Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAQ_F_0400056_20130521_ST_STO-Rpt NORTH CAROLINA DIVISION OF Fayetteville Regional Office AIR QUALITY Piedmont Natural Gas-Wadesboro Compressor Station Stack Test Observation Report NC Facility ID 0400056 Date: 05/22/2013 County/FIPS: Anson/007 Facility Data - Compliance Data Piedmont Natural Gas-Wadesboro Compressor Station Observation Date 05/21/2013 259 Pleasant Grove Church Road Observer's Name Gregory Reeves Wadesboro,NC 28170 Operating Status Operating Lat: 35d 1.4834m Long: 80d 1.6830m Action Code 23/STACK TEST SIC: 4922/Natural Gas Transmission OBSERVED NAICS: 48621 /Pipeline Transportation.of Natural Gas Contact Data Permit Data Facility Contact Authorized Contact Technical Contact Permit 10097/R00 Alicia Mooney Rodney Myers Alicia Mooney Issued 3/28/2011 Environmental Engineer VP of Environmental Engineer Expires 2/28/2016 (704) 731-4I18 Engineering/Operations (704)731-4118 Classification Title V Services Permit Status Active (704)731-4318 Inspe^Siganature: Comments: 4 Source Test Tracking Number Datel2 MI-3 0{ 2013-071ST 1. LOCATION: Piedmont Natural Gas-Wadesboro Compressor Station,259 Pleasant Grove Church Road, Wadesboro,NC, Anson County. 2. DIRECTIONS: From FRO,take US Hwy 401 South through Raeford and Wagram. Just outside Wagram, turn right onto Old Wire Road(NC 144). Follow Old Wire Road across US 151501 and through Laurel Hill to US 74. Turn right onto US 74. Follow US 74 35 miles to Wadesboro,then turn right onto N. Greene St/NC Hwy 109, Drive 4.9 miles,then turn left onto Pleasant Grove Church Road. The Piedmont facility is located approximately 0.3 miles on the left side of the road. 3. SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS: The usual FRO safety gear is required, including hard hat, safety shoes,safety glasses, and hearing protection. There may be numerous pieces of equipment operating on site, including forklifts,personnel lifts,trucks,cars, and other vehicles. At the time of this stack test,the facility was not yet operating. The operations are currently being tested to assure proper operation. 4. FACILITY DESCRIPTION: The facility is a large natural gas pipeline compressor station. The facility accepts natural gas from the Piedmont 30 inch diameter distribution pipeline at 500-800 psig pressure, and compresses this gas to 800-1,000 psig for injection back into the pipeline to transport it to its destination. This facility was installed to be able to supply natural gas to a Progress Energy electrical power station in Wilmington,but the power station has not Piedmont Natural Gas—Wadesboro Compressor Station Stack Test Observation Report 05/21/2013 Page 2 of 4 yet made the switch to natural gas for the facility. The Piedmont facility consists of eight(8)permitted natural gas-fired 4,735 HP compressors, plus a 770 HP natural gas-fired emergency generator. The facility has not yet started operation, and is in the midst of performing stack tests to demonstrate compliance with NSPS Subpart JJJJ requirements for the engines. S. TEST CHRONOLOGY: 04/10/13 FRO received a letter from the company with testing protocols and stack test notifications for both the Wadesboro and Lumberton facilities. Stack testing was proposed for only the emergency generator engines at each of these locations. The proposed date for the test at the Wadesboro facility was May 15,2013. 05/06/13 Mitch Revels of FRO received an email from Gil Vinzani of Piedmont Natural Gas confirming that the testing of the emergency generator engine at Wadesboro was still scheduled for 05115. 05/07/13 DAQ SSCB reviewed the testing protocol and deemed it acceptable. Testing is for the initial - _ performance testing required under NSPS Subpart JJJJ. 05/15/13 Stack testing was proposed, but failure of an analyzer resulted in the testing to be postponed until May 21,2013. 