16159_SHELL ISLAND RESORT HOMEOWNER'S ASSOC_19970314

Wl
CAMA AND DREDGE AND FILL
GENERAL
PERMIT
as authorized by the State of North Carolina
Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources and the Coastal Resources Commission
in an area of environmental concern pursuant to 15A NCAC
� r
Applicant Name
c so— ,4, `� N33r..Phone Number
Arlrlracc
IN 01..
i�r� (/a: ec_
fy 1
City � 4a �..' :'X i, si' State /Y f zip 2.
Project Location (County, State Road, Water Body, etc.) > 415 All��' s '' '(, / ,1r,' ` c�
Type of Project Activity �n , <�li a P v <
PROJECT DESCRIPTION I SKETCH
Pier (dock) length
Groin length
number
Bulkhead length
max. distance offshore
Basin, channel dimensions
cubic yards
Boat ramp dimensions
Other
This permit is subject to compliance with this application, site
drawing and attached general and specific conditions. Any
violation of these terms may subject the permittee to a fine,
imprisonment or civil action; and may cause the permit to be-
come null and void.
This permit must be on the project site and accessible to the
permit officer when the project is inspected for compliance.
The applicant certifies by signing this permit that 1) this pro-
ject is consistent with the local land use plan and all local
ordinances, and 2) a written statement has been obtained from
adjacent riparian landowners certifying that they have no
objections to the proposed work.
In issuing this permit the State of North Carolina certifies that
this project is consistent with the North Carolina Coastal
Management Program.
(SCALE:
Z;kitLL 1b 1�E' �" HOMEONVERS' ASSOCIATION, INC
VY
applicant's signature
/ permit officer's signature
issuing date f expiration date
attachments
application feey 1A

� 3
State of North Carolina
Department of Environment,
Health and Natural Resources
Division of Coastal Management
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Jonathan B, Howes, Secretary
Roger N. Schecter, Director
May 27, 1997
Mr Kenneth H. Shanklin
Shanklin and McDaniel
P.O. Box 1347
214 Market Street
Wilmington, North Carolina 28402-1347
Dear Ken:
fD'E_HNR
FILE
This is in response to your request to extend CAMA General Permit No. 016159-D issued
to Shell Island Homeowner's Association for the installation of a sandbag revetment at Shell Island
Resort. The permit is hereby extended until June 26, 1997 provided that you agree to the attached
amended conditions. These have been revised to address removal of the temporary sheet piles and
sandbag debris from bags installed earlier at this site. Please acknowledge your acceptance of the
conditions in writing.
Please contact me if you have any questions.
cc: Roger Schecter
Bob Stroud
Sincerely,
Preston P. Pate, Jr.
Assistant Director
NHestron Plaza II, 151 B, Highway 24, Morehead City NC 28557 ��y. �� C An Equal Opportunity / Affirmative Action Employer
Voice 919-808-2808 FAX [phone] Courier 11-12- 09 50%recycled / 10% post consumer paper

Conditions for Shell Island Resort Homeowners Association Emergency General Permit
The temporary sandbag revetment will be constructed as depicted on plans entitled "Proposed Sand
Bag Layout with Modified Segment" and included in the report entitled "Variance Request for
Emergency General Permit, Shell Island Homeowner's Association Protection Project" dated January
24, 1997. Construction will also be pursuant to modifications to the application proposed by the
applicant in the stipulated facts of the variance petition as amended by the Coastal Resources
Commission in an order dated February 7, 1997. Those modifications and amendments are as
follows:
A. The temporary sandbag revetment will be removed within two years of the date of completion,
unless the Division of Coastal Management determines, in its sole discretion, that the
revetment or portions of the revetment have become covered by dunes with vegetation
sufficient to be considered stable and natural.
B. During the two year permitted period, the permittee will monitor the sandbags and will report to
the Division on their condition semi-annually. The permittee will perform routine maintenance
on the sandbags not to include enlargement of the structure beyond its permitted dimensions.
