood Folly Community Building County Planning Board 3. Leadership During this phase, the consulting planner, working in cooperation Interviews with the County Planning Director, conducted a series of personal interviews with several local leaders from various walks of life and areas of knowledge in Brunswick County. The purpose of the interviews was to gain in-depth insights into prospects for future growth and development in the county. Each person interviewed was asked two questions: 1) What are Brunswick County's greatest assets? and 2) What are the county's liabilities. or things that are holding the county back? In addition. each person was encouraged to focus on any specific issue they cared to amplify. Specific comments were not attributed to any one individual so as to encourage candidness and assure anonymity. Following the interviews, a summary of several of the common threads running throughout the interviews was prepared for review by the Planning Board. Interviews were conducted on Tuesday, January 28 and Wednesday. January 29, 1992, with the following individuals: Mr. P.R. Hankins Superintendent of Public Instruction, Brunswick County Schools: Mr. Eugene Tomlinson Member, Coastal Resources Commission for some 15 years, Mayor of Southport, 18 years: Mr. Bill Rabon Veterinarian, Chairman, Brunswick County Health Board; Mr. Mike Reeves President, Brunswick Community College; Mr. Jamie Orrock Director of Social Services, Brunswick County and Mr. Ed Gore former Chairman of the County Planning Board, developer of Sunset Beach and environs. Public Meetings Held During This Phase: January 22 and February 19, 1992 County Planning Board 1 Brunswick County Planning Board page 150 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Counry Land Use Plan Summary Of Public Participation 4. Discussion of Based in part on the issues identified during Phases 2 and 3 above. Public Input and and in keeping with the data collection and analysis requirements of Growth Factors the CAMA land use planning guidelines, a growth factors analysis ' was preparea for initial review by the Planning Board. To accomplish tnis task, a completed draft of the analysis was distributed to the Planning Board for their review and comment. ' Each Planning Board member was asked to review the document for both its scope and its accuracy. As a result of the review, changes were made and additional research was conducted to address ' specific comments and points felt to be in need of clarification. Public Meetings Held During This Phase: January 22, February 19, and March 18, 1992 County Planning Board 5. Plan and With the resuits of the initial public input in hand, and with the Growth ' Policy Factors Anaivsis completed, the consulting planner, working closely Development with the County planning staff and Planning Board, prepared a draft Work Sessions set of Growth Policies. The kick off meeting for this process was a ' special, all day work session designed to give the Planning Board the opportunity to review the entire set of existing County policies, and to better understand the way in which the policies interrelate. At ' the same time, this initial session was most beneficial in identifying policies in need of updating, modification, deletion or addition. ' Based on the initial all day work session, the consulting planner then prepared a draft of the Policy Section of the Plan, complete with policy statements and explanatory text. The Planning Board then reviewed the policy section during two regular meetings of the Board. Both meetings were open to the public and public comments were invited and accepted. Each proposed policy statement, along with its ' explanatory text, was reviewed with suggested changes recorded and completed. ' A second element of the plan, also prepared during this phase, was the proposed Land Classification Map. The map was prepared using washable markers on an acetate overlay. This technique allowed for ' instant changes to the map in accordance with directives from the Planning Board during public meetings. ' A third element of the Ian prepared during p p p g this phase was the Implementation Actions section,. Unlike the County's previous land use plans, however, this plan section was prepared as a separate ' element, allowing this section to be updated on an annual basis without altering the balance of the plan. This section was reviewed in a fifth meeting of the Planning Board. ' Brunswick County Planning Board page 151 Glenn Harbeck Associates 2runswicK County Land Use Plan Summary Of Public Particioation Following the completion of this series of review meetings, a revised. completed draft of the policies. text and map was prepared in accordance with the directives and comments of the Planning Board. Public Meetinos Held Dunna This Phase: April 9. 1992 County Planning Board May 20. 1992 June 17, 1992 July 15, 1992 August 19. 1992 County Planning Board County Planning Board County Planning Board County Planning Board All Day Work Session on Policies Review of Land Classification Map Discussion of Draft Policy Section Discussion of Draft Policy' Section and Draft Implementation Actions Final Discussion of Draft Policies and Implementation Actions. Expression of intent for further public comment. 6. Planning A joint work session on the draft plan was held to provide the Board opportunity for the Planning Board and County Commissioners to Presentation/ meet in a round table discussion. The purpose of the meeting was Discussion of not to formally adopt the plan, but rather to reach consensus as to the Draft Plan with adequacy of the plan and its policies for formal public review, and County generally, for submission to the CAMA program staff. While this Commissioners meeting was also open to the public, (and public comments were accepted) its primary intent was to allow the two boards to concentrate their attention on the draft plan, in the absence of formal public dialogue. Public Meetings Held During This Phase: September 21,1992 Joint meeting of Board of County Commissioners/County Planning Board After the joint work session on the draft plan was completed, and 7. Public comments from the two boards received, a formal public meeting was Comment held by the County Commissioners to accept public comments in an Meeting /Follow- organized fashion. Notification for the meeting included large up Review announcements printed in the county's two newspapers of general Session circulation as well as approximately one hundred individual announcements mailed to a broad spectrum of community leaders in the county. All comments received at the meeting, whether favorable, neutral or negative, were noted for the record and for further action as appropriate. Once public comments were accepted and recorded, a review meeting was held with the Planning Board to go over the public comments and to decide upon revisions in response to citizen concerns. Plan revisions were then completed in accordance with directives received from the Planning Board, as the official steering Brunswick County Planning Board page 152 Glenn Harbeck Associates 2runswlCK County Land Use Plan Summary Of Public Particic_::on committee for the land use plan, appointed by the County Commissioners. Public Meetinas Held During This Phase: October 6. 