Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout17040_Stanhope Center_Pre-Occupancy Report_20150722 July 22, 2015 Mr. Tony Duque, Project Manager NCDENR Brownfields Program 217 West Jones Street Raleigh, North Carolina 27603 Subject: PRE-OCCUPANCY TESTING REPORT STANHOPE CENTER II 3001 HILLSBOROUGH STREET RALEIGH, NORTH CAROLINA MID-ATLANTIC PROJECT NO. 000R2490.04 BROWNFIELDS PROJECT NUMBER 17034-13-92 Dear Mr. Duque: Mid-Atlantic Associates, Inc. (Mid-Atlantic) is providing this Pre-Occupancy Testing Report for the Stanhope Center II for your review and approval. BACKGROUND INFORMATION The site is currently being developed as a mixed-use redevelopment with residential and retail components. A 3.31-acre portion of the subject property is subject to an existing Brownfields Agreement (BFA) between the North Carolina Brownfields Program (NCBP) and Hillsborough Ventures, LLC and is identified by the Brownfields Program as Project No. 06011-02-92. The presence of historical soil and groundwater contamination is documented in this BFA. A Brownfields Property Application (BPA) for the subject site was received by the NCBP and was deemed eligible for entry into the Program for continued evaluation for a BFA as stated in an October 16, 2013 Letter of Eligibility. Additional lots have been included in an updated BFA that, in addition to the original 3.31 acres, comprise the entire 4.28 acre site (subject site). The subject site is now listed as NCBP Project No. 17040-13-92. On November 15, 2013 the NCBP approved an Environmental Management Plan (EMP) for the subject property, and on March 24, 2014 the NCBP approved a Vapor Intrusion Mitigation System (VIMS) design and specifications document for use at the subject property. The NCBP-approved EMP and VIMS enabled the redevelopment of the subject site to occur under the existing BFA while the new BFA was being developed. Pre-occupancy Report Stanhope Center II Raleigh, North Carolina July 22, 2015 Page 2 Five buildings (discrete building sections) and a parking deck are being developed as the Stanhope Center II. A vapor intrusion mitigation system (VIMS) was designed for each of the five buildings by Mid-Atlantic, and the design was approved by the NCBP. The VIMS design incorporates seven zones with uninterrupted sub-slab venting layers and active sub-slab depressurization in each zone. The VIMS zones layout is depicted in Drawing 1. Contaminants of Concern (COC’s) on the site identified in groundwater depicted in Exhibit 2 of the draft Brownfields Agreement are as follows: Benzene, Toluene, Ethylbenzene, Xylenes, Naphthalene, Tetrachloroethylene, Trichloroethylene, 1,2-Dichloroethane, 1,2,4-Trimethylbenzene,Isopropylbenzene. INITIAL VIMS EFFECTIVENESS TESTING Mid-Atlantic has completed initial VIMS effectiveness testing at Stanhope Center II for VIMS zone A (March 3, 2015), zone B (March 11, 2015) and zone C (August 1, 2014). For the remaining VIMS zones (zones D, E, F and G), sub-slab pressure monitoring was conducted following permanent blower installation during pre-occupancy testing. For initial VIMS effectiveness testing Mid-Atlantic temporarily connected and operated a RadonAway XR-261 blower (e.g., low energy, 100-watt, 120-volt radon type fan, with 6 inch inlets) at each of the vertical riser stubs. During testing vacuum was only initiated at one riser at a time. The blower depressurized the sub-slab venting layer beneath the floor slab per the VIMS design/horizontal vent layout. Mid-Atlantic installed vapor pins into the floor slab sections at approximate locations depicted in Drawing 1 in order to measure the indoor/sub-slab pressure differentials and evaluate the influence being obtained by the sub-slab depressurization system. Table 