HomeMy WebLinkAboutAQ_F_0400050_20120307_CMPL_InspRpt NORTH CAROLINA DIVISION OF Fayetteville Regional Office
AIR QUALITY NCEMC-Anson Plant
NC Facility ID 0400050
Inspection Report County/FIPS: Anson/007
Date: 03/08/2012
Facility Data Compliance Data
NCEMC-Anson Plant Inspection Date 03/07/2012
749 Blewett Falls Rd Inspector's Name Heather Hawkins
Lilesville,NC 28091 Operating Status Operating
Lat: 34d 58.0837m Long: 79d 55.3361m Compliance Code Compliance-inspection
SIC: 4911 /Electric Services Action Code FCE
NAILS: 221112/Fossil Fuel Electric Power Generation On-Site Inspection Result Compliance
Contact Data Permit Data
Facility Contact Authorized Contact Technical Contact Permit 09492/T05
Shawn Fowler Terrence Ryan June Small Issued 6/24/2010
Manager,Combustion VP,Asset Management Director of Expires 5/31/2015
Turbine Generation (919)875-3111 Environmental Affairs Classification Title V
(704)848-4002 (919)875-3116 Permit Status Active
Inspector's Signature: Comments:
Date of Signature:
MACTs/GACTs:
The facility does not appear to be subject to any MACTs/GACTs at this time.
DIRECTIONS TO SITE:
From FRO take 401 S. to Wagram. Turn right on Old Wire Road(NC 144)just south of Wagram. Stay
on NC 144, (this road will cross over 151501) until you reach HWY 74. Turn right on HWY 74. Just
after crossing the Pee Dee River, turn right onto Power Plant Road. Travel approx a mile and turn left
onto Blewett Falls Road. The facility will be on the right.
SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS:
Required safety equipment includes, safety shoes, eye protection and hardhat. Open no doors and touch
no plumbing while the turbine is in operation.
FACILITY DESCRIPTION:
This facility has simple-cycle, natural gas-fired (low sulfur No. 2 fuel oil backup) combustion turbines
generating electricity in Anson County. The facility can produce 340 MW of electrical power to retail
distribution during periods of high demand or during emergencies. This facility uses six Pratt and
Whitney FT-8 Swift-Pac simple cycle gas turbine generator sets. Each of the six units consists of two
turbines, each equipped with water injection and an oxidation catalyst system, and one generator. The
two turbines associated with each FT-8 do not have to operate simultaneously. The double-ended
configuration allows for greater efficiency during partial load usage. This plant operates as a"peaking"
facility to meet peak power demands on a daily or seasonal basis. Pollution controls are demineralizer
water injection to control NOx, and a high temperature oxidation catalyst to control CO. "Simple cycle
gas turbine" means any stationary gas turbine, which does not recover heat from the gas turbine exhaust
to either preheat the inlet combustion air or to heat water or generate steam.
The Plant Information(PI) System was installed at this facility for plant-wide monitoring and analysis.
The system handles the collection, storage, and retrieval of parametric data. It also acts as a data server
for Microsoft Windows-based client applications that operators, engineers, managers, and other plant
personnel use to view the plant data stored in the PI Data Archive.
The facility chooses to use a predictive emission monitor systems (PEMs) to monitor NOx emissions in
lieu of CEMs. The predictive emission monitor systems have been proven to be as accurate as the CEMs
and are in fact more economical from the cost and maintenance. The facility uses this software program
to monitor and determine NOx emissions from the gas turbines in real time. Continuous NOx emission
rate is determined based on vendor's data and turbine operating parameters.