If the Division determines, in its sole discretion, that routine maintenance is not being
performed, the structure or a portion of the structure is falling into disrepair, or the structure or
portion of the structure has been abandoned, the Division may request the permittee to
replace or repair the structure or a portion of the structure. The permittee will fulfill the
Division's request within 30 days after the request is made. The permittee will not contest the
Division's determination. If the Division determines, in its sole discretion, the structure or
portions of the structure are in beyond repair or has been abandoned, the Division may
request the permittee to remove the structure or portions of the structure. The permittee will
not contest the Division's determination. If, in its sole discretion, the Division determines the
revetment or some portion of the revetment has become unnecessary due to abatement of the
erosion emergency, the permittee will remove the revetment or portion of the revetment. The
permittee will not contest the Division's determination.
C. The permittee will monitor the erosion rate on the inlet and the oceanfront adjacent to the
Shell Island Resort and will report to the Division semi-annually. The monitored area will
extend half a mile south. If, after installation of the sandbag revetment, the Division, in its sole
discretion, determines that the rate of erosion has increased on the monitored area, the
Division may require the permittee to remove or modify the revetment before the expiration of
the two year period. The permittee will not contest the Division's determination.
2. The steel sheet piles used to stabilize the trench during construction shall be removed within 48 hours
after expiration of this permit or 48 hours after installation of the tubes whichever is sooner.
All debris from sandbags installed at this site shall be removed as soon as it is discovered.
4. The Division shall be notified immediately upon completion of construction to make a final inspection
and document the completion date.
Once the temporary sandbag revetment has been installed, the public will have unrestricted access to
the inlet and ocean shoreline.
shellis.con

Conditions for Shell Island Resort Homeowners Association Emergency General Permit
The temporary sandbag revetment will be constructed as depicted on plans entitled
"Proposed Sand Bag Layout with Modified Segment" and included in the report entitled
"Variance Request for Emergency General Permit, Shell Island Homeowner's Association
Protection Project" dated January 24, 1997. Construction will also be pursuant to
modifications to the application proposed by the applicant in the stipulated facts of the
variance petition as amended by the Coastal Resources Commission in an order dated
February 7, 1997. Those modifications and amendments are as follows:
A. The temporary sandbag revetment will be removed within two years of the date of
completion, unless the Division of Coastal Management determines, in its sole
discretion, that the revetment or portions of the revetment have become covered by
dunes with vegetation sufficient to be considered stable and natural.
B. During the two year permitted period, the permittee will monitor the sandbags and
will report to the Division on their condition semi-annually. The permittee will
perform routine maintenance on the sandbags not to include enlargement of the
structure beyond its permitted dimensions. If the Division determines, in its sole
discretion, that routine maintenance is not being performed, the structure or a
portion of the structure is failing into disrepair, or the structure or portion of the
structure has been abandoned, the Division may request the permittee to replace or
repair the structure or a portion of the structure. The permittee will fulfill the
Division's request within 30 days after the request is made. The permittee will not
contest the Division's determination. If the Division determines, in its sole
discretion, the structure or portions of the structure are in beyond repair or has been
abandoned, the Division may request the permittee to remove the structure or
portions of the structure. The permittee will not contest the Division's
determination. If, in its sole discretion, the Division determines the revetment or
some portion of the revetment has become unnecessary due to abatement of the
erosion emergency, the permittee will remove the revetment or portion of the
revetment. The permittee will not contest the Division's determination.
C. The permittee will monitor the erosion rate on the inlet and the oceanfront adjacent
to the Shell Island Resort and will report to the Division semi-annually. The
monitored area will extend half a mile south. If, after installation of the sandbag
revetment, the Division, in its sole discretion, determines that the rate of erosion
has increased on the monitored area, the Division may require the permittee to
remove or modify the revetment before the expiration of the two year period. The
permittee will not contest the Division's determination.
2. The Division shall be notified immediately upon completion of construction to make a final
inspection and document the completion date.
3. Once the temporary sandbag revetment has been installed, the public will have
unrestricted access to the inlet and ocean shoreline.