05/21/13 Testing was conducted on the engine. 6. PURPOSE OF STACK TEST: The purpose of this test is to demonstrate compliance for the initial performance test for the emergency generator natural gas-fired reciprocating internal combustion engine as required under NSPS Subpart JJJJ. This engine is not a "certified" engine, and thus a stack test is required to demonstrate compliance with the NOx, CO,and VOC emission standards under the NSPS regulation. The engine being tested is a Waukesha 880 HP natural gas-fired engine, driving a 600 KW electrical generator. Under NSPS Subpart JJJJ,the emission limits for this engine are as follows: [40 CFR 60, Subpart JJJJ,Table 1] Note that the owner or operator can choose to comply with either the emission limit in g/hp-hr OR the emission limit in ppmvd% 15%Oz. Emissipn LimitErrissAOA »it �Pollutanf�' v. /11` 6ir ; , invil 1' 02""., NOx 2.0 160 CO 4.0 540 VOC 1.0 86 g/hp-hr=grams per horsepower—hour ppmvd=parts per million by volume,dry basis,corrected to 15%Oz content Piedmont Natural Gas—Wadesboro Compressor Station Stack Test Observation Report 05/21/2013 Page 3 of 4 The approved test methods are as follows: Ta`g9t Proposed Test ; Number' ,Test Number of + f of Test Run Samplutg Comments" Poll ; IGlethodr - w +r guns Duration Po nts CO EPA Method 10 3 60 min OZ EPA Method 3A 3 60 min 1-3 No of sampling points is per WE NOx EPA Method 7E 3 60 min stratification test VOC EPA Method 25A 3 60 min Moisture EPA Method 4 3 60 min 1-3 For moisture calculations,correction to dry standard CH4 EPA Method 18 3 60 1-3 Correction of THC to report NMHC THC—total hydrocarbon NMHC—non-methane hydrocarbon Testing is to be conducted at full load+ 10%. Proposed testing rate was 770 HP. 7. STACK TEST OBSERVATIONS: On May 15, 2013, I, Greg Reeves of the Fayetteville Regional Office, arrived at the Piedmont Natural Gas — Wadesboro Compressor Station site to observe stack testing of the emergency generator engine. I met with Gil Vinzani, Environmental Engineer (919-899-6081 office, 919-623-5701 cell), Mike Golombowski, Manager, Gas Control (704-731-4647 office, 704-618-1286 cell), and Tony Jabon, consultant with Trinity Consultants in Charlotte, NC (704-553-4474 office, 214-274-7980 cell). Air-Tech Environmental, LLC was performing the source test for Piedmont. The technician for Air-Tech was Darrel Doerle (919-302-6627 office, 919-544-6338 cell). l,. The test technician informed me that one of the stack gas analyzers had not been operating properly, and a backup unit had been sent for and would arrive later in the day. This is a new facility and has not yet formally commenced operation. The facility personnel conducted me on a tour of the plant. Pictures are available on the FRO LAN G: drive. The facility currently consists of four large natural gas compressors driven by 4,273 HP Natural Gas-fired engines. The facility is permitted for eight of these compressor engines. The facility also includes a 600 KW emergency generator driven by an 880 HP natural gas-fired engine. Facility personnel indicated that full load for the generator in the event of a power outage should not exceed 500 KW. Since the testing was not going to resume until early afternoon, I left the facility to conduct other business. Testing was to commence when the new analyzer arrived. UPDATE 05/16/13: Greg Reeves received an email from Tony Jabon stating that the testing had been postponed, and would commence on Tuesday May 21 2013. Difficulties with the testing equipment had been corrected,but the equipment manufacturer's representative on site had noted some difficulties with engine tuning and gas pressure problems that were also corrected prior to the testing. UPDATE 05/21/13: I