INSPECTION SUMMARY:
On 7 March 2012, 1 met with the facility operator, Frank, at the Anson facility to conduct an air quality
compliance inspection/record review for both the Anson and the Hamlet plants because the facility
contact, Mr. Shawn Fowler, was not available. Frank verified that the contact information is correct,
verified that there have been no changes at the facility since the last inspection, and provided all records
for review, as required by the permit. Due to a manufacturer's defect in the turbine fan system,they are
in the process of disassembling and shipping the fan system to the mfg company for repair. They are
only taking down one unit(two fans)at a time so that they can still be able to generate enough power to
the grid during high demand times. They are currently waiting on manufacturer to return the fans from
the last Unit. Frank stated that even though they run on NG with fuel oil as a back-up, part of their
preventive maintenance program requires them to shut the units down, once a quarter, on fuel oil (and
it's a manufacturer recommendation). He said it keeps them lubricated and running smoothly.
We discussed the up-coming Acid Rain Recertification testing scheduled for April at the Anson plant
and following that at the Hamlet Plant. I told them I (or someone from the office) will probably be
present for several days of the testing.
PERMITTED EMISSION SOURCES:
Emission Emissions Source Description Control Device Control Device
Source ID No. ID No. Description
ES-lA One Pratt&Whitney FT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection system
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-lA Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-1B One Pratt&Whitney FT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection system
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-1B Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-2A One Pratt&Whitney FT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection system
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-2A Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-2B One Pratt&Whitney FT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-2B Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-3A One Pratt&Whitney FT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection system
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-3A Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-3B One Pratt&WhitneyFT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injections stem
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-3B Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-4A One Pratt&Whitney FT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection system
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-4A Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-4B One Pratt&Whitney FT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection system
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-4B Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-5A One Pratt&Whitney FT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection system
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-5A Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-5B One Pratt&Whitney 17178 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection system
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-5B Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-6A One Pratt&Whitney FT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection system
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-6A Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
ES-6B One Pratt&Whitney FT8 Swift-Pac simple-cycle gas turbine(300 CD-1 Water injection system
NSPS million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when firing natural
gas,and 281 million Btu per hour nominal heat input capacity when CD-6B Oxidation catalyst
firing No.2 fuel oil)and one generator per set of turbines system
REGULATORY/STIPULATION REVIEW:
A. 15A NCAC 2D .0521: CONTROL OF VISIBLE EMISSIONS — Subject sources: twelve turbines
(ES-lA&B thru ES-6A&B). VE is limited to 20% opacity for each turbine when averaged over a 6
min period, except during startup, shutdown and malfunction.
IN COMPLIANCE- Facility combusts primarily natural gas, and No. 2 fuel oil only as backup.
Both are clean burning fuels and as such the opacity should always be in compliance with the 20
percent limitation. No turbines were operating during the inspection.
B. 15A NCAC 2D .0524: NSPS, 40 CFR PART 60, SUBPART KKKK — Subject sources: twelve
turbines (ES-lA&B thru ES-6A&B).
a. S02 emissions limit = max sulfur content will be </= 0.05%; S02 monitoring= demonstrate
fuel will not exceed potential of 0.061bs S02/MMBtu. by representative fuel sampling; S02
reporting= submit semi-annual excess emissions reports for all periods including startup,
shutdown, and malfunction.
APPEARS IN COMPLAINCE-The facility initially demonstrated compliance with the NSPS
limits based on source tests reviewed and approved by the Raleigh Central Office. Fuel oil
sulfur content is determined by representative sampling after every load is added to the storage
tank and also quarterly. The most recent quarterly analysis showed 20 ppm S (0.0020%) in
Tank #1 and 7.1 ppm S (0.00071%) in Tank #2. Reports have been received on time and
appear complete and valid.
b. NOx emission limits= 25 ppm at 15 percent 02 when firing NG or 74 ppm at 15 percent 02
when firing No. 2 fuel oil; NOx monitoring= shall install, calibrate, maintain, and operate a
continuous monitoring system; NOx reporting= submit semi-annual excess emissions reports
for all periods including startup, shutdown, and malfunction.
APPEARS IN COMPLIANCE- The facility demonstrated compliance with the NSPS limits
based on source tests reviewed and approved by the Raleigh Central Office. The facility
operates the PENIS as their continuous monitoring system, and it was calibrated in Sept 2010.