VVILH 1V1VU111GU'OVV111C11LM
Public Road \\
(Underground b \
Utilities) �j� •
ach Pu
arking E
---- i
Unties
`T
v x y
` r
4 F 3. t', 4.tv.�as f• 1
V
-6 _
��r Y af 1. _� �1,;,..✓v ti/� �r�
S
0 75
Scale in Feet
Mason's Inlet
Shell Island Resort
(North Tower)
LeL7end
• Monument
Corit6urs`(12/18/96)

ry®
USAAirbill
N�mbe
3889639235
From (please print)
Il, riz.„
)
J. e-7 %.x
Sender's 91' t� 08— 808
Name . PRESTON P._PATE �. Phone.
De
NORTH CAROL.IN� DZ'\,' OF i�t7t�t-STAL
tJRoor/Suhe/Room
Company . P .._._.......
151 P HWY — Ain
Address ._ —.... —....... /..._.......__`�L............_.__.
NftlREHEAD CITY NC 2 f wa 5 7
City __._ State Zip ... .... ...__._._— ......__.._—
© Your Internal Billing Reference Information
IOptionaO)First 24 characters will appear on invoice) —_. ... __.......
.....���.._._._ __._._.._.
To (please print)
Recipient's
Name SUSAN_MCDANIEL...-.---- ..... ... ..Phone!-9.10L2.56-247D.
Dept(Roor/Suite/Roo m
f Company _-SHANKLIN- & MCDANIEL,_...Attorneys_at.-..LaTz.—.___
Address —21:_4 --Market-Street---
(To 'HOLD' at FedEx location, print FedEx address here) (We Cannot Deliver to P.O. Boxes or P.G. Zip Codes)
city—Wilmin -ton-. --...__.. state _NC----.... zip 28402-1347` ......._._
For HOLD at FedEx Location check here For Saturday Delivery check here
�Hold Weekday HOM Satilyday INotavailable ataa )...dons) (Ewa Charge. Not available to all locations)
INot available �INot available FedEx First Overnighter �INotavailahlewiM FedEx Frrt Overnight
FedEx First Ovirmightl FedEx Standard Overnight) or FedEx Standard Overnight)
Service Conditions, Declared Value, and Limit of Liability— By using this Airbill,
you agree to the service conditions in our current Service Guide or U.S.
1 Government Service Guide. Both are available on request SEE BACK OF
SENDER'S COPY OFTHIS AIRBILL FOR INFORMATION AND ADDmONALTERMS.
We vvill not be responsible for any claim in excess of SIOO per package whether
the result of loss, damage, or delay, non -delivery, misdelivery, or misinformation,
unless you declare a higher value, pay an additional charge, and document your
Questions?
Call 1.800'Go-FedEx (1.800-463-3339)
actual loss in a timely manner. Your right to recover from us for any loss includes intrinsic
value of the package, loss of sales, interest profit allDmoys fees, costs, and olherforms
of damage, whether direct, incidental, consequential, or special, and is limited to the
greater of$100 or the declared value but cannot exceed actual documented loss. The
maximum declared value for any FedEx Letter and FedEx Pak is $500. Federal Express
may, upon your request, and with some limitations, refund all transportation charges paid.
See the FedEx Service Guide for further details.
Sendp.' o
Delivery orcommunismin oarea.
XpreSS Package Service Packages under 15016s. be later in some areas.
VedEx Priority Overnight FedEx Standard Overnight FedEx 20aye
•
(Next business morning) INaxt business afternoon) (Second business day)
El
NE W FedEx Fist OvemiQilt - FedEx Loner Rate not available.
IEarliestnextbusinessmorning dal iv ary to select locations) Minimumcharge;
(Higher rases apply) one pound FedEx 20ay rate.
.
Express Freight Service Packages over 150 lbs. Oeliverycommitment may
p g g beI rin some areas.
�Fed'xOvernightFreight ❑FadEx2DayFreight o Fed Ex Express Saver Freight
(Nett businesrday service (Second business-tlay (up to 36usines5-day service
for any distance) service for any distances based upon distance)
•
(Call for delivery schedule. See back for detailed descriptions of freight products.)