arrived back at the site at approximately 8:45 AM on Tuesday 05/21/13. The generator engine had been started up, and the generator was connected to a heat sink load that would allow full load operation. The generator was operating at a load of approximately 550 KW. The first stack test run commenced at approximately 8:55 AM, and finished at approximately 9:55 AM. The load during the test run was very steady at 550-551 KW. Typical field data and field calculations for the run were as follows(Further analysis will be done prior to the final report): Piedmont Natural Gas—Wadesboro Compressor Station Stack Test Observation Report 05/21/2013 Page 4 of 4 Park eter. Uncorrected Reading Corrected Reading -hr 02 7.26% ------ ------ COz 7.37% ------ ------ NOx 231 ppm 105 ppm 1.90 CO 385 ppm 169 ppm 1.87 THC** 775 ppm ------ ------ CH4 743 ppm ------ ------ NMHC 1 32 ppm I ----- ------ includes methane,which will be subtracted to obtain NMHC results. A gas sample taken during the testing showed a methane content of approximately 743 ppm when analyzed on a gas chromatograph. Therefore,the uncorrected NMHC appears to be approximately 32 ppm. I departed the site at 10:30 after the first test run had concluded, and before the second test run had commenced. 8. COMPLIANCE STATEMENT: It appeared that the stack testing during the first test run was conducted in accordance with the requirements of the EPA methods specified. Field results on the analysis of the stack gases and preliminary emission calculations based on field measurements of power generation would appear to indicate compliance with the emission limits set forth in NSPS Subpart JJJJ. However,these were only preliminary field calculations. Final results will be submitted by the company. gwr cc: FRO Facility Files Piedmont 011 Natural Gas April 9, 2013 Ms. Shannon Vogel North Carolina Division of Air Quality APR 10 2011 1641 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699-1641 FAYEMILLEREOIONALOFFICL RE: Stack Test Notifications.and Protocols Lumberton and Wadesboro Sites- NSPS Subpart JJJJ DAQ Permit Nos. 10094R01 (Lumberton)and 10097R00(Wadesboro) Ms. Vogel: Piedmont Natural Gas (Piedmont) is submitting protocols and stack test notifications for two sites: the Lumberton Facility located at 3012 Singletary Church Rd., Lumberton, North Carolina and the Wadesboro Compressor Station located 259 Pleasant Grove Church Rd.,Wadesboro, North Carolina. Piedmont operates a natural gas-fired generator at each location subject to New Source Performance Standard(NSPS)Subpart JJJJ. As required by40 CFR 60.8, Piedmont must complete performance testing on these units within 60 days of achieving maximum production. The Wadesboro unit began operation on March 22, 2013 and the Lumberton unit has yet to begin operation. Piedmont is requesting approval to test both units prior to May 22 In order to meet this requirement. We have contracted with Air-Tech Environmental to conduct testing based on NSPS required test methods. Two protocols and DAQ requested items are included with this letter. If you have any questions or comments with regard to this submittal, please contact me at(919) 899-6081. Sincerely, ��C Gil Vinzani Attachments: DAQ Stack Test Protocols cc: Tony Jabon,Trinity Consultants, Inc. 150 Fayetteville Street, Suite 2810 Raleigh, North Carolina 27601 piedmontng.com 1 �® pq� PROTOCOL ,SUBAUTTAL FORM(Rev.2010a) s "®EN" DrmioN OF STIR QUALITY PAGE 1 OF 2 Purpose: The goals of the Protocol Submittal Form are to initiate communication between representatives of the permitted facility, the testing consultants,and the DAQ as well as to identify and resolve any specific testing concerns prior to testing. Instructions: Use Guidance Document to fill out this form. Submit all forms and additional information