1 shows data from effectiveness testing from VIMS zones A, B and C. The column heading shows the riser location and the rows are sub-slab vapor pin identification numbers. At each vapor pin Mid-Atlantic documented at least 15 pascal (Pa) sub-slab to indoor pressure differential with the blower operating. Pressure differentials were also measured at distant pin locations (pins that had other risers that were closer) with the pressure differential decreasing with increased distance from the riser. PRE-OCCUPANCY TESTING METHODS On June 17, 2015 Mid-Atlantic conducted pre-occupancy sub-slab pressure differential monitoring to demonstrate that the operating VIMS was adequately interrupting the vapor exposure pathway. Our methods for assessment for final pre-occupancy assessment were described in a May 26, 2015 Pre-Occupancy Testing Work Plan provided to the NCBP and approved on May 27, 2015. We conducted the testing following completion of vertical construction, and installation and start-up of all permanent blowers using the full Pre-occupancy Report Stanhope Center II Raleigh, North Carolina July 22, 2015 Page 3 extent of the VIMS piping network in order to assess as–built system performance. Heating, ventilating and air conditioning systems have been installed and were operating in VIMS zones A and C. After it was determined that all roof-top VIMS blowers were functioning, monitoring points were identified in the VIMS zones. A rotary drill was used to penetrate the slab and vapor barrier and a vapor monitoring pin with an air sealed fitting was driven into the slab penetration. A tube leading to a “DP Calc” micromanometer was connected to the vapor pin fitting so that the indoor to sub-slab pressure differential could be measured (Photos 1 and 2). Pressure differential testing was conducted in two to six locations in VIMS zones A, and C through G for a total of 17 monitoring locations. Approximate monitoring pin locations are depicted on Drawing 1. Pre-occupancy VIMS testing was not conducted in VIMS Zone B because post tension cables in the slab of that section precluded drilling in the floor for placement of monitoring probes. Permanent blower operation was verified by recording pressure readings on magnahelic pressure gauges mounted on permanent risers on the roof of the buildings (Photo 3). Magnahelic gauges were not yet operational on June 17, 2015 when pressure monitoring was conducted. Mid-Atlantic returned to the site on July 9 following notification that gauges were functional to record gauge static pressure. Spot sub-slab pressure measurements were collected on that date to assure that sub-slab depressurization was similar to that measured on June 17. PRE-OCCUPANCY TESTING RESULTS Mid-Atlantic observed that all permanent roof mounted VIMS blowers were operational on June 17, 2015. On that date we measured sub-slab to indoor pressure depressurization that ranged from 54 to 221 pascals (Pa) at 17 locations in VIMS zones A and C through G. Results are depicted on Table 2 and Drawing 1. The mean depressurization in Zone A was 178 Pa. (six locations). In Zone C the mean depressurization measured was 72 Pa (two measurements). In Zone D the mean depressurization measured was 74 Pa (two measurements). In Zone E the mean depressurization measured was 191 Pa (three measurements). In Zone F the mean depressurization measured was 185 Pa (two measurements). In Zone G the mean depressurization measured was 199 Pa (two measurements). On July 9, 2015 static fan pressure readings were collected from each of the 15 magnahelic gauges installed on the risers just beneath the roof mounted VIMS blowers (Photo 3). Static pressure measurements ranges from 0.9 to 1. 