Packaging edEx FedEx FedEx FedEx Other
Vletter ❑ Pak ❑ Box Tube Pkg.
L—Declared value limit 5600.—J
.
' Special Handling IMP, e &.it aappar5
strip
Does this shipment contain dangerous goods? ❑ yes ao. l ❑ yes ` )
Drylce CAD Cargo Aircraft Only
Drylce, S,UN 1845111,_.._..__...x .� kg. 904
Mangereus Goods Shipper's Declaration not reeuiredl
•
Payment
Bill Sender Recipient �ThirdPany oCreditCard Cash/
t0: IAccaumno.in Check
section l wil) be billed) adEx account no. or Credit Card no. below)
•
FedEx 1184— 0231-6
Account No.
... _... ....
Credit Exp.
CardNo. _........ .... _... ...... ..._.. —Date
•
Total Packages Total Weight Total Declared Value' Total Charges
$ .00 S
'When declaring a value higher than SIDO per shipment you pay an additional charge. See SERVICE
CONDITIONS, DECLARED VALUE AND UMIT OF UABILIIY section for Further information.
•
Release Signature Sign to authorize deliverywithourobtaining signature.
Your signature authorizes Federal Express to deliver this ship-
ment without obtaining a signature and agrees to indemnify
and hold harmless Federal Express from any resulting claims.
•
The World 0�2 Time
272 Rev. Data 6/96
PART If47955
01%4.96 FedEx
PIiYNiEO IN U.S.A. •
care trot
_ _r—i

Teens And Conditions
Definitions On this airbill, we, our and its refer to Federal
Express Corporation, its employees, and agents. You and your
reter to the sender, its employees, and agents.
Agreement To Terms By giving us your package to deliver,
you agree to all tiff: terms in our current Service Guide, which is
available an request. You also agree to those terms oit behalf of
any third party with an interest in the package. It there ss a
conflict between the Service Guide and this Airbill, the Service
Guide will control. No one is authorized to change the terms of
our Agreement,
Responsibility For Packaging And Completing
Airbill You are responsible far adequately packacirI,yp ur
goods and properly filling out this airbill. If you omitthe n9ber of
packages andlor weight per package, our billing will be based on
our best t'stimafe of the number of packages we received and/or
an estimated "default' weight per package as determined by us.
Responsibility For Payment Even if you give us different
payment instn.uaiens, YOU will alwaysba primarily responsible for
all.dewery costs, as well as any costwe incur in either returning
Your package to you or warehousing it pending disposit oo.
Limitations On Our Liability
And Liabilities Not Assumed
• Our liability for foss or damage to your package is limited to your
actual damage or SIN, unless you declare a higher value, pay
an additional charge, and document your actual loss in a timely
manner. You may pay an additional charge tar each additional
$100 of declared value. The declared value does not constitute,
nor do we provide cargo liability insurance,
• In any event, we wiif not be liable for any damage, whether
incidental; special, or consequential in excess of the
ddclared value of a shipment, whether or not Federal Express
had knowledge that such damages might be incurred including
but not limited to loss of mconte or profits.
• We.. won"t be liable:
- for your acts or omissions including but not limited to
improper or insufficient packing, securing, marking, or
addressing or those of the recipient or anyone else with an
interest in the package
-�N, or the recipient violate any of the terns of an
Agmenien't
For loss or damage to shipments of prtihlbited items
- far loss, damage. or delay caused by events we cannot
control, Including but not limited to acts of God, perils of the
air, weather conditions, acts o1 public enemies, war"strikes,
civil commotions, or acts of public authorities with actual or
apparent authority.
Declared Value Limits
• The highest declared value allomted for FedEx Letter and FedEx
Pak shipments is S500.
• For other shipments, the highest declared value allowed is
S50,000 unless your package contains items of "extraordinary
value," in which case the highest declared value allowed is
$500.