to the DAD Regional Supervisor at least 45 days prior to testing. Complete one form for each sampling location. If this form does not supply sufficient space to completely answer all questions or if additional relevant information is necessary, attach additional documentation and/or information to the original form Questions and/or comments should be directed to the appropriate Regional Supervisor. This form and its Guidance Document are available from the DAQ website(http://daq.StAte.ne-us/enf/Soureetestl) Specify Appropriate Regional Office:(check one) ❑Asheville ®Fayetteville ❑Mooresville ❑Raleigh ❑Washington ❑Wilmington ❑Winston-Salem FacilityName:Piedmont Natural Gas-Wedesboro Testing Company:Air-Tech Environmental,LLC Compressor Station Facility ID No;0400056 _ Facility Contact Person/mailing address&email: Testing Company Contact Person'/mailing address&email: Gil Vlnzani, P.E. Michael W.HartmaaorDarrell H.Doerle Environmental Engineer Air-Tech Environmental,LLC Piedmont Natural Gas P.0.Box 12353 150 Fayetteville St., Suite 2810 Research Triangle Park,NC 27709-2353 Raleigh,NC 27601 Email Address:giLTfimni®piedmontag.com Email Address:answersopass.net Phone:919-899-6081 Fax: Phone:919-544-6338 Pax:919-572-2203 5701 Mobile No.:919-623- Mobile No.:919-270-1810 Air PermitNumber&Revislam 10097R00 Permitted Source Name and ID No.:One four-stroke lean bum natural gas-fired emergency generator EGO Permitted Maximum Process Rate: MaximurallormdOperationProcessRate: TargetProcess Rate for Testing: 770 BF N/A 770 BF 1.1)What is the sproffic purpose for the proposed testing?(permit condition,NSPS,NESBAP,etc,see guidance doe):To demonstrate compliance with 40 CFR Part 60,Subpart JJJ Is this an initial performance test? ©Yes or ®No 1.2)List all state and federal regulations that apply to the proposed testing(see guidance doe):NSPS Subpart JJJJ,15 NCAC 20.0524 13)Will the test results be used for other regulatory purposes(e.g.,emission inventories,penult application,etc.)beyond that stated above? ❑Yes or ®No If yes,explain. 1.4)How will production/process&control device data be documented during testing(list specific control equipment,process parameters, instrumentation that will be used,frequency of data collection,collected by computadmanually,etc.)?TEST WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED Wf£HOUT APPROPRIATE PRODUCTION/PROCESS&CONTROL DEVICE OPERATION DATA. Engine load will be calculated from parameters recorded electronically during testing(e.g„firing rate,timing,rpm). 1.5)Provide a brief description of the source(including control equipment)and attach source or process flow diagram from source through stack exit One 4-stroke lean burn natural gas-fired emergency generator without emission control devices. 1.6)Provide a brief description of the sampling location,attach schematic of sampling location,and indicate whether concurrent testing will be conducted at other sampling locations(Approval of protocol without this data will not exempt you from Method I criteria): Samples will be collected from the unit exhaust stack. No sketch is available at this time. The pretest stratification traverse will be used to demonstrate acceptability of the sampling location for gaseous pollutants. AIR& a PROTOCOL SUBMITTAL FORM(Rev.moa) NCDENR DrMION OF AIR QUALITY PAGr 2 oF2 2.1)Provide the following information for each test parameter. Tgeget Proposed Number of Test Run #of Sampling Comments Pollutant Test Method Test Runs Duration Points Sampling points will be based on results of NOx EPA7E 3 1 1-3 pre-test stratification characterization. VOC will.be determinated as total hydrocarbons (M25A less methane l8 CO EPA 10 3 1 1-3 VOC EPA25A/16 3 1 1-3 021CO2 EPA 3A 3 1 1-3 Moisture EPA 4 3 1 1-3 22) Will all testing be conducted in strict accordance with the applicable test methods? If answer is no,attach ®Yes No complete documentation of all modifications and/or deviations to the applicable test methods. 23) Does the proposed sampling location meet the minimum EPA Method 1 criteria for acceptable measurement sites? ®Yes []No Attach supporting docmmmenmtioa. 2.4) Has cyclonic flow been documented at this source(EPA Method 1 Section 11.4)? ABSENCE OF CYCLONIC FLOW MUST BE VERIFIED DURING CURRENT TESTING. El as No 2.5) Will the oxygen concentration be determined by 0 EPA Method 3 via Orsat or®strict EPA Method 3A(specify) ®Yes El No If answer is no,see Question 2.2 above.(Fyritcs am NOT allowed per 15A NCAC 2D.2606) 2.6) Do any of the proposed test methods require analysis of EPA audit samples? If yes,notify Regional Office ��� No a minimum of 45 days prior to testing to allow for audit sample preparation and shipment. 2.7) Has all testing equipment been calibrated within the past year? If answer is no,explain. ®Yes ❑No 2.8a)Have all calibration gases been certified by EPA Protocol I procedures?(Answer only as applicable) 0 Yes r]No 2.8b)Is a dilution system(via EPA Method 205)proposed?(Answer only as applicable) 0 Yes Z No 2.8c)Attach a summary of expected calibration gas concentrations for all proposed instrumental test methods. 2.9) What is proposed test schedule?DAO Regional Supervisor must be notified a minimum of 15 days prior to the actual test datefsh THIS FORM DOES NOT CONSTITUTE 15 DAY REGIONAL OFFICE NOTIFICATION May 15,2013 Additional Comments: Signatures: Representatives from the permitted facility end the contracted testing company must provide signatures below certifying that the information provided.on.this form and any attached information is accurate and complete. /'w Z F ` "wAo'v� / Permitte.dFacifity pre/sentaEive ate -Testing Company Representative Date Name' Gt ' I/ i Vi 2 Ce t71 Name: Darrell II.Docile Title: t�nVtVGh yHeit�� JJc' plYl�Gt Title: Senior Staff Scientist Compsny: Pedpli o4 Ala—//Und Gas Company: Air-Tech Environmental,LLC Natural Gas May 6, 2013 Mr. Mitchell Revels NC Division of Air Quality 225 Green.Street, Suite 714 Fayetteville, NC 28301-5043 Subject: Stack Testing Notifications and Protocols Lumberton and Wadesboro Sites Dear Mr. Revels: In response to your inquiry this afternoon, I am confirming that the subject testing will occur on May 21 for Lumberton and on May 15 for Wadesboro. This is in agreement with the notice and testing protocols that were submitted on April 9, 2013 to Ms. Shannon Vogel and also to your office (see attached). This formal notification is in addition to the E-mail notification which you were sent earlier today. Should you have any questions, please contact me at (919) 899-6081, w MAY 08 2013 Sincerely' FAYETTEViLLE REGIONAL OFFICE Gil Vinzani, P. E. Environmental Engineer Attachment: April 9, 2013 Cover Letter with Protocol Submittal Forms 150 Fayetteville Street, Suite 2810 Raleigh, North Carolina 27601 piedmontng.com NCDENR North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources Division of Air Quality Pat McCrory Sheila C. Holmah John E. Skvarla, III Governor Director Secretary May 7, 2013 Anson County Mr.Gil Vinzani Piedmont Natural Gas, Ino 150 Fayetteville Street, Suite 2810 Raleigh,North Carolina 27601 Subject: Piedmont Natural Gas,Wadesboro MAY 13 2013. _ = Air Permit No.10097R00,Facility ED 0400056 OENR Proposed Initial Performance Test for ID EG-01,NG-fired engmeAY EVILLE REGIONAL OFFICE Proposed Test Date:May 15, 2013 DAQ Tracking No. 2013-071 ST Dear Mr.VinzaniY North Carolina Division of Air Quality(DAQ)has reviewed the protocol submittal form(PSF)for the subject testing and deemed it acceptable. The source is a 4-stroke lean burn natural gas engine emergency generator rated at 770 horsepower(hp). The proposed testing is the initial performance testing required by applicable regulations for new sources. Applicable regulations: 40 CFR 63 Subpart ZZZZ National Emissions Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants for Stationary Reciprocating Internal Combustion Engines(RICE NESHAP) • Permit including Section 3.0 General Conditions Section JJ General Emissions Testing and Reporting Requirements • 15A NCAC 2D .2600 Source Testing 40 CFR 60 Subpart7JJ7,Standards of Performance for Stationary Spark Ignition Internal Combustion Engines The primary purpose for testing is to demonstrate compliance with 40 CFR 60 Subpart JJJJ. Compliance with 40 CFR 63 Subpart,ZZZZ is met by complying with the emission limits in 40 CFR 60 Subpart JJJJ. 1641 Mail Service Center,Raleigh,North Carolina 27699-1641 217 West Jones Street,Raleigh,North Carolina 27603 _ Phone:919-707-84011 Fax:919-715-0718 Internet:www.ncair.oro Mr. Gil Vinzani May 7, 2013 Page 2 The following emission standards apply to new spark ignition,lean burn burn gas-fired engines constructed after July 1,2010. Table 1: NSPS,40 CFR Part 60, Subpart JJJJ Standards for 4-stroke lean bum natural gas-fired emergency engines> 130 h Pollutant . Emtsswn"Standard 7rr ,,:=ar .,Emisstoil Standard mud at 1,5,°o;4?zJ NOx 2.0 -hr 160 ppmvd at 15% OZ CO 4.0 -hr 540 ppmvd af!5%OZ VOC 1.0 -hr 86 ppmvd at 15%02 g/hp-hr=gram/horsepower—hour;ppmvd=parts per million by volume, dry basis Table 2:Approved Test Methods for May 15, 2013: -_ Number Target Proposed Test of Test Test Run Number of Pollutant Method Runs Duration Sampling Points Comments CO EPA Method 10 3 60 OZ EPA Method 3A 3 60 No. of sampling points is NCx EPA Method 7E 3 60 1-3 per VOC EPA Method 25A 3 6p WE stratification test Moisture EPA Method 4 3 60 1-3 For moisture calculations, correction to standard CH4 EPA Method 18 3 60 1-3 Correction of THC to re ort NMHC THC=total hydrocarbon;NMHC=non-methane hydrocarbons The proposed test methods are acceptable for the specified pollutants. Approval of the protocol does not exempt the tester from the minimum requirements of the applicable methods and 60 Subpart JJJJ requirements. Since no deviations from the applicable testing methodology were addressed in the test protocol,the testing should be conducted in strict accordance with the requirements of EPA Methods 3A, 4, 7E, 10, 18, and 25A. Testing must be conducted at full load f 10%. Testing proposed operating process rate of 770 hp is acceptable. If you have questions,please,contact me at(919)707-8413 or gary.saunders@ncdenr.gov. Sincerely, L. Saunders Environmental Engineer cc: Steven Vozzo,Fayetteville Regional Office Central Files,Anson County 1BEAM Documents Reeves, Gregory W From: Revels, Mitchell Sent: Tuesday, May 07, 2013 8:48 AM To: Reeves, Gregory W Subject: FW: Wadesboro and Lumberton Emergency Generator Testing Notifications From: Gil Vinzanlgn pied montnc com [mailto:Gil Vinzanl(&piedmontnc.com] Sent: Monday, May 06, 2013 2:32 PM To: Revels, Mitchell Cc: tiabon(o)trinityconsultants.com Subject: Wadesboro and Lumberton Emergency Generator Testing Notifications Mitch: _ In response to your inquiry this afternoon, I am confirming that the subject testing will occur on May 21 for Lumberton and _ on May 15 for Wadesboro. This is in agreement with the notice and testing protocols that were submitted on April 9 , 2013 to Shannon Vogel. As you have suggested, I will follow up this E-mail notification with notifications in writing today through the US postal service. Should you have any questions, please contact me at one of the numbers shown below. Thanks, Gil Vinzani, P. E. Environmental Engineer Piedmont Natural Gas 150 Fayetteville St. Suite 2810 Raleigh, NC 27601 (919) 899-6081 Office (919) 623-5701 Mobile 1 i