7 inches water gauge (inches WG) (Table 3). According to the fan manufacturer’s specifications the resulting volumetric flow rate for those static pressure results is approximately 110 cubic feet per minute (cfm) at 1.7 inches WG and 200 cfm at 0.9 inches WG (Attachment 1). Pre-occupancy Report Stanhope Center II Raleigh, North Carolina July 22, 2015 Page 4 Selected sub-slab pressure measurements collected on July 9 were similar to those collected on June 17. Sub-slab depressurization measured at 11 of the 17 points measured on June 17 ranged from 64 to 239 PA. Six of the monitoring points were inaccessible on July 9. Ten of eleven measurements collected on July 9 were higher (greater depressurization) than they were on June 17. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Mid-Atlantic measured adequate sub-slab depressurization across the Stanhope Center II building slabs to effectively interrupt the vapor intrusion pathway. In a 2008 Engineering Issues Report the US EPA states that “… the average range of soil/building depressurization is on the order of 4-10 Pa. Thus, a mitigation system that compensates for a minimum of 4-10 Pa everywhere under the slab should adequately mitigate vapor intrusion.” 1 The measured depressurization at the subject site of approximately 50 to 240 Pa will adequately compensate for building use, climate and other variables that could have some impact on sub-slab depressurization levels. Although we were unable to collect sub-slab depressurization measurements in VIMS zone B during pre-occupancy testing on July, 2015, data collected during system effectiveness testing in March 2015 indicated that there is adequate depressurization across the slab in VIMS zone B to interrupt the vapor intrusion pathway. Additionally, the permanent blowers provide greater fan capacity than those used for effectiveness testing. As was the case in each of the other VIMS zones it is likely that sub-slab depressurization is greater with as-built conditions than it was during effectiveness testing. Magnahelic gauge readings may be used to indicate that adequate depressurization is present in the sub-slab at Stanhope Center II. Mid-Atlantic recommends that monthly fan pressure readings be taken to insure that the blowers are operational and providing adequate fan ventilation to depressurize the building sub-slab. These readings should be documented and kept on site. In the event a fan(s) burns out, malfunctions, or if pressure readings are recorded outside of the observed range, we recommend that repairs and/or adjustments be initiated immediately. 1 US EPA. Engineering Issues: Indoor Air Vapor Intrusion Mitigation Approaches. EPA/600/R-08-115 October 2008. Pre-occupancy Report Stanhope Center II Raleigh, North Carolina July 22, 2015 Page 5 CLOSING Mid-Atlantic appreciates the opportunity to submit this report to the NCBP for review and comment. If you have any question please feel free to contact us at 919-250-9918. MID-ATLANTIC ASSOCIATES, INC. William Service Environmental Toxicologist Darin McClure, P.E. Principal Engineer Attachments: Drawing 1 Tables 1-3 Photographs Attachment 1 WS/DMM/bro/bj DRAWING ´ PR E - O C C U P A N C Y A N D SY S T E M E F F E C T I V E N ES S T E S T I N G R E S U L T S ST A N H O P E C E N T E R I I 30 0 1 H I L L S B O R O U G H S T R E E T RA L E I G H , N O R T H C A R O L I N A DRAWN BY: DATE: JULY 2015 DRAFT CHECK BY: JOB NO.: 000R2490.04 ENGINEER CHECK BY: GIS NO.: 03G-R2490.04-2 APPROVED BY: DRAWING NO.: 1 RE F E R E N C E : M I D - A T L A N T I C F I E L D N O T E S . N O TE : P L E A S E R E F E R T O T H E A P P R O P R I A T E S T R U C T U R A L , F O U N D A T I O N , A N D M E P DRAWINGS FOR ALL CON STRUCTION RELATED DETAILS TABLES TABLE 1 EFFECTIVENESS TESTING