1992 Public Input Meeting hosted by the County ' Commissioners October 21.1992 County Planning Board meeting to discuss and direct revisions 8. State Review Following additional revisions to the plan in accordance with and Comment/ Planning Board (Steering Committee) directives, the plan was sent to Prepare the State CAMA program staff for review and comment in late Revisions As October 1992. Comments received from the review staff in mid - Appropriate February of 1993 were then considered by the Planning Board at ' their regular meeting in March. Revisions were then authorized as appropriate and the plan was submitted a second time in early May. Public Meetings Held During This Phase: ' March 24,1993 County Planning Board meeting to discuss and direct revisions ' 9. County The County Commissioners held a formal public hearing to present Commissioners the plan for a final time for public review and comment. Notice of the ' Adoption of Plan meeting was in accordance with requirements for public hearings for (Public Hearing) the local adoption of CAMA Land Use Plans, as well as the County's normal protocol. Adoption of the plan was contingent, as necessary, upon the preparation of final revisions made in accordance with directives received from the County Commissioners. The plan was then submitted to the Coastal Resources Commission for certification by that body. Public Meetings Held During This Phase: ' (date) Public Hearing by the Board of County Commissioners for consideration of adoption ' The following table summarizes the planning process by month from initial organization to the final public hearing for adoption. I Brunswick County Planning Board page 153 Glenn Harbeck Associates 1=runSWICK CCU^tV Lan0 L._2 P!-=^ �ummary c, Oublic Particioatlon ISummary of Public involvement Prccess ' Month Major Activities October '91 Execute Contract VVith Consulting PlannerOraanize for Planning and Public Invoivement ' adopt Public Participation Plan Begin Growth Factors Analysis ,Vovember ' December '92 Continue Growth Factors Analysis January Continue Growth Factors Analvsis; Identify Growth Issues ,=ebruary Conduct Leadership Interviews Evaluate Growth Issuesi Finalize Growth Factors Analysis ' Marcn Present and Discuss Growth Factors Analysis and Leadership Interviews April Discuss Needed Revisions to Existing Policies and Land Class. Map ' May Prepare Draft of Preliminary Policies and Land Classification June Beain Review of Preliminary Policies and Land Classification ' July Complete Review of Preliminary Policies and Land Classification Present and Review Implementation Actions Begin Compiling Draft Plan in Full for Review ' August Planning Board Review of Progress To Date and Discussion of Joint Meeting with County Commissioners ' September Prepare final working draft. Hold Joint Meeting: County Commissioners and Planning Board ' October Hold Public Review Meeting for Comment Planning Board Action on Public Comments Submit Plan for State and Federal Agency Review ' February '93 Comments received back from State Reviewers March Planning Board Action on State Comments April Revisions as necessary ' May Resubmit revised plan to State Reviewers Comments received back from State Reviewers ' Schedule public hearing 30 days in advance Public hearing before County Commissioners/ Adoption of Plan with revisions as necessary ' Submit Plan to CRC for Certification E I Brunswick County Planning Board page 154 Glenn Harbeck Associates 6. Action Agenda! I 2funSW1Cc County Lana Use Plan Acton Acenaa 6. Action Agenda For the Brunswick County Land Use Plan Introduction to the Action Agenda The Action Agenda of the Brunswick County Land Use Plan is provided to identify specific implementation actions in. furtherance of the Policies and Land Classification Map. These actions are normally intended to be accomplished within the five year planning period between adoption of this plan and the next land use plan update (scheduled for 1997). Implementation actions are designed to suggest several possible courses of action available to the County to carry out the Policies and Map. The suggested actions are not all-inclusive nor are they binding: additional actions may be added and others removed as conditions change. In fact. it is suggested that this summary of policies and implementation actions be reviewed on an annual basis during development of the County's work program and budget approval process. In this manner, the effectiveness of the policies and implementation actions can be better evaluated. Further, by making this Action Agenda a separate section of the plan (as opposed to scattering the implementation actions throughout the narrative), these actions can be updated and re-inserted into the document on a regular basis. Brunswick County Planning Board page 155 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Ccuniv Lana Use Plan 2.1 Resource Protection Policies 2.1.1 CONSTRAINTS TO DEVELOPMENT Policy 2.1.1 (a) Development is encouraged to locate in areas without soil suitability problems and where infrastructure is available; in areas where suitability problems exist, engineering solutions are supported to the extent that the natural environment is not compromised. Policy 2.1.1 (b) Brunswick County supports the administration and enforcement of all applicable flood plain management regulations and the national flood insurance program. Action Aaenca ' IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS (1) Ongoing efforts to incorporate U.S. Soil Conservation Service detailed soil classification maps into the County's geographic information system (GIS) will continue. (2) The County planning staff will review zoning and subdivision proposals with respect to the I soils found on the proposed site. (3) Plans to produce detailed topographic mapping (2' contour intervals) in the County's GIS will continue. (1) The County will continue to enforce the local flood damage prevention ordinance. ' (2) Efforts to disseminate flood insurance rate maps to Realtors, developers, financial institutions, and insurance agencies will continue. (3) Recent initiatives by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) to update the County's flood insurance rate maps will be encouraged and supported. Such mapping should be designed to take advantage of information contained in the County's GIS system and, upon completion, should be incorporated into the County's GIS system. 