• Items of "extraordinary value" include shipments containing
such items as artwork, jewelry, furs, precious metals, nego-
tiable instruments, and other items listed in our Service Guide
• You may send more than one package on this airbnl and fill in
the total declared value for all packages, notto exceed the Stoo,
S500 or $50,000 per package limit described above. (Example: 5
packages can have a total declared value of up to $250,000.) In
that case, our liability is lirnit:ed to the artual value of the pack-
age(s) lost cur damaged, but may not exceed the maximum
allowable declared value(sl or the total declared value, which-
ever is less. You are i esponsible for proving the actual loss or
damage.
Filing A Claim YOU MUST MAKE ALL CLAIMS IN WRITING
and notify us of your claim within strict time Irnits set out ;n the
current Service Guide.
Weil consider your claim filed if you notify our Customer
Service Dapartmont: at 1.800•Go•FedEx and make your clam in
writing as soon as possible. .
Within 90 days after you notify us Of your claim, you must send
us all the information you have about it. We aren't obligated to
art on any claim until you have paid all transportation charges,
and you may not deduct the antoupt of your claim from those
charges.
If the recipient accepts your package without noting any
damage on the delivery record, we will assume the package was
delivered in good condition. For us to process your claim, you
must make the original shipping cartons and pecking available for
inspection.
Right To (nspeciLiWe may. inCOu option open and noSpect
Your packages before or after you opve thery to us to deliver.
Right Of Rejectioril We resr rvo dtiq ightin r'eiect,a
shfpttjdnt_wr tducra si iturie¢t "'Ovid br-Thely ib causedelay or
damage tO dtkershipmeiiis, egwtirrent of personnel or if its
shipment is prohibited by law; or if i ;e shipment would violate
any terms of our Agreement or oue cutterrt Saralee Guide
C.O.D. Services C.0 0. SERVICE IS NOT AVAILABLE WITH
THIS AIRi3ILL If C.O O. Service is required, phase use a Federal',,
Express C.O.D, anal,
Air Transportation Tax Included Our basic rate
ncludes a fader<tl tax refit:fired by internatRevenue Code SasYp
4271 on the air transportation portion ntthis service.
Money -Sack Guarantee In the event of untimefy delivery
Federal Express ,% ill at yoi.n request and vvith some limitations.
refund or credit all transportation charges. See current Service
Guide for more information
Freight Services There are savo,al Freight service options,
depending on your transit titre needs.
• FedEx Overnight Freight: Next husmess-day service to all
points in the 43 states, rates are un icrm. regardless of
distance slipped.
FedEx 2Day Freight: Second b :n s-day service to all
points in the 43 states; rates are rmifar;n, regardless Of
nistanr"e shipped.
• FedEx Express Saver Freight: Up to 3 bus;iiess-day service
to all points in the 48 states: rates orrr based upon tie
distance shipped.
ru+�! is / �s�'I;)9'i1 • R�: G

Conditions for Shell Island Resort Homeowners Association Emergency General Permit
The temporary sandbag revetment will be constructed as depicted on plans entitled
"Proposed Sand Bag Layout with Modified Segment" and included in the report entitled
"Variance Request for Emergency General Permit, Shell Island Homeowner's Association
Protection Project" dated January 24, 1997. Construction will also be pursuant to
modifications to the application proposed by the applicant in the stipulated facts of the
variance petition as amended by the Coastal Resources Commission in an order dated
February 7, 1997. Those modifications and amendments are as follows:
A. The temporary sandbag revetment will be removed within two years of the date of
completion, unless the Division of Coastal Management determines, in its sole
discretion, that the revetment or portions of the revetment have become covered by
dunes with vegetation sufficient to be considered stable and natural.