DATA  STANHOPE II CENTER  3001 HILLSBOROUGH STREET  RALEIGH, NORTH CAROLINA  BROWNFIELDS PROJECT NUMBER 17034‐13‐92  MID‐ATLANTIC ASSOCIATES PROJECT NO. R2490.04 VIMS Zone A Vent Riser ID 3/3/2015 A1 A2 A3 A4 Va p o r  Pi n  ID A‐1 ‐‐‐11 ‐‐‐45 A‐2 ‐‐‐14 ‐‐‐37 A‐3 ‐‐‐20 ‐‐‐29 A‐4 ‐‐‐21 ‐‐‐22 A‐5 ‐‐‐29 ‐‐‐16 A‐6 ‐9 ‐27 ‐‐‐3.9 A‐7 ‐10 ‐16 ‐‐‐‐ A‐8 ‐15 ‐3.5 ‐1.9 ‐‐ A‐9 ‐15 ‐‐‐17 ‐‐ A‐10 ‐11 ‐‐‐36 ‐‐ A‐11 ‐‐‐‐‐49 VIMS Zone B Vent Riser ID 3/11/2015 B1 B2 Va p o r   Pi n   ID B‐1 ‐58 ‐10 B‐2 ‐42 ‐16 B‐3 ‐22 ‐33 B‐4 ‐8.5 ‐22 VIMS Zone C Vent Riser ID 8/1/2014 C1 C2 C1+C2 Va p o r   Pi n   ID C‐1 ‐60 ‐108 ‐196 C‐2 ‐70 ‐100 ‐189 C‐3 ‐70 ‐85 ‐177 C‐4 ‐60 ‐62 ‐150 * All values are in Pascals  ‐‐None measured at this location TABLE 2 PRE‐OCCUPANCY TESTING DATA  STANHOPE II CENTER  3001 HILLSBOROUGH STREET  RALEIGH, NORTH CAROLINA  BROWNFIELDS PROJECT NUMBER 17034‐13‐92  MID‐ATLANTIC ASSOCIATES PROJECT NO. R2490.04 VIMS Zone A Vent Riser IDs : A1, A2, A3, and A4 6/7/2015 7/6/2015 Vapor Pin ID VP‐121 ‐221 ‐229 VP‐132 ‐194 ‐202 VP‐129 ‐190 ‐196 VP‐142 ‐123 ‐‐ VP‐141 ‐172 ‐‐ VP‐145 ‐171 ‐‐ VIMS Zone C Vent Riser IDs : C1 and C2 6/7/2015 7/6/2015 Vapor Pin ID VP‐158 ‐54 ‐64 VP‐161 ‐90 ‐‐ VIMS Zone D Vent Riser IDs : D1 and D2 6/7/2015 7/6/2015 Vapor Pin ID VP‐D1 ‐81 ‐97 VP‐D2 ‐68 ‐‐ VIMS Zone E Vent Riser ID : E1 6/7/2015 7/6/2015 Vapor Pin ID VP‐E‐1‐E ‐191 ‐188 VP‐E‐1‐W ‐157 ‐180 VIMS Zone F Vent Riser IDs : F1 and F2 6/7/2015 7/6/2015 Vapor Pin ID VP‐F1 ‐182 ‐220 VP‐FC ‐189 ‐230 VP‐F2 ‐203 ‐232 VIMS Zone G Vent Riser IDs : G1 and G2 6/7/2015 7/6/2015 Vapor Pin ID VP‐G1 ‐207 ‐239 VP‐G2 ‐191 ‐‐ * All values are in Pascals  ‐‐Not measured on this date TABLE 3 VIMS BLOWER STATIC PRESSURE GAUGE READINGS  PRE‐OCCUPANCY TESTING  STANHOPE II CENTER  3001 HILLSBOROUGH STREET  RALEIGH, NORTH CAROLINA  BROWNFIELDS PROJECT NUMBER 17034‐13‐92  MID‐ATLANTIC ASSOCIATES PROJECT NO. R2490.04 VIMS Zone A GAUGE READINGS 7/9/2015 Riser / Blower ID A1 1.5‐1.6 A2 1.5‐1.7 A3 1.5 A4 1.7 VIMS Zone B GAUGE READINGS 7/9/2015 Riser / Blower ID B1 1.5 B2 1.5‐1.7 VIMS Zone C GAUGE READINGS 7/9/2015 Riser / Blower ID C1 1.3‐1.4 C2 1.4‐1.5 VIMS Zone D GAUGE READINGS 7/9/2015 Riser / Blower ID D1 1.1‐1.2 D2 0.9‐1.0 VIMS Zone E GAUGE READINGS 7/9/2015 Riser / Blower ID E1 1.5‐1.6 VIMS Zone F GAUGE READINGS 7/9/2015 Riser / Blower ID F1 1.5 F2 1 VIMS Zone G GAUGE READINGS 7/9/2015 Riser / Blower ID G1 1.6 G2 1.6 * All values are in inches H2O PHOTOGRAPHS STANHOPE CENTER II  PRE‐OCCUPANCY REPORT  PHOTOS    Photo 1. Slab Penetration and Vapor Pin Prior to Installation    Photo 2. Micromanometer Connected to Vapor Pin Measuring Sub‐Slab to Indoor Pressure Differential        Photo 3. Magnahelic Gage Installed Beneath Roof –Mounted VIMS Blower                                        ATTACHMENT 1 HP220 RADON MITIGATION FAN CURVE H P 2 2 0   R A D O N   M I T I G A T I O N   F A N     2. 6 0 2. 4 0 2. 2 0 2. 0 0 1. 8 0 1. 6 0 1. 2 0 1. 0 0 0. 8 0 HP 2 2 0 0. 6 0 0. 4 0 0. 2 0 0. 0 0 0 5 0 1 0 0 1 5 0 2 0 0 2 5 0 3 0 0 3 5 0 Fl o w R a t e ( C F M ) Te s t e d  wit h  6"  ID  du c t  an d  st a n d a r d  co u p l i n g s .      HP 2 2 0 – E x c e l l e n t c h o i c e f o r s y s t e m s w i t h e l e v a t e d r a d o n l e v e l s , po o r c o m m u n i c a t i o n , m u l t i p l e s u c t i o n p o i n t s a n d l a r g e s u b s l a b f o o t p r i n t . Re p l a c e s F R 1 7 5 . Fa n s a r e a t t a c h e d t o P V C p i p e u s i n g f l e x i b l e c o u p l i n g s . Fo r  4”  PV C  pip e  us e  In d i a n a  Se a l s  #1 5 6 ‐64 ,  Pip e c o n x  PCX  56 ‐64  or  equivalent.  Fo r  3”  PV C  pip e  us e  In d i a n a  Se a l s  #1 5 6 ‐63 ,  Pip e c o n x  PCX  56 ‐63  or  equivalent.  S t a t i c P r e s s u r e ( I n . H 2 O )