'UI U H Brunswick County Planning Board page 156 Glenn Harbeck Associaies H 3runswick County Lana Use Plan Action Aaenaa ' 2.1.2 AREAS OF 2.1.2(a) Coastal Wetland AEC's ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERN IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS Policy 2.1.2(a) Efforts to protect and preserve the i environmental value of coastal wetland AEC's shall be supported. Such protection shall be balanced with the economic and community values of piers, docks, and marinas i which serve the public, whether they be publicly or privately owned. I I ' 2.1.2(b) Estuarine Water AEC's H H 0 Policy 2.1.2(b) i Developments and mitigation I activities which support the function, cleanliness, salinity, and circulation of estuarine water resources are supported. i (1) The County's commitment to the protection of coastal wetland AEC's will continue through County financial and staff support for the minor CAMA permit program. (2) Major CAMA permit reviews and comment by the County's staff will include references to the County's land use policies. Also, the County will request that the State consult with the County on all interpretations of the Land Use Plan, its policies, and land classification map. so that consistent State/local interpretations will be achieved. (3) The County will seek funds for a study addressina the need for publicly financed marinas or boat berthina facilities in the County. (1) The County will call upon the North Carolina Department of Transportation to conduct a study of road drainage patterns within the Lockwood Folly Watershed. The study will examine, for example, the effects of direct ditching to estuarine waters and potential corrective actions. (2) The County will continue to support and improve upon existing regulations dealing with runoff from proposed development. i (3) Upon completion of State studies examining the causes of water quality declines in the Lockwood Folly River, the County will consider the creation of a shoreline overlay i district as part of an overall zoning ordinance. Such overlay district might include requirements for more intense review of proposed drainage, and limitations on the type of land uses allowed within the overlay district. (4) The County will encourage the State and Federal Government to develop appropriate regulations over storm drainage and soil erosion from agricultural and forestry activities. (5) The County will continue to press for implementation of the demonstration project, approved by Congress as part of the Water Resources Development Act of 1992, to reopen the eastern channel of the Lockwood Folly River. Brunswick County Planning Board page 157 Glenn Harbeck Associates ?runswick County Land Use r;an Action Acenoa 2.1.2(c) Public Trust Waters AFC's Policy 2.1.2(c) The community's need for piers and docks, whether publicly or privately owned, shall be tempered by the rights of the public for the free and open use of public trust waters for navigation, shell fishing, and other uses. Efforts of State and Federal agencies to limit the length of docks and piers as they project into estuarine waters (T15A:07H.0208) are especially j supported. 2.1.2(d) Estuarine Shoreline AFC's Policy 2.1.2(d) Brunswick County supports the protection and preservation of its estuarine shorelines, particularly regarding those use standards contained in T15A:07H.0209(e) 2.1.2(e) Ocean Hazard Policy 2.1.2(e) i Brunswick County supports State and Federal guidelines designed to manage development in the i ocean hazard AEC of the Baptist assembly grounds, the only ocean hazard AEC under the County's planning jurisdiction. 2.1.2(f) Public Not applicable. Water Supply AEC's IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS (1) The County will support a strengthening of State's standards concerning pier length and obstruction of shallow -water navigation in the county's public trust waters. (1) Upon completion of State studies examining the causes of water quality declines in the Lockwood Folly River, the County will consider the creation of a shoreline overlay district as part of an overall zoning ordinance. Such overlay district might include requirements for more intense review of proposed drainage, and limitations on the type of land uses allowed within the overlay district. (See 2.1.2(b) above also). (1) The County will continue to support proper enforcement of applicable CAMA regulations for ocean hazard area AEC's, and will continue to consult ,.,rith the staff of the Baptist Assembly. D Brunswick County Planning Board page 158 Glenn Harbeck Associates :--, jnswicK Ccunry Lana Use Plan action L 2.1.2(g) Natural and Cultural Resource A E C's Policy 2.1.2 (g) ; Brunswick County supports the selective designation of appropriate areas as natural and cultural resource AEC's (Coastal Complex Natural Areas, Coastal Areas That Sustain Remnant Species, Unique Geologic Formations, Significant Coastal Archaeological Resources and Significant Coastal Historical Architectural Resources). IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS 1) The County supports ap--ropriate State studies to examine areas witnin Brunswick County for possible AEC designation under the natural and cultural resource AEC category. 2.1 3 OTHER HAZARDOUS OR FRAGILE LAND AREAS 2.1.3 (a) Freshwater Swamps, Marshes, Pocosins, and 404 Wetlands Policy 2.1.3 (a) ' 2.1.3 (b) Maritime Forests 7 Brunswick County will continue to support the efforts of the CAMA program and the US. Army Corps of Engineers 404 permitting program to preserve and protect sensitive fresh water swamp and marsh areas. i (1) In the absence of AEC designation, the j County supports efforts of the North Carolina I Wildlife Resources Commission to identify and designate critical habitat areas within the county, provided that coordination for local study and evaluation is included. Policy 2.1.3 (b) Maritime forests in Brunswick 1 (1) The County will investigate the need for a County shall receive a high level of I local ordinance concerning tree preservation, environmental protection when i particularly regarding outstanding and historic considering the public and private trees, including but not limited to significant sector uses. When development is! live oaks and maritime forest. considered, preferred usage shall be for low intensity or clustered development forms. u Brunswick County Planning Board page 159 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Countv Land Use Plan Action Aaenaa 2.1.3 (c) Outstanding Resource waters (uKw,s Policy 2.1.3 (c) 2.1.3(d) Water �uutjiv A[Ud5. Brunswick Countv supports the efforts of the State to restore the water quality of the Lockwood Folly River, as well as other estuarine waters in the county, to a water quality level deserving of ORW designation. Policy 2.1.3(d) The county's ground water resources shall be recognized as i valuable secondary source of public and private potable water and shall receive a high level of protection when considering development proposals. 2.1.3(e) Cultural and Historic Resources IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS (1) Regardless of whether ORW designation is accomplished, the County will consider creating a special shoreline overlay district within the County's overall zoning ordinance to protect and restore, to the extent possible, water quality in the county's estuarine waters. (See also Policy Sections 2.1.2(b) and 2.1.2(d) above.) (2) The County will continue to press for implementation of the demonstration project. approved by Congress as part of the Water Resources Development Act of 1992, to reopen the eastern channel of the Lockwood Folly River. (1) Demands on the county's groundwater a i resources will be relieved through continued expansion of the county -wide water system, in accordance with the 1990 Water Distribution System Master Plan. Policy 2.1.3(e) i Brunswick County supports the (1) Brunswick County will encourage the State protection of other natural and to update the current list of cultural and historic cultural resource areas (beyond resources in Brunswick County to include those designated as AEC's) to areas such as, especially, Clarendon preserve their cultural, educational Plantation. and aesthetic values and qualities. , 2.1.3(f) Manmade Hazards Policy 2.1.3(f) I Brunswick County will seek to (1) The County will continue to enforce air minimize potential land use space zoning for the Brunswick County conflicts and hazards related to Airport, in keeping with the wishes of the development in areas near existing jurisdiction within which the airport falls, the hazardous facilities. I Southeastern Sanitary District. 2.1.4 HURRICANE AND FLOOD EVACUATION (See Section 2.5) J 1 Brunswick County Planning Board page 160 Glenn Harbeck Associates ?runswicic County Lana Use Plan Action Aaenaa I 2.1.5 PROTECTION OF POTABLE WATER SUPPLY IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS Policy 2.1.5(a) Policy 2.1.5(b) Policy 2.1.5(c) Brunswick County supports all State and Federal efforts to protect the quality of water in the Cape Fear River, whether such protection involves controls over point source discharges, surface runoff, or inter basin water transfers. Brunswick County will continue improvements to and expansion of the area's central, piped water supply system. Brunswick County supports the regulation of toxic waste and other harmful materials which could reach the ground water resource. as well as improved storm water management and erosion/sedimentation controls. 2.1.6 PACKAGE SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANTS (1) Brunswick County will encourage State efforts to prepare targeted studies and effective policies on water allocation, inter - basin transfers, water quality impacts. etc. as these issues affect the Cape Fear River. , (1) Implementation of the Water Distribution i System Master Plan as prepared by William G. Daniel and Associates, September 1990 will continue in accordance with the general phasing of improvements recommended. (1) The proposed zoning ordinance will direct higher density and more intensive development to locate in areas where public water is provided, thereby reserving areas dependent upon the groundwater resource for lower density development. Policy 2.1.6 Until such time that district sewage (1) In areas with uncorrectable soil suitability treatment systems are feasible and problems causing severe limitations for septic available, Brunswick County shall tanks, a package sewage treatment plant will encourage the use of private, small I be required of all major subdivision projects. package sewage treatment plants for appropriately scaled j (2) The County will continue to develop and developments, especially in those improve upon its relatively new responsibilities areas with soil limitations for septic (July 1, 1992) for inspection, and to insure tank use. proper operation and maintenance of subsurface sewage disposal facilities in the county- 2.1.7 STORMWATER RUNOFF ' Policy 2.1.7 Stormwater Runoff t Brunswick County encourages all land use activities to employ effective storm water management practices to protect the quality of l the county's streams, rivers, marshes and estuarine systems. (1) The County will implement and enforce a new provision in the County subdivision I regulations requiring that a copy of the soil erosion/sedimentation control plan be included as a part of all new subdivisions. Detailed standards are included in the new ordinance. (2) Brunswick County will encourage the State to seek appropriate legislation to require that agriculture and forest activities meet reasonable storm water runoff standards. Brunswick County Planning Board page 161 Glenn Harbeck Associates BrunswicK Cc::nty Lana Use Plan Action Aaenca I 2.1.8 MARINA AND FLOATING HOME DEVELOPMENT Policy 2.1.8(a) I Brunswick County discourages floating home development anywhere in the waterways, public trust waters, and along the shorelines of the county, to the extent regulated by the State. Policy 2.1.8(b) Brunswick County encourages environmentally responsible 1 marina development in accordance with all State CAMA standards for AEC's. 2.1.9 INDUSTRIAL IMPACTS ON FRAGILE AREAS IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS I i (1) Brunswick County will continue to support CAMA standards regarding floating structures in coastal waters. (2) Should need require. the County will study other coastal counties such as Carteret County and New Hanover County for appropriate local regulations and standards. (1) The County will seek funds for a study examining the need for possible publicly financed and publicly owned marinas and other boat berthing facilities. Policy 2.1.9 1 Economically beneficial industries 1 (1) The County will implement and enforce will be allowed to locate in fragile industrial performance standards in the areas if environmental impacts can proposed zoning ordinance. be mitigated. (2) The land classification map and zoning ordinance will identify areas not suitable for industrial development. 2.1.10 DEVELOPMENT OF SOUND AND ESTUARINE SYSTEM ISLANDS Policy 2.1.10 Development of sound and estuarine system islands is permitted, provided that impacts on the natural environment are properly mitigated. When such islands are deemed to have greater than local significance, the County encourages the State to purchase these environmentally sensitive areas for the benefit of all residents of the state. (1) The County will continually work to improve its subdivision and zoning regulations to provide for proper environmental protection and development on sensitive estuarine system islands. 7 Brunswick County Planning Board page 162 Glenn Harbeck Associates 3runswicrc Countv Lana Use Tian Action Aaenaa 2.1.11 DEVELOPMENT NEAR SEA LEVEL Policy 2.1.11 Development within areas susceptible to sea level rise, shoreline erosion, and/or wetland loss, should take into consideration such conditions upon initial development. In the event such development is later threatened by shoreline loss, the County will not support efforts to harden the shoreline to protect _ unwise development. 2.1.12 UPLAND EXCAVATION FOR MARINA BASINS Policy 2.1.12 Brunswick County supports the development of marina basins in upland sites in accordance with CAMA standards set forth in 15- NCAC 7H.0208(6)(5). I 2.1.13 MARSH DAMAGE FROM BULKHEAD INSTALLATION Policy 2.1.13 IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS i 1 i The County will continue to enforce the `loop protection ordinance as a means of e-nsurina that new development in low -lying areas is consistent with the limitations of the Jana. ;1 i The County will continue to support CAMA stanaards for the development of marinas in upland locations. (2) The County will seek funds for a study of the need for publicly financed and publicly owned marinas: such study, if approved, to include consideration of upland marina sites. Brunswick County supports state , (1) Brunswick County will continue to support and Federal standards which seek I State and Federal standards for to prevent or minimize marsh environmentally sensitive bulkhead damage from bulkhead or rip rap I installations. installation. The County recognizes, however, that some ! limited marsh damage may be necessary to provide for otherwise i environmentally sound development. Brunswick County Planning Board page 163 Glenn Harbeck Associates 3runswick Countv Land Use P;sn Action Acenda 2.2. Resource Production And Management Policies 2.2.1 PRODUCTIVE AGRICULTURAL LANDS voiicy Z.Z.1 i ne continued agricultural use of the Brunswick County's remaining farmlands shall be encouraged. 2.2.2 COMMERCIAL FOREST LANDS Policy 2.2.2 Brunswick County supports commercial forestry as a major land use. provided significant adverse Impacts on natural resource systems are minimized. 2.2.3 MINERAL PRODUCTION AREAS IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS I (1) The proposed zoning ordinance, once adopted, will be reviewed from time to time as to standards for preservation and protection of the better agriculture lands in the county. (2) The County will encourage the State ana Federal Government to develop appropriate regulations over storm drainage and soil erosion from agricultural and forestry activities (1) The County supports studies regarding the feasibility of using wood chips and residual bark to supplement solid waste combustion to provide sufficient fuel for large scale steam generation or gaseous energy. (2) The County will encourage the State and Federal Government to develop appropriate regulations over storm drainage and soil erosion from agricultural and forestry activities. Policy 2.2.3 " Mineral production and mining i (1) The locations of mineral production and activities will be considered on a i mining activities will be controlled by the case by case review of economic I County's proposed zoning ordinance. After benefits and environmental and adoption of the ordinance, no State i land use impacts. permission will be granted in violation of the j County zoning. 1 H Brunswick County Planning Board page 164 Glenn Harbeck Associates BrunSWICK County Land Use Plan Action Agenda ' 2.2.4 COMMERCIAL AND RECREATIONAL FISHERIES IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS I 0 1 Policy 2.2.4 Brunswick County supports efforts ; (1) The County will support educational to maintain and enhance the seminars to inform local area residents and fisheries resource of its waters, ! business people about the potential for including better fisheries aquaculture development in the county. Such management and enforcement, educational seminars may include courses at and aquaculture development County high schools. efforts -of the local ' activities. Extension Service, and course work at Brunswick Community College, and UNC-W. (2) The County will request the assistance of the Duke Marine Lab. the Marine Crescent and local economic development interests to establish significant aquacultural operations in Brunswick County. (3) The County will continue to provide funding in support of the artificial reef program involving, for example. the sinking of old boats and railroad cars. (4) The County will call upon and cooperate with the State and Federal government for improved marine fisheries management. (5) The County will continue to press for implementation of the demonstration project, approved by Congress as part of the Water Resources Development Act of 1992, to reopen the eastern channel of the Lockwood Folly River. 2.2.5 OFF ROAD VEHICLES lacy 2.2.5 Brunswick County discourages the (1) The County Magistrate and the Sheriff's use of off -road vehicles in all Department will be called upon as necessary to fragile areas because of potential enforce trespassing laws involving off road adverse environmental impacts. vehicles on properly posted private property, as provided for in the General Statutes. 2.2.6 DEVELOPMENT IMPACTS See table of contents to identify policies and implementation actions concerning particular development types. 2.2.7 PEAT OR PHOSPHATE MINING IMPACTS See general mining policy and implementation actions set forth previously under section 2.2.3. Brunswick County Planning Board page 165 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Section 2.3 Economic And Community Development Policies 2.3.1 TYPES AND LOCATIONS OF INDUSTRIES DESIRED Note: the issue of tourism as an industry is discussed under section 2.3.8. Policy 2.3.1 Brunswick County encourages the development of industry throughout the county, provided such development is compatible with surrounding land uses and that potential environmental impacts can be effectively mitigated. 2.3.2 PROVISION OF SERVICES TO DEVELOPMENT Note: Solid waste management, recycling and disposal are discussed specifically under section 2.3.16. Action Aaenaa I IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS (1) The new zoning ordinance contains several manufacturing/industrial zoning districts and an "economic development overlay district'. Such an overlay district would allow the County to respond to concrete requests for new industrial development in an appropriate and flexible manner. (2) The County will continue to support efforts to actively seek blue chip industries with higher pay scales relative to existing pay scales in the county. (3) The County will continue to fund the Resources Development Commission as a principal agency in recruiting new industry to the county, as well as encouraging the expansion of existing industry. (4) The County will consider, when justified, funding of necessary infrastructure and targeted job training at the Community College, in support of new industrial activities in Brunswick County, possibly supplemented by the full university system available within the state. L Brunswick County Planning Board page 166 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County Land Use Plan Action enaa L IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS Policy 2.3.2 Brunswick County will strive, to the 1 (1) The County will continue to expand the best extent possible, to facilitate water distribution system in keeping with the the expansion of public services 1990 Water Distribution Master Plan. and facilities to meet the needs of existing and future populations. (2) The County will continue to coordinate transportation improvements in the area through updates to the County thoroughfare plan, and through review and comment on the transportation improvement program (TIP). (3) The County will continue to participate in the development of the Wilmington Urbanized Area Transportation Plan. i (4) The County Commissions will review allocations for secondary road improvements i on a regular basis. (5) The County will continue to provide its coordinated human services transportation program. (6) The County will continue to require right of way protection as necessary in subdivision reviews. (7) The County will continue to support water and sewer improvement districts by providing seed money to pay for initial studies, and by assisting in the preparation of necessary correspondence and paperwork for grant and loan applications. The County would also participate in a local intergovernmental effort to coordinate the research and development of sewage collection and treatment systems in the County, with a n eye toward developing a County -wide plan for a coordinated series of sewage treatment service areas. (8) The County will continue to serve in a coordinating capacity regarding extra territorial jurisdiction between nearby municipalities (e.g. Sunset Beach, Calabash). (9) The County will consider the appointment of a study committee to re-examine better utilization of the County's existing parks facilities, particularly regarding the availability of community buildings for young people. (Continued on next page) Brunswick County Planning Board page 167 Glenn Harbeck Associates 3runswlCK County Land Use Plan 2.3.3 URBAN GROWTH PATTERN DESIRED Policy 2.3.3 Brunswick County will seek to Improve coordinated development through the creation and implementation of enhanced land use controls, growth management policies and the strategic provision of necessary services and infrastructure. 2.3.4 REDEVELOPMENT —INCLUDING RELOCATION OF THREATENED STRUCTURES Note: a discussion of structures threatened by ocean hazards is included in Section 2.5 (Storm Hazard Mitigation, Post -Disaster Recovery, and Evacuation). icy 2.3.4 Brunswick County supports and encourages the restoration of significant and architecturally Important historic structures. Redevelopment of substandard structures within the zounty shall be supported through public and private sector initiatives for the economic betterment of area residents. Action Aaenaa I IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS (10) The County will request that its legislative delegation to the General Assembly sponsor a study to determine the most effective form of local government for Brunswick County. Such study should give particular attention to the provision of services and facilities by the various service providers in the county. The study should also include consideration of model legislation drafted by the US Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. or other reputable sources for such government form. (1) The land classification map will be employed to direct urban level growth to appropriate locations where services can be provided. (2) The County's water distribution system master plan will be employed to directly support the transition areas identified in the land classification map. (3) The County's proposed zoning ordinance will target and direct growth to areas consistent with the land classification map and the water distribution system. (4) The County will continue to enforce the flood damage prevention ordinance as a means of discouraging inappropriate development in flood prone areas. (1) The County Commissioners will continue to pursue recent initiatives for the County's participation in the Small Cities Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Program, including opportunities for Section 8 housing. (2) The County will continue to work for higher paying jobs and enhanced economic opportunity for local area residents as a means of providing additional income to residents for rehabilitation of their homes. 7 u I,J 7 I Brunswick County Planning Board page 168 Glenn Harbeck Associates II� Brunswick County Lano Use Plan Action Aoenda ' 2.3.5 COMMITMENT TO STATE AND FEDERAL PROGRAMS H Policy 2.3.5 Brunswick County supports applicable State and Federal programs regarding economic and community development, especially those programs related to water quality, fisheries, and water and road transportation system improvements. 2.3.6 CHANNEL MAINTENANCE AND BEACH RENOURISHMENT Policy 2. 3.6 , Brunswick County supports the continued maintenance of navigable channels and inlets and the renourishment of the county's beaches In a timely, coordinated fashion. ' 2.3.7 ENERGY FACILITIES Policy 2.3.7 1 Any new major energy facilities to be located in Brunswick County shall, prior to approval, make a full disclosure of all costs and benefits associated with the project, and will further mitigate all potential adverse impacts of the project. IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS (1) The County will continue to participate in the Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) process. (2) The County will continue to participate in ! shared funding of Brunswick Community College. (3) The County will continue to operate job training programs at the County Industrial Park in coordination with the Community College. (4) The County will participate in UNC- Wilmington's new regional economic development strategic planning program. (5) The County will continue to press for i implementation of the demonstration project, approved by Congress as part of the Water Resources Development Act of 1992, to reopen the eastern channel of the Lockwood Folly River. i (1) The County is committed to ongoing j unified support for channel improvements in waterways throughout the county. i (2) The County will support efforts to place spoil materials from channel maintenance and dredging on Brunswick County beaches, inciuding each of the county's incorporated beach municipalities, as warranted. (3) The County will continue to press for implementation of the demonstration project. approved by Congress as part of the Water Resources Development Act of 1992, to reopen the eastern channel of the Lockwood Folly River. (1) The new County zoning ordinance will include performance standards for private industry, including energy facilities. Brunswick County Planning Board page 169 Glenn Harbeck Associates ?runswick Countv Land User=n Action Aaenaa 2.3.8 TOURISM Policy 2.3.8 Brunswick County encourages the development of a high quality tourism trade as a primary element of the county's economic future. Investments in services, facilities, and growth management shall be employed in furtherance of this objective. 2.3.9 COASTAL AND ESTUARINE BEACH WATER ACCESS The recent (1990) Brunswick County Shoreline Access Plan contains a full policy section, which is summarized in Section 2.3.9 of the Land Use Plan. The Access Plan also includes a total of 43 existing or potential shoreline access sites identified in map form. Policy 2.3.9 1 Brunswick County encourages efforts to provide reasonable public access to the county's i beaches, shores, and waterfronts, in accordance with the County's i shoreline access plan which is adopted herein by reference. 2.3.10 RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT Policy 2.3.10 A variety of residential development types is encouraged within those areas of Brunswick County identified as appropriate by the land classification map in concurrence with the provision of necessary urban services. IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS (1) The County will continue to provide funding on an annual basis to the Southport -Oak Island and South Brunswick Chambers of Commerce for tourism promotion. (2) The County has begun and will continue to develop a Clean County Program, the purpose of which is to educate and organize public and private organizations and individuals to enhance the county's appearance. (1) The County will continue to work toward implementation of the 1990 Brunswick County Shoreline --ess Plan. (1) The new zoning ordinance will accommodate a variety of residential development forms including but not limited to: patio homes, townhomes, manufactured homes, zero lot line and flag lot developments, cluster developments, as well as traditional single family subdivision developments. 1 7 Brunswick County Planning Board page 170 Glenn Harbeck Associates 3runswick Countv Land Use Plan Action Aaenda COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT Policy 2.3.11 Brunswick County encourages commercial development in appropriate locations throughout the County; the County discourages commercial strip development. 2.3.12 BEAUTIFICATION Policy 2.3.12 Brunswick County shall employ a combination of incentives and controls to encourage beautification measures which preserve the natural amenities of the community, especially as seen from the county's main highways and roadways leading to the beaches. ' 2.3.13 AIRPORTS icy 2.3.13 Brunswick County will encourage land development patterns which allow for adequate airport expansion and development. IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS (1) The proposed zoning ordinance includes two commercial districts designed to accommodate a broad spectrum of commercial development. These districts include: commercial -low density, commercial - manufacturing, heavy manufacturing and rural - industrial. (2) The County will continually work to improve road access standards to protect the integrity of. particularly, significant traffic -carrying roadways through the county and to the beaches. (1) The new zoning ordinance will provide for sign regulations appropriate for Brunswick County. Once adopted, these sign regulations will be reviewed periodically for !heir effectiveness. (2) The County has begun and will continue to develop a Clean County program, the purpose of which is to educate and organize public and private organizations and individuals to enhance the county's appearance. (3) The County will update its previous investigation of the feasibility of establishing tree preservation standards for outstanding and historic trees in the unincorporated area. (4) Efforts to eliminate the number of "green box" trash receptacles in the county will continue. Screening of privately owned green boxes will be encouraged. (5) The proposed zoning ordinance establishes development standards over outdoor advertising structures. (1) The County will nontinue to enforce air space zoning for the Brunswick County Airport, in keeping with the wishes of the jurisdiction within which the airport falls, the Southeastern Sanitary District. Brunswick County Planning Board page 171 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick Countv Land Use Plan 2.3.14 EDUCATION Action Aaenca IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS ' Policy 2.3.14(a) j The attainment of a quality j (1) In light of the critical importance of primary educational system shall be education to the future of Brunswick County, recognized as a critical factor in the County Commissioners. in coordination the future economic development with Board of Education and the Brunswick j of Brunswick County. Community College Board of Trustees, and with appropriate assistance from the UNC System. will place increasing emphasis on the development of a quality educational system in the county. The important linkage between a good educational system and economic development/quality of life issues will be i emphasized during such efforts. Policy j Responsibility for improvements to j (1) Activities which encourage on -going school 2.3.14(b) I the educational system shall not visitations and workshops by. parents, and by be placed solely with policy I leaders in business and industry shall be makers, professional educators especially emphasized. and administrators. Programs and actions which emphasize (1) parental involvement and (2) assistance from the business community shall be strongly pursued. I Policy 2.3.14(c) Appropriate educational and (1) The County will continue to provide support training programs shall be for the Brunswick Community College encouraged to help unemployed Industrial Education Center, housed in and underemployed local residents Brunswick County's Industrial Paris in the take advantage of business Leland area. expansion and to stay abreast of new technologies. 2.3.15 RETIREES Policy 2.3.15 Brunswick County shall encourage _!(1) The County will work with developers to retiree recruitment programs which i increase local area awareness of the are designed to attract a higher opportunities to market their developments to income, more highly educated retirees with above average incomes, relative population subgroup. to the national norm. 2.3.16 WASTE MANAGEMENT Policy 2.3.16(a) Local area requirements for solid (1) Long range planning for the County's waste disposal facilities shall landfill needs, as well as alternative waste continue to be anticipated through disposal methods, shall continue. advanced planning; facilities shall be located and designed so as not to adversely impact significant natural or manmade sources. Brunswick County Planning Board page 172 Glenn Harbeck Associates 3runswick Countv Land Use Plan Action Aaenda I IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS n Policy2.3.16(b) i Brunswick County recognizes the ; (1) The County will continue to explore need for a regional solution to the i opportunities for joint regional recycling in solid waste issue. and will support cooperation with adjacent cities and counties. efforts toward that end. Policy 2.3.16(c) i Research and development of (1) The County will undertake an education recycling and resource recovery and enforcement program to curtail programs, whether public or construction material dumping at trash private, shall be encouraged and collection sites. supported. (2) The County will continue to coordinate the recycling efforts of the incorporated municipalities in cooperation with those of the County. 2.3.17 GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT CONTROLS Policy 2.3.17 Brunswick County supports growth management provided by continued improvements to land use and development controls and Is committed to the proper enforcement of such ordinances. (1) Ongoing efforts to introduce county -wide zoning in the unincorporated area of the county will continue to be a priority. (2) The feasibility of establishing tree preservation measures, either has a separate ordinance, or as an addition to the zoning ordinance, will be investigated. (3) Administration and improvement of the County's subdivision regulations will continue. (4) The County will support State initiatives for the appropriate regulation of livestock production facilities. (5) Sign regulations. if implemented as proposed in the County zoning ordinance, will be evaluated and refined periodically as to their appropriateness for the predominantly rural character of Brunswick County. (6) The County will accommodate and provide proper planning for four classes of manufactured housing, as specified in the zoning ordinance. (7) Commercial zoning districts and driveway access standards will be implemented and periodically refined to discourage inappropriate stripping of development along the county's highways. Brunswick County Planning Board page 173 Glenn Harbeck Associates �runswicic County Land Use Plan Action Aaenda 2.4 Public Participation Policies Note: the public participation plan and program for the Brunswick County land use plan is discussed fully in section 5 of this document. IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS ! Policy 2.4.1 (a) ! Brunswick County shall continue to I (1) The County will continue to conduct special employ public participation public meetings as necessary to address techniques at public meetings important growth issues and proposals in which actively involve the public in Brunswick County. Identifying and discussing iplanning issues, thereby "engaged" (2) The County will continue to provide facilitating a form of advance notice and interviews with the press in education. Media attention an effort to inform the public as to the purpose concerning such meetings is also of public meetings in advance of such strongly encouraged and meetings. thankfully acknowledged for the public service they provide. I Policy 2.4.1 (b) I Citizen input in the development ' (1) The Planning Board will periodically I of growth policies shall be I evaluate its effectiveness in achieving this i supported through attention given policy, and will consider special actions to I i to the issues and priorities which encourage participation. the public identified during early 1 input meetings. i Policy 2.4.1 (c) I Following plan adoption, (1) The County will continue to provide for Brunswick County shall employ open meetings of the Planning Board and frequent, constructive and open County Commissioners in both the letter and regular meetings of the Planning spirit of the open meetings law of the State of Board and County Commissioners North Carolina. i as the primary vehicle for engaging public participation in on -going (2) To facilitate constructive input, and so as ' planning Issues and development not to keep otherwise unscheduled speakers projects. I waiting, the Planning Board will continue to schedule opportunities for public input in advance of selected meetings. Brunswick County Planning Board page 174 Glenn Harbeck Associates Brunswick County nano Use Plan Action Aaenda 2.5 Storm Hazard Mitigation, Post -Disaster Recovery and Evacuation Plan 2.5.1 STORM HAZARD MITIGATION IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS Policy 2.5.1(a) Brunswick County shall discourage (1) The County will continue to enforce the high intensity uses and large flood damage prevention ordinance. structures from being constructed within the 100-year floodplain, erosion -prone areas, and other locations susceptible to hurricane and flooding hazards. Policy 2.5.1(b) Brunswick County shall not (1) The County will continue to push for the re - participate in the purchase of land mapping of flood hazard areas to provide a parcels located in hazard areas or more accurate picture of land located in rendered unbuildable by storms or hazardous locations. other events, for the purposes of shorefront access. Policy 2.5.1(c) Brunswick County shall continue to (1) The County will continue to provide enforce the North Carolina building building inspections services for the i code, particularly those provisions unincorporated area, as well as some of the which require construction municipalities in the county, including the ! standards to meet resistive factors, enforcement of all provisions relative to storm i.e. design, wind velocity. safety and resistance. Policy 2.5.1(d) Brunswick County encourages the Note: No action necessary as this policy is placement of utilities underground being implemented on a broad scale by nearly for all new development. all developers. Policy 2.5.1(e) Brunswick County shall employ (1) Continual improvements in the County's growth management techniques to administration of the 911 emergency system ' facilitate effective emergency will be sought. evacuation. The County shall also cooperate on a regional basis with (2) The street signage program will continue. emergency evacuation planning efforts. (3) The county -wide street naming and addressing program will continue. Brunswick County Planning Board page 175 Glenn Harbeck Associates ?runswicK Countv Land Use Plan Action Aaenaa 2.5.2 POST DISASTER RECONSTRUCTION IMPLEMENTATION ACTIONS Policy 2.5.2(a) Policy 2.5.2(b) Policy 2.5.2(c) Policy _2.5.2(d) Policy 2.5.2(e) The Board of County Commissioners of Brunswick County shall be ultimately responsible for supervising the implementation of polices and procedures contained in the disaster relief and assistance plan, and the post -disaster recovery policies of the land use plan. In the event of extensive hurricane damage to public utilities requiring replacement or relocation of these utilities, efforts shall be made to locate damaged utilities away from hurricane hazard areas or to strengthen their construction. Priority will be given to those repairs that will restore service to as many persons as soon as possible. The Board of County Commissioners may declare a moratorium of up to 180 days on the permitting of any new construction, including new utility hookups, or redevelopment construction that would increase the intensity of the land uses existing before the hurricane. Brunswick County shall continue to work closely with emergency management agency personnel in the preparation of the County's evacuation plan. The County shall also continue to press for necessary improvements for effective evacuation of threatened areas. (1) The County's new Emergency Services Center will serve as a logical command center for the directives of the County Commissioners during and after a major storm event. (1) The County will monitor all reconstruction efforts involving both public and private utilities, including roads. to provide for less vulnerable redevelopment after a hurricane. (1) This poiicy will be implemented in accordance with the best practices of public and private utilities regarding the restoration of service following a major storm event. (1) Implementation of any such moratorium will be carried out if, in the opinion of the Board of County Commissioners, insufficiently planned new construction would result in a compromise of the public health, safety, and general welfare. (1) The County will employ the new Emergency Services Center as a convenient facility to coordinate storm preparation efforts. II� r, G' P Brunswick County Planning Board page 176 Glenn Harbeck Associates V CL C. I f B October 19, 1992 ?r. John Harvey Planning Dept. - Brunswick County P.O. Box 249 Bolivia, \C 28422 Dear Mr. Harvey: The Village of Bald Head Island met in monthly session on October 17, 1992. The council discussed the section of the 1992 Brunswick County Land Use Plan that referred to Bald Head Island and agreed unanimously that the statements as presented were satisfactory to our governing body. We are pleased to be able to cooperate in getting your plan before the CRC for approval. Sin erely, I Wallace Martin Town Manager anu _. , . - .- :- _ - — - 4 v , C- TOWN OF VARNAMTOro. N 505 Sabbath Home Rd. Supply, NC 28462 October 15, 1992 Brunswick Count;: P.O. Box 249 3395 Ocean Hwy E. Bolivia, -C 28422 Dear Sir: The Town of Varnamto%%'n., Board of Aldermen met on Monday October 12, 1992 and :jade the following resolution. we resolve to approve submission of the Community and Land Use Plan draft for review. We hope this information will be of help to you in this program. Sincerely, Judy Galloway Mayor cc Haskell Rhett