It is scheduled to be re-calibrated every 5 yrs, or if unit exceeds 168 hrs/quarter for 3
consecutive quarters it will be re-cal every year. The PENIS activates an alarm if NOx
emissions exceed 25ppm for more than 60 seconds and if at 172 seconds the emissions still
exceed then the unit automatically shuts down. Reports have been submitted on time and
appear complete and valid.
C. 15A NCAC 2D .1418: NEW ELECRTRIC GENERATING UNITS- Subject sources: twelve
turbines (ES-lA&B thru ES-6A&B). NOx emissions shall not exceed 0.15 lb/MMBtu when firing
gaseous or solid fuels and 0.18 lb/MMBtu when firing liquid fuels. Compliance shall be determined
by using Appendix E of 40 CFR 75.12 to estimate hourly NOx emission rates in lieu of CEMs.
IN COMPLIANCE- Facility uses Appendix E info to calculate NOx emissions. The records were
complete and appeared valid.
D. 15A NCAC 2Q.0400: ACID RAIN REQUIREMENTS- Subject sources: twelve turbines (ES-lA&B
thru ES-6A&B). There are no specified S02 Allowance Allocations and NOx limits under this rule.
IN COMPLIANCE-There are no S02 allowances and NOx limits are not required for gas and oil fired
units.
E. 15A NCAC 2Q .0317 of 2D .0530: PSD AVOIDANCE- Subject sources: twelve turbines (ES-1A&B
thru ES-6A&B). NOx limit of 245 TPY and CO limit of 245 TPY. Startup/Shutdowns limited to
2hrs/day and must record # of startup/shutdowns per day. Exhaust gas shall be b/w 840 and 1800
degrees F. Calculate and record CO emissions monthly and for prev 12 month period, and NOx
emissions daily. Submit a summary rpt semi-annually.
APPEARS IN COMPLIANCE-Records of startup/shutdown, exhaust gas temp,and monthly CO/daily
NOx emissions appeared valid and complete. Total 2011 emissions for CO and NOx were 61.12 and
105.74 tons,respectively. Reports have been received on time and appear complete and valid.
F. 15A NCAC 2D .1100: CONTROL OF TOXIC AIR POLLUTANTS- Subject sources: twelve
turbines (ES-lA&B thru ES-6A&B). (Required because a sulfuric acid mist(TAP- H2SO4) is part of
the oxidation catalyst system.) Record number of startup/shutdowns per day for each turbine. Limit
turbine startup/shutdown to 2hrs/day. Operation of the combust turbines shall be limited while
burning No. 2 fuel oil as follows:
APPEARS IN COMPLIANCE- The facility combusts only ultra- low sulfur No. 2 fuel oil (<
25ppmw), therefore; the operational turbine hours per day are unlimited. The facility takes quarterly
samples of No. 2 fuel oil from the fuel tanks for the sulfur content analysis. The most recent analysis
showed sulfur content of 20 ppm for Tank #1 and 7.1 ppm for Tank #2. The facility continues to
combusted primarily Natural Gas (due to cost savings compared to fuel oil) but does combust No.2
fuel oil periodically for preventive maintenance purposes. The average startup/shutdown for each
turbine was < '/2 hour per day during 2011. According to Frank, it takes about 5 min to startup and10
minutes to shutdown an engine. In order to exceed 2 hours limit per day, the average startup and
shutdown for each turbine must be more than 6 times per day. The records show that the average
startup and shut down for each turbine during peak times is about 3-4 times per day.
112R STATUS
NCEMC- Anson Plant is not required to have a written plan, but is subject to the General Duty clause
of this regulation.
FIVE YEAR COMPLIANCE HISTORY:
No compliance issues during the last 5 yrs.
CONCLUSIONS/RECOMMENDATIONS:
Based on observations made during the 7 March 2012 inspection,NCEMC Anson County Combustion
Turbine Facility appeared to be in compliance with all requirements outlined in their current air permit.
/hsh