B. During the two year permitted period, the permittee will monitor the sandbags and
will report to the Division on their condition semi-annually. The permittee will
perform routine maintenance on the sandbags not to include enlargement of the
structure beyond its permitted dimensions. If the Division determines, in its sole
discretion, that routine maintenance is not being performed, the structure or a
portion of the structure is falling into disrepair, or the structure or portion of the
structure has been abandoned, the Division may request the permittee to replace or
repair the structure or a portion of the structure. The permittee will fulfill the
Division's request within 30 days after the request is made. The permittee will not
contest the Division's determination. If the Division determines, in its sole
discretion, the structure or portions of the structure are in beyond repair or has been
abandoned, the Division may request the permittee to remove the structure or
portions of the structure. The permittee will not contest the Division's
determination. If, in its sole discretion, the Division determines the revetment or
some portion of the revetment has become unnecessary due to abatement of the
erosion emergency, the permittee will remove the revetment or portion of the
revetment. The permittee will not contest the Division's determination.
C. The permittee will monitor the erosion rate on the inlet and the oceanfront adjacent
to the Shell Island Resort and will report to the Division semi-annually. The
monitored area will extend half a mile south. If, after installation of the sandbag
revetment, the Division, in its sole discretion, determines that the rate of erosion
has increased on the monitored area, the Division may require the permittee to
remove or modify the revetment before the expiration of the two year period. The
permittee will not contest the Division's determination.
2. The Division shall be notified immediately upon completion of construction to make a final
inspection and document the completion date.
3. Once the temporary sandbag revetment has been installed, the public will have
unrestricted access to the inlet and ocean shoreline.

"4
Bag Otit
Proposed - Sand
L."XLL
with MO'di6"�d' Seg,'Ment,,,�.,
13—
Public Road
(Underground
Utilities) --I
9ch Pi
arking.
0 75
Scale in Feet
Mason's Inlet
-----------------------
0
Shell Island Resort
(North Tower)
Legend
0 Monument

-State of North Carolina
Department of Environment,
and Natural Resources
Wilmington Regional Office
Division of Coastal Management
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Bill Holman, Secretary
Donna D Moffitt, Director
CERTIFIED MAIL, # 7099 3400 0003 7009 0786
RETI�RN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Shell Island Homeowner Association
c/o Kenneth A. Shanklin
214 Market Street
Post Office Box 1347
Wilmington, NC 28402-1347
•
NCDENR
RE:)EP.4RTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENT ANC:- NATURAL RESOURCES
June 28, 2000
RE: Request for Extension of Permit
CAMA and Dredge and Fill General Permit No. 016159-D
Geotextile Revetment at Shell Island Resort Hotel
Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc.
New Hanover County
Dear Mr. Shanklin:
ni- 0 6 2000
The Wilmington Field Office has reviewed your June 12, 2000 request, on behalf of the Shell Island
Homeowner's Association, Inc., for an extension to allow the existing geotextile revetment to remain in place until
December 31, 2001. As you are aware, CAMA General Permit No. 016159-D was conditioned to require the
temporary revetment to be removed within two years of the date of completion, unless the Division of Coastal
Management determines, in its sole discretion, that the revetment or portions of the revetment have become covered
oy dkiaes with vege--ion sufficient to be considereO stable and natural. Currently no vegetated dunes cover the
revetment. General Permit No. 016159-D was issued after a variance from T15A NCAC 7H.1705(a)(5) and (10) and
T15A NCAC 7H.0308(a)(2)(E) and (J) was granted by the Coastal Resources Commission. The Final Order in the
matter issued by the Commission on February 7, 1997, placed additional conditions on the project which mandated the
the length of time the revetment could remain in place. On July 23, 1999, the Shell Island Homeowners Association,
petetioned the Coastal Resources Commision and received a variance to to extend the revetment removal date. The
F;"al 0-,dc,- l,i cJ�,uce - 3, ; issued in s sst 5, 1999. and extended the removal date until September 17, kuO.
Your request to allow the revetment to remain in place beyond September 17, 2000 is inconsistent with the
Commission's Final Order and therefore can not be authorized.
If you have questions concerning this matter, please call me at [phone].
cc: Charles S. Jones
Bob Stroud, District Manager
Dave fleeter
S' erel
E. F. Brooks
Field Representative
127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, N.C. 28405-3845 • Telephone [phone] • Fax [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer